#UFOS #UAPS #MH370 Dave Grusch DECEPTIONS! + Ashton Forbes, MH370 The GRIFT goes on!

Download episode

Show Notes

Content created here by Spectral International, LLC.
Music videos by Simon Fly. 
Visit our website here : https://truthseekershow.com 
Buy some merchandise to support our show : 
AMAZON STORE : 
https://www.amazon.com/s?rh=n%3A7141123011%2Cp_4%3ATruthseekershow+Official+Merch&ref=bl_sl_s_ap_web_7141123011
Redbubble store (international shipping) :
https://www.redbubble.com/people/TSGear/shop?asc=u

Subscribe to our youtube channel here :
http://www.youtube.com/c/truthseekershow
Follow Steven Cambian on twitter : @stevencambian Join our Patreon : https://www.patreon.com/stevencambian

Donate by paypal : Send a paypal to TRUTHSEEKERSHOW@GMAIL.COM
Any amount you wish. Please include your chatroom user id, and any message you would like me to read on air. We read every paypal message we are sent and thank every person who sends any paypal support. Listen to the audio podcast : https://www.spreaker.com/user/14526799

Email us : TRUTHSEEKERSHOW@GMAIL.COM

Show Transcript

Barrow, Doctor John Trapatrick, Hearo, Baro, Baro Herrow, Doctor John Trapatrick, Hearo, Hearo Herro, dumpster fire, Hero, Doctor seanrack Patrick takes brush, dumpster fire Arrow, Doctor seanrack Patrick takes rush for the ra says yeah. Harry Nolan, Harry Nolan, Harry Nolan, Harry Nolan, Hero, Barrow, Harry Nolan, Harry Nolan, Harry Nolan, Harry Nolan, Barrow, Sparrow, her narrow, her narrow here, boats here boat Herro arro her ow narrow here, boat here, boats here, boats here, boats here, boat Hero Arrow found no evidence of extraterrestrial technology. The lack of any evidence, any evidence. Barro found no evidence of extraterrestrial technology, the lack of any evidence, any evidence.

Trust me, Bro, don't worry about the evident. David Crush. Trust me, Bro, don't worry about the evident David Brush with zero evidence, incredible evidence into the star, with zero evidence, incredible evidence into the Star, Kirkpatrick's evidence. Where is Arrow's evidence?

Kirkpatrick's evidence? Where is Arrow's evidence? If I if I call your hooker, if I call your mother hooker, if I call your mother hooker, if I call your mother a hooker. If I call your hook Saliens and extraterrestrials, trust me, trust me Bro.

If I call your but hooker, Aliens and extra dress trust me Bro trust me brow hair hair Broke. Aliens and extraterrestrials trust me Brow trust me Brow and you. Aliens and extraterrestrials trust me Bro trust me brow hair hair folk, Aliens and extra terrestrials trust me Bro trust me Brow. Sharoh sharrow like sharrow, Sharoh booker, booker, booker, Pharaoh booker, booker, Boomer Barrow booker, Boober booker, Pharoh booker, booker, over booker, pharoh s.

Greetings and salutations, friends, and welcome back. Tonight. We're going to be covering some recent revelations about Dave Grush, who, for those unaware, as a high ranking former military officer Air Force, in fact an intelligence officer who some time ago three hundred and thirty seven days ago made some out of this world claims. Claims that anybody familiar with UFOs and aliens has probably heard before that the United States government is in possession, in fact of alien spacecraft, alien spacecraft crash debris, and even alien bodies.

Interestingly, it has since been learned that David Grush has very close ties and associations with many of what I call the UFO promoters and others have called the spooky hustlers, the same group of people who have been making these out of this world claims but never actually providing evidence or proof of those claims for many years, in some cases decades. So we are now at three hundred and thirty seven days. I've said it before, I'm going to say it again. The excuses for this man to stand up in front of Congress and make these allegations and claims without providing a single shread of evidence is honestly mind blowing to me.

Equally mind blowing is the media's copy and paste narrative. Dave Grush made these claims. Perhaps thousands of media outlets simply copied and pasted his claims into what most people would call credulous articles, articles which just took mister Grush's claims at face value without actually taking a moment to step back and say he hasn't provided any evidence whatsoever of his claims. So now we're at three hundred and thirty seven days, and many people have suggested that at three hundred and sixty five days, which were coming up one years, it's another thirty days or so, I should bake a cake and we should have a one year Still no evidence from Grush party.

