MH370 HOAX dismantled and DESTROYED. Ashton Forbes retires hoax just in time!

Download episode

Show Notes

MH370 HOAX dismantled and DESTROYED. Ashton Forbes retires hoax just in time!
Content created here by Spectral International, LLC.
Music videos by Simon Fly.
Visit our website here : https://truthseekershow.com
Buy some merchandise to support our show :
AMAZON STORE :
https://www.amazon.com/s?rh=n%3A7141123011%2Cp_4%3ATruthseekershow+Official+Merch&ref=bl_sl_s_ap_web_7141123011
Redbubble store (international shipping) :
https://www.redbubble.com/people/TSGear/shop?asc=u

Subscribe to our youtube channel here :
http://www.youtube.com/c/truthseekershow
Follow Steven Cambian on twitter : @stevencambian Join our Patreon : https://www.patreon.com/stevencambian

Donate by paypal : Send a paypal to TRUTHSEEKERSHOW@GMAIL.COM
Any amount you wish. Please include your chatroom user id, and any message you would like me to read on air. We read every paypal message we are sent and thank every person who sends any paypal support. Listen to the audio podcast : https://www.spreaker.com/user/14526799

Email us : TRUTHSEEKERSHOW@GMAIL.COM
#UFOS #UFO #f2B #STEVENGREER #DISCLOSURE #UAP #UAPS #DISCLOSURE #TTSA #TOMDELONGE #BOBLAZAR #JOEROGAN #ANCIENTALIENS #Roswell #area51 #SSP #SASQUATCH #SSP #SECRETSPACEPROGRAM #UFO #disclosure #SSP #SECRETSPACEPROGRAM #TRUTHSEEKERS #STEVENCAMBIAN #ANJALI #AREA51 #ALIENS #BOBLAZAR #GEORGEKNAPP #JOHNLEAR #S4 #AREA51COVERUP #WEAPONIZEYOURCURIOUSITY #UAPREPORT #MYSTERYWIRE #ALIENBASE #DAVIDWILCOCK #ANCIENTALIENS #EDGARCAYCE #bigfoot

We use streamyard to run our show! Use our referral code to sign up for or upgrade streamyard. https://streamyard.com/pal/d/6711617069252608

Show Transcript

Greetings and salutations friends, and welcome back today. Really by popular requests, so many people keep asking me about this what I think is an absolutely ridiculous farce of this MH three seventy video hoax. For those unt aware, these videos were originally posted by an account called regin on Regicide and non which whose YouTube channel contained a multitude of completely provably fake UFO videos. But somehow, as is often the case, we call it UFO hoax or whack a mole, these things get debunked and enough time goes by that somebody picks up a completely and totally dead proven hoax and runs with it, usually connecting new dots.

We saw this with this alien interview hoax and other hoaxes. Doctor Jonathan Reed that was another one that was completely and totally debunked. The guy goes away for a while and then he just comes back still pretending to be a fake doctor or sorry, pretending to be a real doctor. But it turns out he's not a real doctor, his education is fake.

That whole hoax was busted at the time it came out, and that's what usually happens here. Somebody does a hoax, it gets busted as likely or most likely or completely busted as fake. But along comes some opportunistic person who decides that he can still promote and make money from this hoax. And now let's be very clear, a lot of money has been made by this Ashton Forbes and his and all of the people that he's doing these podcasts with.

I was listening to a space in which somebody who hosted Ashton multiple times, and by the way I listened in on, some of them never asked him any real or critical hard questions, talked about getting a million downloads on their audio podcasts, just so everybody's aware, that's a huge amount of money that alone. But then we've got huge podcasts like Tim Kast and others, you know, jumping in to get their little piece of the hoax pie money. And you know, I was completely disappointed with some of the people that I saw even platform this because what you have to remember, I think it was Lou from Lou Reviews who said this, and he's absolutely right, is that the videos were originally posted on an anonymous YouTube account that was filled with fake UFO videos. Even Ashton admits that that account has a bunch of fake UFO videos.

So you know, to most reasonable or rational people, the discussion should end right there. These were posted by an anonymous YouTube account, which is filled with other completely and totally provably fake cgi UFO videos. But somehow, you know, a guess, to his credit, this guy picks up this completely dead proven hoax and gains a huge following, mostly by connecting the dots. And I think that, you know, we'll get into some things like standards of evidence and expert witnesses.

You know you can't have expert witnesses and virtual effects come forward and say these videos are fake and here's why. And then a guy like Ashton, who has no training, no experience, no proven track record in that field of expertise, just says, no, we debunked their debunk. No you didn't, You're not even qualified debunked their debunk. It's absolutely ridiculous.

And already I'm getting attacked by nameless, faceless, brand new Twitter accounts. And isn't that always funny that when you bust some of these fraud hoaxes, you get attacked on Twitter by nameless, faceless Twitter accounts, you know, all hurling personal insults, like an account that has six followers that is a brand new Twitter account just told me, you know, throwing insults at me. And I believe that Ashton has been using fake socc accounts. That's my personal belief and I'm entitled to it.

And here's why. Right around the time that he started pushing this hoax, a brand new, nameless, faceless Twitter account I'd never interacted with before came to me and said, hey, what do you think of Ashton Forbes and these and these MH three seventy videos? And I said, they're completely fake now, just as they were in twenty fourteen when they were debunked originally. And then again, I'd never interacted with that account, let alone interacted with Ashton, never had any interaction with him.

Immediately after I said the videos were fake, Ashton Ford's blocked me. Now I believe he's since unblocked me. But this shows that this is not an honest effort here. This is a purposeful attempt to deceive.

There's no reason why you should be blocking people that say the videos are fake if your evidence is good. But I believe that this person cannot withstand real debate, real scrutiny, which is why I believe he was going around checking what podcasters are going to help me get publicity that are going to believe this, and anybody that said it was fake, he wouldn't go on their podcast. Isn't that that's a little bit more than a coincidence to me? Of course, I can't prove that he's using soft puff accounts, but many people are saying that because I just don't.

I'm sorry, I don't believe that anybody cares at this much about these fake UFO videos to go attacking people with brand new, nameless, faceless accounts. A lot of people are telling me that he's got a bunch of side accounts. I don't know that that's true, but we have seen that tactic used by other hoaxers and fraudsters like Luel Zondo and others. If you dare speak out against the grift, they will send in the clowns to attack you.

And I believe that's what's been happening here. It's interesting and I just wanted to mention that what caused me I kind of changed my mind. I said, I'm not going to dedicate any time to this. This is stupid, but a few things have changed.

Ashton miraculously says he's going to retire from the MH three seventy hoax or grift or whatever you want to call it. Coincidentally, right at the time, people start filing foyas to find out if he's telling the truth about some of the things that he said. And let me be clear that there's a lot of dishonesty involved with Ashton and the way that he has pushed this hoax, the first of which is what I've just described to you, going and checking if somebody is going to be receptive to the hoax before you know, asking for a guest spot or whatever the case may be. And recently people have said they're filing four your requests to find out if his statements about Arrow or true.

And recently we a friend of the show Real Area of five oh three at Real Area five oh three did one Twitter thread that I think, really, and we're going to get into this tonight, really destroys this entire thing in one thread. I mean, the amount of evidence that these videos are fake is absolutely overwhelming. And sorry, not sorry. If there are three or four twenty year virtual effects veterans looking at these videos and saying these are fake, and here's why you don't get to just say no, they're not.

You have to there's standards of evidence, which means that Ashton has to put up three or four twenty year plus veterans and virtual effects that refute people like the Corriter Crew. Then there was other arguments like, oh, they can't be recreated, would take somebody six months. We've got two people that did recreations, one of which Ashton blocked and refused to interact with until recently when the pressure got too much. So there's all kinds of deceptive tactics being used to push this hoax, and standards of evidence get thrown out the window.

Sorry, not sorry if you've got on the record real people who say these are fake. And here's why you can't just pull anonymous Reddit posters who say they're from Marvel or top Gun Maverick that the videos can't be fake. You can't do that. He didn't even check that those people are who they say they are.

It's absolutely ridiculous that we're even here. But welcome to clown. This is the clown Show. And then some of these other arguments, all the pixels don't match one hundred percent.

This guy's supposed to be an IT professional, he would know that when people manipulate things in an audio or video editor or in a three D rendering program, they're going to stretch things, they're going to change things. Unless you have the hoax's exact settings on everything he used, exact filters and everything he used, it's never gonna match one. But we've got the asset used to create the teleport effect or explosion effect, we've got the original person who took the distill images that the background was faked from, and we've even got a person claiming that he made the videos. Both of those people were blocked by Ashton.

That's not a coincidence that he's blocking people that can disprove him. So we're gonna get into it all tonight and joining me uh as a special guest tonight area of five oh three, and uh, we're gonna get into this. We're going to bring him right in. Welcome, Maddie, good to see you.

Hey, what's up, Steven? Can you hear me? Okay, yeah, that was fine. Let me just check your mic volume there.

Okay, Yeah, that's fine, cool, okay, Yes, So you want to do to go through this thread before we begin to get off in the weeds. This thread of yours, I think perfectly shows why there's I don't there's no honest effort here. You know. I saw this Twitter spaces where everybody was jerking them off, telling them what great research.

And I just want to ask you, Maddie, do you use anonymous Reddit posters that you haven't verified even are who they say they are? Is that good research? No? No, it's not.

No very yeah. Yeah. You got to look at everything you know and all the facts in a case which it seems pretty clear that when you start digging into this, that's not what happened on Ashton's part, that he kind of I think I said that in the tweet. I think I said that he cherry picks speculation ary picks.

Yeah, yeah, yeah. So your thread starts off it says, what does a CGI video that has been passed off as conclusive evidence of MH three seventy being something to a portal have in common with twenty one pilots and a music video with over five hundred and sixty four million views, and and that we could get to the recreation and you go on. Yesterday I found a recreation of the CGI m H three seventy or video and posted it to Twitter because I wanted people on this platform to know its existence. Today.

In response, Ashton posted questioning technical elements of the recreation, and you know, we can get into his arguments, but they're really nonsensical. And everybody that's one of his supporters I also noticed too that they are completely and totally unwilling in my view, to accept any evidence this. Ashton said that this couldn't be recreated. Then he said it could, but it would take huge resources in six months.

This person made this recreation in one day, and I found another person that made a recreation in one day, So that alone shows that his research is worth shit in my view. What do you think about this refutation of this? It's just excuses. It's not one hundred percent exact.

Therefore the videos are still real. It's ridiculous. Why are we even still talking about this? Right?

I agree? A comedy of clowns man. It really is. There's you know, the dismissal and the rationalization that Ashton is demonsting right there.

It's just par for the course. And when you really start digging into it, you see that that's kind of his mo from day one, Like every time somebody brings up a valid point. He just rationalizes it, calls it debunked, and then moves on as if it doesn't exist. Generally ends up blocking the person who brought up the statement.

Just to be clear too, you know, people on Twitter are attacking me, going, no, you can't just show the recreation. You have to provide the assets you used and proved that they were all available in twenty fourteen. That's a nonsense argument. But the person who did the recreation did provide every asset that he used to make it.

So when we get back to Ashton's nonsensical refutation of this, he says, the fake video is immediately apparent due to the stick like figure of the plane. It looks almost exact in the recreation to the original. Why is that a stick figure? But the original video is not a stick figure, and look that supports the claim.

The top gun Maverick post claimed about how hard it is to scale down accurate. Yeah, so he's citing a fake post on Reddit. And by the way, Ashton, I'm going to challenge him on this. You can't use anonymous Reddit posters who claim they are somebody.

Show me the guy's name, his credentials on the record, that he really did work on top gun maverick or is this some random post that you cherry picked out of out of Reddit that for all we know he posted, Right, We've got these all these virtual effects experts that work for Marvel and top Gun Mavericks say the videos can't be fake, but they're anonymous Reddit posters, they're not. He didn't vet anything. He just accepted that because it fits his arguments. Somehow.

The first orb in the video doesn't come in correct, you know, it's it's all just you're right, just anything. Lastly, the zapp is incorrect and could not be recreated in after effects because uh yeah, for whatever reason. Right, well, I'm sure there were software in twenty fourteen that could do this. I just want to pour out something here real quick, Steven.

There's there's a lot of questions that he raises about the VFX, but Ashton is admitted multiple times he has zero training. He doesn't understand things like plays or matts or chroma key or opacity settings or WARPSK key frames, none of that. But he wants to make an argument he should comes across like he's an expert, all right, And the biggest point I want to make about is that if it sounds like you're breaking up here. I don't know if it's just my side of things, but yeah, go ahead, it might be mine.

I get a little bit opinion too. I need to either reboot my computer or or if you want to do that, I'll go. I'll go through your your thread and then by the time you're done, you can jump right back in. You want to try that, okay, all right, yeah, sorry about that, friends, But I hear him cracking up, so I'm you know, the audio files are going to kill me if that's uh uh is going to continue.

Yeah, and and of course somebody said he needs more than a fifty six K connection. Yeah, and you guys hear it too, so hopefully all right. So uh, you know, even with the reference that the original hoaxer would not have, the videos have never been recreated. They've been recreated twice.

So that's just a completely and totally factually inaccurate statement. As for the drone videos, no one has come even remotely close to recreating it. You know, it's like no, you know, it's like talking to a wall. There was a point at which he admitted that the videos were fake, and that's when the original person who made the background still images that the hoax was created from came forward.

And by the way, that guy had plane tickets, receipts and on the record statements from the assets store that he sold them to to prove that those existed at the time this hoax was created. But let's get back to let's get back to the rest of his thread. Area of five h three goes on to say, it turns out that Ashton has known about the recreation for months and responded by blocking the creator of the video. If Ashton has questions about the recreation, why are they asked in his echo chamber where the creator is blocked.

And this is Tony Adams who made the recreation. By the way, we're going to show you that recreation, and that's one of three. Three people have recreated these videos. It's so close that I can't believe that we still have to argue about this.

But Ashton and his followers will say, no, no, it's not pixel for pixel accurate. And again, if Ashton is indeed an IT professional, he would know that it would never be pixel by pixel, you know, one hundred percent a match because of settings, because of compression ratios, video codex because of filters that may have been applied at various times during the creation of it, it will never be exact. But this guy said these couldn't be recreated, and everybody that recreated it did it in about a day, so you know his argument that it would take six months and this and that it all falls apart. So Ashton knew about the recreation and he blocked the person who did the recreation.

Tony Adams says, this morning, Ashton forms made a post about my recreation. He got a bunch of stuff wrong, including my name, but I'm blocked, so I can't respond. This is his modus operandi, and in my experience, you know it is that and start hurling personal attacks. I love when he attacks the appearance of like the virtual effects artists who say it's fake.

That's not relevant. That's called I can't argue with this person, so I'm just going to attack their appearance because I'm pissed off that my grift is coming crashing down. Avery five h three says. Furthermore, it also turns out that the creator of the original CGI video also approached Ashton several times and told him the video was fake, only to also be blocked by Ashton, So this is the echo chamber.

If his evidence that these videos were real was so good, he wouldn't need to be blocking people that proved that his evidence is shit in my opinion, and just for those that are clear, this person, the Joe Lancaster, he did an AMA on Reddit and answered like a hundred questions about how the videos were created. But of course you've got to come up with some excuse for why that guy's deep state or one of the men in black try to cover it up, or some bullshit. So they said he can't provide the files. I don't know about you, but I don't have any files that from projects I did from ten years ago, and most people wouldn't.

But he was able to answer all the questions about how the videos were created to the satisfaction of most reasonable, irrational people. What does Ashton do block the guy so that his followers can't see that the hoaxer has been identified? Right area five h three. That's right, folks.

The creator of the original MHS three seventy abduction video came forward months ago as well as if and if Ashton had not blocked him, he could have asked any technical questions about the creation of that video as well in his recent AMA on Reddit. The original MHS three seventy videos were made for a film project as a supplemental virtual effects element to play in the background of a scene. Since MHS three seventy was not in the news at the time, the creator fashion has worked loosely on that event and added into the UFO aspect. The videos are one hundred percent fake, and here's the music video that Joe Lancaster was responsible for creating the virtual effects for both videos, and this is one of the music videos.

So again that's an on the record real virtual effects expert who says the videos are faked and I faked them and here's how I faked them. Excuses from the Ashton Camp. Airy five HT three says, this is why I never wanted to get involved in this MH three seventy conspiracy theory, because the videos have been debunked multiple times and the architect of this story chooses to block ignore counterfacts while terry picking speculative data to fill his narrative. Yeah, in other words, speculative data.

Somebody that's a virtual effects expert with twenty plus years and virtual effects comes out and says these videos are fake and here's why, and Ashton just says, no, they're not. I have my fake Reddit posters who say that the videos are real, and here's why. You know, it's ridiculous. What Action has to do is he has to understand the standards of evidence.

If you've got four or I believe we could get ten virtual effects artists look at these videos and say these are fake and here's why, then he needs to get ten on the record, real virtual effects artists, not fake Reddit posters, not people he hasn't even vetted, are who they say they are, and he has to bring them forward to refute the claims of the twenty plus year virtual effects experts that have looked at this. We've got three or four on corner alone that have looked at this and said these videos are fake. And here's why. You can't just say I debunked the debunks.

That's called research by proclamation. He has to equal the evidence. So if corn Crew has three twenty plus year virtual effects artists that say the videos are fake and here's why, then Aston needs three or four twenty plus year virtual effects on the record, real virtual effects artists that will say those guys are wrong. And here's why he doesn't do that.

He cherry picks and brings garbage data forward to refute real experts. It's garbage peddling. One oh one previous debunks that were ignored. One the pyromania portal effect was failed.

Yes, it was used in a video game, among other things. And somebody found the exact effect from the portal effect. Oh, but it doesn't match pixel for pixel one. It's so close.

It's ridiculous. And for him to continue to refute it shows that he's not being honest in his research effort. He's just looking for an excuse to excuse away real evidence. That's real evidence, right, And some of these people demanding shit on Twitter.

I love somebody demanded earlier that I recreate it using uh, you know, certain assets and share the No. Oh, the burden of proof is on the person making the fantastic claims. How about Ashton proves that a goddamn airplane, a fucking seven forty seven teleport it out of the goddamn sky. How about he proves that I don't have nobody has to.

And by the way, there's Brandolini's law. Look it up. Brandellini's law states that the amount of evidence required to refute bullshit is orders of magnitude more than it takes to create it. Look at those virtual effects artists from Quarter Crew.

They had to spend an hour or two looking at the video, trying different things, figuring out how you could fake it, and explaining it. Then we get to Ashton and he just says, no, we debunked their debunk You understand Brandellini's law. The amount of effort required to refute the bs is orders of magnitude more than it takes to create it. Ashton could just say anything, Oh look, there's a Reddit poster that says he was the virtual effects leader on Top Gun Maverick.

Did you ever prove that, Ashton? Or are you just taking the word of some anonymous Reddit poster you haven't even vetted is who they say they are. You can look up top Gun Maverick, go find out who the Virtual effects is, call them, get them on the record, ask them if they're that reddit poster. Did you do that?

And people say you should do that, Steven, No, I'm not making the claim. And by the way, Ashton has made that claim on multiple podcasts that the head of virtual effects for Top Gun, Maverick said, the videos cannot be cannot be fake. Great, then get the guy on the record. Why don't you have him on your show?

Right? But he never does that. So going on podcasts using fake evidence is bullshit. Why are we still talking about this?

It's ridiculous. Oh, we're not through. The photographer of the clouds, Jonas came forward, surprise af Ashton blocked the creator of the clouds. So, in other words, somebody took those cloud pictures and proved that they took those cloud pictures and proved that he sold them to textures dot com or whatever website somebody downloaded them from.

And then the original photographer of the clouds proved that it was his photos and how you could splice those photos together to make the fake background of these videos. What does Ashton do? Say that it's not true and block them, right, and give more excuses for why that's not valid evidence. It's excuse.

It's welcome to dumb excuses one oh one hoax or excuses. Oh. The photographer who took the picture of the clouds that were used to fake this hoax came forward and proved that he took the pictures and put them on a texture's website back then. Oh no, we have to come up with some excuses.

Oh uh, they're not available on wayback at certain times or dates, So that guy's not telling the truth. Bullshit. This photographer is again a real on the record source, right, and he showed his receipts and an on the record statement from the website that was selling the video. Excuse me selling those assets that were used to create the fake videos.

And by the way, anybody can get those assets, right, anybody, and see they have a sense of humor. They put a UFO over the assets. These are the assets used to create the fake background, and they one hundred match one match the background. Is that a coincidence?

Ashton? Like? What? Like?

I just don't get it. I just don't get it. And here we could see a JIF file one the lighter one is the actual picture that this person took and showed receipts and proof that he took those pictures of those clouts, and the other is the video using those assets to create a fake background. But we're still gonna argue that those pictures couldn't have been used to create this fake video.

And I love the other thing. Oh no, everybody that's looked at these videos has said that they're static, they don't move right, real twenty year plus veterans of virtual effects look at them. And by the way, I looked at them before Quarter Crew and said that background is a composite that's made from still images. And I'm no virtual effects expert, but I have video editing experience.

I've done some after effects and animation work. I can look at them and say that the videos fake, that the video is using fake still images. Oh no, we proved that that the clouds are moving. Ashton is not a virtual effects expert.

Show me a virtual effects expert that is on par with the experience level of Corriter crew that agrees with Ashton. He can't, he can't, he won't, right, it's just researched by proclamation. Oh no, we prove the clouds are moving. No, you didn't.

You can zoom in on them. You could do anything you want to do. And Quarter Crew proved that if these images were video were taken from the satellite, there'd be huge movement in these clouds, and the clouds would be moving and the scene would be moving. It's not because it's CGI, it's a fake.

I think we have Manny back here, But let me get back to his thread. Okay, calub download or RAR file where somebody recognized Ashton's desire to be proved right and sent him a raw file full of garbage that allegedly helped confirming evidence. Ashton naively donated three thousand dollars for this file. But remove the live streams of that fiasco to save face.

Yeah, that's suspicious as well, right. Area five h three goes on to say, And that is just the debunks of the videos. That doesn't even touch on the physical evidence countering Ashton's conspiracy theories, such as the wreckage of the plane being found. Well, there's a great number of pieces of the wreckage they have to refute all the physical evidence as well a flight simulator found in the pilot's residence where he was practicing the doom flight, etc.

Etc. Do I expect any of these facts to convince Ashton he is wrong and admit the videos are fake. Absolutely not. I suspect Ashen will not be happy until his bias is confirmed and he is cheered by the people for exposing a massive conspiracy.

Unfortunately, for Ashton. All the other evidence he has aggregated of other people's work also hinges on the videos being real, which they are not, or are based on speculation. It must be discounted. Yeah, so that's pretty much the thread that really knocks this to shit.

I don't know if Manny is back. Are you back, Manny? Yeah? Not really.

I don't know if your internet as a potato all of a sudden, what happened? You see? I've been putting it through the ringer on this trying to get these some deliverables done, and I think I might have burned up the CPU. I got to replace my hardware.

Oh great, that's bad timing for us here. I was hoping to hear more from you. Do you want to call my cell phone? I'll give you my cell phone number and we'll just put you on speaker here and we'll try to continue the conversation that way.

Either way, either way, I'm gonna get shipped from these audio file people. But that'll be a little better. Let me send you my cell phone. I'll be right back to you one second, okay for me.

Yeah, it is just a bunch of excuses, I mean, and this is something that I remember saying a couple of weeks back when somebody asked me and they asked me about this, and they said, could you recreate that? And I said, yeah, I could recreate that. I don't know all of the techniques that were used, but by that point, the cloud texture from Jonas was already out there. The portal mania or the pyromania portal effect was already out there, you know.

So when you have all those elements, you're only a wireframe model away from, you know, making the video. But I also remember saying, I'm not going to take the time to do that because exactly I forecasted exactly what these guys are going to say. I said, if it's not pixel perfect, they're going to claim it's not real. It doesn't matter if if you've get ninety eight percent of it right.

And that's because people like Ashton don't know anything about VFX. They don't understand the billions of different variables that go into creating something like that, like warp skew effects and particle generators and smoke and opacity settings and different plates with noise on them and things like that. He just doesn't get it. And even worse, instead of just asking the creator of the of the recreation to explain those answers.

I guess he did. But when the creator started to answer those questions for him, he just got mad and blocked him. He's blocked him so he could have had all of his questions answered, and he did. He just didn't like the answers that he was given because they didn't fit his narrative.

And that's that's the mo that you're going to see time and time again, is that he just asked a few questions, comes up with enough reason to rationalize or as he calls it, debunk these debunks, and then he moves on as if it's still a fact. But all through this there's been just stacks and stacks of people who have called him out or tried to confront him or tried to educate him, and he doesn't want to hear it. He blocks him, and he moves on. He blocks him, he moves on.

You know, it's just it's kind of it's kind of sad, I mean, but it's also kind of funny. I mean, it really is. It's just kind of a joke. I mean, why, like you said at the beginning of the stream, before I started rubber banding and had the ping pong out.

You know, like, the whole thing's just kind of it's kind of a waste of time. It's silly, it's ridiculous, and nobody should be believing what this guy's peddling because it's all speculative garbage from the top to the bottom. Yeah. And one of the other things I loved that he says he found the leaker of the videos.

Right, he says he found the leaker of the videos, but he didn't interview that person. He didn't confirm that that person leaked him. But oh no, I'm ninety nine percent sure of this is the guy that leaked the videos. And here's why.

And then you got to connect a whole bunch of dots that don't make any sense. And you know, this person was arrested for leaking classified material. That was just a speculative shit show bad like Yeah said that when he said, see I think see Thomas Lynn whoever was? He said that that guy was the guy who leaked him.

And his answer was when Chris talked to him about it and asked about it, his answer was, well, what else could it have been? But MX three seventy that's his answer, and Chris explained it to him and he got attacked for it then, and it was straw Man arguments at Hormon and attacks. I mean, there's no evidence whatsoever that that Lynn leaked the MS three seventy videos, and in fact, there's amount of evidence it shows that he didn't like the fact that we know the guy who fucking first place, you know what I mean, like we the guy was here. He almost came on the show tog.

Yeah. And by the way, I'm gonna in the person I'm gonna I'm gonna do what Ashton should have done, and I'm going to interview the person who claims he made the video. So anytime that he's available to do it, I'm going to reach out to him. He reached back out to Manny and said, oh, I can't make the show tonight, but he was going to do it tonight.

He just has something that you know, he had a pre existing commitment here and heard about it last minute. But he's going to come on our show and we'll talk to him about it. And you know, one of these other issues is that all the false statements that Ashton has made, Oh, it would take six months to recreate it. Then how come everybody's recreating it in a day that gives it a try?

