The UFO movie THEY don't want you to see. An interview with Brian Dunning

Download episode

Show Notes

The UFO movie THEY don't want you to see. An interview with Brian Dunning

Content created here by Spectral International, LLC.
Music videos by Simon Fly.
Visit our website here : https://truthseekershow.com
Buy some merchandise to support our show :
AMAZON STORE :
https://www.amazon.com/s?rh=n%3A7141123011%2Cp_4%3ATruthseekershow+Official+Merch&ref=bl_sl_s_ap_web_7141123011
Redbubble store (international shipping) :
https://www.redbubble.com/people/TSGear/shop?asc=u

Subscribe to our youtube channel here :
http://www.youtube.com/c/truthseekershow
Follow Steven Cambian on twitter : @stevencambian Join our Patreon : https://www.patreon.com/stevencambian

Donate by paypal : Send a paypal to TRUTHSEEKERSHOW@GMAIL.COM
Any amount you wish. Please include your chatroom user id, and any message you would like me to read on air. We read every paypal message we are sent and thank every person who sends any paypal support. Listen to the audio podcast : https://www.spreaker.com/user/14526799

Email us : TRUTHSEEKERSHOW@GMAIL.COM
#UFOS #UFO #f2B #STEVENGREER #DISCLOSURE #UAP #UAPS #DISCLOSURE #TTSA #TOMDELONGE #BOBLAZAR #JOEROGAN #ANCIENTALIENS #Roswell #area51 #SSP #SASQUATCH #SSP #SECRETSPACEPROGRAM #UFO #disclosure #SSP #SECRETSPACEPROGRAM #TRUTHSEEKERS #STEVENCAMBIAN #ANJALI #AREA51 #ALIENS #BOBLAZAR #GEORGEKNAPP #JOHNLEAR #S4 #AREA51COVERUP #WEAPONIZEYOURCURIOUSITY #UAPREPORT #MYSTERYWIRE #ALIENBASE #DAVIDWILCOCK #ANCIENTALIENS #EDGARCAYCE #bigfoot

We use streamyard to run our show! Use our referral code to sign up for or upgrade streamyard. https://streamyard.com/pal/d/6711617069252608

Show Transcript

It took the bat about EPP story sto st st st st st st stop stop stop. Greetings and salutations, friends and welcome. I apologize for the long winded intro. However, I think there may be a time zone issue.

I always put what the time zone is in emails and communications, but the first time a guest is here, I'm always a little bit nervous because of the time zone issue. Maybe I should have been clearer. So I'm still waiting for tonight's special guest, Brian Dunning of Skeptoid fame, to arrive. In the meantime, though I have an email prepared I'm going to send him just to check in with them, make sure everything is okay.

In the meantime, I thought that I could talk just for as briefly as I possibly can about this Miami aliens ten foot alien story. It's not a story. It's well it is, but it's a fake one. And so many people are sending me messages or you know, I don't know, videos and other things.

There's an incredible breakdown that somebody did about what a joke that story is. And one of the reasons that you could be sure that it's fake is because the very same people that we're pushing this Las Vegas alien story, which did turn out to bempletely and totally fake. That those same very same people are pushing this Miami alien story. What is the evidence for this?

There is none, virtually none, Right, So is it a strange event what happened? Yet it's not an everyday occurrence that you get that kind of police presence. However, you know, interestingly, strange things happen sometimes. I don't understand now every time something strange happens in the world, we're going to suddenly attach aliens to the situation.

And let's be clear. You know, look at the people that are pushing this story, the same people that push the Las Vegas story, people like third Phase of Moon and Goofon and you know, congratulations, they're making a lot of money, getting a lot of clicks and views pushing this story. It is a completely and totally fake story. Just notice backstage, our special guest is here, so it could breathe a sigh of relief.

I apologize for the first time a guest is ever here. If they're you know, like I always get nervous, like because we we had I can't remember who it was, and I don't want to I don't want to disparage anybody, but do you guys some of you may remember that we waited for a guest for an hour and a half and I talked about his research for an hour and a half while and the guests just I don't know, it's got stuck on a plane or something happened. But I can breathe a sigh of relief now knowing that everything's going to be okay. I have a list of notes and questions.

We want to welcome everybody into live chat for tonight's special event. If you did miss it, we did a complete and thorough review and discussion of mister Dunning's film, which I really think is so incredibly needed right now and a great effort. And also in the description of this video or podcast or wherever you're getting this, in the description, you will find a link to his excellent film, which you can now watch on YouTube completely for free. So we want to bring our special guests in here.

What can I say about tonight's guest. He has been a skeptical voice for many years. He is an author of podcast host, and now an established filmmaker. He's got a background in educating people about science, and I for I'm happy to have him here.

Let's bring him in good evenings, running, good to meet you. Apologies for being late, we had o no, I should have even said anything. I should have filled time for at least ten minutes before I said that, you know, but I'm so glad that you're here. Once in a while, somebody mixes up the time zones and I thought, oh, man, he lives in California or something.

I think, right, you're on the West coast. Yeah, oh or yeah, so yeah, I was worried that that was the case. You know, I don't even know where to begin, but I got a lot of questions for you. And first, the first thing I really wanted to discuss is the film of Course, which I think it is so very needed right now because of this over sensationalism of this topic since at least twenty sixteen, and the fact that you comment in your film, it feels to me like the whole world is getting inundated with these stories.

Have you Do you agree that there's been a rapid or rising increase in these kind of stories in the past couple of years. Oh, it's been and men so Ever, since the twenty seventeen article in the New York Times, anyone who typically would have gone into conspiracy theories or extreme religiosity or whatever it else they might have otherwise gone into the UFO alien truthism thing has been offered up as here's the thing to be obsessed with for this year. So it's had a radically disproportionate share in the public attention, that's for sure. Yeah, and were you aware of this news network?

News Nation? Now it's basically become the UFO News network, Like that's almost all we do. They're covering Grush NonStop. And I have a countdown about David Grush.

I wanted to ask your opinion of this. I think we're up to two hundred and seventeen days of this person, David Grush, who claims to be a whistleblower, and at least for once, his military background is real and his work experience isn't a lie, because sometimes these guys just say they were in the Air Force and you find out they weren't. But we're up to two hundred and seventeen days, and News Nation and many other podcasters, it's like NonStop coverage of this guy. Two hundred and seventeen days, no evidence.

What is your take on Before we get into the film, I have to ask you what your take on Brushes? I have personally, I've never seen a story with so with no evidence whatsoever, pushed this like, you know, aggressively and for so long. You know, normally, if you look at the negative comments that I get on on on the movie, because you know, half the people who watch it, they understand that it's a science film, they go in with that. The other half of people who watch it, they go in thinking it's going to be just another UFO storytelling movie like all the rest, and so they're very disappointed, and so they make negative comments.

And if you look at the negative comments, they all say Grussian fravor. You know, hey, what about Grush and Fravor? They you know, they're military men, they're they're not they can't be wrong. My question is, what would you have said a year ago if you'd never heard of Grush and Fraber?

What would you be saying? Are you left with no evidence at all? Is is David Grush really the strongest evidence? You know?

It was? It was hilarious watching that. I was on News Nation. I think twice, either just before or just after the Grush whistleblower event.

Well, they gave they gave David Grush about I don't know, thousands of hours of coverage and they let Nick west on for like three minutes, so it all equals out right, you know. Yeah, that was somebody like you to like, wait a minute, there's no evidence, Wait a minute, you know, yeah, I mean it was. It was hilarious to watch because, you know, he started telling all of these stories and we were just waiting for any specific detail so we could tell what story he's talking about, but he wouldn't give any and the only two he gave was Roswell and the silly Italy. And it's like, oh my god, it's this bad.

I never would have thought it was going to be that bad for someone to say. Literally, my friend who's a ghost hunter at Skinwalker Ranch told me that Roswell was real and that that's evidence evidence. That's his evidence. It's a guide telling that a ghost hunter told him Roswell is real.

And the fact that this is getting promoted on the news as if it's business. Yeah, this is now government acknowledgment that Roswell was real. Because this dude was in the military ones it's wild. Yeah, and we just we just found out, like my my theory on him from the very beginning.

And and by the way, I did have an insider sort of source that tipped me off about this. I knew that he was hanging out with George Knapp and Jeremy Corbell and some of these other peddlers of stories for a long time before he became a so called whistleblower. And what I said was, all this information is coming from what we call here. We have a lot of terminology.

We call them UFO wackad's, people like how put Off and Eric Davis and Louel Zondo and you know, people that have been saying the same thing Grush has been saying for years or decades and never proving it. And now it turns out we just got confirmation. Eric Davis confirmed he's one of Dave Grush's. So we have something here called the wacka Do prover maneuver.

You get one whack a do that has no evidence and he says that guy's telling the truth, and it's another guy that has no evidence. And in your film you talked about the standards of evidence, which is a great thing that I sort of glanced over and I've never talked about it here, but you were so correct in the film here, and your your point, I think, or you can you can correct me, is if you're gonna claim extraordinary things, you have to have high, super high standards of evidence. And it seems like all these peddlers of these stories, like you just said, like my evidence is a guy told me it's true. Like, so, can we talk about the standards of evidence and what would it take?

Do you think what would be smoking gun proof for evidence of alien visitation on Earth? What would it take. You'd have to have some strong evidence. It would take some kind of testable evidence that survives all attempts at scrutinizing it, and you've got broad experimental replication, you get a scientific consensus, you've got a lot of people around the world doing whatever testing they need to do.

I mean, we have no idea what this hypothetical evidence might be, so it's hard to speculate what that testing might be. But you would need to get a very broad scientific consensus that it says this is indeed an alien artifact. I don't know what you'd paper, right, like a peer reviewed paper. Well more than a peer review paper, you're widely accepted.

Yeah. And a consensus, right, a consensus of multiple scientists. And again, consensus does not mean a bunch of guys get in a room and they all generally agree on something. Consensus means you have experimental replication.

People at different labs all around the world have performed the same tests and experiments and gotten the same results. That's what consensus means in the scientific context. Yeah, and I have a strange question for you. You seem to be very knowledgeable about a great deal of things.

One of the things that bothers me is all of these people who claim to have fragments or physical evidence. And I mean I try to confirm this and talk to a few materials scientists, and it's at least this is my understanding. If you have elements, say aluminum, and it comes from another star system, somebody would know that instantly. If they put in a mass spectrometer and did like an analysis, they would know this is aluminum, but it's not from our star system.

So all these people and that test is twenty minutes, I was told. So all these people that say there's fragments, you know, they have metamaterials TTSA that was one of their You know, big, well, we have all these materials covered materials from crashes. Wouldn't we be able to test it instantly? And why is Gary Nolan, who's an immunologist doing metals analysis or you know, this makes no sense, Like wouldn't you get a material scientist and couldn't you tell immediately that this was from a different star system?

And doesn't this blow away all these people making these claims? Well? Okay, yes, and no, I mean you isotopic analysis is what you're talking about. It's made of aluminum.

But look at all the different isotopes of aluminum that are in there. What proportions are they found in Does that match the proportions that we find aluminum here on Earth? Well it may very well if you had something that was isotopically distinct that you could say, here's a mix of isotopes that we don't find naturally anywhere on Earth. Okay, so it came from off of Earth is one possibility.

Another possibility is that someone made a crapload of money to make that because we couldn't make it. Still, Yeah, this is the point that phil Plate has brought up a lot when he's been asked the same question, what would it take to what would a convincing piece of evidence of, you know, an alien artifact be, And he would go the same place, Well, it's got to be isotopically distinct. So but he mentions that he was a calibration engineer on the Hubble telescope, and to do that, they had a chunk of I don't remember. It might have been palladium.

It's been a long time since I've heard philt Well say exotic metal. Yeah, it had to be isotopically there's a great word for it. It had to all be the exact same isotope. And to get that tiny little piece of palladium like this big all the same isotope, it costs like a million dollars.

So for some rich guy somewhere to say I'm going to fake this piece of aluminum to be I don't know, maybe like Bob Bigelow, rich billionaire that's obsessed with the UFO, Maybe yeah, he could do it. I don't think he would. I really do think that a lot of the people like Bigelow are honest in their beliefs. I think he's wrong but I think he's honestly mistaken.

He's deeply mistaken, and he's gone very far down that rabbit hole. But I don't think he would pull off a hoax to fool people. Sure, sure, and I didn't mean to suggested he would, but he popped in my head as soon as I saw some rich said some billionaire. I'm like, what billionaire do I know of that loves the UFOs and aliens?

Yeah? The next thing, the Mellon family family fortune is not insignificant either. Yeah. You know John William Warner, his cousin has been on my show twice.

He's coming on again, and he rails against them like he basically you know, I don't know. I don't want to speak for him, but he was really against the whole Melon TTSA l as On know, you know, push and the narrative. That's interesting And I wanted to talk to you about these debunks in the film because it's just so interesting to me that all of the available evidence that you used is repeatable, and I always thought that was the mark of good research. If I go after you, I can find the same documents that you showed for say the Maelstrom you know, incident, and that's a mark of great research.

But isn't it interesting that they all do this lie biomission in order to make these stories work, Like in the mailstream incident, they didn't tell you. Nobody when they're telling that story says, oh, and by the way, they're just so happened to be a power failure right at that time and date that he said that these missiles went down and the aliens did it, and it we're only down from ten to forty seconds, and you know, like this doesn't even from a logic perspective. Then you have to go, wait, so aliens came all the way here from another star system just to shut these missiles down for ten to forty seconds, Like this doesn't make any sense. And the fact that nobody says that when they tell this story, at least they should throw that in there.

Oh and you know it could have been that there was a power for it, they'd leave that out. And so I always say this, the lie by omission, that's how these stories work. They all do that, right, Yeah, I mean largely, yeah, I mean most of the people who retell and retell that story and most of these stories, you know, they don't go back to original sources themselves to see what was going on. They go to the sources they've already come to accept, they go to the published sources, they go to the TV shows that have already done the cherry picking.

And I've already put together a presentation that's very carefully chosen to show just the parts of the story that support their narrative. That's and that constitutes ninety nine percent of the bull of what's available online or in printed books. If you want to find the actual facts of what happened, that's stuff that's not interesting, it's not sensational, and so it doesn't get published, it doesn't get onto the TV shows. You have to do the work to go back to the actual documents, and often that's hard to do.

Yeah, you're right, but I think he did an expert job at this. And it's funny to the Rendellshim incident. You know, I couldn't believe. I couldn't believe, Like I followed that story since the beginning, and I totally agree with you.

I remember the first telling of it and it was much more grounded. We saw some lights in the woods, you know. Then there was a you're right there, was another television show or another documentary, and suddenly this guy saw the craft and he put his hand on it. And then years later, I don't think you mentioned it, but even years later, then the binary code story got added to it.

That suddenly, when he touched the craft, he got a binary download that just so happened to translate into English somehow, like aliens communicate through binary that translates to English. Okay, but that got tacked on too, So you're right. They spent a decade tacking on every time somebody needed money or there was a new book deal or new just making up new shit, making up new chapters of the story. Yeah, do you think do you think Roswell is like that?

Roswell's a bit like that because the bodies weren't really part of the original story that got tacked on and then you know, yeah, yeah, I mean the whole story of how you know it was really Stanton Friedman who he was on assignment for the Inquirer when he went and interviewed God, I haven't looked at that for a while. What was the doctor's name, the funeral director or the other doctor now the oh well, it doesn't matter. It was Stanton Friedman, who worked with this guy and worked with other people, and who deliberately collected bits of story, and he knew they didn't go together, and he put him together because he was writing for the Inquirer, is not exactly an academic journal. He had license to be fictitious there because he was writing for the Inquirer.

And so it's a story that never had any legitimacy to begin with. And until he wrote that story, no one had mentioned the word Roswell at all. Between nineteen forty seven and nineteen seventy seventy three was when it came out in the Inquirer. I think it was just a non story.

It didn't exist in the lore anywhere. No one had made it up until Stanton Friedman put it all together. It's suddenly there's hundreds of witnesses and it's confused. The evolution of these stories that are just fascinating to me, And to me, those are much more interesting stories than the actual fake happen.

How did this get put together? I agree with you there they actually did happen, and it is interesting to follow the evolution of these things. Yeah, and so what what's your take on all the you know, just just I guess selfishly, like we try to do things the right way here, you know what I mean, Like, no, I'm not really into clickbait, and we don't just do a story because we know it'll sell. And I don't know what you're aware of, but it seems like there's no ethics or integrity anymore, especially in this media you know, frenzy environment.

Everybody's trying to make content and you know, the clickbait, sensationalized garbage, that's where all the money is. But can we talk for a moment, just let me know what you think about ethics of being a content creator today, Like how do you go against all that and survive in an environment of sharks where everybody's just throwing in there? Yeah, let's sell out Like that that alien in Miami story. People are getting twenty thirty thousand, one hundred thousand views and monetized views, so there's a reward there.

You know, that was just that was just wild. It's like, how the hell did they even get aliens out of that? But I mean there's different kinds of there's a lot of different kinds of creators. I mean there are people like people like newspaper reporters who are very poorly paid.

I mean, the newspaper industry changed more history over the past twenty years. They don't have time to do any independent research. They read the other newspaper articles. And so that's why we're not copy paste journalism.

I call that anything original. You've got creators who are are the people making the TV shows, And these are people who are knowingly making fiction and they don't care. Their business model is not producing true shows, it's producing sensational, entertaining shows. They have license to do whatever they want to do.

That's their business. There are creators who are just random people. Well there's all the people in the all the UFO personalities themselves, who are you know, generally trying to wrangle their notoriety somehow into a government contract. They're all forming these think tanks and founders, so many of them.

Now, yeah, has one, Gary Nolan has one, Louel Zondo had one, has got is working for Nolan doing what they're all trying to get contracts to identify videos as UFOs, as as alien visitors. So that I mean that there's just a lot of different models behind being being a career and why you would do whatever it is you do. You know, I I do what I do, but I'm well aware that what I do is not is not commercially desirable. You know, it's never going to be popular.

Yeah, I think I'm making making my peace with that myself. That's my issue, I think. But I'd rather like be able to sleep at night and and feel like I'm doing some some social benefit. We try to be, you know, good for we tried to be good with what we're doing here, you know, like I don't.

It's it's a bit on the shoulder that wants you to make the face by the way, I'd be great at that. I But you know what's interesting is this this in this sensationalized garbage world, there are good people, but we just kind of get lost in the weeds of it, you know, like you're you and we've got And then I always thought that the numbers are disproportionate, Like there's fouls of people that are out there making aliens in UFOs are real stories, And who do we have on the skeptical side. Not many people, you know, you know, like you, Michael Shermer, Mick West and a couple other guys. And it's like fighting that uphill battle.

You know, you got thousands of these people that are cranking out these stories. There's a lot of us out there. There's a lot of us out there doing good work. It's just not very much of it is very visible work, and so there has to be a lot of people shouldering the load to get some piece of the conversation.

Yeah, and I wanted to ask you also. One of the other things that I really liked about the film is the scientists that you talked to. And I'm going to ask about your perception. Am I wrong that ten or twenty years ago, it seems like more astronomers and astrophysicists and people like learned scientists like that, we're much more measured and cautious when somebody asked them if they were is life in the universe?

But now if you ask one, it seems like they're snapping out, yeah, there must be there has It's like they're they're not as measured anymore. Like a lot of these scientists are really sure that there's life somewhere, and we just we're this close to discovering it. You touched on that on your film, like one we're one camera or one space telescope generation away from being able to identify life on other planets possibly, right, Yeah, the Habitable World's Observatory, that's where I've got my money. That's basically what's going to replace James Web after its life cycle.

Wow, and you really think that that's going to be able to They're going to use that method of like determining what gases are in the atmospheres, and that's going to tell us that, Yeah, this Habitable World's Observatory will be able to resolve exoplanetary spectra to the point that we can tell there's all kinds of different life signs that we know to look for. A more importantly than the biosignatures, though, was the techno signatures, which are you know, it's a different thing. It's techno signatures are interesting. It's things like smog obviously, but like concrete and manufactured materials.

If you were to look at the spectrum of Earth, you would see the spectrum of concrete because we've got big cities that have a lot of concrete on the ground and that's actually makes up a significant part of the part of the signature. Yeah. Yeah, I would assume if we're detecting concrete on an exoplanet. That's not a natural that's not a natural thing.