I have been covering this story critically since it began on June fifth, twenty twenty three. I will continue to cover any developments in the Dave Grush saga. You may be aware that over the weekend I put together two of what I believe are my favorite pieces that should educate people on the claims of Dave Grush, an entire five or six hour special about so called UFO whistleblowers the past. I believe that history truly is our greatest teacher, and what we learn when we take a step back and look at these claims through the lens of history.

What we learn is that no previous so called UFO whistleblower, including many high ranking intelligence and military officers who made claims very similar to Grush, ever proved any of them or ever provided any evidence of their claims. But they all have one thing in common. They all profited a great deal wearing the right shirt for this. Today they all praise the cash every chance they got telling their evidence free, faith based believed stories.

Recently, a researcher on Twitter, which I admire spect I'm going to add his links in the description of the video, made some significant progress towards proving that David Grush is misleading the public. Now, I should say that mister D. D. Johnson is sort of a gentleman.

He's kind of like others that we've talked about here. I lack the tact that some other more professional I would say researchers or journalists have. He was very I think fair in his assessment. But still you showing that Dave Grush and by extension, his followers and the people promoting his story have been misleading the American public have been essentially lying to all of us.

And the proof is very clear, because after all, mister Grush is making claims that should be investigated by the proper governmental office to investigate these claims, and that would be arrow headed by once headed by doctor Scheun Kirkpatrick, who has since retired and left. But interesting that mister Rush fails to provide any proof of evidence to the very governmental office that is tasked with investigating his claims. But yet still somehow claims to be some sort of whistleblower. Where have we ever seen in history that the whistleblower comes out and says, can't show you my evidence.

I know you're the proper authority to investigate my claims here that are blowing the whistle on, but can't show you any of the evidence. I gave it to this other office. But what we're going to see in our presentation tonight is that this is very misleading, I would say, outright deceptive and just lies. If you are caught and call yourself a whistleblower, maybe you should show evidence to the proper investigating authority.

All we have gotten from Dave Grush for three hundred and thirty seven days now by extension, his supporters and the UFO profiteering whoes who are profiting. Some would say that hundreds of thousands of dollars have been made and you know, I know, I get messages in the comments and people send me nasty messages. If you can do third grade math, you can add up all the monetized views on YouTube alone, that's not counting audio podcasts promoting David Grush's evidence free claims, and see that hundreds of thousands of dollars has been generated from Dave Grush telling his stories, but yet there's no evidence. And we've talked about this in great detail.

I have a real problem with what I call the UFO circle jerk crowd. If you're going to cover a story but only cover one half of it, you're not doing anybody any favors. But I guess you're doing your wallet some favors, because, after all, people who just you know, promote these evid it's free claims dead hundreds or thousand times more the views than people who do it the proper way and show both sides of the so called evidence. But it's kind of hard to show both sides of the evidence when so far Dave Grush is not provided any.

But don't let things like facts and evidence. We've learned this before. You do not let things like facts and evidence get in the way of a good fake story that you can profit from. So we're going to get into our presentation, and by the way, I do want apologize last week was very Look, I'm just gonna say this.

Can we all acknowledge that show hosts, including me, are human and sometimes life gets in the way and things take you away from that which you would prefer to be doing. I would prefer to do a show here every night. However, I have a wife, two children, one of them is nonverbal, autistic, special needs child, which requires a great deal of time and energy and attention. And I've also got some financial interests outside of this show that need my attention at times, need all of my attention.

So last week, I honestly I did the best that I could do. It was one of the toughest weeks in the history of our show. I did one live show, and then I put together two sort of montages, one of them five or six hours long and one of them an entire nine hours long on UFO crashes. I forgot to mention that earlier.

If you're interested in the claims being made about many of the things that Dave Grosh has said, please check our video section. There's fourteen hours of material for you to educate yourself on the history of both people making these claims and on the stories of so called UFO crash retrievals. Once I did sort of a wide view of these things, I came away quite honestly underwhelmed. For all of the claims that people make, the evidence is virtually non existent unless you count stories.

We get plenty of stories in UFO land. It's just, you know, the problem comes when you ask for evidence. And also, I just wanted to mention because I got several messages about Michael Schratt's presentation in that UFO Crash piece we did. I wanted to include both sides of the story, and Michael's sort of a true believer who, by the way, makes really beautiful if you're in the UFO poorn like I am, you know, nice pictures of aliens and UFOs and alien crash retrieval sites.