And I get it's not one hundred percent exact, but like, how much effort do we have to go through to prove you wrong? You said it would take six months and tremendous resources. Meanwhile, anybody with the PC and a little bit of software that tried it, it took a day and did it, or at least did it to most people's satisfaction. We're looking at on screen now, these are hardly distinguishable.

They're so close. Yeah, so that the recreation that was done by the user named Tony Adams. I have a lot of respect for Tony, and I hope he's listening, and here's this. I have mad respect for Tony because Tony is a guy who does videos and stuff, but he's not a the FX guy.

And he looked at this as a challenge because he saw that the assets were there, like the Pyromania portal and the clouds and stuff, and he looked at this as a challenge as a way to teach himself some new tricks and after effects. And I have mad respect for that. So it's not even an expert, it's somebody that's just learning and they could do it. Meanwhile, Ashton is telling people would take six months and a whole studio full of you know, experts and all these resources, and no, there's hobbyists that are doing it in a day.

Oh, oh my god, Dan, that is so fucking funny because the guy who made it, Tony, he said that you took him a few days to work on, but most of that was learning how to do new things. Now that he knows how to do those, he feels like he could have done the recreation in less than an hour. Yeah, and he said that he could grow better with more of time, but he didn't. He only puts so much time into it.

So of course you could do better if you put a couple more days into it. You can make it more exact, you know. But it's so close now, And for Ashton to say these can't be recreated and then they are multiple times and he just comes up with new you're right, He just comes up with new excuses and rolls on to the next part of the grift. I guess, yeah, one hundred percent.

That to his m O. And it's not just with the videos, it's with everything else. Every time you bring up something like, you know, the rackage. He's got a million and one excuses for that, and then he just rolls onto it, their excuses, their rationalizations, and then he calls them debunks.

You know, it's absolutely it's just it's comical. It really is comical. I don't know any other way to say it, but if you know, I try to get offended by it, but I just can't, man, because it's such a fucking shit show. It's such a shit show.

The guy doesn't even realize, Like he's so self unaware that he doesn't even understand that he looks like a fucking fool of everybody in front of everybody with his stupid arguments and his ad homine the talents, but as off as as five little Twitter followers, and it gets a few little people to watch his live stream, he doesn't care. That's all he cares about. So all great, man, I'm glad he's got his little echo chamber, but there is an echo chamber of idiots. Yeah, and an estimate of the situation.

Just shared something on Twitter two frames forty nine frames apart. Contrast todjusta as well as clarity. I'm sharing on my screen now if you want to monitor what we're sharing on the screen. So what we're talking about, what are the odds that we see an orbs line up at exactly the same spot relative to the plane at frame difference, that is, multiple of twenty four frames per second with exactly the same noise profile around the plane.

We see this again in another set of frames, and you guessed it forty nine frames apart. And why is there a false color filter added onto the footage after the fact? Happy to be wrong here, but looks like this is a virtual effects job, and we'll share what he found. In other words, you know, mathematically perfect, these orbs are going around mathematically perfect.

Yes it is, and I can explain to you why, which is something that the original creator of the video explained. And this is why I laughed so hard when Ashton and people are like, oh, he didn't make it, I'm like, well, he knew the answer to this. He was the creator because there was an air during render where one frame from the noise got dropped off of the render. So yeah, and when you rendered an animation, it was very common that you had a few frames would drop right, That's how I remember it, right, So he had one frame that was dropped, and instead of rerendering the whole thing, he just went back two seconds and grabbed a frame and slapped it in there.

And that shows that not only is the CGI, but the show is the guy who made it. Yeah, it's so ridiculous, this this clown show where people are just like, oh my god, it's not frame perfect. There's it's just so fucking it's so sad and pathetic and funny to some degree to just watch this guy die on this hill that's been debumped time after time after time, and then I don't want to accept the reality that it's fake, and I think that he is in denial, Like you know, there was a point and it's in my discord where I said, no amount of evidence will ever be enough for him to for him to back down and say I was wrong. You know, at some point you have to you have to go, you know.

And I've heard him say the vast majority of the preponderance of the evidence say the videos are real. What what vast majority of the evidence? The evidence in fantasy land where you're from, Because all the evidence from available experts say the videos are fake. And here's why.

And by the way, we have another recreation that somebody made that looks exact as well, and this one I'm going to share on board for Ashton, these views are one and he's wrong. But before I tell you why I think he's wrong, I wanted to see what I would do if I was going to hoax a video like this. I wanted to make one for myself. And just to be clear, this guy did this in a day as well, and he's no huge expert.

And also because Ashton directly challenged me, okay, he didn't, but being interviewed on another YouTuber's live sto hold on, we're playing that. We're playing the video right now, the recreation. Just hold hold on for a second. Ashton kept saying the videos would be extremely hard or impossible to fake, so this is extremely difficult if they had faked this.

He said that he had even consulted with usual effects artists that had worked on Top Gun, Maverick and Marvel movies. Marvel Vfects lead, whilst claimed it would take at least six months, but as a motion graphics designer and someone who has dabbled a bit with the effects in his career, I was sure that I could do something that was similar or pretty good in much less time. But first, let's do a quick refresher on what this whole thing is about. All right, we're gonna skip the background, because we all know the background of the story.

We'll get to the part where he does his editing. Up one second. I didn't let me get past the commercial here, and we'll go back to it. I apologize one moment.

All right, here we go. Let me put that back on the screen, so you know. And by the way, I found some more people who recreated it, and every one of the recreations is you know, it's not going to be pixel perfect, but they're pretty close. This is my there's commercial for the guy.

He's got a built in commercial. Okay, hold on bank in the way that it does in the original video. A three D model was really the only way to go. Once I had the model into three D program, I animated it along a simple path, turning and banking in roughly the same way as it does in the video.

Next, I made some aliens of other advanced technologies are available. I animated these flying in and then circling the plane. And I'm only about twenty minutes in and I have the basics of my video done already, Maddie. He just said he's only twenty minutes into recreating the video and he's already got the basics of the video down.

He's got the twenty model of the plane, he's got the orbs, he's got the flight path in twenty minutes. So Ashton has made provably false statements claiming that this it would take six months and all these resources. And again this guy didn't call him out. Those virtual effects artists from that he's saying are from Marvel or from top Gun Maverick, he never proved are actually who they say they are.

That those aren't on the record sources. Those are bullshit sources, right, Yeah, that's yeah, that's not confirmed at all. And if they're going to step up and and try to refute court or crew who's got like forty someone hears of experience between the you know, three or four of them, then they should at least put their name behind that. That's some chicken ass shit to use a random guy who's like, I'm a Marvel dude wrong on Twitter, Reddit or Twitter?

Where are you from? I don't know where you's you know, and it really doesn't matter you know. I mean that we've proven that the video, yes, can be recreated, but he's still using the marvel Head talking points and top Gun Maverick talking points from random random on Reddit. He hasn't even proved they are who they say they are.

How can you put that in your arguments? It's like me to you know, Can I just post randomly on Reddit the videos are fake and I made them, and then you accept it. No, you need some evidence to go with that of who the person is, and you know whatever. Let me finish playing this recruits.

I'm heading over into Adobe after Effects, the tool I'm going to use to composite the plane and the clouds and to add all the to make it look like it was filmed on a potato. So I have a plane and I have some UFOs. Now I need some clouds. I went online, but I was struggling to find a good high res image from the right angle.

So then I figured that I could get a bunch of individual clouds and put them into a Pascal generator and make them that way. Next is the So this guy used a particle generator to make some random clouds and make the still image background. But it's it looks pretty close to the original, and I knew this one would be easy. It's not perfect, which means it doesn't count because it's oh yeah, yeah, that's the excuse.

Oh no, that the clouds are different. The clouds are different. And this guy used the exact particle, you know, the portal image thing that was used in the original bunch of stock footage that I'd already used on other projects. Different variables that you can do when you're animating a portal effect like that to where you can, yeah, you can turn it, bend it, pull it, absolutely, stretched, skew it frame by frame even, you know, and you can get down into like billions and billions of permutations of what the original settings were.

And I even wager that the original creator, Joe, if he was given just the assets that he made, would have a hard time recreating that frame by frame because of all of those different they were in a ten year old, you know, animation that he did for just you know, for a student art film. I think it was. Yeah, he's not going to remember exactly what he had for opacity settings and bit rates and and you know how he tracked the different maps, which he probably would remember the broad strokes of creating the animation. But come on, that guy's a professional VFX artist.

You know how many hundreds, if not thousands of projects as he'd done in ten years, And people want to try to pick and be like, oh, he's not the he's not the guy who made it. He can't show me exactly how he made it. He doesn't have to the original files. Yeah, let me continue this recreation video for a few minutes.

In touch would be to add all the nasty compression like we see in the original video. Why would he? Yeah, exactly, all blend together and make it harder for debunkers to find fault instant potato. I'm not unhappy with the result.

It's not perfect and it's not exactly the same as the original, but that was never really the goal. The goal was to see how much I could do with very limited amount of time, to see whether a hoax would even be possible. I only spent about an hour and a half on it. So this guy did this with his recreation manny in an hour and a half.

He did it in ninety minutes. And Ashton said it would take six months, and his fake Victor effects people said it would take six months. You knowair a bit quicker than the Marvel the effects artists, yes to. But ye, yeah he did it one four hundred and sixty times quicker than Ashton said it could be done.

You know it just at some point you go, you know what, what more do you need before you say that Aston's not being honest here? And then we can go to the we can go to the the static images first satellite video fully debunked. The source for the clouds was found, so you know, they found the exact source of the clouds that were used to create the background in the hoax. We've got the original person who took the pictures with receipts from his flight, and on the record statement from the textures dot com website saying, yes, he sold us those assets and we sold it as an asset pack and I'll share the tab with the it's it's the same aspects.

Those clouds are the same as the the person who took the picture showed and again, oh it doesn't match up exactly, but again, when you're creating a composite, you're a stretch, skew resize, so it's never going to match one hundred percent exactly that's a bullshit argument. Oh you guys have to do it one hundred percent pixel by pixel or or the videos are debunked. That just shows that they're being dishonest in their efforts here, one hundred percent. They're being dishonest, Steven.

And this right here is kind of exemplary of everything that goes on here, every every time that there's been a debunk you know, like when the Jonas clouds came out, I thought, okay, good game over. Now everyone knows what the clothes the cloud textures out there. There's zero probability that that's an actual satellite image, because there's no problem, there's no probability none that the satellite would have the same exact images from a picture taken from a plane. So that shows right here that these were stock images.

This is CGI and it's fake. And yet you see the mental gymnastics that a clown like Ashton goes through to discount it, you know, and talk shit. You need a whole stream about how he's talking about Jonahs and how he's not he's suspect, and there's all these different little Yeah, well you just got to muddy the waters, right man, He just muddy the waters enough for the people to still believe it, just put enough doubt that that guy's not on the record. By the way, you know that guy hasn't been caught lying.

Ashton's been caught lying in my view because or at least being dishonest, using fake Reddit posters as the evidence. And somebody put up a great message in the live chat. He's on his stream saying he hasn't made any money, but he's made five thousand dollars already, and his superchats prove it. They've been totaled up, so he made least five thousand super chats, plus the added revenue hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of thousands of monetized views.

His channel is monetized. He is added up six dollars per one thousand monetized views. Hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of thousands of monetized views, plus five thousand dollars in super chats. He's probably made ten or twenty thousand dollars from this.

Show your YouTube statistics if you haven't made any money. Of course, he has made money, and so have all his friends that have platformed him. You know, there's some podcasts that had him on five times because they love the view camp, right, So they're all making money to sit there and do the circle jerk and not show any of the evidence we're showing tonight. Yeah, they definitely are making money.

And Ashton's made a lot of money off the super chats as well. Just like you said, I know that during the Caleb rher Dowlload fiasco, I was watching one show where within ten minutes he had gotten almost three hundred dollars in superchats, you know. So like, I don't know what his total numbers are, and I don't really care, but for him to say that he's not making money off this is a little disingenuous. In fact, you know, you can call it a lie.

I mean, sure, he's definitely making money off it, but I honestly, I don't think he's in it for the money. I think he's in it for the ego. Oh, Ashton says he hasn't asked to come on the show, hasn't been asked to come on this show to defend himself. Well, considering Lou's connection problems, I'd be happy to do that with him and Lou another time, because if I bring Ashton on, you know, with the situation we have right now.

They can't really converse back and forth right now, or you know, I don't know. If we let Maddie go and I'll bring him on, I'd be happy to spend him an invitation, but I'm not gonna sit here and listen to bullshit for two hours. Either he brings evidence or I'm hanging up on him. I'm not going to sit here and listen to fake excuses and bullshit arguments for two hours.

I have no obligation to do that. He's been dishonest about this thing from the very beginning. Yeah, you know, maybe I can try to connect through the browser on my phone so you can bring us both in. If Ashton wants to come on, bring him on, man, bring him on.

Yeah you want to try that, you're going to try. I got a few more things to share, so you've got five minutes to set it up or get it ready here. Maybe have a spare I don't know if you have a laptop beside your desktop or something that you can try. But the connection was terrible.

I don't know why it's always been good before when you've come on. Yeah, I'm having hardware issues. Like I said, let me. Let me try to get on my phone and see if I can get in, and then you can bring in ash I'd loved it.

I'd love to hear what you have to say about this. All right, Let's get a try. Yeah, I think you just need headphones and then your phone. Mike should suffice.

You should be able to connect through stream yard through your phone. Yeah, definitely, let me try it. All right, great, bye bye, all right. I apologize again for the for the problems.

We're going to try to get Manny back here. I'm just playing this recreation yet again. And there are some other things that I could certainly share. I will say this, not every podcast just did the circle jerk.

And I think Danny owns, despite whatever I think about him, for other guests, you know, and platforming certain people, he at least tried to, you know, hold Ashton's speek to the fact that that's that's real, it's not fake. So putting it received date four days after the plane went down, that makes sense because they want to convince people that it was right after. So the narrative that you're building right now is that regisicided on and somehow in on it, that they are somehow involved in producing it. That's that's the speculation.

Yeah, So that's the problem now is that you have to begin if you want to think these videos are fake, you have to begin with regicided On somehow being involved in it. And now this is immediately going to be contrary to the previous assertion that perhaps the military had to be involved in it. And this is part of the reason why we've ruled that narrative out is that you can't have both be true unless you think reticided On is part of the military industrial complex. But what we just saw from the previous image, he has stuff that says debunked, he's not doing what you just claimed.

And he also a ghosts of Boys of Ground. Right, so this isn't exactly the most credible. This doesn't screen to me a person who's trying to convince people that stuff is real. This also doesn't screen to me this is a person who's cgi and stuff themselves.

This is just somebody who's being given videos that they are posting on the internet. Right, what does that mean? You know what that? Uh, there's no way to know that because this is all speculation on the part of Ashton.

Videos subidos means what does that mean in Spanish? I don't know where we're looking from. Let's see where it says under videos. It says videos subidos.

And yeah, if you're doing that, then your butt comments right. Oh two, buttholes look alike doesn't mean there's stinkingly matching left to right right in an original work, you're being creative. You're creating your own thing right in that situation, you're not going to take a visual effect, and then you're not gonna be able to modify it to what we see in our videos because you don't have the frame of reference to modify it like that. You can only do that after the fact, after the fact.

Okay, Well, if I'm trying to make a video of a plan disappearing inside of an explosion, you would use an explosion? Yeah, I can. I would use an explosion effect. I wouldn't make the explode, I would.

That would be the most obvious thing I would do. Yeah, And that's the thing, So why did they not use an explosion effect? They did use an explosion effect, but Ashton is unwilling to accept that they did, citing stupid arguments. Oh, it doesn't match one doesn't pick flow by pixel.

But we've got an explanation for that. Uh. In the other videos, people stretch things, people move things. Let's go back over to the to this video.

You up damning evidence as well. I have damning testimony. I found the stock footage. Yeah, rather, we didn't some people on Reddit this is a stock footage clip from the nineties.

Oh well, yeah, there's a clip in the video, and here is the stock footage. The Corridor crew debunked the whole thing with one trip to Reddit, but I couldn't just take their word for it. I had to check it for myself. I tracked down the Reddit post, found the link to the stock footage.

And by the way, this guy is very honest in that he will say it doesn't match one hundred percent, and I agree, it doesn't match one hundred percent because people stretch things, move things, resize things, skew things, hit download min It's so close, though, that the odds of it being anything else is astronomy. Heart was pounding. It felt like I was solving some kind of huge, world changing mystery, even though I definitely wasn't. Boom.

I got it into Adobe After Effects and started scaling rotating, repositioning all the time hearing Ashton's words in my head. This is like saying that my butthole is your butthole because they're similar. Oh, the butthole argument. And there it was.

Ashton was right. The clips didn't exactly line up. The shape in purple is the original footage and the shape in green is the overlaid stock footage. They were close, but it still wasn't right.

And then it struck me. Visual effects is not a strict process. Artists are always stretching and warping images to fit their purposes. What if the hoaxer had just distorted the stock footage during the creative process.

It could also be that he added some sort of filter to it, some sort of overlay, changed the size, the position. Any change to the original footage would mean that it won't one hundred per pixel by pixel match. And you know, Ashton's pixel by pixel argument falls apart from anybody that knows anything about creating virtual effects knows that people's changed things. They skew them, They resize to fit whatever you know, rescale, rotate, any change or filter would mean it would not fit one pixel by pixel, So I stretched it just a little bit and Bingo virtually a perfect fit.

And with the random nature of explosions, I find it incredibly hard to fathom the odds of these two shapes lining up so closely. But what about all of Ashton's really quite compelling evidence, you know, the weather conditions, the satellite data, the Boeing seven seven seven turning circle. Could a hoaxer have just got really lucky? Yeah?

I believe that a hoaxer could get lucky. And let's go back to this one where he's citing fake virtual effects artists. So here's the thing. Let's pull it up and see I have the super imposed one right here.

So let's look at this together. Okay, So see this is an explode are you there now, Manny? He bounced back out this live show closure effects. This is not what our video is.

And so if you were faking it, you would use the explosion effect. You would have this plane blowing up. Our video is going to show an endothermic event, a cold one that's absorbing energy because it's black, right, yeah, because it's cold and the thermal and you can see that here we can, and here's the nonsensical arguments for why it doesn't match while it's being shown to pretty much ninety nine percent match. Pretty tell that this what we're looking at here is not the same?

Do you do you? Are you? There's a there's a tool that you can use in Adobe Premiere or in Adobe Photoshop where you can invert the colors and change the illumin not only the illuminance, but you can change the balance of the colors, the vibrance of the colors. And you can basically invert something that's black to white, or you can change something.

You can even change the color from purple to pink. Now, tell me a story, is why you're doing that, given the fact that we knows as an original work, Why are you not just using it like the like we see on the screen right now? I don't know, because virtual effects artists always add things like filters or changed at scale or resize it. I don't know.

When I use an effect, I almost never use it completely and totally stock. Are you there now, Manny, Yeah, I'm here? Can you hear me? Okay?

Yeah, that's much better. At least we've got a decent connection. Sorry about no video, friends, but at least he's got a decent connection. So let me get the let me get the invitation link and i'll see if I can't send it to Ashton.

We certainly would wouldn't mind hearing his you know, his explanation for all of these things. Yeah, well you do that, Steven. Let me just say something here too, like Ashton wants to argue about the VFX in both the recreation and the original host video, the original CGI one, and if he had questions, he should have asked the people who made them instead of better them and ignoring them and then calling them losers on his live stream and sticking his morally devoid fans to go fucking attack him like a clown, like, come on, man, it's it's ridiculous. He wants me to explain why somebody else did something, and he could have just asked that guy or he did and he didn't like the answer he was given, so he plucked them and ran away so he could just run with this story.

Man. It's it's absolutely childish. It's it's fucking comedy. When you step when you step back from it for a second and you look, you're just like, oh my god, this is such a fucking joke.

And this pencil that my craft playd weep is gonna fucking solve a conspiracy theory. Like it's just I just find it so fucking funny, man, so funny. So bring him on, man, I hope it comes on. I really hope he does.

Well. His dms are not open, so I'm setting him DM me for invitation to join our live stream. I have the link ready. So yeah, that argument falls apart too.

I mean, you know, he's free to come and trying to defend this kind of stuff. But you know, yeah, and we'll hear the same argument we've heard before, you know, Steven, it'll be the same old ship. It doesn't match Pixel perfect. He doesn't have the original source files.

You know, it was this C. Edward Later, whoever the guy's name is, who got it, because what else could it have been. He's the one who leaked on. I mean, it's just it's it's it's a whole house of cards that's built upon these videos being real and new Slash the fucking videos are fake.

The creators come out and see how they were made. That's the joke of the whole thing is in every single one of his arguments, everything that he's built just crumbles when you realize that the videos are fucking fak man. Yeah, I just want to show so much times I want to show an example of this nameless, faceless, brand new Twitter account. All you have is on at homin and illogical arguments.

You matrix want to be looking MF for how much are sly is in the matrix? Well, you know I'm half blind, So now you're attacking somebody's disability. Maybe you should put some of that money towards an education, you f and half with, like, this is what happens when you show people the truth. You bunch of delusional idiots that want to believe an idiot that's pushing long debunked videos.

They were debunked in twenty fourteen when they first came out almost instantly, But here we are ten years later and people still want to argue that they're not fake. We have the's still images used to fake the background. We have the explosion effect from a virtual effects pack that matches ninety nine percent, but it's not one hundred, So the videos still aren't debunked. According to these people, It's like no amount of evidence is enough.

It's Brandellini's law. How much do we have to do to prove that the videos are fake. How about Ashton proves they're real for a change. Yeah, it's already been proved that they're fake, you know.

I mean we talked to Joe the creator. He did an exhaustive AMA on Reddit where he answered any and all questions that people would have had, hundreds of questions, tons and tons of questions, and he had an answer for everything that only the creator would have, including some stuff only the creator I should have known, like the answer to the question posed by estimate of the situation about those two frames. He explained that in detail about why that happened, and not only mean it took him an hour or that don't mean to take them days to come up with answers, or that he cherry picked answers. He answered every fucking question on there, every question, and if Ashton wanted some answers, he should have been there.

He should have been there to talk to Joe and ask questions. The problem is he just didn't like the answers that Joe was given, which is why he blocked Joe and Joe for his tape to him and said, hey, I'm the one who made those asked me anything you want. He had from what I understand, Joe. I will never block somebody who's asking me valid questions or showing me evidence counter to what I've presented on my show.

But when people come at me and start attacking my discipline and cursing at me, Yeah, especially when they're a nameless, faceless, brand new account. And I think I know for a fact, I believe that Ashton's using fake account. He gets emotional and pissed off and people trying to pull him back to reality from this nonsense, you know, mission that he's been on, and no matter what he does, he's never going to prove those videos are real. He's never going to prove it.

There's just too much you can't because they're they're not they're not real, they're fake. There's no if anymore. The creator's been found. And this is part of the thing that really rubs me.

Wall And I didn't get a chance to explain this, but you know, when when seventy stuff came down and it got hot again, you know, a year or two ago, and read it, which is I think we're asked and glogged onto it. I didn't even buy into it because I already looked at this stuff and I was over it. I was over it. I'm like, this is all garbage.

I'm not into it. It's it's it's it's bad taste to bring this up to the victims of the family. It's just bad taste. And so I stayed out of it.

Now Fluss for I was in that space with Ashton, and I had said something along the lines. I had said something along the lines of We'll never be able to prove or disprove that this is faker will unless the original creator comes forward. And Ashton was in that space, and he knew damn well that the original Creator had come out months before that, months before that, and tried to contact him, and he had blocked him and ignored him and discounted his opinion and found reasons to not listen to him. And he didn't mention any of that.

He didn't say, oh, well, we know who the creator is this this guy named Joe. Hell No, he didn't. He sat there with his mouth shut like a fucking gimp and let people just think that the original Creator has never been found. The original creators out there.

His name is Joe Lancaster. He almost came on the stream today with us to talk about this because we're actually talk to him, we'll try to get him on Yeah, yeah, well we'll talk to him and here is evidence. But you know, it appears to me that, you know, they're just going to excuse that a way too, you know, like, oh, well, he can't produce the files, therefore we can't we can't them. You know, of course there are Stephen one man.

There's no amount of evidence that is going to convince Ashton Forbes that his hill that he chose to die on and his only claim to ten minutes a shame is going to be going away because it's all predicated on a couple of fake videos, which, by the way, folks, and I'm not sure if you know this, there was actually three videos that Joe made, not to two of which got leaked out, but the third wasn't leaked out. It was a cell phoned footage of the same event from inside the plane, and he said that the reason he believed that it didn't get leaked out was because it looked like crap and it was easy to tell it was cgi. So there's a third video out there that this guy's made about this. It's it's absolutely ridiculous.

It's I mean, The fact that somebody could take a couple of de bunch videos on the Internet and turn them into a conspiracy theory that you know, I guess a lot of people still believe is frightening to me. I mean, what's next. I mean, if Ashton Forbes can do this, holy crap, man. And I know he couldn't do it all.

Oh, he had to have gotten platformed by some big name YouTubers and big name podcasters and a couple of other people's clouds, right because their UFO stuff and the conspiracy theory stuff is the biggest, you know, performing videos they've done. You know, like it's it's it's scary, man, It's scary, you know, like it really is. It's I hope people really do wake up and say, God, I need to be a little bit more skeptical about some of this stuff and question some of it.

And when people are trying to call it out time after time again and have made good, good points like fighting the clouds or fighting the portal video, or recreating the video or actually fighting the guy who made it, maybe you should pay a little bit better attention people, you know, and I know a lot of people did it just discounted it, but a lot of people still believe this crap, and it's it's ridiculous, man, It's just it's it's it's it's a comedy of fools, man, a bunch of clowns, a bunch of clowns who don't care about, you know, investigating any claims or counterpoints and only care about making clicks and views and making money. And then on the other side, you got a guy like Ashton who's in it, I believe for his ego, you know, like just to stroke his woefully deficient ego and give him his little shot in the limelight. Well, who ah, man, you got it, you got it.

I just wanted to apologize because I see a bunch of super chats and everybody knows we read them all, but we'll read them a little bit later in the show. I had too much, too many things going on and you know, problems to juggle here. But I wanted to share the car to Crew video for the benefit of people who haven't seen it, because it's like six minutes long. But you know, and the issue that I have with Ashton, a big issue that I have with him, is that he doesn't understand standards of evidence.

If we were in a court of law and I brought in three or four virtual effects experts with you know, a proven track record and experience level and education level and virtual effects, and those or four experts all said these videos are fake. And here's why the court would not accept Ashton just saying. But some anonymous Reddit posters said that different Marvel or you know from top Gun Maverick and they and they said the debunks are deep, are debunked, Like they wouldn't accept that. There's standards of evidence you need the same level.