I thought. I've often thought that they should be there should be some kind of detection to detect power, you know, like electrical power or radio waves or electromagnetic energy being being dispersed and charged or what you know. Maybe that would be another way, because you're right, the techno signature is interesting because if they have to technology, they're intelligent, So that would be even more exciting than just oh, there's oxygen and carbon and likely amino acids, so there's some form of life there. But the techno signature would be bingo, that's intelligent life.

Right. The technosignature is probably going to be more of a more of a proof than a biosignature because most of the biosignatures that we have hypothesized to look for. You know, you've got like Star Trek, the Horta that was silicon based life. Okay, here's what we need to look for.

If there's silicon based life, here's potential potential signatures to look for. There's all these different kinds of things to look for. But most of the biosignatures have natural equivalents. There's like ways that natural processes could create those, but the techno signatures are the ones that are more you know, definitive reliably.

Yeah, it's more definitive that it was artificially created by and the and the scientists in your film. I think all three of them seem to be very convinced that there is life on other planets. And you had what an astrophysicist and astronomer and somebody else, Yeah, somebody else who he was just a random guy who was there at at the telescope where we were shooting, and he was I'm sorry, oh really, Oh I didn't know that. Well, that's that's called a happy accident when you're making He was great.

Yeahs I believe he's a PhD grad student. But yeah, it's it's it's clear that the overwhelming majority of people in the field, they do agree that there is a lot of life out there. Where they don't all agree is that there's a lot of technological life out there. Most of them figure it's probably microbial, probably plant life, things like that.

I am more toward the end of the spectrum where I think there's going to be a lot of every thing, because when you've got any kind of life in a planet. Boom, You've got every kind of life on a planet. You know. It's like it's like, yeah, right, Jurassic Park, life finds a way.

Yeah, yeah, so I'm more gung ho. But but again, these are all just speculations because we don't have any evidence. Sure, everyone's got an opinion, and that's that's where mine is. But I'm the first to say, hey, it's an opinion.

Sure, sure, but it's still it was exciting for me to see three people that are that educated, you know, because I kind of believe just from the vastness of the universe and the laws of chance, like if the Earth happened by a roll of the dice, well that the dice had to fall the same way. Somewhere in this vastness of the universe. There has to be in my view, but when. But maybe that's a little bit of confirmation bias on my part or or hopeful wishful thinking.

But when you hear these very educated people who are studying exoplanets every day and and and really probing the universe, who also belie leave that, it's encouraging, right, I think so yeah, yeah, And I mean I have never personally spoken to an astronomer who thinks that there is no life anywhere. I've personally spoken to one person who thinks that he's well. It's Fraser Kine, from the publisher of Universe Today. There's about an hour long video on my YouTube channel that I posted right before the UFO movie.

We had a talk with him. He is of the school. He's not a working astronomer, he's an amateur astronomer, but he is of the school that believes there is no life anywhere in the universe except on Earth and sad thought. It is a sad thought.

I don't think it's very likely, but it's a very interesting theory. There's been quite a lot of publications on this one particular viewpoint, and it is interesting, but it's a minority view. It's clearly a minority view, okay. And also in the film, one of the things that I loved is this Christmas Tree analogy, and I wanted to see if you can explain it and expand upon it because I always thought about the problem of distance, but I never thought about the problem of time.

And in this film you give this excellent sort of way of understanding that in order for two intelligent species anywhere in the universe to communicate. It's not just a problem of distance, but it's also a problem of time. And I guess I'm not sure if that's a firm me paradox, like how long is the civilization's going to last before the apocalypse themselves? Or can you talk about this possibility of two community, you know, intelligence species anywhere in the universe communicating.

And this Christmas Tree analogy was great. I think it really showed your like background in how to educate people like I got some dumb monkeys to understand this because it's complicated. The Christmas Tree problem is my contribution to the field. I came up with that in two thousand and ten, I think, so you know, it's one of the one of the variables of the Drake equation is what is the life span of a technological civilization?

Well, of course we don't know, and of course they're going to be all over the map. If there are civilizations out there, some of them will have lasted one hundred years, some of them will lasted a million years, and everywhere in between. So we don't know what that is, but it is a real number. There is a number technological civilizations don't last forever.

Planets die, stars die, planet killer asteroids come, wars happen, pandemics happen. All kinds of different things can endo civilization. So when you picture a Christmas tree and it's got strings of blinking lights in it, So all throughout the tree you've got lights turning on and turning off, blinking and turning on and turning off, think of each light as it's on as being a technological civilization's lifespan. So although these lights are very far away, you know, we're talking hundreds or thousands of light years between these lights.

That's really hard for one group to meet another. But when you realize that there are also these lights don't blink on at the same time. Yeah, And the blink and analogy is great because in the long span of time in the universe, like humans, we're a blink, we're a blink, but we're a blank blink. And two lights in the Christmas tree that are right next to each other to be turned on at exactly the same time in order for there to be any possibility of these two having even a radio telescope conversation with sending signals through space.

So that's really horrible and unfortunate, and it sucks because anyone is interested in science, or really anyone at all, would love nothing more than to meet another civilization, an alien civilization from another planet. What would be cooler than that? Yeah? And the Christmas tree problem is just one more on the long list of problems that mean it's it's probably just not ever going to happen, So that sucks.

So while there is probably life throughout the universe, all kinds of life everywhere, the question of can two civilizations ever visit one another is a very different question and it does not have an encouraging answer to it. So yeah, look at this distance, distance and timing, Yeah, distance and time, yeah yeah, separated by multiple dimensions. I also wanted to ask you mentioned briefly about your comments and people getting so angry at you, Like I can, I get it pretty bad, but I can imagine you're you get it pretty like worse. You know, Like I just have a friend that runs Twitter spaces and he keeps telling me come into spaces, Steven.

I went into spaces and people just started yelling about me being there as a listener, like f this guy and what's he doing here listening? And like the hate and the vitriol is kind of like, is it just it's my personal belief that people get so angry with me because I'm messing with their delusional fantasy world that they want to stay in, and any attempt to pull them out kind of you know, gets the mak. I've seen some vieer comments and detractors, and how do you deal with all that? Do you just kind of ignore it or do you just you know, I mean, because it's a lot to be honest, I mean, this is not just you and I that get this.

It's every science writer on the planet gets this. If you wrote an article about COVID nineteen, you've been getting hundreds of death threats a day for years. That's just the way it is being a science writer on the internet. Yeah, you're right about that.

People were So if you're a woman, it's much much worse because you also get death threats, rape threats, all kinds of just really lude horrible shit that that women's science communicators get much worse than menu. It's it's really unfortunate. But you so you just have to have a thick skin. You ignore it, and you just tune it all out.

It's it's part of the business. And it's you know, you look at it in the right in the right light, which is that it's just kind of funny. Well it is. It is funny to a certain extent.

But like, you know, we hosted a filmmaker here that made a film about Loueli Zondo and it wasn't a kind film, do you know what I mean. Like it it really laid it out like he didn't really run a Pentagon UFO program somebody lied to in New York Times like so the truth. I had him here and we just talked about the film, and the true believers went crazy, and the next thing I know, there was people threatening my wife in the LED live chat I name like, went and stalked me on Facebook, like wow, Sherlock Holmes, you found my Facebook profile, like you know, and threatening me and like the the venom is crazy. And some of this stuff is funny, but some of it is dangerous.

Like we did this series here called Murder and UFO Land, and I'm only two in and I got three or four more where people got so wrapped up in this delusional belief system that they killed somebody over it. And you know, so there's a don't you think there's a danger here to letting this stuff run free the way that has been so pumped through our you know, interwebs and into our ears and eyes all the time, because some people get obsessed with this. If there's someone out there who is so obsessed with this that he goes out and kills someone, he was probably going to get obsessed about something else if it wasn't this, probably Yeah, good point. So, yeah, I don't think you can point the point the finger at any particular genre of you know, either misinformation or any particular field of skeptical topics.

It's just part of human nature. You've got some screwed up people out there who are not being treated for some mental health issue, and crazy stuff is going to happen. Yeah. Well, I don't know.

I just it worries me sometimes because some of these people take things too extreme, you know, Yeah, And they don't like you messing with their heroes either. Even if you're one hundred percent right, how are you dealing with You know that a lot of people hate your guts about you just blue like Maelstrom. And that's one of the other things I wanted to talk to you about. I love it when I know for sure that a story is likely really fake, because it's not just the people selling that story.

But then you've got all these UFO talking heads that repeat the story, like how many do you know? Is it just my perception? And do you know many times I've heard somebody talking about UFOs on a podcast or television show or whatever, and they say, well, you know, they're verified incidents where UFOs shut nuclear missiles. And so I love it when we know that the seed of that story is completely fake or likely fake, and then we've got all these one hundred other people repeating that story as if it's factually correct and accurate in one hundred percent verified.

It kind of, you know, blows away the deceptions, right, And I don't know if these people are just they didn't do the research that you did, or they don't care when they're repeating. The amazing thing to me is that it seems to be such a controversial thing to say that you shouldn't believe everything on television and what most of these in the case of the alien truthers is my term for the people who believe we're being visited by aliens and UFOs represent alien spacecraft. Almost all of their information they've essentially gotten it from watching TV shows, and the con research the concept that a TV show might be fictionalized or might be sensationalized or dramatized for television, that is a completely challenging concept for many. It's still it is still very prominently believed that if it's on TV, it must be true.

Yeah, and unfortunately, don't you think we were, like some of us are at the age that we were programmed when we grew up, there was only Channel twelve and those documentaries were good, like and actually to this day PBS News Hour, that's something that you can trust that they actually investigated, that they actually have evidence for the stories. But you know, that's one percent of You're right, that's one percent of what's on television is actually well investigated, well researched, well sourced, well documented, and the rest is you've got to be careful, Like you can't get your information from that stuff, right. Yeah. I do wish more people would watch PBS News Hour instead of whatever else it is they're watching, But good luck with that.

Yeah, And I wanted to talk to you also about this situation with some of these so called government whistleblowers because I don't understand something. For seventy plus years, the story has been at the United States government is covering all this up. But since twenty sixteen, the UFO community, whether people believe it or not, is getting infiltrated by intelligence members. We've got Defense Intelligence Agency person who used to work in information warfare is now an alien contact ee out in the UFO community.

We've got John Ramirez from the CIA. We've got Lil Alzando from the Pentagon. We've got David Grush, We've got John Ramirez formerly of the FBI. All these three letter agency people are suddenly going to bring us the truth alliens, but they never seem to actually talk about any evidence.

But one of the things I've noticed is they all do this sort of shuffle where they kind of claim that they have top secret insider information, but yet they never actually prove anything, and they dance around and talk about their NDA's or that's you know, I've gone too far. It's it's almost like a lark, like a live action role player, like they're they're Fox Molder and they're gonna, you know, they're gonna turn on the government and tell us all the truth, and you made some excellent points, like about this mailstream in the film, like he's been writing books about this. This is not classified information. So are all these people just bluffing to have some kind of insider classified information to sell their stories and sell them So here's here's the thing with all of these ex government and next military officials who are coming out and saying that UFOs are actually aliens.

The reason the networks use these people as their spokesman and the reason the whole you know, the leaders of the UFO movement continue to seek out guys like David Grush to bring him to the four. Hey, look at this guy. He when he was in Afghanistan, he looked at aerial photos. So therefore let's call him an intelligence expert.

So he's a senior intelligence official. The idea is that that people are going to get is that, oh, this guy was in government or the military, and if he says aliens are real, that means he probably learned that as a result of his experience working in the military. So hey, his word is probably pretty good because he had access to really good information in that position. That's not how it works.

That's the opposite of how it works. When you're looking for the next UFO personality, you don't go you don't go to the military and you say, hey, who here has has had some UFO experience in the military, Because no hands are going to raise. You go instead to a UFO conference where everyone there is a full belief in alien truth and you say, hey, who here was ever a veteran? Half the hands in the room are going to go up because that's the distribution of veterans in culture.

So right away you've now got five hundred military veterans with UFO beliefs. It's very easy to find them. Joining the military does not confer immunity from strange beliefs or an intelligence organization, right because we've seen so many of them. Nothing, there is nothing you can do that confers intelligence from immunity against strange beliefs.

We know this from decades of study and conspiracy theories and conspiracy ideation. There's labs around the world that have surveyed hundreds of thousands of people for decades to see who believes what and try to find matches with demographics and if you believe in this, what else do you believe in? And we've got a very detailed picture of how belief systems work. And one thing that we can say for sure is that there is no demographic at all that is immune from weird beliefs, and that includes being in the military or working in the FBI or wherever you want to be.

There's going to be just as many people with weird beliefs in that group as there are in any other group. So it's not hard to find these people. And the fact that there are people like David Grush, who had some intelligence duties at one time, who now believes apparently any any UFO story that a ghost hunter tells him they were wolves too, they were hunting were wolves, tooltergeist. That doesn't mean that it is the conclusion of that agency officially that aliens are visiting the earth.

It means you've got one person with some strange beliefs. Yeah. And you know what else I keep saying, is this conflation of two different things. You know.

Oh, the Intelligence Community Inspector General found his claims his claims to be urgent incredible. The Intelligence Community Inspector General never never commented on mister Grush's alien and UFO claims. He called his complaint urgent incredible, but I was told by a spokesperson they are they find every complaint urgent incredible. But the UFO guys are using this urgent incredible thing to kind of claim that the Intelligence Community Inspector General is co signing his alien in UFO and body alien body claims.

Is conflation kind of part of how some of these stories work. They just kind of move the pieces around to suit their story, or you know, like anybody can call the ICIG and confirm that what I'm saying is accurate. He never co signed his alien and UFO claims. But there's I could show you twenty examples where people are saying that I don't have any information on that.

That's interesting though, But yeah, I mean, I will say it again. It goes back to who the person is and what is their motivation for being interested in this And if you are among the crowd of you know, George Knapp and Jeremy Corbel and Leslie Kane and Luella Zondo and they all got together with David Grush and said, hey, dude, come on, you've been with us for years. Be a whistleblower. Come out and say tell THEE tell these stories as if you're someone coming coming forward, and so when you're in his position.

Here, here's my take on Grush, and I don't of course, I don't know him personally, and this is just a personal observation. He's obviously someone who's very, very inclined to believe in these stories. He wants it to be true. A lot of us want it all to be true.

He believes that it's true. He probably believes that it's very important this information get out there that he believes is true, and so he is willing to put himself out there and get subjected to ridicule and whatever else. And you know, he had the yeah, the thing with the police spilling the fact that he was taking antidepressants or something that was yeah, and he got there too. Yeah.

But you know, he's willing to put up with this because he's doing what he sees as an important and heroic thing because in his mind all this stuff is true, because he believes his friends and all these things his friends told him. That's my take on Grush. Yeah, I don't think very simple. I don't think he's lying either.

I think he truly believes what he's saying. But what he's what he's doing is just repeating stories that people told him, and there's a complete total lack of evidence there. And I also wonder, you know, like mister Dunning, I think you're a married man, Like I wonder about his wife because anybody, and I got in a lot of trouble. People attacked me viciously for this.

But anybody can look on YouTube and see millions and millions and millions and millions and millions of monetized views of interviews with Grush, stories about Grush whatever. There's a lot of money. There are hundreds of thousands of dollars have been generated through him, and I'm curious what's his take on that, and how does his wife and family feel, if you know, because some people are saying he's not getting paid. I keep hearing that, and it makes me think that maybe he's just being taken advantage of by by profiteering people, you know, and that's sad.

It makes me sad for him, It makes me it humanizes him a little bit. Like, you know, I don't want to just attack the guy. I think he's being honest. He believes this stuff.

You have to do this to do what he's doing, You've got to believe it. I guess the standard operating procedure for all of these TV interview shows, all the documentary production companies that are on, all the pseudoscience channels, you know, History not Geo Travel Channel, Science Channel, Discussage, all the popular fake history, fake science channels, the standard, the standard practice is you never pay anyone who comes on as a guest. There are some of us who don't do it anymore unless you pay us something. I mean, I'll do one of those things for fifteen hundred bucks, but I'm not going to do them for free anymore.

Good for you, Yeah, your time is worth something than your contribution. And that that knocks out ninety nine percent of them. They say, they try and feed you some bullshit line. Oh it's going to be great exposure for you, you know whatever.

But yeah, all the news agencies that have grush on all the they're probably they're probably throwing him, you know, a couple of grand He's making some money, but he's not cleaning up and he's not getting rich. Yeah, yeah, is what it makes me think. It makes me think that he's being taken advantage of it because of hundreds of thousands of dollars are being generated by all these people and they're throwing them two grand to do an interview. You know, that's that's not necessarily fair.

And interestingly too, you know they they really harp on these people's credentials. Back to the subject of these people in the military. Is that just because they can't talk about the evidence, so they spend all their time talking about their career and their credentials and credential it's it's it's amazing how Yeah, they rely on credentials a lot of times. I was, who was I talking with?

Who's the current Skinwalker Ranch guy, Brandon fugel h He and I were trying to maintain a cordial relationship on him tries to even talks to you. I was, but I mean, I will try and I will try and do my best. But he eventually ended up just ghosting me. But he was constantly he was very he's very sincere in what he does with with the with his current Skinwalker Ranch show.

He is he is a believer in what he's doing. He thinks he's doing the right thing. He thinks it's worth spending his money on. He's not trying to be deceptive.

He acknowledges that the show sensationalizes some stuff and he expresses some frustration at that. And in my conversations with him, he would constantly talk about how Travis Taylor has two PhDs. Okay, yes, I yes he has. He is a He's an excellent aeronautical engineer.

If I was designing an airplane wing, he is the first guy I would go to. But having two PhDs in you know, aeronautics or whatever. They are optical physics, the wather one, I think optical physic. Yeah.

You watch him on the show, which is amazing because he can't tell the difference between a bug flying by the camera and his alien spaceship doing seventy thousand miles an hour or something like that. You're right, yeah, no, Zary, I am. I. I have had never had any contact with with him.

But my read on him on Travis Taylor is that he he knows, he knows who's paying the bills, and he's just being a showman. He's just being a TV performer. I mean, he's been doing TV for a long long time. He's been doing TV longer than he ever worked in something.

God bless him. I kind of liked that show where he did like hillbilly stuff. They like built a submarine and like trash cants and stuff like. I like that.

That was fun. He knows what he's doing as far as being a TV personality, So that's why you're going to see him do ridiculous stuff like you know, thrown over the page on his whiteboard to say wormhole was his big explanation for Yeah, and he just so happened to already have that there. He just so happened to already have that there, as these guys are ros have been completely ridiculous like that because he knows that that's what makes good television, and the people watching the show say that must be right. He has two PhDs, so credent go an incredibly long way because they're super, super compelling to many viewers.

Yeah, and a lot of it seems to me that a lot of UFO and alien stories are sold on the credentials of the storyteller, but sometimes those credentials turn out to be completely and totally fake. We've been working on this. Charles Hall, who was the originator of the Tall White Alien I called the Tall White Alien myth, and his whole story begins with when I was in the air Force. Then he tells this grand story I was a weather observer.

I went to this class and he gives some pretty specific information. So we checked it all. We went to the National Personnel Record Center. No, Charles Hall, he never served in the Air Force.

We checked again, never served in the Air Force. I had internal Air Force contacts or a source. Luckily, like you've got to be one hundred percent sure, because I don't want to accuse this guy being like a stolen valor fraud. If it turns out, you know, then some issue.

He had three different birthdays, one on Facebook, one in a book once, you know. So we checked all three. No records of him ever being in the Air Force, which is interesting because the whole story begins with when I was in the Air Force. And he's even got pictures of him in like Air Force uniforms that look period, right.

But there's some problems, like here's a picture of me in Vietnam and there's all these street lights, you know, like something's not ray, you know, and so and his answer was, I don't have a need to know. That's why the government won't give me his Air Force records. So some of these myths fall apart on credibility, like they were built on fake credibility. Have you experienced a lot of like stolen valor frauds, And there's a lot of There was a lot of stories for a while about fake Navy steals and things like that.