Michael Shratt does a great job of that. But I will agree with some of our viewers who said that essentially what Michael Schratt does is make pretty pictures to go along with evidence free stories, which I could see how some people would say that really doesn't help. It's just providing another layer to add to the story, like here's some pictures to go with the story that still has no evidence. And while I strongly disagree with many of mister Schratt's conclusions, I like Michael Shratt.

He's you know, an interesting fellow, and I hope that he and I will remain friends and just agree to disagree on things. There's things we completely totally agree on, like Bob Lazaar, which is interesting, but we disagree on many other things. And as far as who he works for, you know, listen, it's not my place. I've expressed what I feel about Michael Schratt and some of the people that he has allowed himself to be employed by.

It's not my place to tell. Man. You know, there's an old saying. I think it's from like, isn't it from the Sopranos?

Like nobody gets to tell you how to cover your nut. It's not my place to tell him who he can and can't work for. While I strongly dislike and disagree with some of the people that he worked for, I'm not going to tell me who he can't work for. I have expressed to him that I think that his credibility is affected by some of the people that he's associated himself with.

It is what it is. You know, I like him as a person. I'm not going to attack them. I'm not gonna you know, and for anybody that says I'm giving him a pass, I'm telling you exactly the same things that I would tell Michael to his face.

We're good, We're okay. And I think it's a good idea sometimes to include the believer side. If we have somebody that's willing to come here and share their thoughts and opinions, even if we wildly disagree on their conclusions, we can still learn something from that. And I for one them all for that.

Sometimes there's some very militant skeptics of my audience, and I love and appreciate all of you, but you have to be kind to the guests or we'll never have any So we're going to get into the Dave Grush situation first, because I think that people have a tendency to miss some things when it's kind of hard to digest. And let's be honest. I remember the days of blogs and everything was in a blog or a text website. But you know, the media landscape has become much more multi media based and rich and video and audio, and you know, so some people miss some of these things because it requires you to have to go old school and read a lot of stuff.

And I get it. Some people don't have the patience for that. And I want to make sure that I remember to tell you this person d Dean Johnson is just an excellent researcher, and it's at D Dean D E. A.

N. Johnson j O H N S O N. For the benefit of the audio listeners, I highly recommend that you follow him because he does some excellent work. He has a piece here called More Zigzags by UFO whistleblower David Grush.

Former Department of Defense senior intelligence official Chris Mellon said to Seun Kirkpatrick, then the director of Pentagon's All Domain Anomaly Research Office AERO, in a June thirteenth, twenty twenty three signal message contained an a four yeer release obtained by john from the Black Vault inserted below. I spoke with Dave Grush at Kirkpatrick's request, and his first question was why hadn't Narrow gotten all the info from the intelligence community Inspector General Inspector General of the intelligence community. It is all there and fully documented, to include confirmation on the alien technology program is a real and AT is real from active cleared insiders. On June thirteenth, Kirkpatrick texted back to Mellon, DOJ Department of Justice has to release it is part of a criminal investigation.

They have it yet, he Dave Grush needs to come and tell us separate from his criminal complaint. By email on April nineteenth, I asked Sean Kirkpatrick a series of questions seeking to understand what the Department of Justice had to do with any of this. He replied to me on April twentieth, twenty twenty four, mister Mellon and I were referring to both of mister Grush's IG complaints, which fall under Department of Justice rules and authorities. In order for Arrow to have received any of his evidence, the Intelligence the Inspector General would have to release it, which would require mister Grush to authorize.

He did not. There is no other investigation, so that's interesting. All of you people that are falsely claiming that the Intelligence Commedian Inspector of General is investigating mister Grush's alien in UFO claims are completely and totally mistaken. Mister Dean goes on to say the answer surprised me, so I then asked Kirkpatrick, do I understand correctly that to this day Arrow has not received the detailed alien reverse engineering allegations that Grush says he provided first to the ICIG then to two intelligence committees in twenty twenty two, and that the ICIG would have been willing to release those transcripts to ARROW if Dave Grush has authorized it, but that Grush refused to authorize the release of the transcripts to ARROW or failed to respond when asked to authorize such release.

To this, Kirkpatrick responded on April twenty first, twenty four, Yes, that is correct. I conveyed this to his attorney in a phone call that all he has to do is authorize release of the ICIG transcripts. That did not happen. In a further response to me on April twenty second, Kirkpatrick said, quote, both the ICIG and DODIG have been supporting ARO insofar as whistleblower protections legally allowed them.