Show me your four virtual effects of artists that say that these guys are wrong, and explain why they're wrong. He can't, and he won't. Yeah, he won't, Steven. It's textbook confirmation bias is what it is.

He will only listen to evidence that supports his claim, and he will find any excuse, no matter how ridiculous, to discount anything that doesn't fit his narrative. Man like. And it's I laugh about it, but it's kind of sad, exactly. It's funny, but it's also sad at it.

It is kind of sad. You know, at some point when you observe that this person will not accept any level of evidence that the videos are fake. At some point you have to you have to admit he's not going to accept any proof that the videos are fake. He's just gonna explain away.

Muddy the waters, deny, deny. Try to punch holes in the debunks if you can. They're not pixel perfect. It's not one hundred per a match, you know, But let's do the let's do the corridor they debunk is pretty good.

Talking about them again, people claiming they have undeniable proof that they're real. Let's start by watching clips. Okay, that's a white thing. The whole frame get brighter.

So one of our base requirements is multiple witnesses, multiple camera angles. This one comes with a second clip, just like, who's wire? What is this plane doing? They're they're taking like a vasive maneuvers.

Who's filling this? Like what what's going on? Like? It's also why is it so shaky?

Because it's like should be on a nice smooth gimbal, But there you have it. It's a weird one. Wouldn't that be cool if that was real? Well, actually, no, that'd be terrible because you know, there's a lot of people on that plane.

Although I guess they're not diamonds bringing a new dimension. Yeah, they might be living it up. The YouTube channel since this was uploaded does not exist, no original footage, just YouTube videos. It's not it's not good.

Your original footage is a YouTube video. Yeah, that's a that's a step. Guys. Is this real or is this VFX?

I'm getting VFXI vibes right now. The first angle is something you could do very simply. The second one is way weirder. So people have said that because these came out so quickly after the airline disappeared, that they'd be possibly to the effects.

How how fast have you, guys? Do these shots too much? Real? Fast?

Yeah? As little as an hour, you know? Yeah, and there you go. That also is a real virtual effects artist who's refuting Ashton's claim that it would take six months and he couldn't have faked these.

It would take too long to fake them. There was two months between the original plane disappearing and the fake videos appearing on the internet. It's plenty of time to make these fake videos, in my opinion and in the opinion of virtual effects experts. I love the fact that he said an hour there, Yeah, he said an hour well, that other guy said he did the majority of the work to recreate him in twenty minutes.

So again Ashton is talking out of his ass when he says it would take six months. He said that on how many podcasts has he said it would take six months? You couldn't do these in that short amount of time. In two months time, you couldn't do it.

Meanwhile, real virtual effects artists who know what they're doing and talking about are saying an hour. The other guy he did the advanced majority of the work to do the recreation in twenty minutes. Okay, after analyzing this footage, it became clear to me at this is visual effects the thing that stands out most to me. So we go back to that first clip.

Look at the background. Are we a satellite? Assume more satellite. Do you know something weird about the background.

Although the clouds are not evolving in any way, shape or form. Nothing's evolving. Yeah, clouds don't stay that. That's still for thirty seconds set a time, and I don't know.

I've been over the background. There's no movement to my eye, but I'm not an expert. But these experts say there's no movement of the clouds. Aston refutes that with bullshit, fake excuses and evidence.

It's a sale frame. Thank you Red. Hey guys, how fast the satellites go? Seventeen thousand miles an hour?

Yeah? Would you jump to the footage of the International Space Station? Oh? Matter is that satellite?

It can't be sad if there would be parallax between the clouds in the ground, that's a big one. But you know what, that doesn't rule out the thermal shot, right, what's up with that thermal shot? Thermal cameras like they don't have they don't have grain. It's not under exposed footage.

And if there's any sort of noise pattern, notice noise pattern. It's a idea of like image is underg almost like a dirty lens. How do you make it look like it's thermal? Well, there's a filtering after effects called COLORAMA.

What COLORAMA does is it goes, all right, let's take black to white and instead of do black to white, we're gonna fill it in with different colors along the way, a rainbow, a spectrum, and then you know that looks like thermal footage. It's just not accurate. Owever, in this case, we see the engines are hot, so maybe you go in touched up the engines, give them a little track some like heat points on, so they were able to recreate the fake thermal in seconds with a filter. I think that's.

Yeah, it's not good evidence that this doesn't take six months to do it. You know, no it doesn't. These are some pretty basic VFX tech techniques and tools that they're talking about here. We're not talking about the uh, you know, the end scene from Avengers endgame.

You know, we're not talking about Marble level stuff here. This is stuff that that pretty much that I could do, and I'm by no means of VFX express but I do to after effects, you know, and then I could do this though. The weird thing I'm noticing with the thermals is on that shockwave in the second clip, Like how cold is that shockwave? Is that like a Is that like a zero?

So I'm confused why it's so dark when like we clearly see the engines are Oh he's got he's got an explanation for that. It's some kind of thermal like hot points. We're geting the yellows the reds. Because if it's a super dark hole, why is it so brightener and then the other one.

It's like a pitch black abyss. The crazy thing about thermals is they see through mist and smoke and all that kind of stuff. If you look at this clip from veritassium, we can't see him. A photons can't pierce the fog, but that that deep infrared, that long wave like the bread goes right through it.

The fog is invisible to infrared. So that's another one. So some of the clouds might be invisible, the contrails would be invisible to the thermal and they're not in the video. They're clearly visible.

So that's there's another data point that points that this is virtual effects. This is not a real thermal video, so those contrails shouldn't even be showing up on thermal. The undergoing footage is it's a three D render on top of a still ring of clouds on top of the still frame clouds. And the reason it is is the particle effect the trail from the plane.

Those are sprites overlaid on top of each other, giving us this additive stacked capacity which creates that build up in the highlight that we see there. If we were to do a volumetric smoke simulation of a similar trail like that. You would see that it doesn't overlap, and it has more consistent values across the whole arc, not just where it's you know, occluding itself. It's a CGI render.

Setting this up in three D is almost trivially simple. You lay a path, you said, an object to follow the path, you know, a little triple helix for the other objects. And by the way, manny do these guys concur with the people who made the recreations. So we've got aupule a lot of people agreeing on how this could easily be faked.

But Ashton has excuses for all three of them, a row, all three different. Know, we've got Tony Adams, We've got the other person who did the recreation and quarter crew. He's saying they're all wrong, all of these experts and virtual effects are wrong. But he has wrote that the guy who admittedly, thank you, that's what I was gonna say, the guy who's never touched after effects in his life, is right.

He is the moral or the ultimate authority on what VFX are not the people who do this ship for a living. And that's why it's again just such a joke. Man, it's just it's so it's so bad. It's so bad.

Well, let's finish this up. Man, put a particle emitter for the contrails. I'd be curious to see when this came out versus when the sprite trail tutorial on Video Copilot came out. I think it was roughly around this time.

But the bion do you have damning evidence as well? I have damning testimony. What if you tell me that this is the shock wave? Do we have this stock wave on our server?

We do now? Actually, so the actual are the actual asset used to fake the video? They found it, but hey, it's not it's not pixela it's not match. So they're wrong.

I found the stock footage. Yeah, rather we didn't. Some people on Reddit this is a stock footage clip from the nineties. Oh hell yeah, there's the clip from the video.

And here is the stock footage Cinderella baby Crella. That's slip right on. Wow, I s a dude, an identified stock asset. Some people have said, you know, pixels don't match perfectly.

You know what, of course, they don't match perfectly. I don't have the exact settings of the used but you look at it it's the exact same. I can't yeah, like I literally can't wear these glasses anymore. There's like nothing, it's just so debugged.

This is visual effects. It's really well done visual effects. So I had the joy of being a guest on a podcast, the Danny Jones Podcast. They had a UFO believer who believes that this footage as we all come on the podcast, and they asked me to break down if it was visual effects or not.

And I presented this. Danny sent me the reaction of the UFO ologist. So as a statement of fact, those do not match. Dude, it is exact saying that my butthole is your butthole because there's but we don't have the same butthole because of that.

So if you want to see our in depth for response to this UFO believer when we have that on our website, orderdigital dot com. We're not trying to get to a super deep back and forth back and forth here and on the YouTube channel, but yeah, so we're there from We'll go check it out, and of course you can watch the actual moment over on Danny Jones's podcast. There's link in the description below. Go check it out.

Well, guys, I've heard your complaints. I know you're you're tired of looking at okay so that they debunked a bunch of other stuff. So you know, I just think, like, how much more do you need, Manny before you say the videos are fake? You know, I don't need any I'm saying they're fake right now.

I'm saying that they're fake. I'll stand behind it. I could take my evidence in front of a jury of my peers and prove my case, and I feel very confident that I would win, as especially when the defense to it would be trust me, bro, what else gonna be? It's gotta be real.

It's Edward Lynn. It's it's gotta be real because aliens zupp ship, Like, come on, man, there's it's just a joke at this point, and it's a going back to what you said at the beginning of the of the episode here of the podcast. It's it's it's a waste of time. It's a waste of time.

There's somebody said, even temple ate him alive too. I haven't watched that whole thing. I start watching it, I just didn't get through it all. But you know the fact that so you know I could be wrong.

Maybe some people did hold his feet to the fire. Besides Danny Jones, Danny Jones is the only one that I that I saw that really said, you know, look, here's these virtual effects experts and they all say it's fake. They all unanimously agree. So all three of them, four of them are roll from Cornor Crew, plus the two people that did the recreations.

They're wrong too. You know, at some point you have to say, you know, again, Ashton's not a virtual effects expert. So when you have all these virtual effects experts saying these are fake, and here's why he's got to come up with better than no, they're not. You know, yeah, the kneer nater poopoo defense doesn't work here.

Sorry, these videos are depunked. It's game over. They're fake, they're hoaxed. And that's even not even taking into account the fact that the guy who made him come out and said, yes, they're fake, you know, like we've got to look at all the evidence here, and when he added all up, yes they're fake, they're bogus, their garbage.

I mean, he did good work. I'm not trying to talk any any kind of smack on the work. That Joe did. He did really good work for what he had to do in the time that he was given to do it.

And the assets that he was creating. He was never creating a full screen element that was supposed to be a primary shot in a picture. These were the background elements. Yes, they were going to be playing on a computer screen in the background, real small as a kind of homage or a kind of Easter egg or something like that.

And you know they were never designed. Yeah, they should never have gone to the public. To be honest with you, I was going to say, just to be clear, you know, for people that are gonna try to slag us, his dms are not opened. And I tweeted at him DM me for an invitation to join the live stream.

I have the link ready and that was twenty minutes ago. So you know, he can join if he would like to. But you know, I don't think. I don't think.

You know, he has avoided critical people like the plague because he kind of melts, you know, under scrutiny. He melts. He knows he can't address the specific virtual effects claims, says christ Lee TV, because he has no knowledge of them. This is why he's not engaging directly with any virtual experts aside from insulting and blocking them.

Yeah, and why block the guy who found the assets that were used to create the hoax? And why block a guy who claims that he created the hoax? If you're if you're you know, really honest in your research effort, you would want to go through that with those people. He has blocked them so that he so that, I think, so that his followers can't see their evidence.

He doesn't want to let his followers see the evidence. Fundy doesn't want them to see that the guy who made the videos come out one hundred percent. He wants to to keep his little echo chamber just like it is so that he can continue to ask these stupid, fricking questions like why isn't a pixel perfect? And how people go, yeah, it's not pixel perfect?

Yeah yeah, Like come on, man, even I said it, Corter Crew said it, other people have said it. Now, it's it's game over, Ashton, game over. It's done. These things are done.

There's cgi there's there's just no there's no coming back from this. And like I said in the tweet too, every little bit of evidence that he's got, including that there's hypersonic tech out there in Portal Tech and UFOs. It's all based on these videos, which means it's all garbage. We found the guy who leaked them, but he's wrong because somebody else claimed that he both created and leaked them, you know, or somebody that he knew got them and right.

But the guy that he claims leaked them is a huge speculative jump that has no basis in reality whatsoever. The guy who he claims leaked them was charged with something else it was. It wasn't even fucking videos. I don't think it might have been photographs, or is information about our nuclear capabilities or information about our spy satellites.

There's no indication whatsoever that the man that he claims leaked these videos had anything to do with them. None. His whole answer with Chris put held him to task on it and the spaces on Friday was what else could it be? But at made three seventy and I'm thinking, fuck, it could be unicorns from Narnia.

It could be fucking doors from Middle Earth. I mean, it could be anything. You know you're gonna go with them then if you're just going to take some fanciful fucking argument out of thin air and go with it. Why not?

Why not doors and unicorns? I mean, that's it's just evidence to show that it was that as it was Ashton's story about UFOs or man made black Tech. Give me a fucking break, man. That's why this whole thing is so comedic.

It's such a joke man, because you literally could take unicorns and dwarves and put them in Ashton's arguments and they'd all be the same. It would make no difference whatsoever, because there's just as much evidence none. No, we have we have in our live chat, we have crash Lee TV who also did a recreation and Ashton didn't want to talk to him. So how many people doing recreations that look almost exactly the same does Ashton not want to talk to And we'll share a little bit of that video.

He's using the zapp virtual effects with after effects to show out it was the asset. You know, it's just so stupid, like how many people have to tell him he's wrong and he's still gonna you know, it's like no, no, no, no, no, no, I can't hear you, you know, like that doesn't work anymore, Ashton. This is why he's retiring because I think the heat's getting too much for him. He can't explain these things away with fake evidence anymore.

And at some point you have to say, you know, I get it. People love conspiracy theories, but when you have all these data points pointing that the videos are fake, and all of these experts and people able to do the recreation. When he said it couldn't be done in two months time, people did it in a few hours. That are experts virtual effects like and he's no expert.

It'd be like me going to a diatrist because I have cancer. You don't go to a pediatrist if you have cancer. If you want to know about virtual effects, so you go to a virtual effects expert. You don't go to somebody that has no training in that field and trust their judgment.

Like trust me, bro, the videos are real. Well, we've got all these virtual effects experts that say they're fake. And here's why why are we still talking about this? And then all this comes from it's all fruit from the poison seed.

It all comes from a channel that posted fake UFO videos, So it's all fruit from a poison seed. The tree is poison to anything coming from the fruit of this poison seed is also poisonous. He's stacking all kinds of shit on top of this, you know, trying to you know, I don't know, put push square peg, you know, push a square peg through a round hole. It just doesn't make sense, you know.

Yeah, he's picked a hill to die on, and good for him, man, you know, Unfortunately it's gonna be a long, horrific and comedic death because everyone now is just laughing at this fucking fool man. You know, anyone who's got any kind of common sense is laughing at him. Well, he just clear. I don't really want to personally insult him.

You know, the evidence is enough. You don't even need to get into the laughing at him for you know, people and I will say that people have attacked him, but maybe deservingly. So if you're gonna make fantastical claims on the internet, you better have fantastic evidence, not a bunch of bullshit that you cobbled together that doesn't make any sense, you know, And like, what is the endgame here? Okay?

So before it was Aliens teleported the plane away. Now people are saying no, no, he's saying it was the government. So the government has teleportation technology, and they teleported an entire plane somewhere, but not an entire plane because parts of the wreckage were found at different places, right, so parts of them. So I guess when they teleported it.

You know, pieces of the plane fell off during the teleporting process. And you're right, you have to ignore all this physical evidence. And by the way, I think they're going to find the vast majority of the plane. I think they're going to find it eventually in the next year or so.

If the government teleported that plane. Even if the government hypothetically teleported that plane, where are the people that were on board? Where are the fricking people? I'm people?

I mean, are are we going for? I think they would unless their families are some kind of actors or something. Is that what he's claiming. I mean, I've never heard him say that, but I don't I don't even know.

Man like his his theories don't seem to make much sense to me because they just don't pan out. They don't pass mustard. You walk them past the sensational front, you know, uh, basic arguments that he has and what's his explanation for where the where the victims of the Crash went, I mean, I I just don't get it. I don't I don't get it.

And it's it's very it's very distasteful, and that's why I stayed out of it for so long. But after this this spaces with him on Friday, where he started attacking people. He attacked Chris, he attacked me, attacked anyone who was questioning, and then he had the balls to cut me off when I was trying to explain that the preponderance of evidence shows that these videos are fake, and he had the balls to cut me off and take actually, the preponderance of evidence shows that they're real. And I was like, oh, motherfucker, you just screwed up.

Now I got to dig into this and destroy your story. And that's what I did. That's what I did. I found the evidence that was out there.

And it's not that I had done any great, amazing research. The people on that airline are Abduction twenty fourteen Reddit Subreddit. They had already done this evidence that I heard this research and then already debunked him months ago, months ago, and he just ignored them, belittled them, and then went to his little echo chamber and continued to spread his narrative, and that's why I had to tell it the story the way that I did in that tweet. I wanted people to know that the evidence was out there.

I didn't collect it, I didn't research it. It was all right there. People had already done it, mastered it followed him in silence, and this is all the evidence. Yea, he doesn't want to talk about.

So it's good that it's all there in one thread and people who are curious can see the evidence that these videos are fake. And again, it's fruit from a poison tree. It's all. It all starts with bullshit, So it doesn't matter to me how much bullshit you pile on top of it, prove the videos are real or step off.

And then there's also the issue of exploiting all those dead people and their families. And I've heard the argument from some of these people. Well, nobody from the families have complained. But I'll ask Ashton if I ever get a chance to if somebody from one of those families complains, will you stop doing what you're doing.

I don't believe he would do you. No nobody complained. Their argument is nobody from the families complained or set down. I really hope that that's the case.

I really hope that his little region of messed up influence on the Internet is so small that it hasn't reached the victims' families in this case. I really hope that's the case, because I would hate to think that this knit with is traumatizing people who are who are already traumatized, just so he can stro ego. That's that's pathetic. That's just down right pathetic.

And so I hope that's the case. And he better hope so too, because he might find himself on the business end of a defamation lawsuit if he doesn't, if he keeps it up. I mean, like, I don't know what he's claiming, but they might. They might come after him.

I mean, there's ben historical this. This is exactly like Alex Jones claiming that those school shootings were staged or false flag events. It's just as damaging to the victims of these families as what Action is doing. And this is my opinion, I'm in tunnel to it.

It's just as as damaging as what Alex Jones did. And look what happened to him for pushing false conspiracy theories and hurting. He's re victimizing all of these people. Now they're all a part of some brand conspiracy and they got teleport to some base for some unknown god.

Why would they even do that. It just makes none of this makes any sense. It's so stupid. It doesn't know, it doesn't, it doesn't.

Anyone who's got some common sense should see right through it. You know, all the evidence is there. There's no reason to entertain this guy anymore or platform him. You know, Joe Rogan, Matt Stags, if you guys are listening, you guys dodged a really big bullet there by not bringing this clown on your show and giving him access to your viewers.

And I'm glad. I'm glad because his reach would have been even bigger. You look at what happened when Johnny Carson had Uri Geller on his show in order to debunk him. And if he hadn't done that, nobody today would even know who Uri Geller is.

Nobody today would care. He would not be a celebrity. And unfortunately, that's what happens when people get brought into the limelight, even if it's to even if if it's just a dumb ball over like Julie or not Juliet Dorsey. Who's the other one you said earlier?

I forget is now Danny Danny Grant, No, what's his last name? Who is Danny Jones? That was on the podcast with him, So he kind of dumped all over him, and you know, like that that right there, even that, I thought he was very respect full about it. Though he wasn't like nasty.

He's just trying to like he was trying to. I think Danny kind of like knew the videos were fake and he wanted to get in his head like okay. He let him talk for hours and show his evidence before he started hitting him with all the debunks and and you know, reasons why these things could be fake. You know, I think he was fair.

Yeah he was. And you'll notice that the reaction was the same out of Ashton. It was just the quick rationalization to excuse his belief and then dismissing the contradictory evidence out of hand, out of hand. He didn't want to hear anything about it.

He just he's got an answer for everything. But unfortunately for Ashton, most of his answers are just complete bullshit, complete bullshit. They don't get perfect. They don't perfect.

Example is using fake Reddit posters who claim they're the head of Marvel Effects. Why would you even do that unless you verify they are who they say they are and get a real the name, their their resume, and get on the record, call them up and say can I can I use this as an on the record comment from you as an expert in Hollywood level virtual effects. He didn't do that. He just ran with using fake evidence.

That's fake evidence. It's not real unless he could prove it. In a challenge of coal On to Ashton, stop using fake talking points unless you prove those people are who they say they are. As recently as yesterday, he's still using the virtual effects head for Marvel top Gun and he never verified that was the Marvel Effects.

The fucking he never verified that person was who they said they were. He's still using that as evidence. That shows you he's not being honest. Either verified that that person is really the virtual effects head for top Gun Maverick or the virtual effects head for Marvel, or stop saying that because you're being dishonest.

You're lying to people using fake Reddit posters, and for all we know, I've said up before, I don't have proof of this, but for all we know, that's Ashton on Reddit saying those things and then screen capture all see the head of Marvel Effects said that those videos can't be fake. No, we need the name, their identity, their resume. We got to have them on a show saying yes, I agree with Ashton, these videos can't be faked. I challenge you, Ashton, go find the head whoever the head of top Gun Maverick Virtual Effects was, get him on your show and get him to verify that's him on Reddit.

Get the head of Marvel Virtual Effects, get him on your show and get him to agree that that was him posting on Reddit. If not, your fake evidence falls apart and you should stop using fake evidence to prove your fake points. That's kind of where I'm at. I'd love to see him do that, Steven.

I'd love to see him get those people on the show, and I'd love to see him show them the Corridor Crew video and also take them to the ama that Joe did on Reddit and show them that and then say what do you think? What do you guys think? Ask him if he if he's if those are really the people that he claims that they are, show them all of the evidence and then ask them and accept what they have to say. But we all know that he won't accept what they have to say.

He won't accept anything that is counter to his narrative. Man, It's like I said earlier, textbook confirmation bias, and that's that's it. That's it. There's no amount of evidence here.

I'm showing the original picture of the clouds that we know who took the picture, and he has proof he took the pictures and the background in the fake videos. But still we're going to argue that these videos are real somehow, even though the backgrounds of them were taken by somebody from an airplane, and he proved it that he took those pictures from an airplane and they matched all most exactly. Not pixel perfect. They're not pixel perfect, manny.

The videos are still real unless you get a pixel perfect And by the way, again, keep parking on this point. He has zero experience with virtual effects. But he's going to refute all these experts. He's going to refute the guy who took the original goddamn pictures.

He has a receipt from his plane ticket. Yeah, you can't use the word plane to take these You know, when you're discussing this with Ashley, you can't use the word expert or else it triggers him and he goes into this appeal to false authority and CNN brain and things like that. It's really fucking weird. It's it's it's weird, it's cringey, and when you step back from it, it's fucking laughable.

It's laughable, man. He just the whole thing is. And you know, I'm glad that we're talking about this today. Let's get it out, let's get the information out.

But I'm not going to be talking about this anymore. I'm just not. I don't want to. It's a waste of my time.

It's a waste of your time. It's a waste of your viewers time, and everybody watching this to have to go over this video and this evidence has been debunk time after time again, just because some cloud named Ashton doesn't want to accept the reality and the facts that are presented to him. It's a waste of everybody's time and they should go. Everyone should just shut the the door on it.

Man. You know that you don't have to cater to him just because he wants to argue all day long, and I'm not going to I'm I don't ever want to talk about this after after today. To be honest with you, I have a feeling that people are going to force me to. Little Reviews is on Twitter saying ash and this is very telling.

Ashton is getting his entire theory toward the shreds with facts, and now he won't show up. We invited him. Just so everybody's clear, you just got to d M me. My dms are open, and then I will send him the invitation link.

If I knew his email, I would try to send it there. I mean, you know, it's if he wants to join, we'd be happy to hear from him. But I have a feeling the show in the chat. No, Manny, Actually, I don't think it would be fair for him to come with both of us, because I don't think he could handle either of us.

Either of us could tear the treads two of us together. He'd be left in a puddle of his own piss, you know, like that's my well, you know, bring him on and I'll step out, or you could take a breather and go, you know, step back, and I'll deal with it. I don't even care about revival. This is great.

The twenty four hundred visual effects shots failed in Top Gun Maverick, which were the responsibility of Ryan Tudhope and the artists at Method Studios, MPC, Lola Effects and Blind Well, I'm gonna call them tomorrow and I'm gonna ask him if that's if he agrees with Ashton, and that's him posting on Reddit, and if not, we'll all know that Ashton has been using fake evidence this entire time. Because if Archaic Revival can find out who was responsible, who was really was the head of virtual effects for Top Gun Maverick, why couldn't Ashton and pick up the phone, get the guy on the phone and get him to verify. He's the Reddit poster.

He can't be won't Yeah, I'm sure he'll have some kind of excuse, like it was somebody who worked under that guy, or it was somebody else, it was it was another guy, it was something else like And this is what he does is he's deceptively vague so that when you call him out on some of the facts, he makes it. He tries to make you look like a fool. He's like he's like, oh, that's not what I said. It was this, you know, like the Joe Rogan tweets thing where he posted a couple of the dms to Joe Rogan, but the blue check mark was missing on one of them for something.

I think. I think he baited everybody. I think he did that. That's my opinion.

Why would he rip the blue check mark out of some of the screenshots. He did that so that people he's lying those screenshots are fake, and then he posted the reality. And by the way, I have heard from somebody who spoke with Joe Rogan just to be clear, and yes, Joe Rogan did reach out to him and say, oh, that's interesting and asked him to come on, but then thought better of it and said no, I don't want you to come on. But see that those guys took that as a victory lap.

I think he baited everybody to think those screenshots were fake on purpose. Why else would he edit out the blue check mark and some of them somebody edited it out. And then number two, you know the fact that Rogan asked him to come on but then said no, forget it. That's not a win for him.

Rogan has platformed Bob Lazar, a convicted pimp, fake scientist. So that means Ashton is worse than a convicted pimp, fake scientist. Ashton is faker than Bob Blazarre, faker then Jeremy Corbel. He's faker than than George Knapp.

The fact that even Rogan, who has been platforming Wackado's for a couple of years now, said this guy's too wackadoo even for me. That's not a win, you know, I just don't think it's a win for him. But he took it as a c Rogan did invite me, Yeah, but then he said no because he knows these things are fake. As anybody that's at least a little bit rational about this whole situation would agree.

The videos are fake, and anything you pile on top of it doesn't matter. Go back to the seed, the start of the story. It's all it's all fake. It's just like a lot of UFO stories.