I can't say I personally have run into a lot of that. I mean, you know, it's it's part of the picture. But you know, I really do believe that with the exception of some of the people at the top, you know, the Luella Zondo's and the Leslie Keynes, these are people who are absolutely consciously deceptive about what they do. But with the exception of those people, the vast, vast, vast majority of the personalities in ufology are honestly mistaken and honestly misled and honestly believe in what they're doing.

I think frauds and hoaxes are a small, small part of the picture. Really. I think maybe I've gotten too cynical because we cover, yeah, we cover an awful lot of scammy stuff here. And so one of my friends told me that I'm getting to wait too cynical because my go to right away is like scam, you know, just before I even dig into it.

And that's not good either. I want to be fair to people, but it seems like I just don't know how. I've often said this, like there's here's a perfect example, third phase of the moon. They they post a video and they and they clickb a title at best UFO video of the year, and in the original video that they sourced, it gives the time and the location of the sighting.

And so I looked at that. I went to flight Radar twenty four dot com and in thirty five seconds I identified it as a high altitude balloon in the exact area. And every you know, it pops up on your screen. So in that case, like they could have identified it in thirty five seconds, And sometimes I think they played dumb, like you know, oh, we're just putting it out there, or you know, help us solve this mystery.

It's not mystery if you can solve it. I made a video and I timed myself going a flame Radar twenty four like look there, oh we see a balloon popping up on the map. There it is. And when we even identified the other plane in thirty five seconds that was in the video, Like don't you think some of this stuff is completely intentional.

And it's just like, because they made a lot of money off that video, and I couldn't have if they were honest about what it was, you know, But this is now, this is this is talking about a segment of creators who are in the entertainment business. They're not in the fact business, and they're not in the belief business. They're in the entertainment business. So it doesn't matter what they do.

Facts and beliefs and what's true and what's not is not a part of their It's not a part of their calculus for what they're doing. If you're trying to make entertainment, entertainment that makes money, none of that matters. Yeah, you just need to keep in our minds what's separate. You need to be able to recognize who is a creator who's just out making money making entertaining programming and doesn't care if it's true or not, and who is someone who's doing their best to get at the facts of a matter.

There was there was a thing on a Skinwalker ranch. Again, well, I had to force myself to watch it. I can't watch it when my friends watches it. When I go over his house and I'm like, oh, come on, dude, I can't sit through this.

There was a thing where they had I don't remember what they were doing, but they're in their little headquarters looking at all their computer screens and whatever it is they're paying attention to was one thing. But then someone said, hey, look there's a government jet circling us. And the government jet was making some weird pattern like this over a Skinwalker ranch. And it's like, well, that's odd, what's up with that?

And then they didn't mention it any further. So I went to I went onder the I think I went onto the metabunk forums where someone had been discussing, Oh, yeah, here's the plane, because you can get the plane on flight aware. Yeah you can see radar twenty four. Yeah, you could see the flight pay at everything.

You get that, you get the end number on the plane, you get its registration number, you look it up, you see who owns it. And this particular plane was owned by some oh shoot, this is a long time ago. It was some federal meteorological agency doing some kind of scientific research. I don't even remember exactly what it was, but the pattern they were flying was absolutely normal for what they were doing.

I believe it had something to do with calibrating their engines. Yeah, so you're going to be going up and down different altitudes to twitt the sensors. It was something like that. It was something really really boring like that.

But when we got the name of the agency that owned the plane, I did what people don't think to do anymore. I simply picked up the phone and called them and asked who's in charge of that plane and got transferred a couple of times and talked to the guy who knew, and he told me exactly what they were doing. No big deal. How hard was that?

So obviously the producers of the Skinwalker Ranch TV show are not going to go to that kind of effort because they don't care what the plane is. Actually effort, which was that there's a scary government plane strange over our ranch. They're spying on us because they know we're uncovering the truth. That was the implication.

That was what they needed for the TV show. Yeah, and I wanted to see to make sure you know my my audience really, I've gotten such incredible feedback. I got so many messages thanking me for showing my audience this film. You want to talk a little bit about your podcast and what you guys do on your podcast.

Ah. Yeah, So my main gig, my full time job is at Skeptoid Media. We're a nonprofit. I started doing the Skeptoid podcast in two thousand and six.

There was two thousand podcasts that existed at the time, so it was really easy to quickly become a big fish in a small pond. So that was great. Good for you. I'm a lado gopper.

About three months after I started the podcast, I got put on the front page of iTunes like new and Notable or whatever, and it went from fourteen thousand downloads a week to forty thousand downloads a week, and I got five hundred dollars bill from my ISP for bandwidth. Oh no, we didn't have back before hosting. Yeah, that was back you had a host. Oh no.

So it became a full time job for me after four years, and then two years after that it became a nonprofit. And now we've got oh we've got probably about twenty five thirty people involved at some level. Only four of us are full time employees and still doing the show. We weekly.

We're producing documentary films, trying to be working on one all the time. We're just now that the UFO movie is finished up, we're going to be starting our next one this year. We're always working on grant funded projects for a video series. We're doing a series for NPR Radio.

We're doing a spec series for PBS Digital. So we're trying to do as much as we can, trying to get this kind of skeptical, scientific skepticism, critical thinking content out into the world to whatever degree we're able. I see a few people in the comments have have mentioned Skeptoid and someone yeah here, Yeah, So I appreciate you all very much. You know, we are a member supported organizations.

So if you want to go to skeptoid dot com, click on any donate or go premium button or whatever and become one of our supporters and you get all kinds of great benefits for doing that. It's well, yeah, and ipodize I put the film in the description. I'll put that in the description as oh, the film is great too, skeptically dot com. Uh yeah, And it was interesting for me to see and encouraging for me to see because, by the way, I'm trying to become a filmmaker to make documentary films as well.

It's one of our big goals for twenty twenty four. I've made a few, made a few free ones, but you know, I'd like to make one where I break even called for twenty twenty four. But I noticed that you went for your for the film. I'm sorry, I have the Skeptoid website, not the film.

You got a bunch of awards, right, You went to a bunch of film festivals and things like that with the film. It's done very well in film festivals. There's the best Documentary at one, Best Director at another one, which I dispute. I don't think I was the best director, but I appreciate the award very much.

And then we've got a bunch of runner up and honorable mention and all these awards listed here. You Yeah, it's all these awards listed here on the website. And the film is made under your nonprofit, so it's a public benefit sort of, yes, and no normally are all of them are because of because of weird complicated thing that we don't get into. I did this one personally as a side project, which we wouldn't do again.

It's basically it's a toid media film and we've already thrown it into the Skeptoid Media Library. I basically just granted the company full rights to use it however, so you can download this and you can buy it from us. And yeah, and then by the way, I I had mentioned, uh, it was on my list to you know, one of those things like oh I got I got it. I gotta pay for this movie because a few different people, skeptical people messaged me and they say, and they all said, Steven, you've got to see this film, like you gots and I went, okay, oh, and then you know, and then I looked and go, I got to buy it.

Oh, I want to support him. I didn't get to it. And then you put the film on YouTube for free. So I was one of the leaches.

But I just want to thank you and tell you that I enjoyed this so much that I'm still going to buy it, just because I want to support you. And do you have plans to do another film like this, in this kind of genre, in this kind of vain. We are not certain yet what the next film is going to be, but probably probably yes. Our previous film, Science Friction, was all talking heads.

I mean there was no host, no narration. It was all scientists, who had been misrepresented, edited out of context when they go on Discovery Channel or whatever. You know, a lot of times these talking head people, they'll have their sentences literally sliced and diced and the words re arranged to make it sound like they said something stupid. Whatever.

The directors wanted wanted to get across with with their pseudoscience documentary. So it was and it was a very good movie. It's science Friction and that's available on all the streaming services to check it out. Yeah, it's that's a fun one.

But it's a very different style from this because there was no narrator. I didn't appear in it at all. I think you can hear me asking someone a question once. Sometimes that's the best way to do a film like oh no, no on come of time for me.

All right. Yeah, we had a different director for that, and that was the way he rolled and his it was a really neat style. So I'm not sure what we're going to do for the next Oh someone asked his Skeptoid podcast on YouTube. Yes it is, yeah, and I will I'm a terrible show host.

I'm going to add his skeptoid dot com website to the description of the video. It'll be here right after broadcast, and I will add the Skeptoid podcast on YouTube links as well, both on YouTube and on You're on all the all the audio podcast platforms, right yeah, And you say you're getting hundreds of thousands of downloads a month. Oh you know. The funny thing is the peak was twenty eleven, and since twenty eleven, the actual number of listeners has gone steadily declined.

Ah, that's sad. I'm sorry to hear that, but but no, if if you compare that to the number of podcasts available and the number of podcasts, these things correlate, Those lines correlate, right, crazy, So actually we have a larger and larger share. Our share has grown when you consider what people are choosing from, what options are available. So it's a really it's a really weird it's a really weird statistic that, Hey, great, our listenership went down again.

Yeah, but we're I think we're one hundred hundred and forty thousand a week something like that. That's crazy. I'm lucky to get ten thousand a month. But our focus is really on the video side of things.

But we shoot out the audio podcast for old timesake, because I started an audio podcast land with my previous show. But like, it's amazing to me when you guys get that that many downloads, Like that's just insane to me because you know, it helps out the show here, just to have that audio podcast, get a couple hundred dollars a month for a new microphone or something I need or you know, whatever is going on. Right I realized turned on my little, my little background lights here. Oh okay, you got a synthesizer behind you too.

You should see what I'm doing right now. They're not working, batteries are dead. Against my better judgment, I just went, I'm gonna dig all my old synthesizers out of my garage and hook everything up again. And I'm four hundred dollars in cables later because I have so much stuff.

And yeah, look, there may be a couple of uncomfortable questions here, but I think we've got a good conversation, and you seem like, you know, you know, get pissed or upset. Spooky is a big Grand Hancock fan and says what happened after Grant Grant Hancock confronted you on Joe Rogan experience. Yeah, I've never had any any dealings with Graham Hancock. So I'm not sure what you're referring to.

Okay, going on Rogan was a mistake. I would never do that again. Really, why did you think you thought it was a bust? Yeah, I mean, I mean you go on there as a as a hostile guest.

I went on there specifically to confront him on his history of promoting false conspiracy theories, and he didn't care for that. And you know, they took the show down only a couple of weeks after it went up. They replaced it with a deceptively edited twenty four minute cut. They cut three hours down to twenty four minutes.

Oh, I gotta find the original. I want to see this. In fact, in fact, Vice is making a documentary right now on Rogan, and they interviewed me for that a couple of months ago. I have no idea when it's going to come out, Probably not too much longer, but keep an eye off for it.

When you see a Vice documentary on the Joe Rogan experience, I'm in that and it's we tell that story, so it should be pretty good. Oh, that's pretty interesting. And we talked about Eric Davis, the Wakado who had He made a paper for the United States government. Eric Davis did it and it had like pictures of Barney the Dinosaur and a time war behind Barney the Dinosaur like he's a whack of do And Gary o'kee says, can I be the first to say I would not trust any government or elite billionaire to tell me what was alien or not.

I'd want to see a live body of myself. Well, thank you all for your kindness, generosity and support of the show. It's much much appreciated. The alien bodies, I don't know if you're aware of this.

And I was interested in the crash retrieval side of things. So we did fourteen different crash retrieval stories and pretty much determined that almost all of them are completely fake or there's zero evidence for all of them. Do you think this recent push with the alien bodies and crash retrievals is this just rehashed stories? Because we found an episode of In Search of with Leonard Nimoy from nineteen eighty one zero where they tell this same story and that's, you know, forty something years ago.

Is this stuff just getting rehashed or is there some some new information somewhere. I think new stories come out from time to time, but mostly it's the it's the old ones getting getting told and retold. I mean, Grush couldn't come up with anything better than Roswell and Italy, you know, nineteen thirty three and nineteen forty seven, and nothing happened in nineteen thirty three. The story wasn't even written until the I think the eighties.

Yeah, and William Brophy was involved in that, who was also involved in the Trinity Crash. He's where they got the idea of bodies and it went to the Vatican, and the Vatican was involved in the He tacked that on William who was also involved in the Trinity Ufo crash. And God bless Jack Vile. I used to like his books, but Jesus, he went, he went balls in on that story and he refuses to believe it was.

It was a hoax. And like the piece of metal somebody identified as a as an industrial part to an industrial windmill, like the part they said that they ripped this piece of metal off the inside of the Flying Saucer and it turns out to be from a windmill. And there's all these other problems with the story. The same guy involved in that hoax is pushing the Italian UFO case or bolstering Bill Brophy is.

I mean, I read a fair amount about him when I was doing an episode on the Mussolini UFO thing, and uh not a doctor have not examined him, but my opinion is that he's very clearly suffers from mental disability of some kind. And that's sad, okay, because when you're just sending letters to people and adding on to their UFO stories, that's that's very welcome input. You know, he doesn't he doesn't really go anywhere and do anything in person or make appearances and stuff. He just would write these strange letters.

But the UFO hucksters must love him though, because he is shit. Grush got on in front of Congress and told that story, told a story that was literally made up by a madman. Thank you, mister, mister Puxley for kind of cenerosity and support, he says, this is awesome. Yeah, and uh yeah, I'm glad that you're here, and I'm glad to know, to be very honest with you.

On a personal side, like seeing this movie made me feel a little bit less alone, you know, I feel I'm screaming from the void here, like this story is fake, and this story is fake, and this story is fake. And it was good to see a big, well produced movie that you know, Okay, I'm not the only sane person in the room, you know, like it was good to see that. You Yeah, and you you mentioned some you know, pretty negative feedback from some of the true believers. Does aren't you getting equal amounts of praise for this, because I've heard many people praise this movie as well as being like a breath fresh air among uto documentaries.

Yeah. No, The feedback on on YouTube anyway, is you don't get feedback from the from the streaming services, but once we put it on YouTube, it's overwhelmingly positive. It's like eighty eight percent you know, up votes and twelve percent down votes. Well, most people people like it.

And I've got a lot of feedback from even people I haven't spoken to from years have just come out of the woodwork and said, hey, I saw the movie. It's it's been very gratifying. Yeah, And what are your plans for the coming year? What are you going to be working on?

You said you mentioned a new film. You guys are starting right, And I guess we are. In our podcast, We're we're juggling kind of four things at once right now, which is trying to figure out what the next movie is going to be, and then there's this potential PBS digital show, and there's this uh in tr NPR program that we're putting together the all the all the episodes of right now, and then of course our regular production schedule with Skeptoid, which is a hell of a grind that takes up most of my time, is just doing the podcast. So yeah, it's a it's a it's a busy year.

It's a crazy well good for you that will keep you out of trouble. Tales of the Sonic Voyde says, great show, great guest, great show. Thanks Stephen and Bryan, thank you for your kindness. I appreciate that.

And listen, Uh, I don't wanna, I don't want to make you feel uncomfortable. I feel like we've had such a great conversation. But you know that some of these true believers will go and take any advantage that they can to try to discredit somebody. And so I was into Spaces and they were talking about your film, and somebody brought up the fact that you had some problems in your past, and my and and my and by the way, I just want to tell you that I support you.

I'm a second chance person, and I know so many people that got kind of railroaded into some situation, and that system is not exactly fair. You know, somehow you're supposed to have the resources to fight you know, the entire government by yourself, but you had some problems in your past, and some people are using that to sort of say his film is not credible. And my kind of thing is like, wait a minute, Like I went and got the documents that he's showing to prove that what he's saying is correct and accurate. So is this a case of if they can't attack your evidence, they attack you personally.

Yeah. That's my favorite feedback to get is when they go they have to resort to the ad hominem it. They either don't have any or can't come up with any, or have run out of arguments against what I'm saying, so they just go, ah, he's got negative show on his Wikipedia page. I wouldn't listen to anything he says.

So that's that's my favorite. If I'm going to get negative feedback, that's my favorite to get that's fair and to be honest with you, you know, reading up on that stuff, I kind of like, I have a background in computer science, and you know, I'm like a lifelong hacker. And I'm sorry, I'm not sorry. That sounds like something that I would do, Like, you know, like maybe I got caught up.

I found some way to exploit to fuck the system, honestly, like I figured some exploit out and uh, and I used it, you know, like I But the fact that people are going to use that against you when your evidence is like it's it's irrefutable, the evidence that you put forth in the show, in the in the film. So I guess that's just an attempt to stay in their delusional fantasy world. Right, I don't know if they're attempting to stay in their delusional fantasy world. I don't know that.

I think it's again, I tend to I tend to find that most people are generally honest and try to do the right thing. And when you are someone who firmly believes in the reality of something whatever that that might be. UFOs are aliens, you're a member of some religion or another, you know that something is true. You're going to say whatever you need to say to make sure the people who in your mind are wrong know that they're wrong.

And I mean it's it's an honest attempt to promote what they believe is the correct, the truth, correct answer. Andrew's got a great question. Is Brian a former UFO Aliens Visiting Earth believer or were you always a skeptic? Everyone I know in the field of science communication grew up reading all of the books on Bigfoot and the Permuta Triangle and Aliens Time Life series.

Remember that when we all had we all believed every word of it. So when I was a kid, I believed every word of all of that stuff that I read, and a lot of these stories in particular, stayed in the back of my head, and I'm wondering what it was actually going on here, What was actually going on with the flight of the five Avengers that crashed in the in the Barrita Triangle, and what was going on with this haunted house where the writing appeared on the walls as people watched and people were recording this, and you know, what's really going on with these situations? And so later on then when I got into you know, I went to college for writing. I was writing for film and television, is what I was doing in college.

So I came into science writing not through science but through writing. So and I had a computer science minor that I never did anything with, but that's kind of how I got into the whole time. Yeah, I was. I was not a fan of computer science education, as much as I love computer but they're terrible educating.

It's like here, learn see by tomorrow. You know, like I didn't have a good experience. But the opportunity to start doing the science podcast was my opportunity to go back into all these stories that had stayed in the back of my mind and say, hey, can we find out what was really going on? And you know, with those two stories that I mentioned, we do know exactly what was really going on, and I actually made a significant contribution to the field and in one of those that is very gratifying.

So it's it's really really exciting to me to go back to stories that I know pretty well because I used to believe in them one hundred percent. I was a little kid, and then when you're in your college age, in your twenties, you don't really think about this stuff too much. But then later, you know, when you're taking a more serious view, you go back to it and you get to actually all of these mysteries, and that is just so much fun for me. I love it.

Yeah, I'm kind of I'm kind of right there with you. Uh yeah. And Steve Long says most of us believe these stories as kids, and if we don't diligently research them, and most don't, life is busy. We continue to believe them as adults, especially if we meet others who reinforce those beliefs.

Yeah, and it looks like I grew up with a lot of those stories too, if it was like a I remember, that's the first thing I would do at a new school is go check out the library and see if they had any books on UFOs, aliens, bigfoot, you lockness, monsters. You know that's the first thing you do. And you're right, I did the same kind of turn back around, like all those stories you loved as a kid, let's dig into them. Oh no, this one's fake.

This one's fake, this one's fake. It's like being a killed joy. Yeah. Well, I definitely want to I definitely want to thank you for both the film and for coming here and I appreciate I appreciate the work that you do, and so much of my audience h does as well.

And just want to let you know you have a lot of supporters here. You always welcome back and we appreciate what you do. Mister Dunning. This was a lot of fun for me too.

Thanks for having me, and it's nice to sort of engage with all the people in the chats here are going on. Oh sure, did you want to take some questions or did you want to take some questions? We can tell you what's limited to fifteen minutes if we can, okay, sure questions from a live chat for mister Dunning. Put them in all cap of letters, will do them in the order they are received.

So if you have questions from mister Dunning, now's the time to do it, and hurry up. He's only got a few minutes, and we do appreciate your time. I know how busy you must be. You know what I always say this, mister Dunning.

The worst person you can ask to do a guest spot for you is somebody that has their own show because they got their own crazy they're where they don't got time to come and talk to you for two hours. People do it to me all the time, and I have to blow I have to well I don't want to say blow them off, but you know, like I have to pick and choose, like or say hey on this week and I'll have some time if you can do it between these hours or you know, so we appreciate it. The first question, what is Brian currently excited about the most? That's a good question, currently excited about?