If you go back to the original story, it doesn't matter how much shit these people pile on top of things. The story's still fake, you know, Yeah, it's it's and it's all based on on fake videos, you know, I mean, it's just we just got to kind of move past that now and say that people still that still want to believe it are gonna believe it no matter what evidence you put in front of them, and so good, honest people who have integrity, who are trying to talk about facts and make real arguments, need to quit wasting their time on this fool and his conspiracy theory that is a bunch of bullshit. Just be done with it, Be done with this clown, and be done with it. You know, the only thing that's gonna get you is is ad Hominem attacks.

He's going to call you a loser, say that you need mental help because you don't believe aliens the plane. You need mental help? Like that's that's the best, right there? Bad, Like it's it's crazy, crazy as anymore.

It's high tech government technology. Oh yeah, so because our black ops didn't Zappa plane, which again doesn't explain where all the people on the plane went, does it. There's other fantastic claims for him, like he cracked the secret of anny gravity somehow as well, you know, oh yeah, I love how he was able to do it in two months with a bunch of shitty evidence. What hell Putoff's been trying to do for a decade, like he's cracked in a gravity.

Good job, Ashton, file that pattent tomorrow, you clown, go right ahead and file that patent. Do it. Can't wait to see you just fall flat on your face again, your knucklehead. Yeah, Vincent.

Vincent says he wanted to get on more podcasts, so he had to change the alien part of the story because it was a little too far fetched, right, change it from aliens to top secret. And I'm sure that he said aliens at some point, or somebody did. I don't know, you know, And yeah this, you know, I get that people are angry at him, and people were taking shots at him, but most of me feel sad for him because I said it before the only other time that we talked about this, when the whole thing came crashing down the walk the last time. But it's like ping pong, you know, it just keeps coming back.

You know. Uh. What I said is that nobody ever paid attention to Ashton, and all of a sudden, all these people are listening to him, so it becomes like a drug. He can't let this go.

He can't admit he was wrong. He can't let it go. He's never made any corrections to his fake evidence. He's never acknowledged he used fake evidence to push this.

That shows he's not being honest. And all the blocking, Oh you have evidence the videos are fake. Block block block. Oh you're the guy who actually made the hoaxed videos, and you have evidence in proof block block block, Oh you did a recreation block block block you know, can't follow.

He's got to keep evidence. No, he's got to keep that echo chamber in text so he can manipulate these people and keep keep I don't know what he's doing. Inflate his ego, fill his wallet. I don't know what he's doing, man, like the uh the Caleb download of rar is A is a really good example of why he's so hot to just be proved right.

And I actually watched a couple of those live streams live and I wish i'd recorded him because he's taken them offline now because they make him look like a fricking fool in front of everybody. Somebody captured him. They're still out there. Somebody captured those Oh I love.

If you've got copies, please send me copies of that other girl he told Remember that girl too. He told that girl that she's ugly and nobody loves her, she should kill herself or something like one of the critics. Oh yeah, he said, the people that are critical again, you know, because you don't. It's like his number one thing is to go right to that homin the attack and just yeah, well yeah, he said some really horrible things.

Just go to his Twitter feed right now if you want to, and search his Twitter feed for the word mental and look at how many times he tells people that their mental or they need mental help, or that they're you know, they need to get off the internet and take a break and all that. And I'm thinking, damn Ashton physician, heal myself, brother, you know myself, Man, go take a walk away from the thing for a month and touch some grass and go pet a kitty cat or something. Dude like he's either gone off the deep edge and he's starting to drink his own koola or he knows that he's a comment and he's just lying at this point. I don't know, and I really don't care.

I really don't. You know. He can, yeah, he does. He can go right back to whatever Rocky crawled out from.

Remember what's that yeah. He continually tells people to go get mental help when they don't believe that a plane teleported out of the sky. You know, that absolutely ridiculous. It is ridiculous, and that's his number one thing to do.

He's done it in spaces, He's done it in on his live stream. Like when when when Tony the guy who made the the recreation that we looked at, the one that I posted not the satellite, not the infrared one, but the other satellite one. When Tony had confronted him and said, or not even confronted him, but approached him and said, hey, look man, look I made a recreation. Here it is.

He went on. Ashton went on a live stream and showed Tony's Twitter account and has read account. It was like, this guy, Tony Adams is a is a liar. He's a liar.

You know, he's a loser. He's you know, right, yeah, get back to yeah, yeah, he just let you know, dude, Tony's not even a UFO guy. For Fox's sakes, Leave out of it, Ashton, You're fucking degenerate. Don't see your fucking fans on somebody because they don't don't agree with you.

Man, Like it's to Yeah, that's pathetic, man, it's pathetic. The the the lengths that this loser will go to in order to fucking get his his to keep his little echo chamber and to keep his bias confirmed. Man, it's just pathetic. It's it's sad.

It's sad. I'm overbeing it laughing about it, and now I just pity the fool man like mister t I pity this fool like. It's so bad it's it's it's cringe worthy at this point. Yeah, I just I agree with you.

And don't you think that this does This whole sit situation from beginning to end, says something about conspiracy land, like how willing, how big this guy got a huge following out of nonsense. And by the way, let's talk about the money aspect for a moment too, Because Ashton's lying and said he didn't make any money, somebody added up five thousand dollars in super chats, which isn't a lot if he's been doing this for a full year, but it's it's money. You can't lie and say I'm not making money while you're collecting five thousand dollars in super chats, plus all the monetized views for hundreds of thousands of views, plus all your friends on all the podcasts that you're on there, all making money. Well, somebody fail loads, you know.

For a million, he is a lot of money for an audio podcast. To be fair, Steven, he did allegedly donate three thousand dollars to the person who sent him that garbage arar file. So's he's lost a little bit of money too, But that's due to his own hubris, and it's due to his own desire to want to be proved. Right when he was when he finally did get that that raar file opened, for a good ten minutes, he was screaming on his live stream.

Yeah, it's about how this was a win. Yeah, yeah, he's gonna prove Yeah, all the debunkers can eat shit. We're gonna we're done. We're losers.

All the debunkers are losers. He's a winner. He's confirmed. Right.

Oh my god, the men in black are gonna come kill me. He said, I need to get this to Congress tomorrow. Congress, I'm gonna testify and coren of Congress like this guy's ego. Holy crap, man, there's not enough roommen in the room for him and his ego, Like you can only deal with Ashtar ego one time.

That's it. There's not enough space in any gime room. There's also the issue of suddenly, when people start filing for you requests to verify some of his claims, he suddenly wants to retire. You know, that's a little problematic for me, you know, like, Oh, we're finally going to get verifiable proof that you've been lying about certain things, and now you're gonna run away.

And that's the other thing. Oh, what was it like last week? Oh, I'm retiring, you know, I'm retired, But he's still going on podcasts and he's still attacking critics and devokers and whatever. You know, Uh, if you're retiring, then you shut up and you move on.

He's not. He doesn't even have the ability to shut up and move on. And what's he gonna come back with I've cracked the secrets of any gravity or some other fake nonsense. I don't think he's done.

I think he's gonna if he does pivot away from this, which I don't even believe he will, I think he's gonna keep bad. But if he does pivot away, from this, he's probably coming back with some other nonsense. What do you think. Yeah, he's just moving He's moving on to another conspiracy theory, is what he's doing.

And he's gonna try to champion that one. And that's that our black budget technology that the US government's got some kind of secret warp drive under lock and key. So he's basically going after the tee to the Alizondo folks, like and all the stuff that they've been saying, you know, from now on, or he's basically joining up with them. He's just saying, yeah, look, you know, Lockheed's had this information for sixty years or fifty years and Backwards Engine heared it, and they've got it under lock and key, and it exists, you know, and good for him.

Let him go down that rabbit hole with all those other schmucks that have tried go for it. Go for it, you asked, improved. He doesn't care about his detractors by appearing here to insult you earlier. Well, he's had the link for thirty he had the invitation for thirty or forty minutes, you know, Like, I don't think it's a coincidence.

I find it real curious that the guy says that he insulted and didn't have anything credible to say to back up the arguments. Really really, so he showed up in it. So he showed up and said, oh yeah, bunch of dick wads, and that proves that he's right. Of course, he doesn't care about his detractors.

He blocks them and he ignores them, and he just tells their opinions. Dude, what is this guy talking about? What is he even talking about? Give me a break, man, Ashton.

You can't hold a fucking argument with somebody who has got a critical thought without going into straw man arguments, deflection, putting words in their mouth at home in the matte, It's like, it's just a hot mess, man. It's a hot, hot mess of a dumpster fire. And that's why I've stepping back from it. Like I said today, I didn't even want to get into it.

But again, after the guy said what he said and acted the way that he acted on Friday in the Spaces, I felt like I needed to do a little research. And when I found out that the original creator had already come out and tried to proach Ashton was blocked. When I found out that the guy who done the recreation had been blocked. When I found out that Jonas, who had filmed the clouds, had been blocked, when I found out that anyone who asked about the portal V effects from Pyromania was blocked, I saw a pattern there of Ashton and his echo chamber, and I wanted to expose that and cast some light on it.

And I think I did that with this tweet thread. And I think it's pretty open and shut, you know. I mean, if people want to continue to go support Ashton and is you know, charging up the hill towards his windmill, go on, have fun with that. But critically thinking people, I think are going to look at the facts here and see that this guy is no good.

He's no good, his story is no good. It's all it's all bunk, and he's just playing for his own ego and his own personal enrichment, whatever that is, cash or go or both. This is all your fault that I'm even doing this because I wasn't aware. I agree with you very strongly that this pattern of blocking people who have evidence to show that the videos are fake, I think he's doing that because he doesn't want his followers on his Twitter threads to see those people and see their evidence.

You know, if he had real arguments against that, he wouldn't need to block people. And people can say whatever they want to help me. I generally don't block people if they're just asking questions or showing you know, if somebody's getting abusive, I will or you know at how you know, these nameless, faceless accounts, I love those, you know. It just I don't know where we go from here, but I agree with you that this is a waste of time.

It's a waste of time because these people will not accept any level of evidence that the videos are fits. Like, how much more do you need? It's it's the point ridiculous now, you know it is it is. We've gone into the comedy part of it, and I'm glad we're back there because that's really that's really where it needs to be.

People just need to look at this guy every time he pops up and laugh. Just laugh at him. Man, he's a he's a joke, he's a clown. He you know, he's gonna block anyone that doesn't agree with him, and you know, just tell his little story, his little echo chamber.

Good for him, man, Let him have it. I'm glad he found it again. Like I said earlier, a little hill to die on. But at this point we're just kind of beating a dead horse about it.

You know, there's not there's no evidence, no mountain of evidence is going to convince live streaming right now? True de Buoker's meltdown right. Great, Well that's too, that's kind of his m O too, Steven is to go on his wivestream and have a one sided diatribe and to his echo chamber. Yeah, he could come over here and answer and face some hardcoreians.

Come over here, Ashton, you pussy. Come on, Come on, man, you're gonna go on your live stream and stream snipe and talk in an echo chamber. How fucking weak is that? Man?

Totally fucking week. Sorry, it's just pathetic. He's not addressing us, He's he seems to be addressing other things. You know, I don't know.

I'm trying to trying to. I'm looking at it now, and it looks like he's playing other people's videos proof of reactions inside a thunderstorm generator for text fusion. What does that have to do with all the evidence that the videos are fake? You know, it's just like Jeremy Corbell debunkers.

Beware, but I can't. I can't debate you. Beware, but I can't debate you. You know, I don't even know what he's talking about.

A lot of very cool substances that literally prove that there is a chemical transmutation. Taking the fact that she's looking into the same stuff I'm looking in. Sooop, this has nothing to do with nothing to do with what we're talking about. But de Boker's beware, de bokers are melting down.

De bokers invited you to defend yourself. You were a bitch Ashton, you know. Oh, I'm sure there was a ten minute I'm sure there was a little ten minutes spree at the beginning where he's calling us all losers and things like that, you know, like that's his momo to run away to his little echo chamber and to put put show people on the screen and call him out by name. It's really it's really sad.

It's really sad man, you know. But let him out. We'll listen in the beginning. You're you're absolutely right.

And by the way, this is a transformative work. We're educating the public and critiquing the video that we are sharing. So this is fair use. Uh that makes three seventy videos one thousand percent true.

Proof he's great at math too, guys. Stream that made three seven videos one thousand percent true. Debunkers melt down chat. I love how you love how they the debunkers always make these extraordinary claims right on their posts just for attention and stuff like that.

Obviously I'm making fun of them with my post right like you notice, like my responses are much more measured than theirs are. Uh, so we're gonna have a little bit of fun tonight. There was a lot of stream by I like, but I don't know. He's one of these like redditor debunkers doing a whole stream about me, And I thought it was gonna be funny if I re streamed it, right, but it turned out to just be like really sad, right serting not to just be like super sad honestly taking up a bunch of bullshit lies and stuff like that, and like trying to pretend like the bulls prove that a show up and what a joke man entertaining.

But I'll address the points because I cry bully. He's a cry bully. We're gonna take a look at some of the debunker's meltdowns tonight. We're gonna have a little bit of fun with it.

And yeah, that's all we're gonna do tonight. I think I'm gonna after that, I'm gonna take a break and I'm gonna read a bunch of science on my own, and then we'll do some other stuff. Oh good, good for you, dude. That's the smartest thing you said all day.

Let's see. I love it. He's gonna let's start with the narrative out there. Chat.

Yeah, why did these guys so mad? That's the thing though, right, So the debunkers are so angry. Yeah, we're so angry because you're pushing bullshit with zero evidence and look at the following you've been asked. Some of us have to do real research and have actual, real facts and evidence.

We're so angry, Manny. By the way, cheers, We'll see drinking. I have another joke, girling apple or something a cloud. Man, it's so funny.

Up, like I announced my retirement. And then it's like they're desperately trying to convince themselves the videos are fake, right, I don't need to convince myself to you, Manny, I'm pretty sure the videos are fake and all the experts videos are fake. Man. It gave as agree with that.

He's got fake redit posters though, so you know, they're not even trying to convince other people's like they're trying to convince themselves. It's so weird like that, oh that Area guy. Now he's talking about you, man, I'm not talking about me. Function is he's literally promoting somebody who pretended to make the video and claim that guy's telling the truth when there's like literally no evidence and there's a ton of evidence that he was a liar, even after the guy said wow, denial.

That's a pretty hard cope there, Manny. The redditors and are literally the thing that they, you know, other people are. I don't know if they don't realize they're just projecting their own insecurities, right. I'm very secure that we have real facts and evidence and real experts on our side.

I don't know about you many Are you insecure? Are not? At all? Man?

Not at all? Just checking, just checking all. I wanted to make sure you were not insecure in your you know, in your evidence based belief system backed up by facts and multiple experts in the fields that apply are about that a plane crashed and this guy is capitalizing on it. I mean, yeah, yeah, this is ridiculous, Steven, Seriously, man, I don't even want to watch anymore of this man because this is just always what he does.

And it's just, you know, if he's too much of a tower to come over here and say this stuff and not till everybody that he loses, game over, game over, he's just gonna do what he always does and go on his own little echo chamber and talk shit about people behind their back. I don't want to entertain this guy with another minute of my time. Man, Let's get back to talk about We talked about them all you want, But I don't want to watch his story, man, I really don't. I do want to mentionine something.

I do want to mentioned something else, because once in a while, somebody throw somebody today threw at me like, oh, Aston's got ten times your followers or something like that, so your points are invalid. Like, it's not about follower count, it's about who's right, and who has the facts and evidence on their side, and who has a bunch of bullshit propping up a house of cards made of each of the cards in the house of cards is made of a lie. It's so stupid. But just just to make a point, somebody's attacking me because he has ten times We have more live viewers than he does right now, so you know, yeah, yeah, got numbers because he went on some very very big podcasts with his garbage story that's been devolved.

I mean, come on, it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that if you go on a big podcast, you're going to get a few followers. You go look at anybody who's on Joe Rogan, and the average anywhere from fifty to one hundred thousand Twitter followers just sewing up on as you let me address. It's not the best he could do, Crypto alchemist, he can call me Grandma's boy. Look, I haven't heard that one hundred times.

The best he could do is attack my appearance. That means I've already won. He can't attack our evidence because his evidence is fucking fake, okay, and he's not an expert. He can't refute the experts with bullshit, right, So go ahead, attack my appearance, attack my eye, my disability.

You know, you know, call me one eyed Willy, call me Grandma's boy. I love it when that happens because I know I've already won. They have no argument left when they start attacking the appearance, you know, yep, and the way I've never attacked his appearance, And there's plenty there to go to. You know what I want, and I'll call it.

You're personal, though, Man, the evidence speaks for itself. Let the evidence speak. I know, Stephen, and you know that. I don't like to go there, man, But when this people like him come out and try to bully people and talk shit like that to everyone else, including like Tony, who's not even a UFO person.

For him to go and do that, he's got some come uppings, man, And if he can't fucking take it, then he shouldn't be dishing it out. He shouldn't be dishing it out. If he's got thin skin and he's gonna cry about someone calling him a minecraft weep, then he shouldn't be calling people liars and losers on his fucking stream like he's just doing it on people the ugly and nobody loves them. Like I love that what he did that at one woman, and all she did was say that the videos were fake, and again with the personal attacks.

You know, he couldn't refute what she was saying in her video calling the videos faith, so he just made a video saying that she was fat and ugly and nobody loves her. Like, come on, man, this little douchebag. Man, what a douchebag? Like he's just a he's a cloud man.

Like it's so pathetic, dude, It's just so pathetic, dude. Like, I'm just I'm over and I'm glad. We got to talk about the facts, man, and I would I would love to talk about his mind. I appreciate you doing this because I didn't want to.

I didn't really want to do it, but I figured out if Manny will do it, and he's already got the outline, you know, we could go through this stuff and try to educate people. And this is how these this is how these fake stories work. First of all, they're built on a house of cards, where each of the cards in that house of cards is a lie or a half truth or a misstatement or a fake evidence, you know, And then everybody makes tons of money. I love how so many people rushed in to get him on their show.

And come on my show five times telling the same bullshit, like, come on, it's it is about money at the end of the day. Everybody's generating money out of it. So don't don't just play along. Don't don't show your audience the evidence that the videos are faked from the very start.

That's called the lie biomission. That's how these things work because they won't tell the audience the whole story, you know. Yeah, yeah, and that's been illustrated, you know, more times then we need even need to mention. Is that he's just cherry picking, you know, speculative data that fits his narrative, and anything that doesn't fit his narrative gets quickly dismissed.

He calls it people Reddit debunkers or evil Reddit people or you have CNN brain. He's got all these different little terms that are just oh god, they're so cringe worthy, man, all of them. You know. He does it to people on his live stream, he does it to people on Twitter, he does it to people in spaces, and it's just it's it's abhorrent, it's it's sad.

Just be clear, I'll be clear, because I have a feeling that you know, people are gonna people are gonna start more shit. If you're willing to debate him here, I'll I'll do that, But I don't think he's going to want to do that. And and if if he's going to come here and debate somebody, it really shouldn't be two on one. So I would just like keep time and you know, not interject my own thoughts and feelings.

I give my word on that. But I don't think he wants to face a real skeptic or critic because he can't just bowl over somebody like you that's so well informed and his hoax works because he has a low information zone audience. They don't have all the stuff that we've showed you tonight, or he's muddied the waters to try to make all the stuff that we showed you tonight completely irrelevant and a conspiracy still real. No, it's not.

It's all fruit from a poison tree. Yeah, it is that, which is a great legal doctrine which people should look up if they're not familiar with, look up fruit from the poisonous tree. And you know, just a paraphrase, it means that any evidence that's derived from another piece of evidence that's obtained illegal here in this case that's based on false evidence is fruit from the poisonous tree and goes out with that evidence. So, and that's what we're saying here is that any all of Ashton's evidence that he has that's not subjective or speculative, is all based on these videos being real.

There's no evidence that there is any sort of advanced propulsion. There's no evidence that there was sort of black budget projects that were being you know, used out their portals. Well, let's stop for a minute. Let me stop you for a minute.

There's no evidence whatsoever that the plane depicted in the video, whether it's real, fake or not, is the three seventy plane. There's no evidence that was one of the first points I knows. Yeah, there's it's you're not right. You don't see a tail numbers.

No, there's no one. Yeah, no one ever proved that that that video was Malaysian Airlines flight three seventy. No one ever proved it, you know, no, but it had to be because the guy who uploaded it to YouTube put the GPS coordinates for Diego Garcia and the YouTube comments so legedly even though they're not there anymore. It's just it's a joke man.

Everything it's it's a whole house of cards. It's come crashing down. And now what you're seeing is there's a whole lot of cope going on to to maintain the illusion that there's some big conspiracy theory when there isn't. When there isn't, there's not a big conspiracy theory.

There's no evidence that anything other than a street seventy crashed and it was a tragic event. You know, over three hundred people I think lost their lives there. And it's really sad and pathetic that somebody like this is going to rise to fame by creating a conspiracy theory around it. I'm not even creating one by Gloman on somebody else's conspiracy theory based upon a video that a guy made for background, Like he didn't even make it up.

Yeah, it's it's sad, it's tragic, but it shows the world we live in. And you know, I hope people are wisened up by this, and I hope the facts get out and you know, don't bother going after Ashton and trying to change his mind. Nothing will change that guy's mind, nothing other than his own confirmation byers. Yeah, it's clear nothing is going to change his mind.

Nothing will change no, and any arguments he makes are just ingenuous and you shouldn't be baited into arguing with them either, because that's all he wants is to argue. Are you argue and make these silly ass points that he's made over and over and over again. And it just needs to be flushed down like a bad turd. Put it down the toilet, be done with it.

You know, we're done with it. Yeah, I agree with you, but yeah, I'm gonna let you go and try to wrap up. I got to read these super chats and stuff, and I don't want you just you know, there's a big number of them here, so I appreciate you doing this, though I'm sorry for the technical problems. And by the way, just to be clear to the audience, I may have to private this video, download it, clip something out and re upload it.

So if if this video is not there after that we close broadcast. That's why it will be there back as quickly as I can get it there. I hate to do it, download and re upload, but sometimes they don't have a choice, you know, so you lose all the momentum of the live stream. But yeah, and let me just say, I'm kind of sorry to everyone for wasting your time by bringing this up again, but I felt it needed to be addressed.

You know, I don't have a whole lot of time. You know, I'm busy as hell working on getting these projects going with Bob Kivat. You know, we've got that Mandela Effect movie that's coming out here real quick, that's in the delivery stages, and you know, I don't want to take my time away from good productive work to do this stuff, but sometimes it needs to be done.

And you know, yeah, I'm just sorry to everyone for kind of having to drudge this up again, you know, I mean, but apparently it needed to be done because I don't think people on Twitter knew that, you know, or even on YouTube or even anywhere off with that subreddit knew that the original person who made the video had come out, that Ashton had blocked all these people who tried to, you know, show him that these videos were faked and that they were CGI, And I don't think people understood the level of the echo chamber that this guy's created on his little platforms. So I think it needed to be told. And I don't regret spending the time on it, but there's definitely better ways I could have been spending my time, So take that into account and how I feel about it. I feel like it's just like, really do I have to do this?

But my audience all but demanded. Once some people saw your thread, they were like, Steve, and you've got to talk about this, and like, okay, well try to. But every every time I have to, I'm forced to talk about this. I feel like that's enough, don't.

It's Brandellini's law. The amount of time and resources and energy required to refute bullshit is orders of magnitude more than it takes to create it. And I don't want to keep putting more time and energy. You know, It's like, if this any reasonable rational person sees all this evidence we show tonight, if they don't, if they still don't believe those videos are fake, we can't help you go back to delusional fantasy land where airplanes teleport out of existence to another dimension.

You know, whatever, we've done what we could do. We've saved two we could right, Yeah, yeah, we've done the legwork, we've done the research and mainly found it. Like I didn't do a whole lot of research. I just found another research that people had done, and yeah, to acknowledge it wasn't all your research, but it was easy to compile it all together and like a pretty convincing case that this person's not being honest selling this hoax one hundred percent.

One hundred percent. So there's a lot of people out there that tried and we're either bullied into silence by Ashton and his crew or yeah, well me and you are not. Both of us, neither of us are people. Yeah, I think somebody learned a hard lesson about that one tonight.

So uh yeah, be good people, have fun out there. Check out the movie I've been working on with Bob when it comes out, and I'll be around if anyone's got questions, hit me up on DMS, on Twitter. I'm always active on Twitter. I'm not doing much on my YouTube channel nowadays, having for a while.

Probably won't get got my filmmaker job, you prick, so no time for you to whatever. I love you, Steve Man, I love you Brooks, Steve. I got that filmmaker job that Steve champions God, but that's okay. No, I'm happy for you and you guys are welcome back.

When you get those out, we'll talk about them and thanks for doing that. Love to man, love too. All right, all right, good night, everybody, have a good night, take care. Thanks for having me on, Stephen.

Yeah, there's many Area five go through. Sorry about all of the technical problems, but it's nice to know that one way or the other you just roll with the punches. We had a lot of technical problems at the start of the broadcast, which I apologize for, So I want to take a moment to recognize all you kind and generous benefactors. For those unaware, we generally read every super chat, but sometimes we wait towards the end of the show.

So I want to thank high Speed Chase, who's been a member for one month and says Ashton Forbes is a wookie spanker. You heard it here. And high Speed Chase thanks for two things, being a member and a two dollars super chat, says let the super chat again. Another one says thank you Steven, and high Speed Chase gifted five truth Seekers memberships, which is a great reason why you should hit subscribe button for those unaware people by gift memberships all the time here and the way that YouTube does it is just randomly distribute the gift memberships to subscribers who are not yet members, so you could get some extra goodies.

Just by hitting that subscribe button. You could win a free True Seekers membership. We'd give a couple of extra goodies. Thank you.

High Speed Chase. Also, high speed Chase kind of generous two dollars said Art and Paranormal is amazing. High Speed Chase with another kind of generous two dollars. Ashton Forbe is more ridiculous than Beavis.

We have welcome to the show. The kind of generous ninety nine pound or what is it ninety nine pence supersticker. Thank you for your kindness. High Speed Chase with a five dollars one.

Hashton Forbes obviously does not care about the family members of flight and makes three seventy. Yeah. I don't think he does, because if he did, he wouldn't be profiting from the tragic death of two hundred and thirty nine people. And I'm pretty sure that if you called every family of those two and thirty nine people, at least some of those people would object to what Ashton is doing spreading false conspiracy theories based on completely and totally fake CGI videos and horseshit crazy nonsensical theories, you know, and the fact that he doesn't recognize that maybe he is revictimizing those people.

To me, it's exactly like the Alex Jones situation where he created false conspiracy theories out of a tragedy that has a detrimental effect. That is not a good thing to do to people, you know. In my opinion, Local five five six, with kind of generous ten dollars, says that imaginary Gnome account is absolutely Ashton's all. The account made in September of last year and only tweets vitriol to critics of Ashton.

It's him, same vernacular, same insults. Thank you for letting me know. So now we have additional proof that Ashton Forbes is using alt or sock puppet accounts to attack his critics. I wonder who we learned that from.

Maybe lou Alizondo. Right, So instead of a faceless bureaucrat, we have an imaginary Nome account. Yeah, and it's interesting. I wanted to see then if we could.

I think I blocked that person already, h though Local five five six, Uh, it's just interesting that other people are recognizing that there's these accounts and all they do is is attack Ashton's critics. That's not suspicious at all, Right, I think I think it is suspicious, you know. And yeah, I think I blocked that account. So I'm trying to find the uh, you know, I'll try to find the link to where that person was talking.

I think it should still be in there. But you know, well, it's amazing that they have to use, uh, that they have to use fake accounts, like just come at me with your real name and face. Don't be a bitch, you know, like, you know, I don't get it. I just don't get it.

And people are free to form their own opinions, but at some point you go, you know, And there was two accounts that were tweeting at

Comments & Upvotes

Transcript

Greetings and salutations friends, and welcome back today. Really by popular requests, so many people keep asking me about this what I think is an absolutely ridiculous farce of this MH three seventy video hoax. For those unt aware, these videos were originally posted by an account called regin on Regicide and non which whose YouTube channel contained a multitude of completely provably fake UFO videos. But somehow, as is often the case, we call it UFO hoax or whack a mole, these things get debunked and enough time goes by that somebody picks up a completely and totally dead proven hoax and runs with it, usually connecting new dots.

We saw this with this alien interview hoax and other hoaxes. Doctor Jonathan Reed that was another one that was completely and totally debunked. The guy goes away for a while and then he just comes back still pretending to be a fake doctor or sorry, pretending to be a real doctor. But it turns out he's not a real doctor, his education is fake.

That whole hoax was busted at the time it came out, and that's what usually happens here. Somebody does a hoax, it gets busted as likely or most likely or completely busted as fake. But along comes some opportunistic person who decides that he can still promote and make money from this hoax. And now let's be very clear, a lot of money has been made by this Ashton Forbes and his and all of the people that he's doing these podcasts with.

I was listening to a space in which somebody who hosted Ashton multiple times, and by the way I listened in on, some of them never asked him any real or critical hard questions, talked about getting a million downloads on their audio podcasts, just so everybody's aware, that's a huge amount of money that alone. But then we've got huge podcasts like Tim Kast and others, you know, jumping in to get their little piece of the hoax pie money. And you know, I was completely disappointed with some of the people that I saw even platform this because what you have to remember, I think it was Lou from Lou Reviews who said this, and he's absolutely right, is that the videos were originally posted on an anonymous YouTube account that was filled with fake UFO videos. Even Ashton admits that that account has a bunch of fake UFO videos.

So you know, to most reasonable or rational people, the discussion should end right there. These were posted by an anonymous YouTube account, which is filled with other completely and totally provably fake cgi UFO videos. But somehow, you know, a guess, to his credit, this guy picks up this completely dead proven hoax and gains a huge following, mostly by connecting the dots. And I think that, you know, we'll get into some things like standards of evidence and expert witnesses.

You know you can't have expert witnesses and virtual effects come forward and say these videos are fake and here's why. And then a guy like Ashton, who has no training, no experience, no proven track record in that field of expertise, just says, no, we debunked their debunk. No you didn't, You're not even qualified debunked their debunk. It's absolutely ridiculous.

And already I'm getting attacked by nameless, faceless, brand new Twitter accounts. And isn't that always funny that when you bust some of these fraud hoaxes, you get attacked on Twitter by nameless, faceless Twitter accounts, you know, all hurling personal insults, like an account that has six followers that is a brand new Twitter account just told me, you know, throwing insults at me. And I believe that Ashton has been using fake socc accounts. That's my personal belief and I'm entitled to it.

And here's why. Right around the time that he started pushing this hoax, a brand new, nameless, faceless Twitter account I'd never interacted with before came to me and said, hey, what do you think of Ashton Forbes and these and these MH three seventy videos? And I said, they're completely fake now, just as they were in twenty fourteen when they were debunked originally. And then again, I'd never interacted with that account, let alone interacted with Ashton, never had any interaction with him.

Immediately after I said the videos were fake, Ashton Ford's blocked me. Now I believe he's since unblocked me. But this shows that this is not an honest effort here. This is a purposeful attempt to deceive.

There's no reason why you should be blocking people that say the videos are fake if your evidence is good. But I believe that this person cannot withstand real debate, real scrutiny, which is why I believe he was going around checking what podcasters are going to help me get publicity that are going to believe this, and anybody that said it was fake, he wouldn't go on their podcast. Isn't that that's a little bit more than a coincidence to me? Of course, I can't prove that he's using soft puff accounts, but many people are saying that because I just don't.

I'm sorry, I don't believe that anybody cares at this much about these fake UFO videos to go attacking people with brand new, nameless, faceless accounts. A lot of people are telling me that he's got a bunch of side accounts. I don't know that that's true, but we have seen that tactic used by other hoaxers and fraudsters like Luel Zondo and others. If you dare speak out against the grift, they will send in the clowns to attack you.

And I believe that's what's been happening here. It's interesting and I just wanted to mention that what caused me I kind of changed my mind. I said, I'm not going to dedicate any time to this. This is stupid, but a few things have changed.

Ashton miraculously says he's going to retire from the MH three seventy hoax or grift or whatever you want to call it. Coincidentally, right at the time, people start filing foyas to find out if he's telling the truth about some of the things that he said. And let me be clear that there's a lot of dishonesty involved with Ashton and the way that he has pushed this hoax, the first of which is what I've just described to you, going and checking if somebody is going to be receptive to the hoax before you know, asking for a guest spot or whatever the case may be. And recently people have said they're filing four your requests to find out if his statements about Arrow or true.

And recently we a friend of the show Real Area of five oh three at Real Area five oh three did one Twitter thread that I think, really, and we're going to get into this tonight, really destroys this entire thing in one thread. I mean, the amount of evidence that these videos are fake is absolutely overwhelming. And sorry, not sorry. If there are three or four twenty year virtual effects veterans looking at these videos and saying these are fake, and here's why you don't get to just say no, they're not.

You have to there's standards of evidence, which means that Ashton has to put up three or four twenty year plus veterans and virtual effects that refute people like the Corriter Crew. Then there was other arguments like, oh, they can't be recreated, would take somebody six months. We've got two people that did recreations, one of which Ashton blocked and refused to interact with until recently when the pressure got too much. So there's all kinds of deceptive tactics being used to push this hoax, and standards of evidence get thrown out the window.

Sorry, not sorry if you've got on the record real people who say these are fake. And here's why you can't just pull anonymous Reddit posters who say they're from Marvel or top Gun Maverick that the videos can't be fake. You can't do that. He didn't even check that those people are who they say they are.

It's absolutely ridiculous that we're even here. But welcome to clown. This is the clown Show. And then some of these other arguments, all the pixels don't match one hundred percent.

This guy's supposed to be an IT professional, he would know that when people manipulate things in an audio or video editor or in a three D rendering program, they're going to stretch things, they're going to change things. Unless you have the hoax's exact settings on everything he used, exact filters and everything he used, it's never gonna match one. But we've got the asset used to create the teleport effect or explosion effect, we've got the original person who took the distill images that the background was faked from, and we've even got a person claiming that he made the videos. Both of those people were blocked by Ashton.

That's not a coincidence that he's blocking people that can disprove him. So we're gonna get into it all tonight and joining me uh as a special guest tonight area of five oh three, and uh, we're gonna get into this. We're going to bring him right in. Welcome, Maddie, good to see you.

Hey, what's up, Steven? Can you hear me? Okay, yeah, that was fine. Let me just check your mic volume there.

Okay, Yeah, that's fine, cool, okay, Yes, So you want to do to go through this thread before we begin to get off in the weeds. This thread of yours, I think perfectly shows why there's I don't there's no honest effort here. You know. I saw this Twitter spaces where everybody was jerking them off, telling them what great research.

And I just want to ask you, Maddie, do you use anonymous Reddit posters that you haven't verified even are who they say they are? Is that good research? No? No, it's not.

No very yeah. Yeah. You got to look at everything you know and all the facts in a case which it seems pretty clear that when you start digging into this, that's not what happened on Ashton's part, that he kind of I think I said that in the tweet. I think I said that he cherry picks speculation ary picks.

Yeah, yeah, yeah. So your thread starts off it says, what does a CGI video that has been passed off as conclusive evidence of MH three seventy being something to a portal have in common with twenty one pilots and a music video with over five hundred and sixty four million views, and and that we could get to the recreation and you go on. Yesterday I found a recreation of the CGI m H three seventy or video and posted it to Twitter because I wanted people on this platform to know its existence. Today.

In response, Ashton posted questioning technical elements of the recreation, and you know, we can get into his arguments, but they're really nonsensical. And everybody that's one of his supporters I also noticed too that they are completely and totally unwilling in my view, to accept any evidence this. Ashton said that this couldn't be recreated. Then he said it could, but it would take huge resources in six months.

This person made this recreation in one day, and I found another person that made a recreation in one day, So that alone shows that his research is worth shit in my view. What do you think about this refutation of this? It's just excuses. It's not one hundred percent exact.

Therefore the videos are still real. It's ridiculous. Why are we even still talking about this? Right?

I agree? A comedy of clowns man. It really is. There's you know, the dismissal and the rationalization that Ashton is demonsting right there.

It's just par for the course. And when you really start digging into it, you see that that's kind of his mo from day one, Like every time somebody brings up a valid point. He just rationalizes it, calls it debunked, and then moves on as if it doesn't exist. Generally ends up blocking the person who brought up the statement.

Just to be clear too, you know, people on Twitter are attacking me, going, no, you can't just show the recreation. You have to provide the assets you used and proved that they were all available in twenty fourteen. That's a nonsense argument. But the person who did the recreation did provide every asset that he used to make it.

So when we get back to Ashton's nonsensical refutation of this, he says, the fake video is immediately apparent due to the stick like figure of the plane. It looks almost exact in the recreation to the original. Why is that a stick figure? But the original video is not a stick figure, and look that supports the claim.

The top gun Maverick post claimed about how hard it is to scale down accurate. Yeah, so he's citing a fake post on Reddit. And by the way, Ashton, I'm going to challenge him on this. You can't use anonymous Reddit posters who claim they are somebody.

Show me the guy's name, his credentials on the record, that he really did work on top gun maverick or is this some random post that you cherry picked out of out of Reddit that for all we know he posted, Right, We've got these all these virtual effects experts that work for Marvel and top Gun Mavericks say the videos can't be fake, but they're anonymous Reddit posters, they're not. He didn't vet anything. He just accepted that because it fits his arguments. Somehow.

The first orb in the video doesn't come in correct, you know, it's it's all just you're right, just anything. Lastly, the zapp is incorrect and could not be recreated in after effects because uh yeah, for whatever reason. Right, well, I'm sure there were software in twenty fourteen that could do this. I just want to pour out something here real quick, Steven.

There's there's a lot of questions that he raises about the VFX, but Ashton is admitted multiple times he has zero training. He doesn't understand things like plays or matts or chroma key or opacity settings or WARPSK key frames, none of that. But he wants to make an argument he should comes across like he's an expert, all right, And the biggest point I want to make about is that if it sounds like you're breaking up here. I don't know if it's just my side of things, but yeah, go ahead, it might be mine.

I get a little bit opinion too. I need to either reboot my computer or or if you want to do that, I'll go. I'll go through your your thread and then by the time you're done, you can jump right back in. You want to try that, okay, all right, yeah, sorry about that, friends, But I hear him cracking up, so I'm you know, the audio files are going to kill me if that's uh uh is going to continue.

Yeah, and and of course somebody said he needs more than a fifty six K connection. Yeah, and you guys hear it too, so hopefully all right. So uh, you know, even with the reference that the original hoaxer would not have, the videos have never been recreated. They've been recreated twice.

So that's just a completely and totally factually inaccurate statement. As for the drone videos, no one has come even remotely close to recreating it. You know, it's like no, you know, it's like talking to a wall. There was a point at which he admitted that the videos were fake, and that's when the original person who made the background still images that the hoax was created from came forward.

And by the way, that guy had plane tickets, receipts and on the record statements from the assets store that he sold them to to prove that those existed at the time this hoax was created. But let's get back to let's get back to the rest of his thread. Area of five h three goes on to say, it turns out that Ashton has known about the recreation for months and responded by blocking the creator of the video. If Ashton has questions about the recreation, why are they asked in his echo chamber where the creator is blocked.

And this is Tony Adams who made the recreation. By the way, we're going to show you that recreation, and that's one of three. Three people have recreated these videos. It's so close that I can't believe that we still have to argue about this.

But Ashton and his followers will say, no, no, it's not pixel for pixel accurate. And again, if Ashton is indeed an IT professional, he would know that it would never be pixel by pixel, you know, one hundred percent a match because of settings, because of compression ratios, video codex because of filters that may have been applied at various times during the creation of it, it will never be exact. But this guy said these couldn't be recreated, and everybody that recreated it did it in about a day, so you know his argument that it would take six months and this and that it all falls apart. So Ashton knew about the recreation and he blocked the person who did the recreation.

Tony Adams says, this morning, Ashton forms made a post about my recreation. He got a bunch of stuff wrong, including my name, but I'm blocked, so I can't respond. This is his modus operandi, and in my experience, you know it is that and start hurling personal attacks. I love when he attacks the appearance of like the virtual effects artists who say it's fake.

That's not relevant. That's called I can't argue with this person, so I'm just going to attack their appearance because I'm pissed off that my grift is coming crashing down. Avery five h three says. Furthermore, it also turns out that the creator of the original CGI video also approached Ashton several times and told him the video was fake, only to also be blocked by Ashton, So this is the echo chamber.

If his evidence that these videos were real was so good, he wouldn't need to be blocking people that proved that his evidence is shit in my opinion, and just for those that are clear, this person, the Joe Lancaster, he did an AMA on Reddit and answered like a hundred questions about how the videos were created. But of course you've got to come up with some excuse for why that guy's deep state or one of the men in black try to cover it up, or some bullshit. So they said he can't provide the files. I don't know about you, but I don't have any files that from projects I did from ten years ago, and most people wouldn't.

But he was able to answer all the questions about how the videos were created to the satisfaction of most reasonable, irrational people. What does Ashton do block the guy so that his followers can't see that the hoaxer has been identified? Right area five h three. That's right, folks.

The creator of the original MHS three seventy abduction video came forward months ago as well as if and if Ashton had not blocked him, he could have asked any technical questions about the creation of that video as well in his recent AMA on Reddit. The original MHS three seventy videos were made for a film project as a supplemental virtual effects element to play in the background of a scene. Since MHS three seventy was not in the news at the time, the creator fashion has worked loosely on that event and added into the UFO aspect. The videos are one hundred percent fake, and here's the music video that Joe Lancaster was responsible for creating the virtual effects for both videos, and this is one of the music videos.

So again that's an on the record real virtual effects expert who says the videos are faked and I faked them and here's how I faked them. Excuses from the Ashton Camp. Airy five HT three says, this is why I never wanted to get involved in this MH three seventy conspiracy theory, because the videos have been debunked multiple times and the architect of this story chooses to block ignore counterfacts while terry picking speculative data to fill his narrative. Yeah, in other words, speculative data.

Somebody that's a virtual effects expert with twenty plus years and virtual effects comes out and says these videos are fake and here's why, and Ashton just says, no, they're not. I have my fake Reddit posters who say that the videos are real, and here's why. You know, it's ridiculous. What Action has to do is he has to understand the standards of evidence.

If you've got four or I believe we could get ten virtual effects artists look at these videos and say these are fake and here's why, then he needs to get ten on the record, real virtual effects artists, not fake Reddit posters, not people he hasn't even vetted, are who they say they are, and he has to bring them forward to refute the claims of the twenty plus year virtual effects experts that have looked at this. We've got three or four on corner alone that have looked at this and said these videos are fake. And here's why. You can't just say I debunked the debunks.

That's called research by proclamation. He has to equal the evidence. So if corn Crew has three twenty plus year virtual effects artists that say the videos are fake and here's why, then Aston needs three or four twenty plus year virtual effects on the record, real virtual effects artists that will say those guys are wrong. And here's why he doesn't do that.

He cherry picks and brings garbage data forward to refute real experts. It's garbage peddling. One oh one previous debunks that were ignored. One the pyromania portal effect was failed.

Yes, it was used in a video game, among other things. And somebody found the exact effect from the portal effect. Oh, but it doesn't match pixel for pixel one. It's so close.

It's ridiculous. And for him to continue to refute it shows that he's not being honest in his research effort. He's just looking for an excuse to excuse away real evidence. That's real evidence, right, And some of these people demanding shit on Twitter.

I love somebody demanded earlier that I recreate it using uh, you know, certain assets and share the No. Oh, the burden of proof is on the person making the fantastic claims. How about Ashton proves that a goddamn airplane, a fucking seven forty seven teleport it out of the goddamn sky. How about he proves that I don't have nobody has to.

And by the way, there's Brandolini's law. Look it up. Brandellini's law states that the amount of evidence required to refute bullshit is orders of magnitude more than it takes to create it. Look at those virtual effects artists from Quarter Crew.

They had to spend an hour or two looking at the video, trying different things, figuring out how you could fake it, and explaining it. Then we get to Ashton and he just says, no, we debunked their debunk You understand Brandellini's law. The amount of effort required to refute the bs is orders of magnitude more than it takes to create it. Ashton could just say anything, Oh look, there's a Reddit poster that says he was the virtual effects leader on Top Gun Maverick.

Did you ever prove that, Ashton? Or are you just taking the word of some anonymous Reddit poster you haven't even vetted is who they say they are. You can look up top Gun Maverick, go find out who the Virtual effects is, call them, get them on the record, ask them if they're that reddit poster. Did you do that?

And people say you should do that, Steven, No, I'm not making the claim. And by the way, Ashton has made that claim on multiple podcasts that the head of virtual effects for Top Gun, Maverick said, the videos cannot be cannot be fake. Great, then get the guy on the record. Why don't you have him on your show?

Right? But he never does that. So going on podcasts using fake evidence is bullshit. Why are we still talking about this?

It's ridiculous. Oh, we're not through. The photographer of the clouds, Jonas came forward, surprise af Ashton blocked the creator of the clouds. So, in other words, somebody took those cloud pictures and proved that they took those cloud pictures and proved that he sold them to textures dot com or whatever website somebody downloaded them from.

And then the original photographer of the clouds proved that it was his photos and how you could splice those photos together to make the fake background of these videos. What does Ashton do? Say that it's not true and block them, right, and give more excuses for why that's not valid evidence. It's excuse.

It's welcome to dumb excuses one oh one hoax or excuses. Oh. The photographer who took the picture of the clouds that were used to fake this hoax came forward and proved that he took the pictures and put them on a texture's website back then. Oh no, we have to come up with some excuses.

Oh uh, they're not available on wayback at certain times or dates, So that guy's not telling the truth. Bullshit. This photographer is again a real on the record source, right, and he showed his receipts and an on the record statement from the website that was selling the video. Excuse me selling those assets that were used to create the fake videos.

And by the way, anybody can get those assets, right, anybody, and see they have a sense of humor. They put a UFO over the assets. These are the assets used to create the fake background, and they one hundred match one match the background. Is that a coincidence?

Ashton? Like? What? Like?

I just don't get it. I just don't get it. And here we could see a JIF file one the lighter one is the actual picture that this person took and showed receipts and proof that he took those pictures of those clouts, and the other is the video using those assets to create a fake background. But we're still gonna argue that those pictures couldn't have been used to create this fake video.

And I love the other thing. Oh no, everybody that's looked at these videos has said that they're static, they don't move right, real twenty year plus veterans of virtual effects look at them. And by the way, I looked at them before Quarter Crew and said that background is a composite that's made from still images. And I'm no virtual effects expert, but I have video editing experience.

I've done some after effects and animation work. I can look at them and say that the videos fake, that the video is using fake still images. Oh no, we proved that that the clouds are moving. Ashton is not a virtual effects expert.

Show me a virtual effects expert that is on par with the experience level of Corriter crew that agrees with Ashton. He can't, he can't, he won't, right, it's just researched by proclamation. Oh no, we prove the clouds are moving. No, you didn't.

You can zoom in on them. You could do anything you want to do. And Quarter Crew proved that if these images were video were taken from the satellite, there'd be huge movement in these clouds, and the clouds would be moving and the scene would be moving. It's not because it's CGI, it's a fake.

I think we have Manny back here, But let me get back to his thread. Okay, calub download or RAR file where somebody recognized Ashton's desire to be proved right and sent him a raw file full of garbage that allegedly helped confirming evidence. Ashton naively donated three thousand dollars for this file. But remove the live streams of that fiasco to save face.

Yeah, that's suspicious as well, right. Area five h three goes on to say, And that is just the debunks of the videos. That doesn't even touch on the physical evidence countering Ashton's conspiracy theories, such as the wreckage of the plane being found. Well, there's a great number of pieces of the wreckage they have to refute all the physical evidence as well a flight simulator found in the pilot's residence where he was practicing the doom flight, etc.

Etc. Do I expect any of these facts to convince Ashton he is wrong and admit the videos are fake. Absolutely not. I suspect Ashen will not be happy until his bias is confirmed and he is cheered by the people for exposing a massive conspiracy.

Unfortunately, for Ashton. All the other evidence he has aggregated of other people's work also hinges on the videos being real, which they are not, or are based on speculation. It must be discounted. Yeah, so that's pretty much the thread that really knocks this to shit.

I don't know if Manny is back. Are you back, Manny? Yeah? Not really.

I don't know if your internet as a potato all of a sudden, what happened? You see? I've been putting it through the ringer on this trying to get these some deliverables done, and I think I might have burned up the CPU. I got to replace my hardware.

Oh great, that's bad timing for us here. I was hoping to hear more from you. Do you want to call my cell phone? I'll give you my cell phone number and we'll just put you on speaker here and we'll try to continue the conversation that way.

Either way, either way, I'm gonna get shipped from these audio file people. But that'll be a little better. Let me send you my cell phone. I'll be right back to you one second, okay for me.

Yeah, it is just a bunch of excuses, I mean, and this is something that I remember saying a couple of weeks back when somebody asked me and they asked me about this, and they said, could you recreate that? And I said, yeah, I could recreate that. I don't know all of the techniques that were used, but by that point, the cloud texture from Jonas was already out there. The portal mania or the pyromania portal effect was already out there, you know.

So when you have all those elements, you're only a wireframe model away from, you know, making the video. But I also remember saying, I'm not going to take the time to do that because exactly I forecasted exactly what these guys are going to say. I said, if it's not pixel perfect, they're going to claim it's not real. It doesn't matter if if you've get ninety eight percent of it right.

And that's because people like Ashton don't know anything about VFX. They don't understand the billions of different variables that go into creating something like that, like warp skew effects and particle generators and smoke and opacity settings and different plates with noise on them and things like that. He just doesn't get it. And even worse, instead of just asking the creator of the of the recreation to explain those answers.

I guess he did. But when the creator started to answer those questions for him, he just got mad and blocked him. He's blocked him so he could have had all of his questions answered, and he did. He just didn't like the answers that he was given because they didn't fit his narrative.

And that's that's the mo that you're going to see time and time again, is that he just asked a few questions, comes up with enough reason to rationalize or as he calls it, debunk these debunks, and then he moves on as if it's still a fact. But all through this there's been just stacks and stacks of people who have called him out or tried to confront him or tried to educate him, and he doesn't want to hear it. He blocks him, and he moves on. He blocks him, he moves on.

You know, it's just it's kind of it's kind of sad, I mean, but it's also kind of funny. I mean, it really is. It's just kind of a joke. I mean, why, like you said at the beginning of the stream, before I started rubber banding and had the ping pong out.

You know, like, the whole thing's just kind of it's kind of a waste of time. It's silly, it's ridiculous, and nobody should be believing what this guy's peddling because it's all speculative garbage from the top to the bottom. Yeah. And one of the other things I loved that he says he found the leaker of the videos.

Right, he says he found the leaker of the videos, but he didn't interview that person. He didn't confirm that that person leaked him. But oh no, I'm ninety nine percent sure of this is the guy that leaked the videos. And here's why.

And then you got to connect a whole bunch of dots that don't make any sense. And you know, this person was arrested for leaking classified material. That was just a speculative shit show bad like Yeah said that when he said, see I think see Thomas Lynn whoever was? He said that that guy was the guy who leaked him.

And his answer was when Chris talked to him about it and asked about it, his answer was, well, what else could it have been? But MX three seventy that's his answer, and Chris explained it to him and he got attacked for it then, and it was straw Man arguments at Hormon and attacks. I mean, there's no evidence whatsoever that that Lynn leaked the MS three seventy videos, and in fact, there's amount of evidence it shows that he didn't like the fact that we know the guy who fucking first place, you know what I mean, like we the guy was here. He almost came on the show tog.

Yeah. And by the way, I'm gonna in the person I'm gonna I'm gonna do what Ashton should have done, and I'm going to interview the person who claims he made the video. So anytime that he's available to do it, I'm going to reach out to him. He reached back out to Manny and said, oh, I can't make the show tonight, but he was going to do it tonight.

He just has something that you know, he had a pre existing commitment here and heard about it last minute. But he's going to come on our show and we'll talk to him about it. And you know, one of these other issues is that all the false statements that Ashton has made, Oh, it would take six months to recreate it. Then how come everybody's recreating it in a day that gives it a try?

And I get it's not one hundred percent exact, but like, how much effort do we have to go through to prove you wrong? You said it would take six months and tremendous resources. Meanwhile, anybody with the PC and a little bit of software that tried it, it took a day and did it, or at least did it to most people's satisfaction. We're looking at on screen now, these are hardly distinguishable.

They're so close. Yeah, so that the recreation that was done by the user named Tony Adams. I have a lot of respect for Tony, and I hope he's listening, and here's this. I have mad respect for Tony because Tony is a guy who does videos and stuff, but he's not a the FX guy.

And he looked at this as a challenge because he saw that the assets were there, like the Pyromania portal and the clouds and stuff, and he looked at this as a challenge as a way to teach himself some new tricks and after effects. And I have mad respect for that. So it's not even an expert, it's somebody that's just learning and they could do it. Meanwhile, Ashton is telling people would take six months and a whole studio full of you know, experts and all these resources, and no, there's hobbyists that are doing it in a day.