Like what subject? Does you know? An interesting thing about doing my weekly show is that every single week is something a totally different subject, and I'm deeply immersed in something that's completely different from what I was doing the week before. But I think that the thing I was working on this past week is I think a direction that we're probably going to go for our next movie, which is the context and the motivation of people making strange claims.

The subject was I'll just be really brief here. The subject of this episode was the chronovisor have you heard of that? I think so that nineteen seventy Jesus thing. Yes, he said he came up with some machine that lets you see into the past.

You can see and hear into the past, and so We talked about that, and you know, it's easy to you know, debunk the story and that no such device ever existed. That's not the interesting part. The interesting part is when you come to the question of why is this monk coming up with this bullet that, yeah, and it was really interesting. We don't know because he's dead and he never spoke about why he did it.

But what was interesting was that he claimed one of the scientists who helped him build it was Werner Vone Brown of the Saturn five rocket. What an odd person to help you build a time machine. Why would you claim that, living in Italy, that Werner von Braun came over from the US and spent weeks and months with you building this device. And the reason he picked Braun von Braun was that his first publication about his device came just a few days after Apollo sixteen splashed down.

Oh so, of course the time in the world when science was grabbing more and more of the public consciousness and taking more attention away from the church, and so this guy was feeling more and more marginalized, and he came up with this science based device to prove the factuality of religion. And when you look at it that way, it's like, oh, okay, it kind of makes sense that he was just trying to get himself out of being marginalized. He was trying to bring the church back into problem with this device. So that's an interesting take that you can look at something and again humanizing the people involved, you've always find out something far more interesting than just whatever the myth was.

That's interesting. Great, great question, mister ian. Take a look at a couple more of these really quick. Yeah, here we go, Randy nineteen seventy nine.

Wouldn't the people at bettwater Is be aware of the orphan the lighthouse at the time of the rendelstam Ufo event. So there's a lot of different people involved. The issue with the Americans, these guys who you know were all the primary characters is these were American teenagers and they had been there a matter of weeks or months. Many of them had not left the base at all, and if they did, there was like this one pub that they were allowed to go to.

They didn't go town at all. They had never seen it from the air, they didn't know anything about it. They didn't even know which way the beach was. So no, they did not know of the existence of the Orford Nusts Lighthouse.

Undoubtedly some people did. I mean, if you look at the police report when they called the police and say, hey, we think something might have crashed here in the forest, can you come help us check it out? Yeah, they were just like, oh, that was the lighthouse. Yeah, they were pointing at the blinking light of Orford Dust lighthouse.

Case closed because of course the police knew about it. But these American teenagers who'd been there for a short period of time. No, it's actually quite reasonable to accept that a lot of them did not know about the exist Uh, Gary, come on, mister conspiracy. Does Brian believe the leads of the world are controlling all the grifters and ultimately us, Yes, no doubt about it.

Next question, Next question, Has anything Brian? This is a great question. Actually, I want to know this myself. Has anything Brian investigated stuck with him as particularly hard to explain a lot of a lot of these stories, a lot of urban legends are impossible to come up with a conclusion.

But the reason isn't that they're just so mysterious. The reason is that there's just not enough information. You can't call me you don't have any information to work from. And you can say this that just about any famous case, you know, black eyed children, that's one of theirs that there's just not another stories.

There's not enough information information, There is no there's no photographs, there's no videotape, there's nothing that you can actually look at to consider. You don't have a piece of evidence that you can test, and so it's like, I don't know, maybe something happened that we don't know because we just don't have enough evidence. Yeah, So that's that's the unfortunate answer to that question. I wish.

I wish the answer to that question was, Oh, yeah, this case, it was so mysterious, it just doesn't fit into our understanding of the world. We could only say that if we had enough information to make that conclusion, and we just never do. Yeah. Great.

And one one of the things I wanted to make sure that I ask you is I grew up Catholic, and you know, there's a lot of paranormal things in Catholicism, like incorruptible bodies, if you're familiar with that concept. And I once got in a lot of trouble because I went to Saint John Newman Cathedral in Philadelphia, where one of the incorruptible bodies was and on the in the altar in a glass case is supposed to be the body of Saint John Newman. And being a curious teenager and looking around and noticing there's nobody in this whole cathedral. That was in the middle of the day.

It's like two o'clock in the afternoon. There's nobody there. Maybe there's a couple of people praying, but they were weigh in the back. So I figured I could get away with it.

I walked right on to the altar, and I was an altar boy, so I don't know. Somehow I thought that would give me a pass. This was not my church. And I walk right up to the thing, and I put my face right near the face, and I'm looking at it, and I'm going, this is a wax mask.

This isn't real. All of a sudden, a priest comes out and I got in a lot of you know, well, I got scolded. I didn't get in a lot of trouble. And he sat down with me though, and explained to me that the hands and the mask are wax, and it just kind of blew the whole incorruptible bodies to shreds to me, because if the body doesn't decay, why do you need to you know, essentially, what the Saint John Newman body is is a wax covered skeleton that was artists artistically created to appear as he was in life.

And then there is the these, uh, these other things like the Crown of Thorns, and do you think there's any reality to any of that stuff or do you think that this is just the same kind of huckstering we see in the UFO community to sell, to sell what they're doing, the incorruptibles, the Crown of Thorns, the shroud of Turin, all the all the nails that were supposed to be from the original Cross of Christ and these. I'm sorry, I just want to get your take on sort of catholic the Catholic version of paranormal and if you think there's any reality to it or if it's just the same as the incorruptibles. Is a great example, because you know a lot of these, a lot of these, uh they openly will say that's a wax mask and one of them, one of them is somewhere is is is actually latex.

But yes, these wax masks and or or sometimes it's even just a painted wooden sculpture, and they say, well, that's just the cover and you know, the actual bodies underneath whatever. They openly admit this, and yet they still come out and write a report saying that this is miracle, and therefore we can certify sanctifying this person and making them a saint because this is a miraculous There's just a lot of cognitive dissonance going on within the Catholic Church. I think that's the thing that you can say for sure about them. So many of the cases that they have certified as miraculous, meaning there's no way that they could have happened naturally.

They've even acknowledged the evidence of what actually happened naturally. It's just it's a staggering case of cognitive dissonance. YEA. Pretty much every Catholic miracle case that I've looked into turns out this way.

Yeah. Yeah. The big disappointment for me was the Padre Pios worry, because it turns out that he may have created his own stigmata with a form of acid. And that's really disappointing, you know, when you especially when you grew up with that kind of a story.

That was one of the Catholic heroes that they pushed on you like this padre Po, And yeah, it's incredible that so many people will just blindly believe, just like so many people blindly believe all the UFOs must be aliens somehow, right. Yeah, in that case, I mean it was a straight up fundraising thing, Yeah, because they made so much money from the people come into the churches for each of the you know, whatever they had on display. You know. Yeah, I wasn't aware that you did an Incomptible Bodies episode.

Now I have to find that because because that's kind of one of my things. It's one of the early episodes we did here, and I talked about my own experience with it, and interestingly, like the priest would not, he didn't. You know, I'm talking to the priest that runs the church, and I'm like, but it's it's a lie. Then, you know, it's not a lie.

It's not a lie. It's not a lie, young man. You know, like, Okay, but you got a wax covered skeleton up there that you're saying doesn't rot in a glass case. You know, it's it's it was disappointing to me because I want to check out the Incorruptible episode because there's a lot of interesting cases in there.

The Catholic ones make up, you know, a part of that story, but there's there's other cases of incorruptible bodies outside of Catholicism, including actual incorruptible bodies that there's a lot of interesting stuff in that talk. Yeah, that's definitely, that's definitely a little bit weird. Well, I appreciate you taking the time to be here. I don't see any more questions from our live chat.

I appreciate you taking the time to do this with us, and I will add those links. I will add those links to the description. So we'll put your website, the movie website, and the link to your podcast as well into the links. Anybody listening, you'll be able to find mister Dunning easily.

I hope you won't be a stranger, mister Dunning. Yeah, let's do this again for sure. All right, thanks very much, you have a great night, all right, friends. Well, there we go.

That was interesting for me and a reminder to me that a lot of you people are asking me to do more interviews, and I certainly would like to deliver what people want. But I really you know, it's not that I haven't enjoyed. I enjoyed most of the interviews, but this one was extremely enjoyable. And in order for me to want to do these things, these interviews that everybody wants, we have to get some great guests.

So if you have any guest suggestions, you can email me at Truth Seekert Show at gmail dot com. I think mister Dunning's doing some great work. He definitely made me feel like, you know, there's oh, I'm not the only sane person in this mental asylum and other people are seeing through these deceptive fake stories and you know, bringing people the reality behind them. I appreciate what he does and I know a little bit about what it takes to do that, and especially when it comes to you know, there's a price to pay.

And I did like his advice on just ignore the vitriol and the venom from some of these people and keep dealing what you're doing. Yeah, and Art and Paranormal is reminding everybody that you can email me at True Seeker Show at gmail dot com. I want to take a moment to thank all you superchat people once again, matthew A, Gary OK one hundred, Spooky Pusley, and Tales of the Sonic Voyage. We thank all of you for your kindness, generosity, and support.

I always feel a little weird about those super chats while I'm talking to the guest, I don't want to interrupt the interview. So thank you all for your patience and helping us to praise the cash tonight. Thank you for your kindness, generosity and support. So we've got a full week for you here.

I noticed Steve Longs in the chat. He will be here Wednesday night at nine pm, so he's previous guest. Apparently he fixed his Internet, which was previously run by a Potato. His WiFi router was a Potato before.

Remember, he always had problems, but hopefully he's got that sort of out. I got to tell you the truth though, I saw him. What was the show you were on, Steve? Oh?

I saw him on Erica Lukes and his Internet everything worked and he didn't have drop offs or problems or bandwidth issues. I was like, what's going on, man? He's got good internet for Erica Lukes, but the Potato Internet for me operations shutdown. Thank you for being members says thank you, Brian, thank you Steven.

We thank you for your kindness, jet erosity and support. Amy Collins, can you be seen at all? Yeah? I don't know what everybody thinks.

Did you get timed out or something by accident? Amy Collins, I don't know. Luel come on, man, oh, I didn't see your question. I apologize.

Where was your question? I apologize? Mine? Was there not answered?

Did I skip your question? I didn't see your question. I remember questions in all caps for the guests. I didn't see a question from you.

I apologize, and Amy Collins, please accept my apology. You know that I'm a little visually impaired. So if I missed it, I apologize. It wasn't my intention.

I missed it. I apologize. Yeah, and he did have limited time as well, So lick the stream, says Daisy b And thank you for being a member. It wasn't all caps.

How did I miss it? Then? I apologize, Amy, I really apologize. All right?

Well, I apologize, Amy. You know I'm sorry that happened. He did have limited time. I thought I got them all.

I'm still scrolling back. I don't see your question. What are the rest of them? I can try to send it to him off air, and I'll email it to him for you.

I'd be happy to do that since I missed it. Yeah, I'm still not saying it. I'm scrolling through my version of the chat here. I saw a question from Randy and from Gary and from Smith, and then I don't see one from you.

It could be a problem with the stream yard chat. In any case, I apologize. Send me your question and I'll try. I'll try to send it to you to him and let you Nobody says I apologize.

Algaret is here. If Steve Wong runs his Internet off of potato, surely he knows the secrets of free energy exactly exactly. That's exactly at Albaret, thanks for holding down the twitch chat. We also want to take a moment to thank all of you new viewers on Instagram.

You can follow me on Instagram. It's at Truth Secret Show on Instagram. We broadcast our first hour on Instagram. Then I keep forgetting, but I'm supposed to remind people that Instagram only allows an hour, so please come on over to our YouTube live chat.

But I notice I'm getting a whole bunch of followers on Instagram and That's interesting because I had that account for a decade and never used it. Today I began uploading some images, So anything image related to the Truth Seeker Show, I'll be on Instagram. I uploaded some pictures earlier. I'm going to show you of my Midi studio nightmare.

It's turning into quite quite the project. Oh and I have something else I wanted to talk about real quickly as well. Yeah, so the Instagram is at True Seeker show and anything related to the show now, I'm going to be taking pictures of it and it'll be on my Instagram at True Secret Show and we'll be broadcasting live streams. Here's some shots of the new Midi studio that's slowly coming together.

It looks a mess, It sounds a mess even right now, still working on things. My god, the amount of cables that I need for those unaware, you need three cables for each device, two for the audio and one for the Midi. Well four they needed a power cable and you need to place plug that power. So this is turning into you know, four cables per device that you see in these pics.

This is turning into quite the project. And uh oh, I don't want to get to that one yet. Yeah. So I've got far too many devices and not enough wires, and I've already spent so much money on Amazon buying all these wires and I'm not even halfway through hooking it all up.

Something else that I wanted to mention, and a viewer that I want to thank, at least d Avalon, longtime show supporter, sent me this. Oh well, I have it right here, I can. I can show you this. Oh look how thick this thing is.

This is a big binder. And what is this? Uh this, my friends, is UFO gold right here? Look at how thick this is.

Look at this, It's huge. It's a binder. And this, interestingly, it says through the Instagram Disclosure Project briefing document And this was something that doctor Stephen Greer back in two thousand and one was sending people And is that interesting? And these are this is the presidential briefing and all this other nonsense from doctor Stephen Greer.

You have a need to know, you have a need to know about aliens. Oh my god. It is just a treasure trove of bullshitery the lex which I have never seen. And this is the original stuff that he would send his huge supporters.

Look, it's in this big binder. It's just there's just so much of it. It's so much and this is all the stuff that he used to send his donors and supporters for cash back in the day. And oh, we're going to be going through this.

We're going to be going through this stuff. Also, very kind of her, she sent me along with this document, she sent me a truth Seekers Tarot deck. And I'm going to try again for those unaware, I used to do a mentalism show and I would read fortune cards, but not tarot cards fortune cards. Here we go again with the mod wars.

Anyway, I try to memorize all of the tarot cards. And I've always had such a hard time doing tarot cards for people because I need to read the book in order to do it, you know, like I'm going to do the spreads and whatever, but I forget what these card means. Maybe I'll give it a try again, but we think at least Diavalon, I guess she saw this and thought of me, the truth Seekers taro and it is. It's a beautiful deck, very nice, very nice artwork on all the cards.

And I don't know about the rest of you. Even if I'm not really a believer in fortune telling or taro, some of the art on some of these decks is beautiful and nice to have around in your bookshelf. So we thank our viewer and friend, Leashee Avalon. It's nice to have supporters all around the world.

And besides this treasure trove of doctor Stephen Greer's briefing, bullshity documents and all this other stuff, also all the original VHS tapes that doctor Stephen Greer used to make and sell his fans for big bucks. We got all of them and they're all digitized and we're going to go through all of them, so you guys can expect a lot of new content centered around doctor Stephen Greer's early efforts at disclosure, and at least is in the live chat. So I'm glad that you're here to see me, Thank you and arrive today. I'm so happy to see those documents, especially, I went, oh my god, I started reading through them and I was like a kid in a candy store.

Thank you at least the Avalon for your kindness, generosity and support. Uh, Gerry, my chat just shut down. It was finished for the night. Maybe there's a problem for some Yeah, I don't know.

Yeah, and that could be somebody saying that comments are being deleted from the live chat. Arden Is are one of our moderators here and says I have seen comments disappear from chats with no mods doing it, So I think it's a glitch with YouTube. Yes, So before anybody starts making accusations about censorship and you know, people having their comments lead it, know that, yes, And I agree with arden. I am completely and totally aware that some comments just don't end up.

You know, somebody wise type something out and hit enter and it just doesn't appear in the live chat for whatever reason. We have a free speech platform here. Nobody's timed out, muted, banned, or whatever unless it's absolutely necessary. And I don't know if anybody else's comments are getting deleted.

I'll have to deal with that after the show. If they are indeed getting deleted, then, Lizzie says, I read taro. Yeah. Do you know that we once had a tarot card reader was coming to come here once a week, a girl named Stephanie from Willow Unity.

She was a nice girl. I miss her. She was fun and the reason that I did it is because I wanted to observe somebody reading taro, and I thought, if this girl will come here every week and do this, then I can sit and just watch and learn, you know, how they do it. And so a lot of people enjoyed it.

Maybe we'll have you do some tarrort readings here, Ben Lizzy. But a lot of people lost their goddamn minds when we did that, you know, because for whatever reason any case. Yeah, yeah, a lot of people think that gift that you said is very cool. And I agree, and at last says you're welcome.

No, you're welcome, or thank you. We truly appreciate that. Because some of this material, nobody else is going to have that stuff, at least only us. I'm sure somebody's got it, but nobody's gonna be doing shows about it and talking about it.

So I started to get ads for stuff related stuff. Some of the ads are weird. Yeah, Third Coast Swing is here and says, and I'm up from my slumber. Good morning, Steve, Good morning.

You're just getting up, dude. I hope you're in another country because it's like eleven pm here. If you're just getting up at eleven pm, you must have a rough day. YouTube does mob down some key words.

I've been digging the live panels since third co swing good times, yeah, good, happy to hear it. Oh man, some drama rama going on in the live chat there usually is. Yeah, thank you Atlish, We appreciate you, Thanks for appreciating us, and thanks for thinking of me. At least knew that I could use this stuff.

At least saw that stuff and said Steve Campie would love to see this shit and listen. Oh my god, I'm listening to all the videos we have, like all the original Disclosure witnesses, and it's like twelve hours of video. I think it's a lot of material. And this huge book.

I was very busy today, so it came and I came about four o'clock home with my son off the bus, and I only got to read like a little bit of it. But I can't wait to get to it. I'm gonna do it right after the show. We're gonna we're gonna go onto that all right, Uh?

What is this guy? Why? Why fools? Then you get banned from a couple of shows for being like belligerent?

Can you just behave like please, like just be nice. We don't ask much. One of our carnivals is don't be a dickhead? Can you just not be a dickhead?

Right, we'd appreciate that. Don't be like that. I just had four comments about round object that you throw blocked by the YouTube filter. Yeah, that's not the thing.

If you put curses in your whatever you're writing, Uh, then you could get your comments deleted or whatever. Right, yeah, there you go. Don't be don't be like that. Look, we got we've got two attack broads in there.

Did you know that the only moderators that I will have going forward. I decided that what I need is I need divine, feminine energy and amazon like strong powerful women protecting the best interests of me and my show. So we that are in paranormal and then Lizzie Borden in there and they don't play. They're not going to play with you being a dickhead.

So don't do it. Uh yeah, yeah, you wish, dude, You wish, dude, you wish. Yeah. Yeah.

So yeah, we're only going to have We're only going to have female moderators here. And that has nothing to do with the fact that those female moderators may attract more viewers, given that we have an eighty five percent male audience that had nothing to do with the decision at all. Nothing. No, I just think that, you know how, those women have that like motherly protective kind of instinct.

That's what I thought would be best for chatroom moderators, because they really do have to, you know, they have to protect the show's best interest, and if somebody's in there acting a fool, they got to deal with it. Albaa says the divine feminine, like Elizabeth Wilcock talks about exactly exactly we got to do the divine feminine. Well, folks, we're just about two hours. I think we've done our due diligence.

I want to thank all of you kind and generous benefactors. We want to think also thank you PayPal pledgers, you Patreon supporters, YouTube chat or excuse me, YouTube channel members, you Twitch, Twitch subscribers. Oh, we want to thank initials a V for a kind of generous ten dollars PayPal pledge. It says, thank you for your consistent content and your hard work.

We thank you for your kindness, generosity and support and for helping us to praise the cash and so we thank all of our kind and generous benefactors and supporters. We thank all of you viewers. You people download those podcasts too, are listening to the audio podcasts. Shout out to you guys, the audio crew.

We appreciate you that I was talking about this earlier to our guests, but the audio podcast downloads are really really increasing lately. So we thank all of you, and no matter where you're listening or watching, we thank you for doing so. Please sort of like, comment, subscribe, and share wherever you're like listening or watching. It really really does help to increase our reach.

Also, want to mention one more time. We're on Instagram streaming live every show now please follow me there. It's at True Seeker Show on Instagram, and you should also follow me on Twitter it's at Stephen Cambi and we post a lot of show related material there. So that's all we got for you.