Oh, oh my god, Dan, that is so fucking funny because the guy who made it, Tony, he said that you took him a few days to work on, but most of that was learning how to do new things. Now that he knows how to do those, he feels like he could have done the recreation in less than an hour. Yeah, and he said that he could grow better with more of time, but he didn't. He only puts so much time into it.

So of course you could do better if you put a couple more days into it. You can make it more exact, you know. But it's so close now, And for Ashton to say these can't be recreated and then they are multiple times and he just comes up with new you're right, He just comes up with new excuses and rolls on to the next part of the grift. I guess, yeah, one hundred percent.

That to his m O. And it's not just with the videos, it's with everything else. Every time you bring up something like, you know, the rackage. He's got a million and one excuses for that, and then he just rolls onto it, their excuses, their rationalizations, and then he calls them debunks.

You know, it's absolutely it's just it's comical. It really is comical. I don't know any other way to say it, but if you know, I try to get offended by it, but I just can't, man, because it's such a fucking shit show. It's such a shit show.

The guy doesn't even realize, Like he's so self unaware that he doesn't even understand that he looks like a fucking fool of everybody in front of everybody with his stupid arguments and his ad homine the talents, but as off as as five little Twitter followers, and it gets a few little people to watch his live stream, he doesn't care. That's all he cares about. So all great, man, I'm glad he's got his little echo chamber, but there is an echo chamber of idiots. Yeah, and an estimate of the situation.

Just shared something on Twitter two frames forty nine frames apart. Contrast todjusta as well as clarity. I'm sharing on my screen now if you want to monitor what we're sharing on the screen. So what we're talking about, what are the odds that we see an orbs line up at exactly the same spot relative to the plane at frame difference, that is, multiple of twenty four frames per second with exactly the same noise profile around the plane.

We see this again in another set of frames, and you guessed it forty nine frames apart. And why is there a false color filter added onto the footage after the fact? Happy to be wrong here, but looks like this is a virtual effects job, and we'll share what he found. In other words, you know, mathematically perfect, these orbs are going around mathematically perfect.

Yes it is, and I can explain to you why, which is something that the original creator of the video explained. And this is why I laughed so hard when Ashton and people are like, oh, he didn't make it, I'm like, well, he knew the answer to this. He was the creator because there was an air during render where one frame from the noise got dropped off of the render. So yeah, and when you rendered an animation, it was very common that you had a few frames would drop right, That's how I remember it, right, So he had one frame that was dropped, and instead of rerendering the whole thing, he just went back two seconds and grabbed a frame and slapped it in there.

And that shows that not only is the CGI, but the show is the guy who made it. Yeah, it's so ridiculous, this this clown show where people are just like, oh my god, it's not frame perfect. There's it's just so fucking it's so sad and pathetic and funny to some degree to just watch this guy die on this hill that's been debumped time after time after time, and then I don't want to accept the reality that it's fake, and I think that he is in denial, Like you know, there was a point and it's in my discord where I said, no amount of evidence will ever be enough for him to for him to back down and say I was wrong. You know, at some point you have to you have to go, you know.

And I've heard him say the vast majority of the preponderance of the evidence say the videos are real. What what vast majority of the evidence? The evidence in fantasy land where you're from, Because all the evidence from available experts say the videos are fake. And here's why.

And by the way, we have another recreation that somebody made that looks exact as well, and this one I'm going to share on board for Ashton, these views are one and he's wrong. But before I tell you why I think he's wrong, I wanted to see what I would do if I was going to hoax a video like this. I wanted to make one for myself. And just to be clear, this guy did this in a day as well, and he's no huge expert.

And also because Ashton directly challenged me, okay, he didn't, but being interviewed on another YouTuber's live sto hold on, we're playing that. We're playing the video right now, the recreation. Just hold hold on for a second. Ashton kept saying the videos would be extremely hard or impossible to fake, so this is extremely difficult if they had faked this.

He said that he had even consulted with usual effects artists that had worked on Top Gun, Maverick and Marvel movies. Marvel Vfects lead, whilst claimed it would take at least six months, but as a motion graphics designer and someone who has dabbled a bit with the effects in his career, I was sure that I could do something that was similar or pretty good in much less time. But first, let's do a quick refresher on what this whole thing is about. All right, we're gonna skip the background, because we all know the background of the story.

We'll get to the part where he does his editing. Up one second. I didn't let me get past the commercial here, and we'll go back to it. I apologize one moment.

All right, here we go. Let me put that back on the screen, so you know. And by the way, I found some more people who recreated it, and every one of the recreations is you know, it's not going to be pixel perfect, but they're pretty close. This is my there's commercial for the guy.

He's got a built in commercial. Okay, hold on bank in the way that it does in the original video. A three D model was really the only way to go. Once I had the model into three D program, I animated it along a simple path, turning and banking in roughly the same way as it does in the video.

Next, I made some aliens of other advanced technologies are available. I animated these flying in and then circling the plane. And I'm only about twenty minutes in and I have the basics of my video done already, Maddie. He just said he's only twenty minutes into recreating the video and he's already got the basics of the video down.

He's got the twenty model of the plane, he's got the orbs, he's got the flight path in twenty minutes. So Ashton has made provably false statements claiming that this it would take six months and all these resources. And again this guy didn't call him out. Those virtual effects artists from that he's saying are from Marvel or from top Gun Maverick, he never proved are actually who they say they are.

That those aren't on the record sources. Those are bullshit sources, right, Yeah, that's yeah, that's not confirmed at all. And if they're going to step up and and try to refute court or crew who's got like forty someone hears of experience between the you know, three or four of them, then they should at least put their name behind that. That's some chicken ass shit to use a random guy who's like, I'm a Marvel dude wrong on Twitter, Reddit or Twitter?

Where are you from? I don't know where you's you know, and it really doesn't matter you know. I mean that we've proven that the video, yes, can be recreated, but he's still using the marvel Head talking points and top Gun Maverick talking points from random random on Reddit. He hasn't even proved they are who they say they are.

How can you put that in your arguments? It's like me to you know, Can I just post randomly on Reddit the videos are fake and I made them, and then you accept it. No, you need some evidence to go with that of who the person is, and you know whatever. Let me finish playing this recruits.

I'm heading over into Adobe after Effects, the tool I'm going to use to composite the plane and the clouds and to add all the to make it look like it was filmed on a potato. So I have a plane and I have some UFOs. Now I need some clouds. I went online, but I was struggling to find a good high res image from the right angle.

So then I figured that I could get a bunch of individual clouds and put them into a Pascal generator and make them that way. Next is the So this guy used a particle generator to make some random clouds and make the still image background. But it's it looks pretty close to the original, and I knew this one would be easy. It's not perfect, which means it doesn't count because it's oh yeah, yeah, that's the excuse.

Oh no, that the clouds are different. The clouds are different. And this guy used the exact particle, you know, the portal image thing that was used in the original bunch of stock footage that I'd already used on other projects. Different variables that you can do when you're animating a portal effect like that to where you can, yeah, you can turn it, bend it, pull it, absolutely, stretched, skew it frame by frame even, you know, and you can get down into like billions and billions of permutations of what the original settings were.

And I even wager that the original creator, Joe, if he was given just the assets that he made, would have a hard time recreating that frame by frame because of all of those different they were in a ten year old, you know, animation that he did for just you know, for a student art film. I think it was. Yeah, he's not going to remember exactly what he had for opacity settings and bit rates and and you know how he tracked the different maps, which he probably would remember the broad strokes of creating the animation. But come on, that guy's a professional VFX artist.

You know how many hundreds, if not thousands of projects as he'd done in ten years, And people want to try to pick and be like, oh, he's not the he's not the guy who made it. He can't show me exactly how he made it. He doesn't have to the original files. Yeah, let me continue this recreation video for a few minutes.

In touch would be to add all the nasty compression like we see in the original video. Why would he? Yeah, exactly, all blend together and make it harder for debunkers to find fault instant potato. I'm not unhappy with the result.

It's not perfect and it's not exactly the same as the original, but that was never really the goal. The goal was to see how much I could do with very limited amount of time, to see whether a hoax would even be possible. I only spent about an hour and a half on it. So this guy did this with his recreation manny in an hour and a half.

He did it in ninety minutes. And Ashton said it would take six months, and his fake Victor effects people said it would take six months. You knowair a bit quicker than the Marvel the effects artists, yes to. But ye, yeah he did it one four hundred and sixty times quicker than Ashton said it could be done.

You know it just at some point you go, you know what, what more do you need before you say that Aston's not being honest here? And then we can go to the we can go to the the static images first satellite video fully debunked. The source for the clouds was found, so you know, they found the exact source of the clouds that were used to create the background in the hoax. We've got the original person who took the pictures with receipts from his flight, and on the record statement from the textures dot com website saying, yes, he sold us those assets and we sold it as an asset pack and I'll share the tab with the it's it's the same aspects.

Those clouds are the same as the the person who took the picture showed and again, oh it doesn't match up exactly, but again, when you're creating a composite, you're a stretch, skew resize, so it's never going to match one hundred percent exactly that's a bullshit argument. Oh you guys have to do it one hundred percent pixel by pixel or or the videos are debunked. That just shows that they're being dishonest in their efforts here, one hundred percent. They're being dishonest, Steven.

And this right here is kind of exemplary of everything that goes on here, every every time that there's been a debunk you know, like when the Jonas clouds came out, I thought, okay, good game over. Now everyone knows what the clothes the cloud textures out there. There's zero probability that that's an actual satellite image, because there's no problem, there's no probability none that the satellite would have the same exact images from a picture taken from a plane. So that shows right here that these were stock images.

This is CGI and it's fake. And yet you see the mental gymnastics that a clown like Ashton goes through to discount it, you know, and talk shit. You need a whole stream about how he's talking about Jonahs and how he's not he's suspect, and there's all these different little Yeah, well you just got to muddy the waters, right man, He just muddy the waters enough for the people to still believe it, just put enough doubt that that guy's not on the record. By the way, you know that guy hasn't been caught lying.

Ashton's been caught lying in my view because or at least being dishonest, using fake Reddit posters as the evidence. And somebody put up a great message in the live chat. He's on his stream saying he hasn't made any money, but he's made five thousand dollars already, and his superchats prove it. They've been totaled up, so he made least five thousand super chats, plus the added revenue hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of thousands of monetized views.

His channel is monetized. He is added up six dollars per one thousand monetized views. Hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of thousands of monetized views, plus five thousand dollars in super chats. He's probably made ten or twenty thousand dollars from this.

Show your YouTube statistics if you haven't made any money. Of course, he has made money, and so have all his friends that have platformed him. You know, there's some podcasts that had him on five times because they love the view camp, right, So they're all making money to sit there and do the circle jerk and not show any of the evidence we're showing tonight. Yeah, they definitely are making money.

And Ashton's made a lot of money off the super chats as well. Just like you said, I know that during the Caleb rher Dowlload fiasco, I was watching one show where within ten minutes he had gotten almost three hundred dollars in superchats, you know. So like, I don't know what his total numbers are, and I don't really care, but for him to say that he's not making money off this is a little disingenuous. In fact, you know, you can call it a lie.

I mean, sure, he's definitely making money off it, but I honestly, I don't think he's in it for the money. I think he's in it for the ego. Oh, Ashton says he hasn't asked to come on the show, hasn't been asked to come on this show to defend himself. Well, considering Lou's connection problems, I'd be happy to do that with him and Lou another time, because if I bring Ashton on, you know, with the situation we have right now.

They can't really converse back and forth right now, or you know, I don't know. If we let Maddie go and I'll bring him on, I'd be happy to spend him an invitation, but I'm not gonna sit here and listen to bullshit for two hours. Either he brings evidence or I'm hanging up on him. I'm not going to sit here and listen to fake excuses and bullshit arguments for two hours.

I have no obligation to do that. He's been dishonest about this thing from the very beginning. Yeah, you know, maybe I can try to connect through the browser on my phone so you can bring us both in. If Ashton wants to come on, bring him on, man, bring him on.

Yeah you want to try that, you're going to try. I got a few more things to share, so you've got five minutes to set it up or get it ready here. Maybe have a spare I don't know if you have a laptop beside your desktop or something that you can try. But the connection was terrible.

I don't know why it's always been good before when you've come on. Yeah, I'm having hardware issues. Like I said, let me. Let me try to get on my phone and see if I can get in, and then you can bring in ash I'd loved it.

I'd love to hear what you have to say about this. All right, Let's get a try. Yeah, I think you just need headphones and then your phone. Mike should suffice.

You should be able to connect through stream yard through your phone. Yeah, definitely, let me try it. All right, great, bye bye, all right. I apologize again for the for the problems.

We're going to try to get Manny back here. I'm just playing this recreation yet again. And there are some other things that I could certainly share. I will say this, not every podcast just did the circle jerk.

And I think Danny owns, despite whatever I think about him, for other guests, you know, and platforming certain people, he at least tried to, you know, hold Ashton's speek to the fact that that's that's real, it's not fake. So putting it received date four days after the plane went down, that makes sense because they want to convince people that it was right after. So the narrative that you're building right now is that regisicided on and somehow in on it, that they are somehow involved in producing it. That's that's the speculation.

Yeah, So that's the problem now is that you have to begin if you want to think these videos are fake, you have to begin with regicided On somehow being involved in it. And now this is immediately going to be contrary to the previous assertion that perhaps the military had to be involved in it. And this is part of the reason why we've ruled that narrative out is that you can't have both be true unless you think reticided On is part of the military industrial complex. But what we just saw from the previous image, he has stuff that says debunked, he's not doing what you just claimed.

And he also a ghosts of Boys of Ground. Right, so this isn't exactly the most credible. This doesn't screen to me a person who's trying to convince people that stuff is real. This also doesn't screen to me this is a person who's cgi and stuff themselves.

This is just somebody who's being given videos that they are posting on the internet. Right, what does that mean? You know what that? Uh, there's no way to know that because this is all speculation on the part of Ashton.

Videos subidos means what does that mean in Spanish? I don't know where we're looking from. Let's see where it says under videos. It says videos subidos.

And yeah, if you're doing that, then your butt comments right. Oh two, buttholes look alike doesn't mean there's stinkingly matching left to right right in an original work, you're being creative. You're creating your own thing right in that situation, you're not going to take a visual effect, and then you're not gonna be able to modify it to what we see in our videos because you don't have the frame of reference to modify it like that. You can only do that after the fact, after the fact.

Okay, Well, if I'm trying to make a video of a plan disappearing inside of an explosion, you would use an explosion? Yeah, I can. I would use an explosion effect. I wouldn't make the explode, I would.

That would be the most obvious thing I would do. Yeah, And that's the thing, So why did they not use an explosion effect? They did use an explosion effect, but Ashton is unwilling to accept that they did, citing stupid arguments. Oh, it doesn't match one doesn't pick flow by pixel.

But we've got an explanation for that. Uh. In the other videos, people stretch things, people move things. Let's go back over to the to this video.

You up damning evidence as well. I have damning testimony. I found the stock footage. Yeah, rather, we didn't some people on Reddit this is a stock footage clip from the nineties.

Oh well, yeah, there's a clip in the video, and here is the stock footage. The Corridor crew debunked the whole thing with one trip to Reddit, but I couldn't just take their word for it. I had to check it for myself. I tracked down the Reddit post, found the link to the stock footage.

And by the way, this guy is very honest in that he will say it doesn't match one hundred percent, and I agree, it doesn't match one hundred percent because people stretch things, move things, resize things, skew things, hit download min It's so close, though, that the odds of it being anything else is astronomy. Heart was pounding. It felt like I was solving some kind of huge, world changing mystery, even though I definitely wasn't. Boom.

I got it into Adobe After Effects and started scaling rotating, repositioning all the time hearing Ashton's words in my head. This is like saying that my butthole is your butthole because they're similar. Oh, the butthole argument. And there it was.

Ashton was right. The clips didn't exactly line up. The shape in purple is the original footage and the shape in green is the overlaid stock footage. They were close, but it still wasn't right.

And then it struck me. Visual effects is not a strict process. Artists are always stretching and warping images to fit their purposes. What if the hoaxer had just distorted the stock footage during the creative process.

It could also be that he added some sort of filter to it, some sort of overlay, changed the size, the position. Any change to the original footage would mean that it won't one hundred per pixel by pixel match. And you know, Ashton's pixel by pixel argument falls apart from anybody that knows anything about creating virtual effects knows that people's changed things. They skew them, They resize to fit whatever you know, rescale, rotate, any change or filter would mean it would not fit one pixel by pixel, So I stretched it just a little bit and Bingo virtually a perfect fit.

And with the random nature of explosions, I find it incredibly hard to fathom the odds of these two shapes lining up so closely. But what about all of Ashton's really quite compelling evidence, you know, the weather conditions, the satellite data, the Boeing seven seven seven turning circle. Could a hoaxer have just got really lucky? Yeah?

I believe that a hoaxer could get lucky. And let's go back to this one where he's citing fake virtual effects artists. So here's the thing. Let's pull it up and see I have the super imposed one right here.

So let's look at this together. Okay, So see this is an explode are you there now, Manny? He bounced back out this live show closure effects. This is not what our video is.

And so if you were faking it, you would use the explosion effect. You would have this plane blowing up. Our video is going to show an endothermic event, a cold one that's absorbing energy because it's black, right, yeah, because it's cold and the thermal and you can see that here we can, and here's the nonsensical arguments for why it doesn't match while it's being shown to pretty much ninety nine percent match. Pretty tell that this what we're looking at here is not the same?

Do you do you? Are you? There's a there's a tool that you can use in Adobe Premiere or in Adobe Photoshop where you can invert the colors and change the illumin not only the illuminance, but you can change the balance of the colors, the vibrance of the colors. And you can basically invert something that's black to white, or you can change something.

You can even change the color from purple to pink. Now, tell me a story, is why you're doing that, given the fact that we knows as an original work, Why are you not just using it like the like we see on the screen right now? I don't know, because virtual effects artists always add things like filters or changed at scale or resize it. I don't know.

When I use an effect, I almost never use it completely and totally stock. Are you there now, Manny, Yeah, I'm here? Can you hear me? Okay?

Yeah, that's much better. At least we've got a decent connection. Sorry about no video, friends, but at least he's got a decent connection. So let me get the let me get the invitation link and i'll see if I can't send it to Ashton.

We certainly would wouldn't mind hearing his you know, his explanation for all of these things. Yeah, well you do that, Steven. Let me just say something here too, like Ashton wants to argue about the VFX in both the recreation and the original host video, the original CGI one, and if he had questions, he should have asked the people who made them instead of better them and ignoring them and then calling them losers on his live stream and sticking his morally devoid fans to go fucking attack him like a clown, like, come on, man, it's it's ridiculous. He wants me to explain why somebody else did something, and he could have just asked that guy or he did and he didn't like the answer he was given, so he plucked them and ran away so he could just run with this story.

Man. It's it's absolutely childish. It's it's fucking comedy. When you step when you step back from it for a second and you look, you're just like, oh my god, this is such a fucking joke.

And this pencil that my craft playd weep is gonna fucking solve a conspiracy theory. Like it's just I just find it so fucking funny, man, so funny. So bring him on, man, I hope it comes on. I really hope he does.

Well. His dms are not open, so I'm setting him DM me for invitation to join our live stream. I have the link ready. So yeah, that argument falls apart too.

I mean, you know, he's free to come and trying to defend this kind of stuff. But you know, yeah, and we'll hear the same argument we've heard before, you know, Steven, it'll be the same old ship. It doesn't match Pixel perfect. He doesn't have the original source files.

You know, it was this C. Edward Later, whoever the guy's name is, who got it, because what else could it have been. He's the one who leaked on. I mean, it's just it's it's it's a whole house of cards that's built upon these videos being real and new Slash the fucking videos are fake.

The creators come out and see how they were made. That's the joke of the whole thing is in every single one of his arguments, everything that he's built just crumbles when you realize that the videos are fucking fak man. Yeah, I just want to show so much times I want to show an example of this nameless, faceless, brand new Twitter account. All you have is on at homin and illogical arguments.

You matrix want to be looking MF for how much are sly is in the matrix? Well, you know I'm half blind, So now you're attacking somebody's disability. Maybe you should put some of that money towards an education, you f and half with, like, this is what happens when you show people the truth. You bunch of delusional idiots that want to believe an idiot that's pushing long debunked videos.

They were debunked in twenty fourteen when they first came out almost instantly, But here we are ten years later and people still want to argue that they're not fake. We have the's still images used to fake the background. We have the explosion effect from a virtual effects pack that matches ninety nine percent, but it's not one hundred, So the videos still aren't debunked. According to these people, It's like no amount of evidence is enough.

It's Brandellini's law. How much do we have to do to prove that the videos are fake. How about Ashton proves they're real for a change. Yeah, it's already been proved that they're fake, you know.

I mean we talked to Joe the creator. He did an exhaustive AMA on Reddit where he answered any and all questions that people would have had, hundreds of questions, tons and tons of questions, and he had an answer for everything that only the creator would have, including some stuff only the creator I should have known, like the answer to the question posed by estimate of the situation about those two frames. He explained that in detail about why that happened, and not only mean it took him an hour or that don't mean to take them days to come up with answers, or that he cherry picked answers. He answered every fucking question on there, every question, and if Ashton wanted some answers, he should have been there.

He should have been there to talk to Joe and ask questions. The problem is he just didn't like the answers that Joe was given, which is why he blocked Joe and Joe for his tape to him and said, hey, I'm the one who made those asked me anything you want. He had from what I understand, Joe. I will never block somebody who's asking me valid questions or showing me evidence counter to what I've presented on my show.

But when people come at me and start attacking my discipline and cursing at me, Yeah, especially when they're a nameless, faceless, brand new account. And I think I know for a fact, I believe that Ashton's using fake account. He gets emotional and pissed off and people trying to pull him back to reality from this nonsense, you know, mission that he's been on, and no matter what he does, he's never going to prove those videos are real. He's never going to prove it.

There's just too much you can't because they're they're not they're not real, they're fake. There's no if anymore. The creator's been found. And this is part of the thing that really rubs me.

Wall And I didn't get a chance to explain this, but you know, when when seventy stuff came down and it got hot again, you know, a year or two ago, and read it, which is I think we're asked and glogged onto it. I didn't even buy into it because I already looked at this stuff and I was over it. I was over it. I'm like, this is all garbage.

I'm not into it. It's it's it's it's bad taste to bring this up to the victims of the family. It's just bad taste. And so I stayed out of it.

Now Fluss for I was in that space with Ashton, and I had said something along the lines. I had said something along the lines of We'll never be able to prove or disprove that this is faker will unless the original creator comes forward. And Ashton was in that space, and he knew damn well that the original Creator had come out months before that, months before that, and tried to contact him, and he had blocked him and ignored him and discounted his opinion and found reasons to not listen to him. And he didn't mention any of that.

He didn't say, oh, well, we know who the creator is this this guy named Joe. Hell No, he didn't. He sat there with his mouth shut like a fucking gimp and let people just think that the original Creator has never been found. The original creators out there.

His name is Joe Lancaster. He almost came on the stream today with us to talk about this because we're actually talk to him, we'll try to get him on Yeah, yeah, well we'll talk to him and here is evidence. But you know, it appears to me that, you know, they're just going to excuse that a way too, you know, like, oh, well, he can't produce the files, therefore we can't we can't them. You know, of course there are Stephen one man.

There's no amount of evidence that is going to convince Ashton Forbes that his hill that he chose to die on and his only claim to ten minutes a shame is going to be going away because it's all predicated on a couple of fake videos, which, by the way, folks, and I'm not sure if you know this, there was actually three videos that Joe made, not to two of which got leaked out, but the third wasn't leaked out. It was a cell phoned footage of the same event from inside the plane, and he said that the reason he believed that it didn't get leaked out was because it looked like crap and it was easy to tell it was cgi. So there's a third video out there that this guy's made about this. It's it's absolutely ridiculous.

It's I mean, The fact that somebody could take a couple of de bunch videos on the Internet and turn them into a conspiracy theory that you know, I guess a lot of people still believe is frightening to me. I mean, what's next. I mean, if Ashton Forbes can do this, holy crap, man. And I know he couldn't do it all.

Oh, he had to have gotten platformed by some big name YouTubers and big name podcasters and a couple of other people's clouds, right because their UFO stuff and the conspiracy theory stuff is the biggest, you know, performing videos they've done. You know, like it's it's it's scary, man, It's scary, you know, like it really is. It's I hope people really do wake up and say, God, I need to be a little bit more skeptical about some of this stuff and question some of it. And when people are trying to call it out time after time again and have made good, good points like fighting the clouds or fighting the portal video, or recreating the video or actually fighting the guy who made it, maybe you should pay a little bit better attention people, you know, and I know a lot of people did it just discounted it, but a lot of people still believe this crap, and it's it's ridiculous, man, It's just it's it's it's it's a comedy of fools, man, a bunch of clowns, a bunch of clowns who don't care about, you know, investigating any claims or counterpoints and only care about making clicks and views and making money.

And then on the other side, you got a guy like Ashton who's in it, I believe for his ego, you know, like just to stroke his woefully deficient ego and give him his little shot in the limelight. Well, who ah, man, you got it, you got it. I just wanted to apologize because I see a bunch of super chats and everybody knows we read them all, but we'll read them a little bit later in the show. I had too much, too many things going on and you know, problems to juggle here.

But I wanted to share the car to Crew video for the benefit of people who haven't seen it, because it's like six minutes long. But you know, and the issue that I have with Ashton, a big issue that I have with him, is that he doesn't understand standards of evidence. If we were in a court of law and I brought in three or four virtual effects experts with you know, a proven track record and experience level and education level and virtual effects, and those or four experts all said these videos are fake. And here's why the court would not accept Ashton just saying.

But some anonymous Reddit posters said that different Marvel or you know from top Gun Maverick and they and they said the debunks are deep, are debunked, Like they wouldn't accept that. There's standards of evidence you need the same level. Show me your four virtual effects of artists that say that these guys are wrong, and explain why they're wrong. He can't, and he won't.

Yeah, he won't, Steven. It's textbook confirmation bias is what it is. He will only listen to evidence that supports his claim, and he will find any excuse, no matter how ridiculous, to discount anything that doesn't fit his narrative. Man like.

And it's I laugh about it, but it's kind of sad, exactly. It's funny, but it's also sad at it. It is kind of sad. You know, at some point when you observe that this person will not accept any level of evidence that the videos are fake.

At some point you have to you have to admit he's not going to accept any proof that the videos are fake. He's just gonna explain away. Muddy the waters, deny, deny. Try to punch holes in the debunks if you can.

They're not pixel perfect. It's not one hundred per a match, you know, But let's do the let's do the corridor they debunk is pretty good. Talking about them again, people claiming they have undeniable proof that they're real. Let's start by watching clips.

Okay, that's a white thing. The whole frame get brighter. So one of our base requirements is multiple witnesses, multiple camera angles. This one comes with a second clip, just like, who's wire?

What is this plane doing? They're they're taking like a vasive maneuvers. Who's filling this? Like what what's going on?

Like? It's also why is it so shaky? Because it's like should be on a nice smooth gimbal, But there you have it. It's a weird one.

Wouldn't that be cool if that was real? Well, actually, no, that'd be terrible because you know, there's a lot of people on that plane. Although I guess they're not diamonds bringing a new dimension. Yeah, they might be living it up.

The YouTube channel since this was uploaded does not exist, no original footage, just YouTube videos. It's not it's not good. Your original footage is a YouTube video. Yeah, that's a that's a step.

Guys. Is this real or is this VFX? I'm getting VFXI vibes right now. The first angle is something you could do very simply.

The second one is way weirder. So people have said that because these came out so quickly after the airline disappeared, that they'd be possibly to the effects. How how fast have you, guys? Do these shots too much?

Real? Fast? Yeah? As little as an hour, you know?

Yeah, and there you go. That also is a real virtual effects artist who's refuting Ashton's claim that it would take six months and he couldn't have faked these. It would take too long to fake them. There was two months between the original plane disappearing and the fake videos appearing on the internet.

It's plenty of time to make these fake videos, in my opinion and in the opinion of virtual effects experts. I love the fact that he said an hour there, Yeah, he said an hour well, that other guy said he did the majority of the work to recreate him in twenty minutes. So again Ashton is talking out of his ass when he says it would take six months. He said that on how many podcasts has he said it would take six months?

You couldn't do these in that short amount of time. In two months time, you couldn't do it. Meanwhile, real virtual effects artists who know what they're doing and talking about are saying an hour. The other guy he did the advanced majority of the work to do the recreation in twenty minutes.

Okay, after analyzing this footage, it became clear to me at this is visual effects the thing that stands out most to me. So we go back to that first clip. Look at the background. Are we a satellite?

Assume more satellite. Do you know something weird about the background. Although the clouds are not evolving in any way, shape or form. Nothing's evolving.

Yeah, clouds don't stay that. That's still for thirty seconds set a time, and I don't know. I've been over the background. There's no movement to my eye, but I'm not an expert.

But these experts say there's no movement of the clouds. Aston refutes that with bullshit, fake excuses and evidence. It's a sale frame. Thank you Red.

Hey guys, how fast the satellites go? Seventeen thousand miles an hour? Yeah? Would you jump to the footage of the International Space Station?

Oh? Matter is that satellite? It can't be sad if there would be parallax between the clouds in the ground, that's a big one. But you know what, that doesn't rule out the thermal shot, right, what's up with that thermal shot?

Thermal cameras like they don't have they don't have grain. It's not under exposed footage. And if there's any sort of noise pattern, notice noise pattern. It's a idea of like image is underg almost like a dirty lens.

How do you make it look like it's thermal? Well, there's a filtering after effects called COLORAMA. What COLORAMA does is it goes, all right, let's take black to white and instead of do black to white, we're gonna fill it in with different colors along the way, a rainbow, a spectrum, and then you know that looks like thermal footage. It's just not accurate.

Owever, in this case, we see the engines are hot, so maybe you go in touched up the engines, give them a little track some like heat points on, so they were able to recreate the fake thermal in seconds with a filter. I think that's. Yeah, it's not good evidence that this doesn't take six months to do it. You know, no it doesn't.

These are some pretty basic VFX tech techniques and tools that they're talking about here. We're not talking about the uh, you know, the end scene from Avengers endgame. You know, we're not talking about Marble level stuff here. This is stuff that that pretty much that I could do, and I'm by no means of VFX express but I do to after effects, you know, and then I could do this though.

The weird thing I'm noticing with the thermals is on that shockwave in the second clip, Like how cold is that shockwave? Is that like a Is that like a zero? So I'm confused why it's so dark when like we clearly see the engines are Oh he's got he's got an explanation for that. It's some kind of thermal like hot points.

We're geting the yellows the reds. Because if it's a super dark hole, why is it so brightener and then the other one. It's like a pitch black abyss. The crazy thing about thermals is they see through mist and smoke and all that kind of stuff.

If you look at this clip from veritassium, we can't see him. A photons can't pierce the fog, but that that deep infrared, that long wave like the bread goes right through it. The fog is invisible to infrared. So that's another one.

So some of the clouds might be invisible, the contrails would be invisible to the thermal and they're not in the video. They're clearly visible. So that's there's another data point that points that this is virtual effects. This is not a real thermal video, so those contrails shouldn't even be showing up on thermal.

The undergoing footage is it's a three D render on top of a still ring of clouds on top of the still frame clouds. And the reason it is is the particle effect the trail from the plane. Those are sprites overlaid on top of each other, giving us this additive stacked capacity which creates that build up in the highlight that we see there. If we were to do a volumetric smoke simulation of a similar trail like that.

You would see that it doesn't overlap, and it has more consistent values across the whole arc, not just where it's you know, occluding itself. It's a CGI render. Setting this up in three D is almost trivially simple. You lay a path, you said, an object to follow the path, you know, a little triple helix for the other objects.

And by the way, manny do these guys concur with the people who made the recreations. So we've got aupule a lot of people agreeing on how this could easily be faked. But Ashton has excuses for all three of them, a row, all three different. Know, we've got Tony Adams, We've got the other person who did the recreation and quarter crew.

He's saying they're all wrong, all of these experts and virtual effects are wrong. But he has wrote that the guy who admittedly, thank you, that's what I was gonna say, the guy who's never touched after effects in his life, is right. He is the moral or the ultimate authority on what VFX are not the people who do this ship for a living. And that's why it's again just such a joke.

Man, it's just it's so it's so bad. It's so bad. Well, let's finish this up. Man, put a particle emitter for the contrails.

I'd be curious to see when this came out versus when the sprite trail tutorial on Video Copilot came out. I think it was roughly around this time. But the bion do you have damning evidence as well? I have damning testimony.

What if you tell me that this is the shock wave? Do we have this stock wave on our server? We do now? Actually, so the actual are the actual asset used to fake the video?

They found it, but hey, it's not it's not pixela it's not match. So they're wrong. I found the stock footage. Yeah, rather we didn't.

Some people on Reddit this is a stock footage clip from the nineties. Oh hell yeah, there's the clip from the video. And here is the stock footage Cinderella baby Crella. That's slip right on.

Wow, I s a dude, an identified stock asset. Some people have said, you know, pixels don't match perfectly. You know what, of course, they don't match perfectly. I don't have the exact settings of the used but you look at it it's the exact same.

I can't yeah, like I literally can't wear these glasses anymore. There's like nothing, it's just so debugged. This is visual effects. It's really well done visual effects.

So I had the joy of being a guest on a podcast, the Danny Jones Podcast. They had a UFO believer who believes that this footage as we all come on the podcast, and they asked me to break down if it was visual effects or not. And I presented this. Danny sent me the reaction of the UFO ologist.

So as a statement of fact, those do not match. Dude, it is exact saying that my butthole is your butthole because there's but we don't have the same butthole because of that. So if you want to see our in depth for response to this UFO believer when we have that on our website, orderdigital dot com. We're not trying to get to a super deep back and forth back and forth here and on the YouTube channel, but yeah, so we're there from We'll go check it out, and of course you can watch the actual moment over on Danny Jones's podcast.

There's link in the description below. Go check it out. Well, guys, I've heard your complaints. I know you're you're tired of looking at okay so that they debunked a bunch of other stuff.

So you know, I just think, like, how much more do you need, Manny before you say the videos are fake? You know, I don't need any I'm saying they're fake right now. I'm saying that they're fake. I'll stand behind it.

I could take my evidence in front of a jury of my peers and prove my case, and I feel very confident that I would win, as especially when the defense to it would be trust me, bro, what else gonna be? It's gotta be real. It's Edward Lynn. It's it's gotta be real because aliens zupp ship, Like, come on, man, there's it's just a joke at this point, and it's a going back to what you said at the beginning of the of the episode here of the podcast.

It's it's it's a waste of time. It's a waste of time. There's somebody said, even temple ate him alive too. I haven't watched that whole thing.

I start watching it, I just didn't get through it all. But you know the fact that so you know I could be wrong. Maybe some people did hold his feet to the fire. Besides Danny Jones, Danny Jones is the only one that I that I saw that really said, you know, look, here's these virtual effects experts and they all say it's fake.

They all unanimously agree. So all three of them, four of them are roll from Cornor Crew, plus the two people that did the recreations. They're wrong too. You know, at some point you have to say, you know, again, Ashton's not a virtual effects expert.

So when you have all these virtual effects experts saying these are fake, and here's why he's got to come up with better than no, they're not. You know, yeah, the kneer nater poopoo defense doesn't work here. Sorry, these videos are depunked. It's game over.

They're fake, they're hoaxed. And that's even not even taking into account the fact that the guy who made him come out and said, yes, they're fake, you know, like we've got to look at all the evidence here, and when he added all up, yes they're fake, they're bogus, their garbage. I mean, he did good work. I'm not trying to talk any any kind of smack on the work.

That Joe did. He did really good work for what he had to do in the time that he was given to do it. And the assets that he was creating. He was never creating a full screen element that was supposed to be a primary shot in a picture.

These were the background elements. Yes, they were going to be playing on a computer screen in the background, real small as a kind of homage or a kind of Easter egg or something like that. And you know they were never designed. Yeah, they should never have gone to the public.

To be honest with you, I was going to say, just to be clear, you know, for people that are gonna try to slag us, his dms are not opened. And I tweeted at him DM me for an invitation to join the live stream. I have the link ready and that was twenty minutes ago. So you know, he can join if he would like to.

But you know, I don't think. I don't think. You know, he has avoided critical people like the plague because he kind of melts, you know, under scrutiny. He melts.

He knows he can't address the specific virtual effects claims, says christ Lee TV, because he has no knowledge of them. This is why he's not engaging directly with any virtual experts aside from insulting and blocking them. Yeah, and why block the guy who found the assets that were used to create the hoax? And why block a guy who claims that he created the hoax?

If you're if you're you know, really honest in your research effort, you would want to go through that with those people. He has blocked them so that he so that, I think, so that his followers can't see their evidence. He doesn't want to let his followers see the evidence. Fundy doesn't want them to see that the guy who made the videos come out one hundred percent.

He wants to to keep his little echo chamber just like it is so that he can continue to ask these stupid, fricking questions like why isn't a pixel perfect? And how people go, yeah, it's not pixel perfect? Yeah yeah, Like come on, man, even I said it, Corter Crew said it, other people have said it. Now, it's it's game over, Ashton, game over.

It's done. These things are done. There's cgi there's there's just no there's no coming back from this. And like I said in the tweet too, every little bit of evidence that he's got, including that there's hypersonic tech out there in Portal Tech and UFOs.

It's all based on these videos, which means it's all garbage. We found the guy who leaked them, but he's wrong because somebody else claimed that he both created and leaked them, you know, or somebody that he knew got them and right. But the guy that he claims leaked them is a huge speculative jump that has no basis in reality whatsoever. The guy who he claims leaked them was charged with something else it was.

It wasn't even fucking videos. I don't think it might have been photographs, or is information about our nuclear capabilities or information about our spy satellites. There's no indication whatsoever that the man that he claims leaked these videos had anything to do with them. None.

His whole answer with Chris put held him to task on it and the spaces on Friday was what else could it be? But at made three seventy and I'm thinking, fuck, it could be unicorns from Narnia. It could be fucking doors from Middle Earth. I mean, it could be anything.

You know you're gonna go with them then if you're just going to take some fanciful fucking argument out of thin air and go with it. Why not? Why not doors and unicorns? I mean, that's it's just evidence to show that it was that as it was Ashton's story about UFOs or man made black Tech.

Give me a fucking break, man. That's why this whole thing is so comedic. It's such a joke man, because you literally could take unicorns and dwarves and put them in Ashton's arguments and they'd all be the same. It would make no difference whatsoever, because there's just as much evidence none.

No, we have we have in our live chat, we have crash Lee TV who also did a recreation and Ashton didn't want to talk to him. So how many people doing recreations that look almost exactly the same does Ashton not want to talk to And we'll share a little bit of that video. He's using the zapp virtual effects with after effects to show out it was the asset. You know, it's just so stupid, like how many people have to tell him he's wrong and he's still gonna you know, it's like no, no, no, no, no, no, I can't hear you, you know, like that doesn't work anymore, Ashton.

This is why he's retiring because I think the heat's getting too much for him. He can't explain these things away with fake evidence anymore. And at some point you have to say, you know, I get it. People love conspiracy theories, but when you have all these data points pointing that the videos are fake, and all of these experts and people able to do the recreation.

When he said it couldn't be done in two months time, people did it in a few hours. That are experts virtual effects like and he's no expert. It'd be like me going to a diatrist because I have cancer. You don't go to a pediatrist if you have cancer.

If you want to know about virtual effects, so you go to a virtual effects expert. You don't go to somebody that has no training in that field and trust their judgment. Like trust me, bro, the videos are real. Well, we've got all these virtual effects experts that say they're fake.

And here's why why are we still talking about this? And then all this comes from it's all fruit from the poison seed. It all comes from a channel that posted fake UFO videos, So it's all fruit from a poison seed. The tree is poison to anything coming from the fruit of this poison seed is also poisonous.

He's stacking all kinds of shit on top of this, you know, trying to you know, I don't know, put push square peg, you know, push a square peg through a round hole. It just doesn't make sense, you know. Yeah, he's picked a hill to die on, and good for him, man, you know, Unfortunately it's gonna be a long, horrific and comedic death because everyone now is just laughing at this fucking fool man. You know, anyone who's got any kind of common sense is laughing at him.

Well, he just clear. I don't really want to personally insult him. You know, the evidence is enough. You don't even need to get into the laughing at him for you know, people and I will say that people have attacked him, but maybe deservingly.

So if you're gonna make fantastical claims on the internet, you better have fantastic evidence, not a bunch of bullshit that you cobbled together that doesn't make any sense, you know, And like, what is the endgame here? Okay? So before it was Aliens teleported the plane away. Now people are saying no, no, he's saying it was the government.

So the government has teleportation technology, and they teleported an entire plane somewhere, but not an entire plane because parts of the wreckage were found at different places, right, so parts of them. So I guess when they teleported it. You know, pieces of the plane fell off during the teleporting process. And you're right, you have to ignore all this physical evidence.

And by the way, I think they're going to find the vast majority of the plane. I think they're going to find it eventually in the next year or so. If the government teleported that plane. Even if the government hypothetically teleported that plane, where are the people that were on board?

Where are the fricking people? I'm people? I mean, are are we going for? I think they would unless their families are some kind of actors or something.

Is that what he's claiming. I mean, I've never heard him say that, but I don't I don't even know. Man like his his theories don't seem to make much sense to me because they just don't pan out. They don't pass mustard.

You walk them past the sensational front, you know, uh, basic arguments that he has and what's his explanation for where the where the victims of the Crash went, I mean, I I just don't get it. I don't I don't get it. And it's it's very it's very distasteful, and that's why I stayed out of it for so long. But after this this spaces with him on Friday, where he started attacking people.

He attacked Chris, he attacked me, attacked anyone who was questioning, and then he had the balls to cut me off when I was trying to explain that the preponderance of evidence shows that these videos are fake, and he had the balls to cut me off and take actually, the preponderance of evidence shows that they're real. And I was like, oh, motherfucker, you just screwed up. Now I got to dig into this and destroy your story. And that's what I did.

That's what I did. I found the evidence that was out there. And it's not that I had done any great, amazing research. The people on that airline are Abduction twenty fourteen Reddit Subreddit.

They had already done this evidence that I heard this research and then already debunked him months ago, months ago, and he just ignored them, belittled them, and then went to his little echo chamber and continued to spread his narrative, and that's why I had to tell it the story the way that I did in that tweet. I wanted people to know that the evidence was out there. I didn't collect it, I didn't research it. It was all right there.

People had already done it, mastered it followed him in silence, and this is all the evidence. Yea, he doesn't want to talk about. So it's good that it's all there in one thread and people who are curious can see the evidence that these videos are fake. And again, it's fruit from a poison tree.

It's all. It all starts with bullshit, So it doesn't matter to me how much bullshit you pile on top of it, prove the videos are real or step off. And then there's also the issue of exploiting all those dead people and their families. And I've heard the argument from some of these people.

Well, nobody from the families have complained. But I'll ask Ashton if I ever get a chance to if somebody from one of those families complains, will you stop doing what you're doing. I don't believe he would do you. No nobody complained.

Their argument is nobody from the families complained or set down. I really hope that that's the case. I really hope that his little region of messed up influence on the Internet is so small that it hasn't reached the victims' families in this case. I really hope that's the case, because I would hate to think that this knit with is traumatizing people who are who are already traumatized, just so he can stro ego.

That's that's pathetic. That's just down right pathetic. And so I hope that's the case. And he better hope so too, because he might find himself on the business end of a defamation lawsuit if he doesn't, if he keeps it up.

I mean, like, I don't know what he's claiming, but they might. They might come after him. I mean, there's ben historical this. This is exactly like Alex Jones claiming that those school shootings were staged or false flag events.

It's just as damaging to the victims of these families as what Action is doing. And this is my opinion, I'm in tunnel to it. It's just as as damaging as what Alex Jones did. And look what happened to him for pushing false conspiracy theories and hurting.

He's re victimizing all of these people. Now they're all a part of some brand conspiracy and they got teleport to some base for some unknown god. Why would they even do that. It just makes none of this makes any sense.

It's so stupid. It doesn't know, it doesn't, it doesn't. Anyone who's got some common sense should see right through it. You know, all the evidence is there.

There's no reason to entertain this guy anymore or platform him. You know, Joe Rogan, Matt Stags, if you guys are listening, you guys dodged a really big bullet there by not bringing this clown on your show and giving him access to your viewers. And I'm glad. I'm glad because his reach would have been even bigger.

You look at what happened when Johnny Carson had Uri Geller on his show in order to debunk him. And if he hadn't done that, nobody today would even know who Uri Geller is. Nobody today would care. He would not be a celebrity.

And unfortunately, that's what happens when people get brought into the limelight, even if it's to even if if it's just a dumb ball over like Julie or not Juliet Dorsey. Who's the other one you said earlier? I forget is now Danny Danny Grant, No, what's his last name? Who is Danny Jones?

That was on the podcast with him, So he kind of dumped all over him, and you know, like that that right there, even that, I thought he was very respect full about it. Though he wasn't like nasty. He's just trying to like he was trying to. I think Danny kind of like knew the videos were fake and he wanted to get in his head like okay.

He let him talk for hours and show his evidence before he started hitting him with all the debunks and and you know, reasons why these things could be fake. You know, I think he was fair. Yeah he was. And you'll notice that the reaction was the same out of Ashton.

It was just the quick rationalization to excuse his belief and then dismissing the contradictory evidence out of hand, out of hand. He didn't want to hear anything about it. He just he's got an answer for everything. But unfortunately for Ashton, most of his answers are just complete bullshit, complete bullshit.

They don't get perfect. They don't perfect. Example is using fake Reddit posters who claim they're the head of Marvel Effects. Why would you even do that unless you verify they are who they say they are and get a real the name, their their resume, and get on the record, call them up and say can I can I use this as an on the record comment from you as an expert in Hollywood level virtual effects.

He didn't do that. He just ran with using fake evidence. That's fake evidence. It's not real unless he could prove it.

In a challenge of coal On to Ashton, stop using fake talking points unless you prove those people are who they say they are. As recently as yesterday, he's still using the virtual effects head for Marvel top Gun and he never verified that was the Marvel Effects. The fucking he never verified that person was who they said they were. He's still using that as evidence.

That shows you he's not being honest. Either verified that that person is really the virtual effects head for top Gun Maverick or the virtual effects head for Marvel, or stop saying that because you're being dishonest. You're lying to people using fake Reddit posters, and for all we know, I've said up before, I don't have proof of this, but for all we know, that's Ashton on Reddit saying those things and then screen capture all see the head of Marvel Effects said that those videos can't be fake. No, we need the name, their identity, their resume.

We got to have them on a show saying yes, I agree with Ashton, these videos can't be faked. I challenge you, Ashton, go find the head whoever the head of top Gun Maverick Virtual Effects was, get him on your show and get him to verify that's him on Reddit. Get the head of Marvel Virtual Effects, get him on your show and get him to agree that that was him posting on Reddit. If not, your fake evidence falls apart and you should stop using fake evidence to prove your fake points.

That's kind of where I'm at. I'd love to see him do that, Steven. I'd love to see him get those people on the show, and I'd love to see him show them the Corridor Crew video and also take them to the ama that Joe did on Reddit and show them that and then say what do you think? What do you guys think?

Ask him if he if he's if those are really the people that he claims that they are, show them all of the evidence and then ask them and accept what they have to say. But we all know that he won't accept what they have to say. He won't accept anything that is counter to his narrative. Man, It's like I said earlier, textbook confirmation bias, and that's that's it.

That's it. There's no amount of evidence here. I'm showing the original picture of the clouds that we know who took the picture, and he has proof he took the pictures and the background in the fake videos. But still we're going to argue that these videos are real somehow, even though the backgrounds of them were taken by somebody from an airplane, and he proved it that he took those pictures from an airplane and they matched all most exactly.

Not pixel perfect. They're not pixel perfect, manny. The videos are still real unless you get a pixel perfect And by the way, again, keep parking on this point. He has zero experience with virtual effects.

But he's going to refute all these experts. He's going to refute the guy who took the original goddamn pictures. He has a receipt from his plane ticket. Yeah, you can't use the word plane to take these You know, when you're discussing this with Ashley, you can't use the word expert or else it triggers him and he goes into this appeal to false authority and CNN brain and things like that.

It's really fucking weird. It's it's it's weird, it's cringey, and when you step back from it, it's fucking laughable. It's laughable, man. He just the whole thing is.

And you know, I'm glad that we're talking about this today. Let's get it out, let's get the information out. But I'm not going to be talking about this anymore. I'm just not.

I don't want to. It's a waste of my time. It's a waste of your time. It's a waste of your viewers time, and everybody watching this to have to go over this video and this evidence has been debunk time after time again, just because some cloud named Ashton doesn't want to accept the reality and the facts that are presented to him.

It's a waste of everybody's time and they should go. Everyone should just shut the the door on it. Man. You know that you don't have to cater to him just because he wants to argue all day long, and I'm not going to I'm I don't ever want to talk about this after after today.

To be honest with you, I have a feeling that people are going to force me to. Little Reviews is on Twitter saying ash and this is very telling. Ashton is getting his entire theory toward the shreds with facts, and now he won't show up. We invited him.

Just so everybody's clear, you just got to d M me. My dms are open, and then I will send him the invitation link. If I knew his email, I would try to send it there. I mean, you know, it's if he wants to join, we'd be happy to hear from him.

But I have a feeling the show in the chat. No, Manny, Actually, I don't think it would be fair for him to come with both of us, because I don't think he could handle either of us. Either of us could tear the treads two of us together. He'd be left in a puddle of his own piss, you know, like that's my well, you know, bring him on and I'll step out, or you could take a breather and go, you know, step back, and I'll deal with it.

I don't even care about revival. This is great. The twenty four hundred visual effects shots failed in Top Gun Maverick, which were the responsibility of Ryan Tudhope and the artists at Method Studios, MPC, Lola Effects and Blind Well, I'm gonna call them tomorrow and I'm gonna ask him if that's if he agrees with Ashton, and that's him posting on Reddit, and if not, we'll all know that Ashton has been using fake evidence this entire time. Because if Archaic Revival can find out who was responsible, who was really was the head of virtual effects for Top Gun Maverick, why couldn't Ashton and pick up the phone, get the guy on the phone and get him to verify.

He's the Reddit poster. He can't be won't Yeah, I'm sure he'll have some kind of excuse, like it was somebody who worked under that guy, or it was somebody else, it was it was another guy, it was something else like And this is what he does is he's deceptively vague so that when you call him out on some of the facts, he makes it. He tries to make you look like a fool. He's like he's like, oh, that's not what I said.

It was this, you know, like the Joe Rogan tweets thing where he posted a couple of the dms to Joe Rogan, but the blue check mark was missing on one of them for something. I think. I think he baited everybody. I think he did that.

That's my opinion. Why would he rip the blue check mark out of some of the screenshots. He did that so that people he's lying those screenshots are fake, and then he posted the reality. And by the way, I have heard from somebody who spoke with Joe Rogan just to be clear, and yes, Joe Rogan did reach out to him and say, oh, that's interesting and asked him to come on, but then thought better of it and said no, I don't want you to come on.

But see that those guys took that as a victory lap. I think he baited everybody to think those screenshots were fake on purpose. Why else would he edit out the blue check mark and some of them somebody edited it out. And then number two, you know the fact that Rogan asked him to come on but then said no, forget it.

That's not a win for him. Rogan has platformed Bob Lazar, a convicted pimp, fake scientist. So that means Ashton is worse than a convicted pimp, fake scientist. Ashton is faker than Bob Blazarre, faker then Jeremy Corbel.

He's faker than than George Knapp. The fact that even Rogan, who has been platforming Wackado's for a couple of years now, said this guy's too wackadoo even for me. That's not a win, you know, I just don't think it's a win for him. But he took it as a c Rogan did invite me, Yeah, but then he said no because he knows these things are fake.

As anybody that's at least a little bit rational about this whole situation would agree. The videos are fake, and anything you pile on top of it doesn't matter. Go back to the seed, the start of the story. It's all it's all fake.

It's just like a lot of UFO stories. If you go back to the original story, it doesn't matter how much shit these people pile on top of things. The story's still fake, you know, Yeah, it's it's and it's all based on on fake videos, you know, I mean, it's just we just got to kind of move past that now and say that people still that still want to believe it are gonna believe it no matter what evidence you put in front of them, and so good, honest people who have integrity, who are trying to talk about facts and make real arguments, need to quit wasting their time on this fool and his conspiracy theory that is a bunch of bullshit. Just be done with it, Be done with this clown, and be done with it.

You know, the only thing that's gonna get you is is ad Hominem attacks. He's going to call you a loser, say that you need mental help because you don't believe aliens the plane. You need mental help? Like that's that's the best, right there?

Bad, Like it's it's crazy, crazy as anymore. It's high tech government technology. Oh yeah, so because our black ops didn't Zappa plane, which again doesn't explain where all the people on the plane went, does it. There's other fantastic claims for him, like he cracked the secret of anny gravity somehow as well, you know, oh yeah, I love how he was able to do it in two months with a bunch of shitty evidence.

What hell Putoff's been trying to do for a decade, like he's cracked in a gravity. Good job, Ashton, file that pattent tomorrow, you clown, go right ahead and file that patent. Do it. Can't wait to see you just fall flat on your face again, your knucklehead.