I will be back tomorrow night, nine pm Eastern Standard time. I know I'll be here Wednesday with special guest Steve Long, and Thursday. I'm not sure about the rest of the week, but we'll figure that out as we go along. So that's all we got for your friends.

So I will be back tomorrow night, nine pm Eastern Standard time, and I hope, I hope that you will be here with me. So that's all I got for your friends. Oh, speaking of thanking everybody, we also want to thank our special guest tonight, Brian Dunning, Skeptoid dot Com. I will be adding the links as soon as the broadcast ends.

Right now. The link to the movie that his movie that you can watch for free on YouTube is in the description of the video. But I will be adding the other links as soon as I sign off here, and that would be skeptoid dot com and I'll get you the links to his podcast on YouTube and more so, thanks to mister Dunning for you know, coming here and I had a great evening, hope you did too. I'll be back tomorrow night, nine pm Eastern Standard time.

Hope you're here with us. Until next time, friends. My name is Stephen Cambia. Good night, God blessed all of you.

Listened something listens, sissss A, nonsensations listens, siss happens listens susss SO schools s s s S school assss

Comments & Upvotes

Transcript

It took the bat about EPP story sto st st st st st st stop stop stop. Greetings and salutations, friends and welcome. I apologize for the long winded intro. However, I think there may be a time zone issue.

I always put what the time zone is in emails and communications, but the first time a guest is here, I'm always a little bit nervous because of the time zone issue. Maybe I should have been clearer. So I'm still waiting for tonight's special guest, Brian Dunning of Skeptoid fame, to arrive. In the meantime, though I have an email prepared I'm going to send him just to check in with them, make sure everything is okay.

In the meantime, I thought that I could talk just for as briefly as I possibly can about this Miami aliens ten foot alien story. It's not a story. It's well it is, but it's a fake one. And so many people are sending me messages or you know, I don't know, videos and other things.

There's an incredible breakdown that somebody did about what a joke that story is. And one of the reasons that you could be sure that it's fake is because the very same people that we're pushing this Las Vegas alien story, which did turn out to bempletely and totally fake. That those same very same people are pushing this Miami alien story. What is the evidence for this?

There is none, virtually none, Right, So is it a strange event what happened? Yet it's not an everyday occurrence that you get that kind of police presence. However, you know, interestingly, strange things happen sometimes. I don't understand now every time something strange happens in the world, we're going to suddenly attach aliens to the situation.

And let's be clear. You know, look at the people that are pushing this story, the same people that push the Las Vegas story, people like third Phase of Moon and Goofon and you know, congratulations, they're making a lot of money, getting a lot of clicks and views pushing this story. It is a completely and totally fake story. Just notice backstage, our special guest is here, so it could breathe a sigh of relief.

I apologize for the first time a guest is ever here. If they're you know, like I always get nervous, like because we we had I can't remember who it was, and I don't want to I don't want to disparage anybody, but do you guys some of you may remember that we waited for a guest for an hour and a half and I talked about his research for an hour and a half while and the guests just I don't know, it's got stuck on a plane or something happened. But I can breathe a sigh of relief now knowing that everything's going to be okay. I have a list of notes and questions.

We want to welcome everybody into live chat for tonight's special event. If you did miss it, we did a complete and thorough review and discussion of mister Dunning's film, which I really think is so incredibly needed right now and a great effort. And also in the description of this video or podcast or wherever you're getting this, in the description, you will find a link to his excellent film, which you can now watch on YouTube completely for free. So we want to bring our special guests in here.

What can I say about tonight's guest. He has been a skeptical voice for many years. He is an author of podcast host, and now an established filmmaker. He's got a background in educating people about science, and I for I'm happy to have him here.

Let's bring him in good evenings, running, good to meet you. Apologies for being late, we had o no, I should have even said anything. I should have filled time for at least ten minutes before I said that, you know, but I'm so glad that you're here. Once in a while, somebody mixes up the time zones and I thought, oh, man, he lives in California or something.

I think, right, you're on the West coast. Yeah, oh or yeah, so yeah, I was worried that that was the case. You know, I don't even know where to begin, but I got a lot of questions for you. And first, the first thing I really wanted to discuss is the film of Course, which I think it is so very needed right now because of this over sensationalism of this topic since at least twenty sixteen, and the fact that you comment in your film, it feels to me like the whole world is getting inundated with these stories.

Have you Do you agree that there's been a rapid or rising increase in these kind of stories in the past couple of years. Oh, it's been and men so Ever, since the twenty seventeen article in the New York Times, anyone who typically would have gone into conspiracy theories or extreme religiosity or whatever it else they might have otherwise gone into the UFO alien truthism thing has been offered up as here's the thing to be obsessed with for this year. So it's had a radically disproportionate share in the public attention, that's for sure. Yeah, and were you aware of this news network?

News Nation? Now it's basically become the UFO News network, Like that's almost all we do. They're covering Grush NonStop. And I have a countdown about David Grush.

I wanted to ask your opinion of this. I think we're up to two hundred and seventeen days of this person, David Grush, who claims to be a whistleblower, and at least for once, his military background is real and his work experience isn't a lie, because sometimes these guys just say they were in the Air Force and you find out they weren't. But we're up to two hundred and seventeen days, and News Nation and many other podcasters, it's like NonStop coverage of this guy. Two hundred and seventeen days, no evidence.

What is your take on Before we get into the film, I have to ask you what your take on Brushes? I have personally, I've never seen a story with so with no evidence whatsoever, pushed this like, you know, aggressively and for so long. You know, normally, if you look at the negative comments that I get on on on the movie, because you know, half the people who watch it, they understand that it's a science film, they go in with that. The other half of people who watch it, they go in thinking it's going to be just another UFO storytelling movie like all the rest, and so they're very disappointed, and so they make negative comments.

And if you look at the negative comments, they all say Grussian fravor. You know, hey, what about Grush and Fravor? They you know, they're military men, they're they're not they can't be wrong. My question is, what would you have said a year ago if you'd never heard of Grush and Fraber?

What would you be saying? Are you left with no evidence at all? Is is David Grush really the strongest evidence? You know?

It was? It was hilarious watching that. I was on News Nation. I think twice, either just before or just after the Grush whistleblower event.

Well, they gave they gave David Grush about I don't know, thousands of hours of coverage and they let Nick west on for like three minutes, so it all equals out right, you know. Yeah, that was somebody like you to like, wait a minute, there's no evidence, Wait a minute, you know, yeah, I mean it was. It was hilarious to watch because, you know, he started telling all of these stories and we were just waiting for any specific detail so we could tell what story he's talking about, but he wouldn't give any and the only two he gave was Roswell and the silly Italy. And it's like, oh my god, it's this bad.

I never would have thought it was going to be that bad for someone to say. Literally, my friend who's a ghost hunter at Skinwalker Ranch told me that Roswell was real and that that's evidence evidence. That's his evidence. It's a guide telling that a ghost hunter told him Roswell is real.

And the fact that this is getting promoted on the news as if it's business. Yeah, this is now government acknowledgment that Roswell was real. Because this dude was in the military ones it's wild. Yeah, and we just we just found out, like my my theory on him from the very beginning.

And and by the way, I did have an insider sort of source that tipped me off about this. I knew that he was hanging out with George Knapp and Jeremy Corbell and some of these other peddlers of stories for a long time before he became a so called whistleblower. And what I said was, all this information is coming from what we call here. We have a lot of terminology.

We call them UFO wackad's, people like how put Off and Eric Davis and Louel Zondo and you know, people that have been saying the same thing Grush has been saying for years or decades and never proving it. And now it turns out we just got confirmation. Eric Davis confirmed he's one of Dave Grush's. So we have something here called the wacka Do prover maneuver.

You get one whack a do that has no evidence and he says that guy's telling the truth, and it's another guy that has no evidence. And in your film you talked about the standards of evidence, which is a great thing that I sort of glanced over and I've never talked about it here, but you were so correct in the film here, and your your point, I think, or you can you can correct me, is if you're gonna claim extraordinary things, you have to have high, super high standards of evidence. And it seems like all these peddlers of these stories, like you just said, like my evidence is a guy told me it's true. Like, so, can we talk about the standards of evidence and what would it take?

Do you think what would be smoking gun proof for evidence of alien visitation on Earth? What would it take. You'd have to have some strong evidence. It would take some kind of testable evidence that survives all attempts at scrutinizing it, and you've got broad experimental replication, you get a scientific consensus, you've got a lot of people around the world doing whatever testing they need to do.

I mean, we have no idea what this hypothetical evidence might be, so it's hard to speculate what that testing might be. But you would need to get a very broad scientific consensus that it says this is indeed an alien artifact. I don't know what you'd paper, right, like a peer reviewed paper. Well more than a peer review paper, you're widely accepted.

Yeah. And a consensus, right, a consensus of multiple scientists. And again, consensus does not mean a bunch of guys get in a room and they all generally agree on something. Consensus means you have experimental replication.

People at different labs all around the world have performed the same tests and experiments and gotten the same results. That's what consensus means in the scientific context. Yeah, and I have a strange question for you. You seem to be very knowledgeable about a great deal of things.

One of the things that bothers me is all of these people who claim to have fragments or physical evidence. And I mean I try to confirm this and talk to a few materials scientists, and it's at least this is my understanding. If you have elements, say aluminum, and it comes from another star system, somebody would know that instantly. If they put in a mass spectrometer and did like an analysis, they would know this is aluminum, but it's not from our star system.

So all these people and that test is twenty minutes, I was told. So all these people that say there's fragments, you know, they have metamaterials TTSA that was one of their You know, big, well, we have all these materials covered materials from crashes. Wouldn't we be able to test it instantly? And why is Gary Nolan, who's an immunologist doing metals analysis or you know, this makes no sense, Like wouldn't you get a material scientist and couldn't you tell immediately that this was from a different star system?

And doesn't this blow away all these people making these claims? Well? Okay, yes, and no, I mean you isotopic analysis is what you're talking about. It's made of aluminum.

But look at all the different isotopes of aluminum that are in there. What proportions are they found in Does that match the proportions that we find aluminum here on Earth? Well it may very well if you had something that was isotopically distinct that you could say, here's a mix of isotopes that we don't find naturally anywhere on Earth. Okay, so it came from off of Earth is one possibility.

Another possibility is that someone made a crapload of money to make that because we couldn't make it. Still, Yeah, this is the point that phil Plate has brought up a lot when he's been asked the same question, what would it take to what would a convincing piece of evidence of, you know, an alien artifact be, And he would go the same place, Well, it's got to be isotopically distinct. So but he mentions that he was a calibration engineer on the Hubble telescope, and to do that, they had a chunk of I don't remember. It might have been palladium.

It's been a long time since I've heard philt Well say exotic metal. Yeah, it had to be isotopically there's a great word for it. It had to all be the exact same isotope. And to get that tiny little piece of palladium like this big all the same isotope, it costs like a million dollars.

So for some rich guy somewhere to say I'm going to fake this piece of aluminum to be I don't know, maybe like Bob Bigelow, rich billionaire that's obsessed with the UFO, Maybe yeah, he could do it. I don't think he would. I really do think that a lot of the people like Bigelow are honest in their beliefs. I think he's wrong but I think he's honestly mistaken.

He's deeply mistaken, and he's gone very far down that rabbit hole. But I don't think he would pull off a hoax to fool people. Sure, sure, and I didn't mean to suggested he would, but he popped in my head as soon as I saw some rich said some billionaire. I'm like, what billionaire do I know of that loves the UFOs and aliens?

Yeah? The next thing, the Mellon family family fortune is not insignificant either. Yeah. You know John William Warner, his cousin has been on my show twice.

He's coming on again, and he rails against them like he basically you know, I don't know. I don't want to speak for him, but he was really against the whole Melon TTSA l as On know, you know, push and the narrative. That's interesting And I wanted to talk to you about these debunks in the film because it's just so interesting to me that all of the available evidence that you used is repeatable, and I always thought that was the mark of good research. If I go after you, I can find the same documents that you showed for say the Maelstrom you know, incident, and that's a mark of great research.

But isn't it interesting that they all do this lie biomission in order to make these stories work, Like in the mailstream incident, they didn't tell you. Nobody when they're telling that story says, oh, and by the way, they're just so happened to be a power failure right at that time and date that he said that these missiles went down and the aliens did it, and it we're only down from ten to forty seconds, and you know, like this doesn't even from a logic perspective. Then you have to go, wait, so aliens came all the way here from another star system just to shut these missiles down for ten to forty seconds, Like this doesn't make any sense. And the fact that nobody says that when they tell this story, at least they should throw that in there.

Oh and you know it could have been that there was a power for it, they'd leave that out. And so I always say this, the lie by omission, that's how these stories work. They all do that, right, Yeah, I mean largely, yeah, I mean most of the people who retell and retell that story and most of these stories, you know, they don't go back to original sources themselves to see what was going on. They go to the sources they've already come to accept, they go to the published sources, they go to the TV shows that have already done the cherry picking.

And I've already put together a presentation that's very carefully chosen to show just the parts of the story that support their narrative. That's and that constitutes ninety nine percent of the bull of what's available online or in printed books. If you want to find the actual facts of what happened, that's stuff that's not interesting, it's not sensational, and so it doesn't get published, it doesn't get onto the TV shows. You have to do the work to go back to the actual documents, and often that's hard to do.

Yeah, you're right, but I think he did an expert job at this. And it's funny to the Rendellshim incident. You know, I couldn't believe. I couldn't believe, Like I followed that story since the beginning, and I totally agree with you.

I remember the first telling of it and it was much more grounded. We saw some lights in the woods, you know. Then there was a you're right there, was another television show or another documentary, and suddenly this guy saw the craft and he put his hand on it. And then years later, I don't think you mentioned it, but even years later, then the binary code story got added to it.

That suddenly, when he touched the craft, he got a binary download that just so happened to translate into English somehow, like aliens communicate through binary that translates to English. Okay, but that got tacked on too, So you're right. They spent a decade tacking on every time somebody needed money or there was a new book deal or new just making up new shit, making up new chapters of the story. Yeah, do you think do you think Roswell is like that?

Roswell's a bit like that because the bodies weren't really part of the original story that got tacked on and then you know, yeah, yeah, I mean the whole story of how you know it was really Stanton Friedman who he was on assignment for the Inquirer when he went and interviewed God, I haven't looked at that for a while. What was the doctor's name, the funeral director or the other doctor now the oh well, it doesn't matter. It was Stanton Friedman, who worked with this guy and worked with other people, and who deliberately collected bits of story, and he knew they didn't go together, and he put him together because he was writing for the Inquirer, is not exactly an academic journal. He had license to be fictitious there because he was writing for the Inquirer.

And so it's a story that never had any legitimacy to begin with. And until he wrote that story, no one had mentioned the word Roswell at all. Between nineteen forty seven and nineteen seventy seventy three was when it came out in the Inquirer. I think it was just a non story.

It didn't exist in the lore anywhere. No one had made it up until Stanton Friedman put it all together. It's suddenly there's hundreds of witnesses and it's confused. The evolution of these stories that are just fascinating to me, And to me, those are much more interesting stories than the actual fake happen.

How did this get put together? I agree with you there they actually did happen, and it is interesting to follow the evolution of these things. Yeah, and so what what's your take on all the you know, just just I guess selfishly, like we try to do things the right way here, you know what I mean, Like, no, I'm not really into clickbait, and we don't just do a story because we know it'll sell. And I don't know what you're aware of, but it seems like there's no ethics or integrity anymore, especially in this media you know, frenzy environment.

Everybody's trying to make content and you know, the clickbait, sensationalized garbage, that's where all the money is. But can we talk for a moment, just let me know what you think about ethics of being a content creator today, Like how do you go against all that and survive in an environment of sharks where everybody's just throwing in there? Yeah, let's sell out Like that that alien in Miami story. People are getting twenty thirty thousand, one hundred thousand views and monetized views, so there's a reward there.

You know, that was just that was just wild. It's like, how the hell did they even get aliens out of that? But I mean there's different kinds of there's a lot of different kinds of creators. I mean there are people like people like newspaper reporters who are very poorly paid.

I mean, the newspaper industry changed more history over the past twenty years. They don't have time to do any independent research. They read the other newspaper articles. And so that's why we're not copy paste journalism.

I call that anything original. You've got creators who are are the people making the TV shows, And these are people who are knowingly making fiction and they don't care. Their business model is not producing true shows, it's producing sensational, entertaining shows. They have license to do whatever they want to do.

That's their business. There are creators who are just random people. Well there's all the people in the all the UFO personalities themselves, who are you know, generally trying to wrangle their notoriety somehow into a government contract. They're all forming these think tanks and founders, so many of them.

Now, yeah, has one, Gary Nolan has one, Louel Zondo had one, has got is working for Nolan doing what they're all trying to get contracts to identify videos as UFOs, as as alien visitors. So that I mean that there's just a lot of different models behind being being a career and why you would do whatever it is you do. You know, I I do what I do, but I'm well aware that what I do is not is not commercially desirable. You know, it's never going to be popular.

Yeah, I think I'm making making my peace with that myself. That's my issue, I think. But I'd rather like be able to sleep at night and and feel like I'm doing some some social benefit. We try to be, you know, good for we tried to be good with what we're doing here, you know, like I don't.

It's it's a bit on the shoulder that wants you to make the face by the way, I'd be great at that. I But you know what's interesting is this this in this sensationalized garbage world, there are good people, but we just kind of get lost in the weeds of it, you know, like you're you and we've got And then I always thought that the numbers are disproportionate, Like there's fouls of people that are out there making aliens in UFOs are real stories, And who do we have on the skeptical side. Not many people, you know, you know, like you, Michael Shermer, Mick West and a couple other guys. And it's like fighting that uphill battle.

You know, you got thousands of these people that are cranking out these stories. There's a lot of us out there. There's a lot of us out there doing good work. It's just not very much of it is very visible work, and so there has to be a lot of people shouldering the load to get some piece of the conversation.

Yeah, and I wanted to ask you also. One of the other things that I really liked about the film is the scientists that you talked to. And I'm going to ask about your perception. Am I wrong that ten or twenty years ago, it seems like more astronomers and astrophysicists and people like learned scientists like that, we're much more measured and cautious when somebody asked them if they were is life in the universe?

But now if you ask one, it seems like they're snapping out, yeah, there must be there has It's like they're they're not as measured anymore. Like a lot of these scientists are really sure that there's life somewhere, and we just we're this close to discovering it. You touched on that on your film, like one we're one camera or one space telescope generation away from being able to identify life on other planets possibly, right, Yeah, the Habitable World's Observatory, that's where I've got my money. That's basically what's going to replace James Web after its life cycle.

Wow, and you really think that that's going to be able to They're going to use that method of like determining what gases are in the atmospheres, and that's going to tell us that, Yeah, this Habitable World's Observatory will be able to resolve exoplanetary spectra to the point that we can tell there's all kinds of different life signs that we know to look for. A more importantly than the biosignatures, though, was the techno signatures, which are you know, it's a different thing. It's techno signatures are interesting. It's things like smog obviously, but like concrete and manufactured materials.

If you were to look at the spectrum of Earth, you would see the spectrum of concrete because we've got big cities that have a lot of concrete on the ground and that's actually makes up a significant part of the part of the signature. Yeah. Yeah, I would assume if we're detecting concrete on an exoplanet. That's not a natural that's not a natural thing.

I thought. I've often thought that they should be there should be some kind of detection to detect power, you know, like electrical power or radio waves or electromagnetic energy being being dispersed and charged or what you know. Maybe that would be another way, because you're right, the techno signature is interesting because if they have to technology, they're intelligent, So that would be even more exciting than just oh, there's oxygen and carbon and likely amino acids, so there's some form of life there. But the techno signature would be bingo, that's intelligent life.

Right. The technosignature is probably going to be more of a more of a proof than a biosignature because most of the biosignatures that we have hypothesized to look for. You know, you've got like Star Trek, the Horta that was silicon based life. Okay, here's what we need to look for.

If there's silicon based life, here's potential potential signatures to look for. There's all these different kinds of things to look for. But most of the biosignatures have natural equivalents. There's like ways that natural processes could create those, but the techno signatures are the ones that are more you know, definitive reliably.