Yeah, Vincent. Vincent says he wanted to get on more podcasts, so he had to change the alien part of the story because it was a little too far fetched, right, change it from aliens to top secret. And I'm sure that he said aliens at some point, or somebody did. I don't know, you know, And yeah this, you know, I get that people are angry at him, and people were taking shots at him, but most of me feel sad for him because I said it before the only other time that we talked about this, when the whole thing came crashing down the walk the last time.

But it's like ping pong, you know, it just keeps coming back. You know. Uh. What I said is that nobody ever paid attention to Ashton, and all of a sudden, all these people are listening to him, so it becomes like a drug.

He can't let this go. He can't admit he was wrong. He can't let it go. He's never made any corrections to his fake evidence.

He's never acknowledged he used fake evidence to push this. That shows he's not being honest. And all the blocking, Oh you have evidence the videos are fake. Block block block.

Oh you're the guy who actually made the hoaxed videos, and you have evidence in proof block block block, Oh you did a recreation block block block you know, can't follow. He's got to keep evidence. No, he's got to keep that echo chamber in text so he can manipulate these people and keep keep I don't know what he's doing. Inflate his ego, fill his wallet.

I don't know what he's doing, man, like the uh the Caleb download of rar is A is a really good example of why he's so hot to just be proved right. And I actually watched a couple of those live streams live and I wish i'd recorded him because he's taken them offline now because they make him look like a fricking fool in front of everybody. Somebody captured him. They're still out there.

Somebody captured those Oh I love. If you've got copies, please send me copies of that other girl he told Remember that girl too. He told that girl that she's ugly and nobody loves her, she should kill herself or something like one of the critics. Oh yeah, he said, the people that are critical again, you know, because you don't.

It's like his number one thing is to go right to that homin the attack and just yeah, well yeah, he said some really horrible things. Just go to his Twitter feed right now if you want to, and search his Twitter feed for the word mental and look at how many times he tells people that their mental or they need mental help, or that they're you know, they need to get off the internet and take a break and all that. And I'm thinking, damn Ashton physician, heal myself, brother, you know myself, Man, go take a walk away from the thing for a month and touch some grass and go pet a kitty cat or something. Dude like he's either gone off the deep edge and he's starting to drink his own koola or he knows that he's a comment and he's just lying at this point.

I don't know, and I really don't care. I really don't. You know. He can, yeah, he does.

He can go right back to whatever Rocky crawled out from. Remember what's that yeah. He continually tells people to go get mental help when they don't believe that a plane teleported out of the sky. You know, that absolutely ridiculous.

It is ridiculous, and that's his number one thing to do. He's done it in spaces, He's done it in on his live stream. Like when when when Tony the guy who made the the recreation that we looked at, the one that I posted not the satellite, not the infrared one, but the other satellite one. When Tony had confronted him and said, or not even confronted him, but approached him and said, hey, look man, look I made a recreation.

Here it is. He went on. Ashton went on a live stream and showed Tony's Twitter account and has read account. It was like, this guy, Tony Adams is a is a liar.

He's a liar. You know, he's a loser. He's you know, right, yeah, get back to yeah, yeah, he just let you know, dude, Tony's not even a UFO guy. For Fox's sakes, Leave out of it, Ashton, You're fucking degenerate.

Don't see your fucking fans on somebody because they don't don't agree with you. Man, Like it's to Yeah, that's pathetic, man, it's pathetic. The the the lengths that this loser will go to in order to fucking get his his to keep his little echo chamber and to keep his bias confirmed. Man, it's just pathetic.

It's it's sad. It's sad. I'm overbeing it laughing about it, and now I just pity the fool man like mister t I pity this fool like. It's so bad it's it's it's cringe worthy at this point.

Yeah, I just I agree with you. And don't you think that this does This whole sit situation from beginning to end, says something about conspiracy land, like how willing, how big this guy got a huge following out of nonsense. And by the way, let's talk about the money aspect for a moment too, Because Ashton's lying and said he didn't make any money, somebody added up five thousand dollars in super chats, which isn't a lot if he's been doing this for a full year, but it's it's money. You can't lie and say I'm not making money while you're collecting five thousand dollars in super chats, plus all the monetized views for hundreds of thousands of views, plus all your friends on all the podcasts that you're on there, all making money.

Well, somebody fail loads, you know. For a million, he is a lot of money for an audio podcast. To be fair, Steven, he did allegedly donate three thousand dollars to the person who sent him that garbage arar file. So's he's lost a little bit of money too, But that's due to his own hubris, and it's due to his own desire to want to be proved.

Right when he was when he finally did get that that raar file opened, for a good ten minutes, he was screaming on his live stream. Yeah, it's about how this was a win. Yeah, yeah, he's gonna prove Yeah, all the debunkers can eat shit. We're gonna we're done.

We're losers. All the debunkers are losers. He's a winner. He's confirmed.

Right. Oh my god, the men in black are gonna come kill me. He said, I need to get this to Congress tomorrow. Congress, I'm gonna testify and coren of Congress like this guy's ego.

Holy crap, man, there's not enough roommen in the room for him and his ego, Like you can only deal with Ashtar ego one time. That's it. There's not enough space in any gime room. There's also the issue of suddenly, when people start filing for you requests to verify some of his claims, he suddenly wants to retire.

You know, that's a little problematic for me, you know, like, Oh, we're finally going to get verifiable proof that you've been lying about certain things, and now you're gonna run away. And that's the other thing. Oh, what was it like last week? Oh, I'm retiring, you know, I'm retired, But he's still going on podcasts and he's still attacking critics and devokers and whatever.

You know, Uh, if you're retiring, then you shut up and you move on. He's not. He doesn't even have the ability to shut up and move on. And what's he gonna come back with I've cracked the secrets of any gravity or some other fake nonsense.

I don't think he's done. I think he's gonna if he does pivot away from this, which I don't even believe he will, I think he's gonna keep bad. But if he does pivot away, from this, he's probably coming back with some other nonsense. What do you think.

Yeah, he's just moving He's moving on to another conspiracy theory, is what he's doing. And he's gonna try to champion that one. And that's that our black budget technology that the US government's got some kind of secret warp drive under lock and key. So he's basically going after the tee to the Alizondo folks, like and all the stuff that they've been saying, you know, from now on, or he's basically joining up with them.

He's just saying, yeah, look, you know, Lockheed's had this information for sixty years or fifty years and Backwards Engine heared it, and they've got it under lock and key, and it exists, you know, and good for him. Let him go down that rabbit hole with all those other schmucks that have tried go for it. Go for it, you asked, improved. He doesn't care about his detractors by appearing here to insult you earlier.

Well, he's had the link for thirty he had the invitation for thirty or forty minutes, you know, Like, I don't think it's a coincidence. I find it real curious that the guy says that he insulted and didn't have anything credible to say to back up the arguments. Really really, so he showed up in it. So he showed up and said, oh yeah, bunch of dick wads, and that proves that he's right.

Of course, he doesn't care about his detractors. He blocks them and he ignores them, and he just tells their opinions. Dude, what is this guy talking about? What is he even talking about?

Give me a break, man, Ashton. You can't hold a fucking argument with somebody who has got a critical thought without going into straw man arguments, deflection, putting words in their mouth at home in the matte, It's like, it's just a hot mess, man. It's a hot, hot mess of a dumpster fire. And that's why I've stepping back from it.

Like I said today, I didn't even want to get into it. But again, after the guy said what he said and acted the way that he acted on Friday in the Spaces, I felt like I needed to do a little research. And when I found out that the original creator had already come out and tried to proach Ashton was blocked. When I found out that the guy who done the recreation had been blocked.

When I found out that Jonas, who had filmed the clouds, had been blocked, when I found out that anyone who asked about the portal V effects from Pyromania was blocked, I saw a pattern there of Ashton and his echo chamber, and I wanted to expose that and cast some light on it. And I think I did that with this tweet thread. And I think it's pretty open and shut, you know. I mean, if people want to continue to go support Ashton and is you know, charging up the hill towards his windmill, go on, have fun with that.

But critically thinking people, I think are going to look at the facts here and see that this guy is no good. He's no good, his story is no good. It's all it's all bunk, and he's just playing for his own ego and his own personal enrichment, whatever that is, cash or go or both. This is all your fault that I'm even doing this because I wasn't aware.

I agree with you very strongly that this pattern of blocking people who have evidence to show that the videos are fake, I think he's doing that because he doesn't want his followers on his Twitter threads to see those people and see their evidence. You know, if he had real arguments against that, he wouldn't need to block people. And people can say whatever they want to help me. I generally don't block people if they're just asking questions or showing you know, if somebody's getting abusive, I will or you know at how you know, these nameless, faceless accounts, I love those, you know.

It just I don't know where we go from here, but I agree with you that this is a waste of time. It's a waste of time because these people will not accept any level of evidence that the videos are fits. Like, how much more do you need? It's it's the point ridiculous now, you know it is it is.

We've gone into the comedy part of it, and I'm glad we're back there because that's really that's really where it needs to be. People just need to look at this guy every time he pops up and laugh. Just laugh at him. Man, he's a he's a joke, he's a clown.

He you know, he's gonna block anyone that doesn't agree with him, and you know, just tell his little story, his little echo chamber. Good for him, man, Let him have it. I'm glad he found it again. Like I said earlier, a little hill to die on.

But at this point we're just kind of beating a dead horse about it. You know, there's not there's no evidence, no mountain of evidence is going to convince live streaming right now? True de Buoker's meltdown right. Great, Well that's too, that's kind of his m O too, Steven is to go on his wivestream and have a one sided diatribe and to his echo chamber.

Yeah, he could come over here and answer and face some hardcoreians. Come over here, Ashton, you pussy. Come on, Come on, man, you're gonna go on your live stream and stream snipe and talk in an echo chamber. How fucking weak is that?

Man? Totally fucking week. Sorry, it's just pathetic. He's not addressing us, He's he seems to be addressing other things.

You know, I don't know. I'm trying to trying to. I'm looking at it now, and it looks like he's playing other people's videos proof of reactions inside a thunderstorm generator for text fusion. What does that have to do with all the evidence that the videos are fake?

You know, it's just like Jeremy Corbell debunkers. Beware, but I can't. I can't debate you. Beware, but I can't debate you.

You know, I don't even know what he's talking about. A lot of very cool substances that literally prove that there is a chemical transmutation. Taking the fact that she's looking into the same stuff I'm looking in. Sooop, this has nothing to do with nothing to do with what we're talking about.

But de Boker's beware, de bokers are melting down. De bokers invited you to defend yourself. You were a bitch Ashton, you know. Oh, I'm sure there was a ten minute I'm sure there was a little ten minutes spree at the beginning where he's calling us all losers and things like that, you know, like that's his momo to run away to his little echo chamber and to put put show people on the screen and call him out by name.

It's really it's really sad. It's really sad man, you know. But let him out. We'll listen in the beginning.

You're you're absolutely right. And by the way, this is a transformative work. We're educating the public and critiquing the video that we are sharing. So this is fair use.

Uh that makes three seventy videos one thousand percent true. Proof he's great at math too, guys. Stream that made three seven videos one thousand percent true. Debunkers melt down chat.

I love how you love how they the debunkers always make these extraordinary claims right on their posts just for attention and stuff like that. Obviously I'm making fun of them with my post right like you notice, like my responses are much more measured than theirs are. Uh, so we're gonna have a little bit of fun tonight. There was a lot of stream by I like, but I don't know.

He's one of these like redditor debunkers doing a whole stream about me, And I thought it was gonna be funny if I re streamed it, right, but it turned out to just be like really sad, right serting not to just be like super sad honestly taking up a bunch of bullshit lies and stuff like that, and like trying to pretend like the bulls prove that a show up and what a joke man entertaining. But I'll address the points because I cry bully. He's a cry bully. We're gonna take a look at some of the debunker's meltdowns tonight.

We're gonna have a little bit of fun with it. And yeah, that's all we're gonna do tonight. I think I'm gonna after that, I'm gonna take a break and I'm gonna read a bunch of science on my own, and then we'll do some other stuff. Oh good, good for you, dude.

That's the smartest thing you said all day. Let's see. I love it. He's gonna let's start with the narrative out there.

Chat. Yeah, why did these guys so mad? That's the thing though, right, So the debunkers are so angry. Yeah, we're so angry because you're pushing bullshit with zero evidence and look at the following you've been asked.

Some of us have to do real research and have actual, real facts and evidence. We're so angry, Manny. By the way, cheers, We'll see drinking. I have another joke, girling apple or something a cloud.

Man, it's so funny. Up, like I announced my retirement. And then it's like they're desperately trying to convince themselves the videos are fake, right, I don't need to convince myself to you, Manny, I'm pretty sure the videos are fake and all the experts videos are fake. Man.

It gave as agree with that. He's got fake redit posters though, so you know, they're not even trying to convince other people's like they're trying to convince themselves. It's so weird like that, oh that Area guy. Now he's talking about you, man, I'm not talking about me.

Function is he's literally promoting somebody who pretended to make the video and claim that guy's telling the truth when there's like literally no evidence and there's a ton of evidence that he was a liar, even after the guy said wow, denial. That's a pretty hard cope there, Manny. The redditors and are literally the thing that they, you know, other people are. I don't know if they don't realize they're just projecting their own insecurities, right.

I'm very secure that we have real facts and evidence and real experts on our side. I don't know about you many Are you insecure? Are not? At all?

Man? Not at all? Just checking, just checking all. I wanted to make sure you were not insecure in your you know, in your evidence based belief system backed up by facts and multiple experts in the fields that apply are about that a plane crashed and this guy is capitalizing on it.

I mean, yeah, yeah, this is ridiculous, Steven, Seriously, man, I don't even want to watch anymore of this man because this is just always what he does. And it's just, you know, if he's too much of a tower to come over here and say this stuff and not till everybody that he loses, game over, game over, he's just gonna do what he always does and go on his own little echo chamber and talk shit about people behind their back. I don't want to entertain this guy with another minute of my time. Man, Let's get back to talk about We talked about them all you want, But I don't want to watch his story, man, I really don't.

I do want to mentionine something. I do want to mentioned something else, because once in a while, somebody throw somebody today threw at me like, oh, Aston's got ten times your followers or something like that, so your points are invalid. Like, it's not about follower count, it's about who's right, and who has the facts and evidence on their side, and who has a bunch of bullshit propping up a house of cards made of each of the cards in the house of cards is made of a lie. It's so stupid.

But just just to make a point, somebody's attacking me because he has ten times We have more live viewers than he does right now, so you know, yeah, yeah, got numbers because he went on some very very big podcasts with his garbage story that's been devolved. I mean, come on, it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that if you go on a big podcast, you're going to get a few followers. You go look at anybody who's on Joe Rogan, and the average anywhere from fifty to one hundred thousand Twitter followers just sewing up on as you let me address. It's not the best he could do, Crypto alchemist, he can call me Grandma's boy.

Look, I haven't heard that one hundred times. The best he could do is attack my appearance. That means I've already won. He can't attack our evidence because his evidence is fucking fake, okay, and he's not an expert.

He can't refute the experts with bullshit, right, So go ahead, attack my appearance, attack my eye, my disability. You know, you know, call me one eyed Willy, call me Grandma's boy. I love it when that happens because I know I've already won. They have no argument left when they start attacking the appearance, you know, yep, and the way I've never attacked his appearance, And there's plenty there to go to.

You know what I want, and I'll call it. You're personal, though, Man, the evidence speaks for itself. Let the evidence speak. I know, Stephen, and you know that.

I don't like to go there, man, But when this people like him come out and try to bully people and talk shit like that to everyone else, including like Tony, who's not even a UFO person. For him to go and do that, he's got some come uppings, man, And if he can't fucking take it, then he shouldn't be dishing it out. He shouldn't be dishing it out. If he's got thin skin and he's gonna cry about someone calling him a minecraft weep, then he shouldn't be calling people liars and losers on his fucking stream like he's just doing it on people the ugly and nobody loves them.

Like I love that what he did that at one woman, and all she did was say that the videos were fake, and again with the personal attacks. You know, he couldn't refute what she was saying in her video calling the videos faith, so he just made a video saying that she was fat and ugly and nobody loves her. Like, come on, man, this little douchebag. Man, what a douchebag?

Like he's just a he's a cloud man. Like it's so pathetic, dude, It's just so pathetic, dude. Like, I'm just I'm over and I'm glad. We got to talk about the facts, man, and I would I would love to talk about his mind.

I appreciate you doing this because I didn't want to. I didn't really want to do it, but I figured out if Manny will do it, and he's already got the outline, you know, we could go through this stuff and try to educate people. And this is how these this is how these fake stories work. First of all, they're built on a house of cards, where each of the cards in that house of cards is a lie or a half truth or a misstatement or a fake evidence, you know, And then everybody makes tons of money.

I love how so many people rushed in to get him on their show. And come on my show five times telling the same bullshit, like, come on, it's it is about money at the end of the day. Everybody's generating money out of it. So don't don't just play along.

Don't don't show your audience the evidence that the videos are faked from the very start. That's called the lie biomission. That's how these things work because they won't tell the audience the whole story, you know. Yeah, yeah, and that's been illustrated, you know, more times then we need even need to mention.

Is that he's just cherry picking, you know, speculative data that fits his narrative, and anything that doesn't fit his narrative gets quickly dismissed. He calls it people Reddit debunkers or evil Reddit people or you have CNN brain. He's got all these different little terms that are just oh god, they're so cringe worthy, man, all of them. You know.

He does it to people on his live stream, he does it to people on Twitter, he does it to people in spaces, and it's just it's it's abhorrent, it's it's sad. Just be clear, I'll be clear, because I have a feeling that you know, people are gonna people are gonna start more shit. If you're willing to debate him here, I'll I'll do that, But I don't think he's going to want to do that. And and if if he's going to come here and debate somebody, it really shouldn't be two on one.

So I would just like keep time and you know, not interject my own thoughts and feelings. I give my word on that. But I don't think he wants to face a real skeptic or critic because he can't just bowl over somebody like you that's so well informed and his hoax works because he has a low information zone audience. They don't have all the stuff that we've showed you tonight, or he's muddied the waters to try to make all the stuff that we showed you tonight completely irrelevant and a conspiracy still real.

No, it's not. It's all fruit from a poison tree. Yeah, it is that, which is a great legal doctrine which people should look up if they're not familiar with, look up fruit from the poisonous tree. And you know, just a paraphrase, it means that any evidence that's derived from another piece of evidence that's obtained illegal here in this case that's based on false evidence is fruit from the poisonous tree and goes out with that evidence.

So, and that's what we're saying here is that any all of Ashton's evidence that he has that's not subjective or speculative, is all based on these videos being real. There's no evidence that there is any sort of advanced propulsion. There's no evidence that there was sort of black budget projects that were being you know, used out their portals. Well, let's stop for a minute.

Let me stop you for a minute. There's no evidence whatsoever that the plane depicted in the video, whether it's real, fake or not, is the three seventy plane. There's no evidence that was one of the first points I knows. Yeah, there's it's you're not right.

You don't see a tail numbers. No, there's no one. Yeah, no one ever proved that that that video was Malaysian Airlines flight three seventy. No one ever proved it, you know, no, but it had to be because the guy who uploaded it to YouTube put the GPS coordinates for Diego Garcia and the YouTube comments so legedly even though they're not there anymore.

It's just it's a joke man. Everything it's it's a whole house of cards. It's come crashing down. And now what you're seeing is there's a whole lot of cope going on to to maintain the illusion that there's some big conspiracy theory when there isn't.

When there isn't, there's not a big conspiracy theory. There's no evidence that anything other than a street seventy crashed and it was a tragic event. You know, over three hundred people I think lost their lives there. And it's really sad and pathetic that somebody like this is going to rise to fame by creating a conspiracy theory around it.

I'm not even creating one by Gloman on somebody else's conspiracy theory based upon a video that a guy made for background, Like he didn't even make it up. Yeah, it's it's sad, it's tragic, but it shows the world we live in. And you know, I hope people are wisened up by this, and I hope the facts get out and you know, don't bother going after Ashton and trying to change his mind. Nothing will change that guy's mind, nothing other than his own confirmation byers.

Yeah, it's clear nothing is going to change his mind. Nothing will change no, and any arguments he makes are just ingenuous and you shouldn't be baited into arguing with them either, because that's all he wants is to argue. Are you argue and make these silly ass points that he's made over and over and over again. And it just needs to be flushed down like a bad turd.

Put it down the toilet, be done with it. You know, we're done with it. Yeah, I agree with you, but yeah, I'm gonna let you go and try to wrap up. I got to read these super chats and stuff, and I don't want you just you know, there's a big number of them here, so I appreciate you doing this, though I'm sorry for the technical problems.

And by the way, just to be clear to the audience, I may have to private this video, download it, clip something out and re upload it. So if if this video is not there after that we close broadcast. That's why it will be there back as quickly as I can get it there. I hate to do it, download and re upload, but sometimes they don't have a choice, you know, so you lose all the momentum of the live stream.

But yeah, and let me just say, I'm kind of sorry to everyone for wasting your time by bringing this up again, but I felt it needed to be addressed. You know, I don't have a whole lot of time. You know, I'm busy as hell working on getting these projects going with Bob Kivat. You know, we've got that Mandela Effect movie that's coming out here real quick, that's in the delivery stages, and you know, I don't want to take my time away from good productive work to do this stuff, but sometimes it needs to be done.

And you know, yeah, I'm just sorry to everyone for kind of having to drudge this up again, you know, I mean, but apparently it needed to be done because I don't think people on Twitter knew that, you know, or even on YouTube or even anywhere off with that subreddit knew that the original person who made the video had come out, that Ashton had blocked all these people who tried to, you know, show him that these videos were faked and that they were CGI, And I don't think people understood the level of the echo chamber that this guy's created on his little platforms. So I think it needed to be told. And I don't regret spending the time on it, but there's definitely better ways I could have been spending my time, So take that into account and how I feel about it. I feel like it's just like, really do I have to do this?

But my audience all but demanded. Once some people saw your thread, they were like, Steve, and you've got to talk about this, and like, okay, well try to. But every every time I have to, I'm forced to talk about this. I feel like that's enough, don't.

It's Brandellini's law. The amount of time and resources and energy required to refute bullshit is orders of magnitude more than it takes to create it. And I don't want to keep putting more time and energy. You know, It's like, if this any reasonable rational person sees all this evidence we show tonight, if they don't, if they still don't believe those videos are fake, we can't help you go back to delusional fantasy land where airplanes teleport out of existence to another dimension.

You know, whatever, we've done what we could do. We've saved two we could right, Yeah, yeah, we've done the legwork, we've done the research and mainly found it. Like I didn't do a whole lot of research. I just found another research that people had done, and yeah, to acknowledge it wasn't all your research, but it was easy to compile it all together and like a pretty convincing case that this person's not being honest selling this hoax one hundred percent.

One hundred percent. So there's a lot of people out there that tried and we're either bullied into silence by Ashton and his crew or yeah, well me and you are not. Both of us, neither of us are people. Yeah, I think somebody learned a hard lesson about that one tonight.

So uh yeah, be good people, have fun out there. Check out the movie I've been working on with Bob when it comes out, and I'll be around if anyone's got questions, hit me up on DMS, on Twitter. I'm always active on Twitter. I'm not doing much on my YouTube channel nowadays, having for a while.

Probably won't get got my filmmaker job, you prick, so no time for you to whatever. I love you, Steve Man, I love you Brooks, Steve. I got that filmmaker job that Steve champions God, but that's okay. No, I'm happy for you and you guys are welcome back.

When you get those out, we'll talk about them and thanks for doing that. Love to man, love too. All right, all right, good night, everybody, have a good night, take care. Thanks for having me on, Stephen.

Yeah, there's many Area five go through. Sorry about all of the technical problems, but it's nice to know that one way or the other you just roll with the punches. We had a lot of technical problems at the start of the broadcast, which I apologize for, So I want to take a moment to recognize all you kind and generous benefactors. For those unaware, we generally read every super chat, but sometimes we wait towards the end of the show.

So I want to thank high Speed Chase, who's been a member for one month and says Ashton Forbes is a wookie spanker. You heard it here. And high Speed Chase thanks for two things, being a member and a two dollars super chat, says let the super chat again. Another one says thank you Steven, and high Speed Chase gifted five truth Seekers memberships, which is a great reason why you should hit subscribe button for those unaware people by gift memberships all the time here and the way that YouTube does it is just randomly distribute the gift memberships to subscribers who are not yet members, so you could get some extra goodies.

Just by hitting that subscribe button. You could win a free True Seekers membership. We'd give a couple of extra goodies. Thank you.

High Speed Chase. Also, high speed Chase kind of generous two dollars said Art and Paranormal is amazing. High Speed Chase with another kind of generous two dollars. Ashton Forbe is more ridiculous than Beavis.

We have welcome to the show. The kind of generous ninety nine pound or what is it ninety nine pence supersticker. Thank you for your kindness. High Speed Chase with a five dollars one.

Hashton Forbes obviously does not care about the family members of flight and makes three seventy. Yeah. I don't think he does, because if he did, he wouldn't be profiting from the tragic death of two hundred and thirty nine people. And I'm pretty sure that if you called every family of those two and thirty nine people, at least some of those people would object to what Ashton is doing spreading false conspiracy theories based on completely and totally fake CGI videos and horseshit crazy nonsensical theories, you know, and the fact that he doesn't recognize that maybe he is revictimizing those people.

To me, it's exactly like the Alex Jones situation where he created false conspiracy theories out of a tragedy that has a detrimental effect. That is not a good thing to do to people, you know. In my opinion, Local five five six, with kind of generous ten dollars, says that imaginary Gnome account is absolutely Ashton's all. The account made in September of last year and only tweets vitriol to critics of Ashton.

It's him, same vernacular, same insults. Thank you for letting me know. So now we have additional proof that Ashton Forbes is using alt or sock puppet accounts to attack his critics. I wonder who we learned that from.

Maybe lou Alizondo. Right, So instead of a faceless bureaucrat, we have an imaginary Nome account. Yeah, and it's interesting. I wanted to see then if we could.

I think I blocked that person already, h though Local five five six, Uh, it's just interesting that other people are recognizing that there's these accounts and all they do is is attack Ashton's critics. That's not suspicious at all, Right, I think I think it is suspicious, you know. And yeah, I think I blocked that account. So I'm trying to find the uh, you know, I'll try to find the link to where that person was talking.

I think it should still be in there. But you know, well, it's amazing that they have to use, uh, that they have to use fake accounts, like just come at me with your real name and face. Don't be a bitch, you know, like, you know, I don't get it. I just don't get it.

And people are free to form their own opinions, but at some point you go, you know, And there was two accounts that were tweeting at