Yeah, it's more definitive that it was artificially created by and the and the scientists in your film. I think all three of them seem to be very convinced that there is life on other planets. And you had what an astrophysicist and astronomer and somebody else, Yeah, somebody else who he was just a random guy who was there at at the telescope where we were shooting, and he was I'm sorry, oh really, Oh I didn't know that. Well, that's that's called a happy accident when you're making He was great.

Yeahs I believe he's a PhD grad student. But yeah, it's it's it's clear that the overwhelming majority of people in the field, they do agree that there is a lot of life out there. Where they don't all agree is that there's a lot of technological life out there. Most of them figure it's probably microbial, probably plant life, things like that.

I am more toward the end of the spectrum where I think there's going to be a lot of every thing, because when you've got any kind of life in a planet. Boom, You've got every kind of life on a planet. You know. It's like it's like, yeah, right, Jurassic Park, life finds a way.

Yeah, yeah, so I'm more gung ho. But but again, these are all just speculations because we don't have any evidence. Sure, everyone's got an opinion, and that's that's where mine is. But I'm the first to say, hey, it's an opinion.

Sure, sure, but it's still it was exciting for me to see three people that are that educated, you know, because I kind of believe just from the vastness of the universe and the laws of chance, like if the Earth happened by a roll of the dice, well that the dice had to fall the same way. Somewhere in this vastness of the universe. There has to be in my view, but when. But maybe that's a little bit of confirmation bias on my part or or hopeful wishful thinking.

But when you hear these very educated people who are studying exoplanets every day and and and really probing the universe, who also belie leave that, it's encouraging, right, I think so yeah, yeah, And I mean I have never personally spoken to an astronomer who thinks that there is no life anywhere. I've personally spoken to one person who thinks that he's well. It's Fraser Kine, from the publisher of Universe Today. There's about an hour long video on my YouTube channel that I posted right before the UFO movie.

We had a talk with him. He is of the school. He's not a working astronomer, he's an amateur astronomer, but he is of the school that believes there is no life anywhere in the universe except on Earth and sad thought. It is a sad thought.

I don't think it's very likely, but it's a very interesting theory. There's been quite a lot of publications on this one particular viewpoint, and it is interesting, but it's a minority view. It's clearly a minority view, okay. And also in the film, one of the things that I loved is this Christmas Tree analogy, and I wanted to see if you can explain it and expand upon it because I always thought about the problem of distance, but I never thought about the problem of time.

And in this film you give this excellent sort of way of understanding that in order for two intelligent species anywhere in the universe to communicate. It's not just a problem of distance, but it's also a problem of time. And I guess I'm not sure if that's a firm me paradox, like how long is the civilization's going to last before the apocalypse themselves? Or can you talk about this possibility of two community, you know, intelligence species anywhere in the universe communicating.

And this Christmas Tree analogy was great. I think it really showed your like background in how to educate people like I got some dumb monkeys to understand this because it's complicated. The Christmas Tree problem is my contribution to the field. I came up with that in two thousand and ten, I think, so you know, it's one of the one of the variables of the Drake equation is what is the life span of a technological civilization?

Well, of course we don't know, and of course they're going to be all over the map. If there are civilizations out there, some of them will have lasted one hundred years, some of them will lasted a million years, and everywhere in between. So we don't know what that is, but it is a real number. There is a number technological civilizations don't last forever.

Planets die, stars die, planet killer asteroids come, wars happen, pandemics happen. All kinds of different things can endo civilization. So when you picture a Christmas tree and it's got strings of blinking lights in it, So all throughout the tree you've got lights turning on and turning off, blinking and turning on and turning off, think of each light as it's on as being a technological civilization's lifespan. So although these lights are very far away, you know, we're talking hundreds or thousands of light years between these lights.

That's really hard for one group to meet another. But when you realize that there are also these lights don't blink on at the same time. Yeah, And the blink and analogy is great because in the long span of time in the universe, like humans, we're a blink, we're a blink, but we're a blank blink. And two lights in the Christmas tree that are right next to each other to be turned on at exactly the same time in order for there to be any possibility of these two having even a radio telescope conversation with sending signals through space.

So that's really horrible and unfortunate, and it sucks because anyone is interested in science, or really anyone at all, would love nothing more than to meet another civilization, an alien civilization from another planet. What would be cooler than that? Yeah? And the Christmas tree problem is just one more on the long list of problems that mean it's it's probably just not ever going to happen, So that sucks.

So while there is probably life throughout the universe, all kinds of life everywhere, the question of can two civilizations ever visit one another is a very different question and it does not have an encouraging answer to it. So yeah, look at this distance, distance and timing, Yeah, distance and time, yeah yeah, separated by multiple dimensions. I also wanted to ask you mentioned briefly about your comments and people getting so angry at you, Like I can, I get it pretty bad, but I can imagine you're you get it pretty like worse. You know, Like I just have a friend that runs Twitter spaces and he keeps telling me come into spaces, Steven.

I went into spaces and people just started yelling about me being there as a listener, like f this guy and what's he doing here listening? And like the hate and the vitriol is kind of like, is it just it's my personal belief that people get so angry with me because I'm messing with their delusional fantasy world that they want to stay in, and any attempt to pull them out kind of you know, gets the mak. I've seen some vieer comments and detractors, and how do you deal with all that? Do you just kind of ignore it or do you just you know, I mean, because it's a lot to be honest, I mean, this is not just you and I that get this.

It's every science writer on the planet gets this. If you wrote an article about COVID nineteen, you've been getting hundreds of death threats a day for years. That's just the way it is being a science writer on the internet. Yeah, you're right about that.

People were So if you're a woman, it's much much worse because you also get death threats, rape threats, all kinds of just really lude horrible shit that that women's science communicators get much worse than menu. It's it's really unfortunate. But you so you just have to have a thick skin. You ignore it, and you just tune it all out.

It's it's part of the business. And it's you know, you look at it in the right in the right light, which is that it's just kind of funny. Well it is. It is funny to a certain extent.

But like, you know, we hosted a filmmaker here that made a film about Loueli Zondo and it wasn't a kind film, do you know what I mean. Like it it really laid it out like he didn't really run a Pentagon UFO program somebody lied to in New York Times like so the truth. I had him here and we just talked about the film, and the true believers went crazy, and the next thing I know, there was people threatening my wife in the LED live chat I name like, went and stalked me on Facebook, like wow, Sherlock Holmes, you found my Facebook profile, like you know, and threatening me and like the the venom is crazy. And some of this stuff is funny, but some of it is dangerous.

Like we did this series here called Murder and UFO Land, and I'm only two in and I got three or four more where people got so wrapped up in this delusional belief system that they killed somebody over it. And you know, so there's a don't you think there's a danger here to letting this stuff run free the way that has been so pumped through our you know, interwebs and into our ears and eyes all the time, because some people get obsessed with this. If there's someone out there who is so obsessed with this that he goes out and kills someone, he was probably going to get obsessed about something else if it wasn't this, probably Yeah, good point. So, yeah, I don't think you can point the point the finger at any particular genre of you know, either misinformation or any particular field of skeptical topics.

It's just part of human nature. You've got some screwed up people out there who are not being treated for some mental health issue, and crazy stuff is going to happen. Yeah. Well, I don't know.

I just it worries me sometimes because some of these people take things too extreme, you know, Yeah, And they don't like you messing with their heroes either. Even if you're one hundred percent right, how are you dealing with You know that a lot of people hate your guts about you just blue like Maelstrom. And that's one of the other things I wanted to talk to you about. I love it when I know for sure that a story is likely really fake, because it's not just the people selling that story.

But then you've got all these UFO talking heads that repeat the story, like how many do you know? Is it just my perception? And do you know many times I've heard somebody talking about UFOs on a podcast or television show or whatever, and they say, well, you know, they're verified incidents where UFOs shut nuclear missiles. And so I love it when we know that the seed of that story is completely fake or likely fake, and then we've got all these one hundred other people repeating that story as if it's factually correct and accurate in one hundred percent verified.

It kind of, you know, blows away the deceptions, right, And I don't know if these people are just they didn't do the research that you did, or they don't care when they're repeating. The amazing thing to me is that it seems to be such a controversial thing to say that you shouldn't believe everything on television and what most of these in the case of the alien truthers is my term for the people who believe we're being visited by aliens and UFOs represent alien spacecraft. Almost all of their information they've essentially gotten it from watching TV shows, and the con research the concept that a TV show might be fictionalized or might be sensationalized or dramatized for television, that is a completely challenging concept for many. It's still it is still very prominently believed that if it's on TV, it must be true.

Yeah, and unfortunately, don't you think we were, like some of us are at the age that we were programmed when we grew up, there was only Channel twelve and those documentaries were good, like and actually to this day PBS News Hour, that's something that you can trust that they actually investigated, that they actually have evidence for the stories. But you know, that's one percent of You're right, that's one percent of what's on television is actually well investigated, well researched, well sourced, well documented, and the rest is you've got to be careful, Like you can't get your information from that stuff, right. Yeah. I do wish more people would watch PBS News Hour instead of whatever else it is they're watching, But good luck with that.

Yeah, And I wanted to talk to you also about this situation with some of these so called government whistleblowers because I don't understand something. For seventy plus years, the story has been at the United States government is covering all this up. But since twenty sixteen, the UFO community, whether people believe it or not, is getting infiltrated by intelligence members. We've got Defense Intelligence Agency person who used to work in information warfare is now an alien contact ee out in the UFO community.

We've got John Ramirez from the CIA. We've got Lil Alzando from the Pentagon. We've got David Grush, We've got John Ramirez formerly of the FBI. All these three letter agency people are suddenly going to bring us the truth alliens, but they never seem to actually talk about any evidence.

But one of the things I've noticed is they all do this sort of shuffle where they kind of claim that they have top secret insider information, but yet they never actually prove anything, and they dance around and talk about their NDA's or that's you know, I've gone too far. It's it's almost like a lark, like a live action role player, like they're they're Fox Molder and they're gonna, you know, they're gonna turn on the government and tell us all the truth, and you made some excellent points, like about this mailstream in the film, like he's been writing books about this. This is not classified information. So are all these people just bluffing to have some kind of insider classified information to sell their stories and sell them So here's here's the thing with all of these ex government and next military officials who are coming out and saying that UFOs are actually aliens.

The reason the networks use these people as their spokesman and the reason the whole you know, the leaders of the UFO movement continue to seek out guys like David Grush to bring him to the four. Hey, look at this guy. He when he was in Afghanistan, he looked at aerial photos. So therefore let's call him an intelligence expert.

So he's a senior intelligence official. The idea is that that people are going to get is that, oh, this guy was in government or the military, and if he says aliens are real, that means he probably learned that as a result of his experience working in the military. So hey, his word is probably pretty good because he had access to really good information in that position. That's not how it works.

That's the opposite of how it works. When you're looking for the next UFO personality, you don't go you don't go to the military and you say, hey, who here has has had some UFO experience in the military, Because no hands are going to raise. You go instead to a UFO conference where everyone there is a full belief in alien truth and you say, hey, who here was ever a veteran? Half the hands in the room are going to go up because that's the distribution of veterans in culture.

So right away you've now got five hundred military veterans with UFO beliefs. It's very easy to find them. Joining the military does not confer immunity from strange beliefs or an intelligence organization, right because we've seen so many of them. Nothing, there is nothing you can do that confers intelligence from immunity against strange beliefs.

We know this from decades of study and conspiracy theories and conspiracy ideation. There's labs around the world that have surveyed hundreds of thousands of people for decades to see who believes what and try to find matches with demographics and if you believe in this, what else do you believe in? And we've got a very detailed picture of how belief systems work. And one thing that we can say for sure is that there is no demographic at all that is immune from weird beliefs, and that includes being in the military or working in the FBI or wherever you want to be.

There's going to be just as many people with weird beliefs in that group as there are in any other group. So it's not hard to find these people. And the fact that there are people like David Grush, who had some intelligence duties at one time, who now believes apparently any any UFO story that a ghost hunter tells him they were wolves too, they were hunting were wolves, tooltergeist. That doesn't mean that it is the conclusion of that agency officially that aliens are visiting the earth.

It means you've got one person with some strange beliefs. Yeah. And you know what else I keep saying, is this conflation of two different things. You know.

Oh, the Intelligence Community Inspector General found his claims his claims to be urgent incredible. The Intelligence Community Inspector General never never commented on mister Grush's alien and UFO claims. He called his complaint urgent incredible, but I was told by a spokesperson they are they find every complaint urgent incredible. But the UFO guys are using this urgent incredible thing to kind of claim that the Intelligence Community Inspector General is co signing his alien in UFO and body alien body claims.

Is conflation kind of part of how some of these stories work. They just kind of move the pieces around to suit their story, or you know, like anybody can call the ICIG and confirm that what I'm saying is accurate. He never co signed his alien and UFO claims. But there's I could show you twenty examples where people are saying that I don't have any information on that.

That's interesting though, But yeah, I mean, I will say it again. It goes back to who the person is and what is their motivation for being interested in this And if you are among the crowd of you know, George Knapp and Jeremy Corbel and Leslie Kane and Luella Zondo and they all got together with David Grush and said, hey, dude, come on, you've been with us for years. Be a whistleblower. Come out and say tell THEE tell these stories as if you're someone coming coming forward, and so when you're in his position.

Here, here's my take on Grush, and I don't of course, I don't know him personally, and this is just a personal observation. He's obviously someone who's very, very inclined to believe in these stories. He wants it to be true. A lot of us want it all to be true.

He believes that it's true. He probably believes that it's very important this information get out there that he believes is true, and so he is willing to put himself out there and get subjected to ridicule and whatever else. And you know, he had the yeah, the thing with the police spilling the fact that he was taking antidepressants or something that was yeah, and he got there too. Yeah.

But you know, he's willing to put up with this because he's doing what he sees as an important and heroic thing because in his mind all this stuff is true, because he believes his friends and all these things his friends told him. That's my take on Grush. Yeah, I don't think very simple. I don't think he's lying either.

I think he truly believes what he's saying. But what he's what he's doing is just repeating stories that people told him, and there's a complete total lack of evidence there. And I also wonder, you know, like mister Dunning, I think you're a married man, Like I wonder about his wife because anybody, and I got in a lot of trouble. People attacked me viciously for this.

But anybody can look on YouTube and see millions and millions and millions and millions and millions of monetized views of interviews with Grush, stories about Grush whatever. There's a lot of money. There are hundreds of thousands of dollars have been generated through him, and I'm curious what's his take on that, and how does his wife and family feel, if you know, because some people are saying he's not getting paid. I keep hearing that, and it makes me think that maybe he's just being taken advantage of by by profiteering people, you know, and that's sad.

It makes me sad for him, It makes me it humanizes him a little bit. Like, you know, I don't want to just attack the guy. I think he's being honest. He believes this stuff.

You have to do this to do what he's doing, You've got to believe it. I guess the standard operating procedure for all of these TV interview shows, all the documentary production companies that are on, all the pseudoscience channels, you know, History not Geo Travel Channel, Science Channel, Discussage, all the popular fake history, fake science channels, the standard, the standard practice is you never pay anyone who comes on as a guest. There are some of us who don't do it anymore unless you pay us something. I mean, I'll do one of those things for fifteen hundred bucks, but I'm not going to do them for free anymore.

Good for you, Yeah, your time is worth something than your contribution. And that that knocks out ninety nine percent of them. They say, they try and feed you some bullshit line. Oh it's going to be great exposure for you, you know whatever.

But yeah, all the news agencies that have grush on all the they're probably they're probably throwing him, you know, a couple of grand He's making some money, but he's not cleaning up and he's not getting rich. Yeah, yeah, is what it makes me think. It makes me think that he's being taken advantage of it because of hundreds of thousands of dollars are being generated by all these people and they're throwing them two grand to do an interview. You know, that's that's not necessarily fair.

And interestingly too, you know they they really harp on these people's credentials. Back to the subject of these people in the military. Is that just because they can't talk about the evidence, so they spend all their time talking about their career and their credentials and credential it's it's it's amazing how Yeah, they rely on credentials a lot of times. I was, who was I talking with?

Who's the current Skinwalker Ranch guy, Brandon fugel h He and I were trying to maintain a cordial relationship on him tries to even talks to you. I was, but I mean, I will try and I will try and do my best. But he eventually ended up just ghosting me. But he was constantly he was very he's very sincere in what he does with with the with his current Skinwalker Ranch show.

He is he is a believer in what he's doing. He thinks he's doing the right thing. He thinks it's worth spending his money on. He's not trying to be deceptive.

He acknowledges that the show sensationalizes some stuff and he expresses some frustration at that. And in my conversations with him, he would constantly talk about how Travis Taylor has two PhDs. Okay, yes, I yes he has. He is a He's an excellent aeronautical engineer.

If I was designing an airplane wing, he is the first guy I would go to. But having two PhDs in you know, aeronautics or whatever. They are optical physics, the wather one, I think optical physic. Yeah.

You watch him on the show, which is amazing because he can't tell the difference between a bug flying by the camera and his alien spaceship doing seventy thousand miles an hour or something like that. You're right, yeah, no, Zary, I am. I. I have had never had any contact with with him.

But my read on him on Travis Taylor is that he he knows, he knows who's paying the bills, and he's just being a showman. He's just being a TV performer. I mean, he's been doing TV for a long long time. He's been doing TV longer than he ever worked in something.

God bless him. I kind of liked that show where he did like hillbilly stuff. They like built a submarine and like trash cants and stuff like. I like that.

That was fun. He knows what he's doing as far as being a TV personality, So that's why you're going to see him do ridiculous stuff like you know, thrown over the page on his whiteboard to say wormhole was his big explanation for Yeah, and he just so happened to already have that there. He just so happened to already have that there, as these guys are ros have been completely ridiculous like that because he knows that that's what makes good television, and the people watching the show say that must be right. He has two PhDs, so credent go an incredibly long way because they're super, super compelling to many viewers.

Yeah, and a lot of it seems to me that a lot of UFO and alien stories are sold on the credentials of the storyteller, but sometimes those credentials turn out to be completely and totally fake. We've been working on this. Charles Hall, who was the originator of the Tall White Alien I called the Tall White Alien myth, and his whole story begins with when I was in the air Force. Then he tells this grand story I was a weather observer.

I went to this class and he gives some pretty specific information. So we checked it all. We went to the National Personnel Record Center. No, Charles Hall, he never served in the Air Force.

We checked again, never served in the Air Force. I had internal Air Force contacts or a source. Luckily, like you've got to be one hundred percent sure, because I don't want to accuse this guy being like a stolen valor fraud. If it turns out, you know, then some issue.

He had three different birthdays, one on Facebook, one in a book once, you know. So we checked all three. No records of him ever being in the Air Force, which is interesting because the whole story begins with when I was in the Air Force. And he's even got pictures of him in like Air Force uniforms that look period, right.

But there's some problems, like here's a picture of me in Vietnam and there's all these street lights, you know, like something's not ray, you know, and so and his answer was, I don't have a need to know. That's why the government won't give me his Air Force records. So some of these myths fall apart on credibility, like they were built on fake credibility. Have you experienced a lot of like stolen valor frauds, And there's a lot of There was a lot of stories for a while about fake Navy steals and things like that.

I can't say I personally have run into a lot of that. I mean, you know, it's it's part of the picture. But you know, I really do believe that with the exception of some of the people at the top, you know, the Luella Zondo's and the Leslie Keynes, these are people who are absolutely consciously deceptive about what they do. But with the exception of those people, the vast, vast, vast majority of the personalities in ufology are honestly mistaken and honestly misled and honestly believe in what they're doing.

I think frauds and hoaxes are a small, small part of the picture. Really. I think maybe I've gotten too cynical because we cover, yeah, we cover an awful lot of scammy stuff here. And so one of my friends told me that I'm getting to wait too cynical because my go to right away is like scam, you know, just before I even dig into it.

And that's not good either. I want to be fair to people, but it seems like I just don't know how. I've often said this, like there's here's a perfect example, third phase of the moon. They they post a video and they and they clickb a title at best UFO video of the year, and in the original video that they sourced, it gives the time and the location of the sighting.

And so I looked at that. I went to flight Radar twenty four dot com and in thirty five seconds I identified it as a high altitude balloon in the exact area. And every you know, it pops up on your screen. So in that case, like they could have identified it in thirty five seconds, And sometimes I think they played dumb, like you know, oh, we're just putting it out there, or you know, help us solve this mystery.

It's not mystery if you can solve it. I made a video and I timed myself going a flame Radar twenty four like look there, oh we see a balloon popping up on the map. There it is. And when we even identified the other plane in thirty five seconds that was in the video, Like don't you think some of this stuff is completely intentional.

And it's just like, because they made a lot of money off that video, and I couldn't have if they were honest about what it was, you know, But this is now, this is this is talking about a segment of creators who are in the entertainment business. They're not in the fact business, and they're not in the belief business. They're in the entertainment business. So it doesn't matter what they do.

Facts and beliefs and what's true and what's not is not a part of their It's not a part of their calculus for what they're doing. If you're trying to make entertainment, entertainment that makes money, none of that matters. Yeah, you just need to keep in our minds what's separate. You need to be able to recognize who is a creator who's just out making money making entertaining programming and doesn't care if it's true or not, and who is someone who's doing their best to get at the facts of a matter.

There was there was a thing on a Skinwalker ranch. Again, well, I had to force myself to watch it. I can't watch it when my friends watches it. When I go over his house and I'm like, oh, come on, dude, I can't sit through this.

There was a thing where they had I don't remember what they were doing, but they're in their little headquarters looking at all their computer screens and whatever it is they're paying attention to was one thing. But then someone said, hey, look there's a government jet circling us. And the government jet was making some weird pattern like this over a Skinwalker ranch. And it's like, well, that's odd, what's up with that?

And then they didn't mention it any further. So I went to I went onder the I think I went onto the metabunk forums where someone had been discussing, Oh, yeah, here's the plane, because you can get the plane on flight aware. Yeah you can see radar twenty four. Yeah, you could see the flight pay at everything.

You get that, you get the end number on the plane, you get its registration number, you look it up, you see who owns it. And this particular plane was owned by some oh shoot, this is a long time ago. It was some federal meteorological agency doing some kind of scientific research. I don't even remember exactly what it was, but the pattern they were flying was absolutely normal for what they were doing.

I believe it had something to do with calibrating their engines. Yeah, so you're going to be going up and down different altitudes to twitt the sensors. It was something like that. It was something really really boring like that.

But when we got the name of the agency that owned the plane, I did what people don't think to do anymore. I simply picked up the phone and called them and asked who's in charge of that plane and got transferred a couple of times and talked to the guy who knew, and he told me exactly what they were doing. No big deal. How hard was that?

So obviously the producers of the Skinwalker Ranch TV show are not going to go to that kind of effort because they don't care what the plane is. Actually effort, which was that there's a scary government plane strange over our ranch. They're spying on us because they know we're uncovering the truth. That was the implication.

That was what they needed for the TV show. Yeah, and I wanted to see to make sure you know my my audience really, I've gotten such incredible feedback. I got so many messages thanking me for showing my audience this film. You want to talk a little bit about your podcast and what you guys do on your podcast.

Ah. Yeah, So my main gig, my full time job is at Skeptoid Media. We're a nonprofit. I started doing the Skeptoid podcast in two thousand and six.

There was two thousand podcasts that existed at the time, so it was really easy to quickly become a big fish in a small pond. So that was great. Good for you. I'm a lado gopper.

About three months after I started the podcast, I got put on the front page of iTunes like new and Notable or whatever, and it went from fourteen thousand downloads a week to forty thousand downloads a week, and I got five hundred dollars bill from my ISP for bandwidth. Oh no, we didn't have back before hosting. Yeah, that was back you had a host. Oh no.

So it became a full time job for me after four years, and then two years after that it became a nonprofit. And now we've got oh we've got probably about twenty five thirty people involved at some level. Only four of us are full time employees and still doing the show. We weekly.

We're producing documentary films, trying to be working on one all the time. We're just now that the UFO movie is finished up, we're going to be starting our next one this year. We're always working on grant funded projects for a video series. We're doing a series for NPR Radio.

We're doing a spec series for PBS Digital. So we're trying to do as much as we can, trying to get this kind of skeptical, scientific skepticism, critical thinking content out into the world to whatever degree we're able. I see a few people in the comments have have mentioned Skeptoid and someone yeah here, Yeah, So I appreciate you all very much. You know, we are a member supported organizations.

So if you want to go to skeptoid dot com, click on any donate or go premium button or whatever and become one of our supporters and you get all kinds of great benefits for doing that. It's well, yeah, and ipodize I put the film in the description. I'll put that in the description as oh, the film is great too, skeptically dot com. Uh yeah, And it was interesting for me to see and encouraging for me to see because, by the way, I'm trying to become a filmmaker to make documentary films as well.

It's one of our big goals for twenty twenty four. I've made a few, made a few free ones, but you know, I'd like to make one where I break even called for twenty twenty four. But I noticed that you went for your for the film. I'm sorry, I have the Skeptoid website, not the film.

You got a bunch of awards, right, You went to a bunch of film festivals and things like that with the film. It's done very well in film festivals. There's the best Documentary at one, Best Director at another one, which I dispute. I don't think I was the best director, but I appreciate the award very much.

And then we've got a bunch of runner up and honorable mention and all these awards listed here. You Yeah, it's all these awards listed here on the website. And the film is made under your nonprofit, so it's a public benefit sort of, yes, and no normally are all of them are because of because of weird complicated thing that we don't get into. I did this one personally as a side project, which we wouldn't do again.

It's basically it's a toid media film and we've already thrown it into the Skeptoid Media Library. I basically just granted the company full rights to use it however, so you can download this and you can buy it from us. And yeah, and then by the way, I I had mentioned, uh, it was on my list to you know, one of those things like oh I got I got it. I gotta pay for this movie because a few different people, skeptical people messaged me and they say, and they all said, Steven, you've got to see this film, like you gots and I went, okay, oh, and then you know, and then I looked and go, I got to buy it.

Oh, I want to support him. I didn't get to it. And then you put the film on YouTube for free. So I was one of the leaches.

But I just want to thank you and tell you that I enjoyed this so much that I'm still going to buy it, just because I want to support you. And do you have plans to do another film like this, in this kind of genre, in this kind of vain. We are not certain yet what the next film is going to be, but probably probably yes. Our previous film, Science Friction, was all talking heads.

I mean there was no host, no narration. It was all scientists, who had been misrepresented, edited out of context when they go on Discovery Channel or whatever. You know, a lot of times these talking head people, they'll have their sentences literally sliced and diced and the words re arranged to make it sound like they said something stupid. Whatever.

The directors wanted wanted to get across with with their pseudoscience documentary. So it was and it was a very good movie. It's science Friction and that's available on all the streaming services to check it out. Yeah, it's that's a fun one.

But it's a very different style from this because there was no narrator. I didn't appear in it at all. I think you can hear me asking someone a question once. Sometimes that's the best way to do a film like oh no, no on come of time for me.

All right. Yeah, we had a different director for that, and that was the way he rolled and his it was a really neat style. So I'm not sure what we're going to do for the next Oh someone asked his Skeptoid podcast on YouTube. Yes it is, yeah, and I will I'm a terrible show host.

I'm going to add his skeptoid dot com website to the description of the video. It'll be here right after broadcast, and I will add the Skeptoid podcast on YouTube links as well, both on YouTube and on You're on all the all the audio podcast platforms, right yeah, And you say you're getting hundreds of thousands of downloads a month. Oh you know. The funny thing is the peak was twenty eleven, and since twenty eleven, the actual number of listeners has gone steadily declined.

Ah, that's sad. I'm sorry to hear that, but but no, if if you compare that to the number of podcasts available and the number of podcasts, these things correlate, Those lines correlate, right, crazy, So actually we have a larger and larger share. Our share has grown when you consider what people are choosing from, what options are available. So it's a really it's a really weird it's a really weird statistic that, Hey, great, our listenership went down again.

Yeah, but we're I think we're one hundred hundred and forty thousand a week something like that. That's crazy. I'm lucky to get ten thousand a month. But our focus is really on the video side of things.

But we shoot out the audio podcast for old timesake, because I started an audio podcast land with my previous show. But like, it's amazing to me when you guys get that that many downloads, Like that's just insane to me because you know, it helps out the show here, just to have that audio podcast, get a couple hundred dollars a month for a new microphone or something I need or you know, whatever is going on. Right I realized turned on my little, my little background lights here. Oh okay, you got a synthesizer behind you too.

You should see what I'm doing right now. They're not working, batteries are dead. Against my better judgment, I just went, I'm gonna dig all my old synthesizers out of my garage and hook everything up again. And I'm four hundred dollars in cables later because I have so much stuff.

And yeah, look, there may be a couple of uncomfortable questions here, but I think we've got a good conversation, and you seem like, you know, you know, get pissed or upset. Spooky is a big Grand Hancock fan and says what happened after Grant Grant Hancock confronted you on Joe Rogan experience. Yeah, I've never had any any dealings with Graham Hancock. So I'm not sure what you're referring to.

Okay, going on Rogan was a mistake. I would never do that again. Really, why did you think you thought it was a bust? Yeah, I mean, I mean you go on there as a as a hostile guest.

I went on there specifically to confront him on his history of promoting false conspiracy theories, and he didn't care for that. And you know, they took the show down only a couple of weeks after it went up. They replaced it with a deceptively edited twenty four minute cut. They cut three hours down to twenty four minutes.

Oh, I gotta find the original. I want to see this. In fact, in fact, Vice is making a documentary right now on Rogan, and they interviewed me for that a couple of months ago. I have no idea when it's going to come out, Probably not too much longer, but keep an eye off for it.

When you see a Vice documentary on the Joe Rogan experience, I'm in that and it's we tell that story, so it should be pretty good. Oh, that's pretty interesting. And we talked about Eric Davis, the Wakado who had He made a paper for the United States government. Eric Davis did it and it had like pictures of Barney the Dinosaur and a time war behind Barney the Dinosaur like he's a whack of do And Gary o'kee says, can I be the first to say I would not trust any government or elite billionaire to tell me what was alien or not.

I'd want to see a live body of myself. Well, thank you all for your kindness, generosity and support of the show. It's much much appreciated. The alien bodies, I don't know if you're aware of this.

And I was interested in the crash retrieval side of things. So we did fourteen different crash retrieval stories and pretty much determined that almost all of them are completely fake or there's zero evidence for all of them. Do you think this recent push with the alien bodies and crash retrievals is this just rehashed stories? Because we found an episode of In Search of with Leonard Nimoy from nineteen eighty one zero where they tell this same story and that's, you know, forty something years ago.

Is this stuff just getting rehashed or is there some some new information somewhere. I think new stories come out from time to time, but mostly it's the it's the old ones getting getting told and retold. I mean, Grush couldn't come up with anything better than Roswell and Italy, you know, nineteen thirty three and nineteen forty seven, and nothing happened in nineteen thirty three. The story wasn't even written until the I think the eighties.

Yeah, and William Brophy was involved in that, who was also involved in the Trinity Crash. He's where they got the idea of bodies and it went to the Vatican, and the Vatican was involved in the He tacked that on William who was also involved in the Trinity Ufo crash. And God bless Jack Vile. I used to like his books, but Jesus, he went, he went balls in on that story and he refuses to believe it was.

It was a hoax. And like the piece of metal somebody identified as a as an industrial part to an industrial windmill, like the part they said that they ripped this piece of metal off the inside of the Flying Saucer and it turns out to be from a windmill. And there's all these other problems with the story. The same guy involved in that hoax is pushing the Italian UFO case or bolstering Bill Brophy is.

I mean, I read a fair amount about him when I was doing an episode on the Mussolini UFO thing, and uh not a doctor have not examined him, but my opinion is that he's very clearly suffers from mental disability of some kind. And that's sad, okay, because when you're just sending letters to people and adding on to their UFO stories, that's that's very welcome input. You know, he doesn't he doesn't really go anywhere and do anything in person or make appearances and stuff. He just would write these strange letters.

But the UFO hucksters must love him though, because he is shit. Grush got on in front of Congress and told that story, told a story that was literally made up by a madman. Thank you, mister, mister Puxley for kind of cenerosity and support, he says, this is awesome. Yeah, and uh yeah, I'm glad that you're here, and I'm glad to know, to be very honest with you.

On a personal side, like seeing this movie made me feel a little bit less alone, you know, I feel I'm screaming from the void here, like this story is fake, and this story is fake, and this story is fake. And it was good to see a big, well produced movie that you know, Okay, I'm not the only sane person in the room, you know, like it was good to see that. You Yeah, and you you mentioned some you know, pretty negative feedback from some of the true believers. Does aren't you getting equal amounts of praise for this, because I've heard many people praise this movie as well as being like a breath fresh air among uto documentaries.

Yeah. No, The feedback on on YouTube anyway, is you don't get feedback from the from the streaming services, but once we put it on YouTube, it's overwhelmingly positive. It's like eighty eight percent you know, up votes and twelve percent down votes. Well, most people people like it.

And I've got a lot of feedback from even people I haven't spoken to from years have just come out of the woodwork and said, hey, I saw the movie. It's it's been very gratifying. Yeah, And what are your plans for the coming year? What are you going to be working on?

You said you mentioned a new film. You guys are starting right, And I guess we are. In our podcast, We're we're juggling kind of four things at once right now, which is trying to figure out what the next movie is going to be, and then there's this potential PBS digital show, and there's this uh in tr NPR program that we're putting together the all the all the episodes of right now, and then of course our regular production schedule with Skeptoid, which is a hell of a grind that takes up most of my time, is just doing the podcast. So yeah, it's a it's a it's a busy year.

It's a crazy well good for you that will keep you out of trouble. Tales of the Sonic Voyde says, great show, great guest, great show. Thanks Stephen and Bryan, thank you for your kindness. I appreciate that.

And listen, Uh, I don't wanna, I don't want to make you feel uncomfortable. I feel like we've had such a great conversation. But you know that some of these true believers will go and take any advantage that they can to try to discredit somebody. And so I was into Spaces and they were talking about your film, and somebody brought up the fact that you had some problems in your past, and my and and my and by the way, I just want to tell you that I support you.

I'm a second chance person, and I know so many people that got kind of railroaded into some situation, and that system is not exactly fair. You know, somehow you're supposed to have the resources to fight you know, the entire government by yourself, but you had some problems in your past, and some people are using that to sort of say his film is not credible. And my kind of thing is like, wait a minute, Like I went and got the documents that he's showing to prove that what he's saying is correct and accurate. So is this a case of if they can't attack your evidence, they attack you personally.

Yeah. That's my favorite feedback to get is when they go they have to resort to the ad hominem it. They either don't have any or can't come up with any, or have run out of arguments against what I'm saying, so they just go, ah, he's got negative show on his Wikipedia page. I wouldn't listen to anything he says.

So that's that's my favorite. If I'm going to get negative feedback, that's my favorite to get that's fair and to be honest with you, you know, reading up on that stuff, I kind of like, I have a background in computer science, and you know, I'm like a lifelong hacker. And I'm sorry, I'm not sorry. That sounds like something that I would do, Like, you know, like maybe I got caught up.

I found some way to exploit to fuck the system, honestly, like I figured some exploit out and uh, and I used it, you know, like I But the fact that people are going to use that against you when your evidence is like it's it's irrefutable, the evidence that you put forth in the show, in the in the film. So I guess that's just an attempt to stay in their delusional fantasy world. Right, I don't know if they're attempting to stay in their delusional fantasy world. I don't know that.

I think it's again, I tend to I tend to find that most people are generally honest and try to do the right thing. And when you are someone who firmly believes in the reality of something whatever that that might be. UFOs are aliens, you're a member of some religion or another, you know that something is true. You're going to say whatever you need to say to make sure the people who in your mind are wrong know that they're wrong.

And I mean it's it's an honest attempt to promote what they believe is the correct, the truth, correct answer. Andrew's got a great question. Is Brian a former UFO Aliens Visiting Earth believer or were you always a skeptic? Everyone I know in the field of science communication grew up reading all of the books on Bigfoot and the Permuta Triangle and Aliens Time Life series.

Remember that when we all had we all believed every word of it. So when I was a kid, I believed every word of all of that stuff that I read, and a lot of these stories in particular, stayed in the back of my head, and I'm wondering what it was actually going on here, What was actually going on with the flight of the five Avengers that crashed in the in the Barrita Triangle, and what was going on with this haunted house where the writing appeared on the walls as people watched and people were recording this, and you know, what's really going on with these situations? And so later on then when I got into you know, I went to college for writing. I was writing for film and television, is what I was doing in college.

So I came into science writing not through science but through writing. So and I had a computer science minor that I never did anything with, but that's kind of how I got into the whole time. Yeah, I was. I was not a fan of computer science education, as much as I love computer but they're terrible educating.

It's like here, learn see by tomorrow. You know, like I didn't have a good experience. But the opportunity to start doing the science podcast was my opportunity to go back into all these stories that had stayed in the back of my mind and say, hey, can we find out what was really going on? And you know, with those two stories that I mentioned, we do know exactly what was really going on, and I actually made a significant contribution to the field and in one of those that is very gratifying.

So it's it's really really exciting to me to go back to stories that I know pretty well because I used to believe in them one hundred percent. I was a little kid, and then when you're in your college age, in your twenties, you don't really think about this stuff too much. But then later, you know, when you're taking a more serious view, you go back to it and you get to actually all of these mysteries, and that is just so much fun for me. I love it.

Yeah, I'm kind of I'm kind of right there with you. Uh yeah. And Steve Long says most of us believe these stories as kids, and if we don't diligently research them, and most don't, life is busy. We continue to believe them as adults, especially if we meet others who reinforce those beliefs.

Yeah, and it looks like I grew up with a lot of those stories too, if it was like a I remember, that's the first thing I would do at a new school is go check out the library and see if they had any books on UFOs, aliens, bigfoot, you lockness, monsters. You know that's the first thing you do. And you're right, I did the same kind of turn back around, like all those stories you loved as a kid, let's dig into them. Oh no, this one's fake.

This one's fake, this one's fake. It's like being a killed joy. Yeah. Well, I definitely want to I definitely want to thank you for both the film and for coming here and I appreciate I appreciate the work that you do, and so much of my audience h does as well.

And just want to let you know you have a lot of supporters here. You always welcome back and we appreciate what you do. Mister Dunning. This was a lot of fun for me too.

Thanks for having me, and it's nice to sort of engage with all the people in the chats here are going on. Oh sure, did you want to take some questions or did you want to take some questions? We can tell you what's limited to fifteen minutes if we can, okay, sure questions from a live chat for mister Dunning. Put them in all cap of letters, will do them in the order they are received.

So if you have questions from mister Dunning, now's the time to do it, and hurry up. He's only got a few minutes, and we do appreciate your time. I know how busy you must be. You know what I always say this, mister Dunning.

The worst person you can ask to do a guest spot for you is somebody that has their own show because they got their own crazy they're where they don't got time to come and talk to you for two hours. People do it to me all the time, and I have to blow I have to well I don't want to say blow them off, but you know, like I have to pick and choose, like or say hey on this week and I'll have some time if you can do it between these hours or you know, so we appreciate it. The first question, what is Brian currently excited about the most? That's a good question, currently excited about?

Like what subject? Does you know? An interesting thing about doing my weekly show is that every single week is something a totally different subject, and I'm deeply immersed in something that's completely different from what I was doing the week before. But I think that the thing I was working on this past week is I think a direction that we're probably going to go for our next movie, which is the context and the motivation of people making strange claims.

The subject was I'll just be really brief here. The subject of this episode was the chronovisor have you heard of that? I think so that nineteen seventy Jesus thing. Yes, he said he came up with some machine that lets you see into the past.

You can see and hear into the past, and so We talked about that, and you know, it's easy to you know, debunk the story and that no such device ever existed. That's not the interesting part. The interesting part is when you come to the question of why is this monk coming up with this bullet that, yeah, and it was really interesting. We don't know because he's dead and he never spoke about why he did it.

But what was interesting was that he claimed one of the scientists who helped him build it was Werner Vone Brown of the Saturn five rocket. What an odd person to help you build a time machine. Why would you claim that, living in Italy, that Werner von Braun came over from the US and spent weeks and months with you building this device. And the reason he picked Braun von Braun was that his first publication about his device came just a few days after Apollo sixteen splashed down.

Oh so, of course the time in the world when science was grabbing more and more of the public consciousness and taking more attention away from the church, and so this guy was feeling more and more marginalized, and he came up with this science based device to prove the factuality of religion. And when you look at it that way, it's like, oh, okay, it kind of makes sense that he was just trying to get himself out of being marginalized. He was trying to bring the church back into problem with this device. So that's an interesting take that you can look at something and again humanizing the people involved, you've always find out something far more interesting than just whatever the myth was.

That's interesting. Great, great question, mister ian. Take a look at a couple more of these really quick. Yeah, here we go, Randy nineteen seventy nine.

Wouldn't the people at bettwater Is be aware of the orphan the lighthouse at the time of the rendelstam Ufo event. So there's a lot of different people involved. The issue with the Americans, these guys who you know were all the primary characters is these were American teenagers and they had been there a matter of weeks or months. Many of them had not left the base at all, and if they did, there was like this one pub that they were allowed to go to.

They didn't go town at all. They had never seen it from the air, they didn't know anything about it. They didn't even know which way the beach was. So no, they did not know of the existence of the Orford Nusts Lighthouse.

Undoubtedly some people did. I mean, if you look at the police report when they called the police and say, hey, we think something might have crashed here in the forest, can you come help us check it out? Yeah, they were just like, oh, that was the lighthouse. Yeah, they were pointing at the blinking light of Orford Dust lighthouse.

Case closed because of course the police knew about it. But these American teenagers who'd been there for a short period of time. No, it's actually quite reasonable to accept that a lot of them did not know about the exist Uh, Gary, come on, mister conspiracy. Does Brian believe the leads of the world are controlling all the grifters and ultimately us, Yes, no doubt about it.

Next question, Next question, Has anything Brian? This is a great question. Actually, I want to know this myself. Has anything Brian investigated stuck with him as particularly hard to explain a lot of a lot of these stories, a lot of urban legends are impossible to come up with a conclusion.

But the reason isn't that they're just so mysterious. The reason is that there's just not enough information. You can't call me you don't have any information to work from. And you can say this that just about any famous case, you know, black eyed children, that's one of theirs that there's just not another stories.

There's not enough information information, There is no there's no photographs, there's no videotape, there's nothing that you can actually look at to consider. You don't have a piece of evidence that you can test, and so it's like, I don't know, maybe something happened that we don't know because we just don't have enough evidence. Yeah, So that's that's the unfortunate answer to that question. I wish.

I wish the answer to that question was, Oh, yeah, this case, it was so mysterious, it just doesn't fit into our understanding of the world. We could only say that if we had enough information to make that conclusion, and we just never do. Yeah. Great.

And one one of the things I wanted to make sure that I ask you is I grew up Catholic, and you know, there's a lot of paranormal things in Catholicism, like incorruptible bodies, if you're familiar with that concept. And I once got in a lot of trouble because I went to Saint John Newman Cathedral in Philadelphia, where one of the incorruptible bodies was and on the in the altar in a glass case is supposed to be the body of Saint John Newman. And being a curious teenager and looking around and noticing there's nobody in this whole cathedral. That was in the middle of the day.

It's like two o'clock in the afternoon. There's nobody there. Maybe there's a couple of people praying, but they were weigh in the back. So I figured I could get away with it.

I walked right on to the altar, and I was an altar boy, so I don't know. Somehow I thought that would give me a pass. This was not my church. And I walk right up to the thing, and I put my face right near the face, and I'm looking at it, and I'm going, this is a wax mask.

This isn't real. All of a sudden, a priest comes out and I got in a lot of you know, well, I got scolded. I didn't get in a lot of trouble. And he sat down with me though, and explained to me that the hands and the mask are wax, and it just kind of blew the whole incorruptible bodies to shreds to me, because if the body doesn't decay, why do you need to you know, essentially, what the Saint John Newman body is is a wax covered skeleton that was artists artistically created to appear as he was in life.

And then there is the these, uh, these other things like the Crown of Thorns, and do you think there's any reality to any of that stuff or do you think that this is just the same kind of huckstering we see in the UFO community to sell, to sell what they're doing, the incorruptibles, the Crown of Thorns, the shroud of Turin, all the all the nails that were supposed to be from the original Cross of Christ and these. I'm sorry, I just want to get your take on sort of catholic the Catholic version of paranormal and if you think there's any reality to it or if it's just the same as the incorruptibles. Is a great example, because you know a lot of these, a lot of these, uh they openly will say that's a wax mask and one of them, one of them is somewhere is is is actually latex. But yes, these wax masks and or or sometimes it's even just a painted wooden sculpture, and they say, well, that's just the cover and you know, the actual bodies underneath whatever.

They openly admit this, and yet they still come out and write a report saying that this is miracle, and therefore we can certify sanctifying this person and making them a saint because this is a miraculous There's just a lot of cognitive dissonance going on within the Catholic Church. I think that's the thing that you can say for sure about them. So many of the cases that they have certified as miraculous, meaning there's no way that they could have happened naturally. They've even acknowledged the evidence of what actually happened naturally.

It's just it's a staggering case of cognitive dissonance. YEA. Pretty much every Catholic miracle case that I've looked into turns out this way. Yeah.

Yeah. The big disappointment for me was the Padre Pios worry, because it turns out that he may have created his own stigmata with a form of acid. And that's really disappointing, you know, when you especially when you grew up with that kind of a story. That was one of the Catholic heroes that they pushed on you like this padre Po, And yeah, it's incredible that so many people will just blindly believe, just like so many people blindly believe all the UFOs must be aliens somehow, right.

Yeah, in that case, I mean it was a straight up fundraising thing, Yeah, because they made so much money from the people come into the churches for each of the you know, whatever they had on display. You know. Yeah, I wasn't aware that you did an Incomptible Bodies episode. Now I have to find that because because that's kind of one of my things.

It's one of the early episodes we did here, and I talked about my own experience with it, and interestingly, like the priest would not, he didn't. You know, I'm talking to the priest that runs the church, and I'm like, but it's it's a lie. Then, you know, it's not a lie. It's not a lie.

It's not a lie, young man. You know, like, Okay, but you got a wax covered skeleton up there that you're saying doesn't rot in a glass case. You know, it's it's it was disappointing to me because I want to check out the Incorruptible episode because there's a lot of interesting cases in there. The Catholic ones make up, you know, a part of that story, but there's there's other cases of incorruptible bodies outside of Catholicism, including actual incorruptible bodies that there's a lot of interesting stuff in that talk.

Yeah, that's definitely, that's definitely a little bit weird. Well, I appreciate you taking the time to be here. I don't see any more questions from our live chat. I appreciate you taking the time to do this with us, and I will add those links.

I will add those links to the description. So we'll put your website, the movie website, and the link to your podcast as well into the links. Anybody listening, you'll be able to find mister Dunning easily. I hope you won't be a stranger, mister Dunning.

Yeah, let's do this again for sure. All right, thanks very much, you have a great night, all right, friends. Well, there we go. That was interesting for me and a reminder to me that a lot of you people are asking me to do more interviews, and I certainly would like to deliver what people want.

But I really you know, it's not that I haven't enjoyed. I enjoyed most of the interviews, but this one was extremely enjoyable. And in order for me to want to do these things, these interviews that everybody wants, we have to get some great guests. So if you have any guest suggestions, you can email me at Truth Seekert Show at gmail dot com.

I think mister Dunning's doing some great work. He definitely made me feel like, you know, there's oh, I'm not the only sane person in this mental asylum and other people are seeing through these deceptive fake stories and you know, bringing people the reality behind them. I appreciate what he does and I know a little bit about what it takes to do that, and especially when it comes to you know, there's a price to pay. And I did like his advice on just ignore the vitriol and the venom from some of these people and keep dealing what you're doing.

Yeah, and Art and Paranormal is reminding everybody that you can email me at True Seeker Show at gmail dot com. I want to take a moment to thank all you superchat people once again, matthew A, Gary OK one hundred, Spooky Pusley, and Tales of the Sonic Voyage. We thank all of you for your kindness, generosity, and support. I always feel a little weird about those super chats while I'm talking to the guest, I don't want to interrupt the interview.

So thank you all for your patience and helping us to praise the cash tonight. Thank you for your kindness, generosity and support. So we've got a full week for you here. I noticed Steve Longs in the chat.

He will be here Wednesday night at nine pm, so he's previous guest. Apparently he fixed his Internet, which was previously run by a Potato. His WiFi router was a Potato before. Remember, he always had problems, but hopefully he's got that sort of out.

I got to tell you the truth though, I saw him. What was the show you were on, Steve? Oh? I saw him on Erica Lukes and his Internet everything worked and he didn't have drop offs or problems or bandwidth issues.

I was like, what's going on, man? He's got good internet for Erica Lukes, but the Potato Internet for me operations shutdown. Thank you for being members says thank you, Brian, thank you Steven. We thank you for your kindness, jet erosity and support.

Amy Collins, can you be seen at all? Yeah? I don't know what everybody thinks. Did you get timed out or something by accident?

Amy Collins, I don't know. Luel come on, man, oh, I didn't see your question. I apologize. Where was your question?

I apologize? Mine? Was there not answered? Did I skip your question?

I didn't see your question. I remember questions in all caps for the guests. I didn't see a question from you. I apologize, and Amy Collins, please accept my apology.

You know that I'm a little visually impaired. So if I missed it, I apologize. It wasn't my intention. I missed it.

I apologize. Yeah, and he did have limited time as well, So lick the stream, says Daisy b And thank you for being a member. It wasn't all caps. How did I miss it?

Then? I apologize, Amy, I really apologize. All right? Well, I apologize, Amy.

You know I'm sorry that happened. He did have limited time. I thought I got them all. I'm still scrolling back.

I don't see your question. What are the rest of them? I can try to send it to him off air, and I'll email it to him for you. I'd be happy to do that since I missed it.

Yeah, I'm still not saying it. I'm scrolling through my version of the chat here. I saw a question from Randy and from Gary and from Smith, and then I don't see one from you. It could be a problem with the stream yard chat.

In any case, I apologize. Send me your question and I'll try. I'll try to send it to you to him and let you Nobody says I apologize. Algaret is here.

If Steve Wong runs his Internet off of potato, surely he knows the secrets of free energy exactly exactly. That's exactly at Albaret, thanks for holding down the twitch chat. We also want to take a moment to thank all of you new viewers on Instagram. You can follow me on Instagram.

It's at Truth Secret Show on Instagram. We broadcast our first hour on Instagram. Then I keep forgetting, but I'm supposed to remind people that Instagram only allows an hour, so please come on over to our YouTube live chat. But I notice I'm getting a whole bunch of followers on Instagram and That's interesting because I had that account for a decade and never used it.

Today I began uploading some images, So anything image related to the Truth Seeker Show, I'll be on Instagram. I uploaded some pictures earlier. I'm going to show you of my Midi studio nightmare. It's turning into quite quite the project.

Oh and I have something else I wanted to talk about real quickly as well. Yeah, so the Instagram is at True Seeker show and anything related to the show now, I'm going to be taking pictures of it and it'll be on my Instagram at True Secret Show and we'll be broadcasting live streams. Here's some shots of the new Midi studio that's slowly coming together. It looks a mess, It sounds a mess even right now, still working on things.

My god, the amount of cables that I need for those unaware, you need three cables for each device, two for the audio and one for the Midi. Well four they needed a power cable and you need to place plug that power. So this is turning into you know, four cables per device that you see in these pics. This is turning into quite the project.

And uh oh, I don't want to get to that one yet. Yeah. So I've got far too many devices and not enough wires, and I've already spent so much money on Amazon buying all these wires and I'm not even halfway through hooking it all up. Something else that I wanted to mention, and a viewer that I want to thank, at least d Avalon, longtime show supporter, sent me this.

Oh well, I have it right here, I can. I can show you this. Oh look how thick this thing is. This is a big binder.

And what is this? Uh this, my friends, is UFO gold right here? Look at how thick this is. Look at this, It's huge.

It's a binder. And this, interestingly, it says through the Instagram Disclosure Project briefing document And this was something that doctor Stephen Greer back in two thousand and one was sending people And is that interesting? And these are this is the presidential briefing and all this other nonsense from doctor Stephen Greer. You have a need to know, you have a need to know about aliens.

Oh my god. It is just a treasure trove of bullshitery the lex which I have never seen. And this is the original stuff that he would send his huge supporters. Look, it's in this big binder.

It's just there's just so much of it. It's so much and this is all the stuff that he used to send his donors and supporters for cash back in the day. And oh, we're going to be going through this. We're going to be going through this stuff.

Also, very kind of her, she sent me along with this document, she sent me a truth Seekers Tarot deck. And I'm going to try again for those unaware, I used to do a mentalism show and I would read fortune cards, but not tarot cards fortune cards. Here we go again with the mod wars. Anyway, I try to memorize all of the tarot cards.

And I've always had such a hard time doing tarot cards for people because I need to read the book in order to do it, you know, like I'm going to do the spreads and whatever, but I forget what these card means. Maybe I'll give it a try again, but we think at least Diavalon, I guess she saw this and thought of me, the truth Seekers taro and it is. It's a beautiful deck, very nice, very nice artwork on all the cards. And I don't know about the rest of you.

Even if I'm not really a believer in fortune telling or taro, some of the art on some of these decks is beautiful and nice to have around in your bookshelf. So we thank our viewer and friend, Leashee Avalon. It's nice to have supporters all around the world. And besides this treasure trove of doctor Stephen Greer's briefing, bullshity documents and all this other stuff, also all the original VHS tapes that doctor Stephen Greer used to make and sell his fans for big bucks.

We got all of them and they're all digitized and we're going to go through all of them, so you guys can expect a lot of new content centered around doctor Stephen Greer's early efforts at disclosure, and at least is in the live chat. So I'm glad that you're here to see me, Thank you and arrive today. I'm so happy to see those documents, especially, I went, oh my god, I started reading through them and I was like a kid in a candy store. Thank you at least the Avalon for your kindness, generosity and support.

Uh, Gerry, my chat just shut down. It was finished for the night. Maybe there's a problem for some Yeah, I don't know. Yeah, and that could be somebody saying that comments are being deleted from the live chat.

Arden Is are one of our moderators here and says I have seen comments disappear from chats with no mods doing it, So I think it's a glitch with YouTube. Yes, So before anybody starts making accusations about censorship and you know, people having their comments lead it, know that, yes, And I agree with arden. I am completely and totally aware that some comments just don't end up. You know, somebody wise type something out and hit enter and it just doesn't appear in the live chat for whatever reason.

We have a free speech platform here. Nobody's timed out, muted, banned, or whatever unless it's absolutely necessary. And I don't know if anybody else's comments are getting deleted. I'll have to deal with that after the show.

If they are indeed getting deleted, then, Lizzie says, I read taro. Yeah. Do you know that we once had a tarot card reader was coming to come here once a week, a girl named Stephanie from Willow Unity. She was a nice girl.

I miss her. She was fun and the reason that I did it is because I wanted to observe somebody reading taro, and I thought, if this girl will come here every week and do this, then I can sit and just watch and learn, you know, how they do it. And so a lot of people enjoyed it. Maybe we'll have you do some tarrort readings here, Ben Lizzy.

But a lot of people lost their goddamn minds when we did that, you know, because for whatever reason any case. Yeah, yeah, a lot of people think that gift that you said is very cool. And I agree, and at last says you're welcome. No, you're welcome, or thank you.

We truly appreciate that. Because some of this material, nobody else is going to have that stuff, at least only us. I'm sure somebody's got it, but nobody's gonna be doing shows about it and talking about it. So I started to get ads for stuff related stuff.

Some of the ads are weird. Yeah, Third Coast Swing is here and says, and I'm up from my slumber. Good morning, Steve, Good morning. You're just getting up, dude.

I hope you're in another country because it's like eleven pm here. If you're just getting up at eleven pm, you must have a rough day. YouTube does mob down some key words. I've been digging the live panels since third co swing good times, yeah, good, happy to hear it.

Oh man, some drama rama going on in the live chat there usually is. Yeah, thank you Atlish, We appreciate you, Thanks for appreciating us, and thanks for thinking of me. At least knew that I could use this stuff. At least saw that stuff and said Steve Campie would love to see this shit and listen.

Oh my god, I'm listening to all the videos we have, like all the original Disclosure witnesses, and it's like twelve hours of video. I think it's a lot of material. And this huge book. I was very busy today, so it came and I came about four o'clock home with my son off the bus, and I only got to read like a little bit of it.

But I can't wait to get to it. I'm gonna do it right after the show. We're gonna we're gonna go onto that all right, Uh? What is this guy?

Why? Why fools? Then you get banned from a couple of shows for being like belligerent? Can you just behave like please, like just be nice.

We don't ask much. One of our carnivals is don't be a dickhead? Can you just not be a dickhead? Right, we'd appreciate that.

Don't be like that. I just had four comments about round object that you throw blocked by the YouTube filter. Yeah, that's not the thing. If you put curses in your whatever you're writing, Uh, then you could get your comments deleted or whatever.

Right, yeah, there you go. Don't be don't be like that. Look, we got we've got two attack broads in there. Did you know that the only moderators that I will have going forward.

I decided that what I need is I need divine, feminine energy and amazon like strong powerful women protecting the best interests of me and my show. So we that are in paranormal and then Lizzie Borden in there and they don't play. They're not going to play with you being a dickhead. So don't do it.

Uh yeah, yeah, you wish, dude, You wish, dude, you wish. Yeah. Yeah. So yeah, we're only going to have We're only going to have female moderators here.

And that has nothing to do with the fact that those female moderators may attract more viewers, given that we have an eighty five percent male audience that had nothing to do with the decision at all. Nothing. No, I just think that, you know how, those women have that like motherly protective kind of instinct. That's what I thought would be best for chatroom moderators, because they really do have to, you know, they have to protect the show's best interest, and if somebody's in there acting a fool, they got to deal with it.

Albaa says the divine feminine, like Elizabeth Wilcock talks about exactly exactly we got to do the divine feminine. Well, folks, we're just about two hours. I think we've done our due diligence. I want to thank all of you kind and generous benefactors.

We want to think also thank you PayPal pledgers, you Patreon supporters, YouTube chat or excuse me, YouTube channel members, you Twitch, Twitch subscribers. Oh, we want to thank initials a V for a kind of generous ten dollars PayPal pledge. It says, thank you for your consistent content and your hard work. We thank you for your kindness, generosity and support and for helping us to praise the cash and so we thank all of our kind and generous benefactors and supporters.

We thank all of you viewers. You people download those podcasts too, are listening to the audio podcasts. Shout out to you guys, the audio crew. We appreciate you that I was talking about this earlier to our guests, but the audio podcast downloads are really really increasing lately.

So we thank all of you, and no matter where you're listening or watching, we thank you for doing so. Please sort of like, comment, subscribe, and share wherever you're like listening or watching. It really really does help to increase our reach. Also, want to mention one more time.

We're on Instagram streaming live every show now please follow me there. It's at True Seeker Show on Instagram, and you should also follow me on Twitter it's at Stephen Cambi and we post a lot of show related material there. So that's all we got for you. I will be back tomorrow night, nine pm Eastern Standard time.

I know I'll be here Wednesday with special guest Steve Long, and Thursday. I'm not sure about the rest of the week, but we'll figure that out as we go along. So that's all we got for your friends. So I will be back tomorrow night, nine pm Eastern Standard time, and I hope, I hope that you will be here with me.

So that's all I got for your friends. Oh, speaking of thanking everybody, we also want to thank our special guest tonight, Brian Dunning, Skeptoid dot Com. I will be adding the links as soon as the broadcast ends. Right now.

The link to the movie that his movie that you can watch for free on YouTube is in the description of the video. But I will be adding the other links as soon as I sign off here, and that would be skeptoid dot com and I'll get you the links to his podcast on YouTube and more so, thanks to mister Dunning for you know, coming here and I had a great evening, hope you did too. I'll be back tomorrow night, nine pm Eastern Standard time. Hope you're here with us.

Until next time, friends. My name is Stephen Cambia. Good night, God blessed all of you. Listened something listens, sissss A, nonsensations listens, siss happens listens susss SO schools s s s S school assss