David Grusse said on May third written statement to News Nation reproduced below to be clear, Arrow that does not have we have access to the information I provided to the Intelligence Community, Inspector General, and of the Congressional Intelligence Committee under PDP nineteen whistle blowing process. Then goes on to say my comments on the above. In the Foyer release obtained by John Greenwald, we saw first that Grush challenged Kirkpatrick Vam Mellen as to why Kirkpatrick had not examined the ICIG interview transcript Yet now we learn that subsequently Grush failed to authorize the release of those same transcripts to Aro after Aro explicitly asked that he do so. Regrettably, this appears to be another example in an emerging pattern of zigzags and substantially misleading public statements on certain matters by Grush.

Enlightened the communications that were occurring as early as June twenty twenty three between Grush and Aro, some of which now are spread to the public record thanks to the work of John Greenwald. I believe that Grush engendered a misleading impression in the public's mind regarding Arrow's interest in hearing his testimony. Grush October thirty one, twenty twenty three statements in News Nation calling Shoan Kirkpatrick a liar for saying that Aro had repeatedly reached out to Grush was misleading. Kirkpatrick was entirely truthful in the specific statement to which Grush was reacting.

Misleading in some way, in my opinion, is the second sentence of Grush's May third twenty twenty four statements in News Nation. We should also recall Grush's words to the Congresswoman Anna Paulina Luna during the July twenty six, twenty twenty three UAP hearing before the National Security Subcommittee of the House Over sit and Accountability Committee, when Grush said, quote, I had a classified conversation with Sean Kirkpatrick in April twenty twenty two before he took over Arrow in July twenty twenty two, and I provided him some concerns I had. I was happy to give sage counsel to him on where to look when he took the helm of Arrow. From that exchange, no viewer would have gotten the impression that Grush would be unwilling to share his classified testimony with AERO.

Grush might have good reasons for not participating in a classified interview with ARO, but Grush's stated reasons for not participating in a classified interview with Arrow have been contrived and implausible. So essentially what we have here is, you know, everybody is saying, oh, well, he gave the Intelligence Community Inspector General all the evidence. Yeah, and he's supposed to be giving that evidence to ARO, and he could all he has to do is authorize the release of that information from the ICIG, who could then give it all to ARO. He has so far either refused or denied doing that.

He will not allow the Office of ARO to get the same information. Why is that Some have been speculating that he knows that he knew that the Intelligence Community Inspector General would not he would not investigate his alien in UFO claims, so he gave some evidence to them knowing it's worthless to them. They're not going to investigate anything. But Arrow is investigating all the claims made to them.

So maybe, just maybe this is a shell game because Grush had heard through the grapevine, and I've heard this from several sources that some of these people go into Arrow, heard that Arrow is exhaustively investigating the claims that people are making to them. Perhaps mister Grush knew that his claims could not stand up to real investigative scrutiny and therefore didn't want to give that information to them. Yeah, so essentially, nobody claims that Grush is legally obligated. The article goes on to state nobody claims that Grush is legally obligated to submit to an interview with Arrow, or that Arrow has any authority to compel Grush's testimony.

If a lawyer's client does not wish to do something that he is not legally required to do, that lawyer might provide his client with ideas for optical justifications for what the client has already decided to do. But that is something very different from asserting that the client would be placing himself in legal jeopardy by complying with the formal requests of high ranking government officials. So one of the other excuses is Arrow doesn't have the required clearances to see the evidence that mister Grush has that has been proven completely and totally false. And one of the other excuses all he could go to prison if he releases that information to Arrow.

He gave it to the ICIG. This is all a shell game. Grush could give that evidence to Arrow. They're legally entitled to have any evidence at all, according to the Office of Arrow and doctor Schouan Kirkpatrick.

Johnson in this article goes on to say, Sean Kirkpatrick told me April twentieth, I don't want to speculate on motivations, but clearly, as documented, we gave every written authorization assurance and pointed to the law as written authorizing Arrow to get him in to review his evidence. We had an Office of General Counsel, Department of Defense provide an official Pentagon read of the law in mister Grush's lawyer through the Congress. We also provided further od and I Office of Director of National Intelligence assurances. In the face of all that he has still not come in.

I even spoke with his attorney directly. Given all of these efforts, I would say that any commentators suggesting legal prudence are perhaps blind to the truth and are continuing to pedal misinformation. So every excuse that Grush has for not giving his evidence to Arrow, which is the office that's supposed to be investigating his claims, fall apart under scrutiny. And here's where it gets great.

Is the Intelligence Community Inspector General currently investigating alien tech claims. As I previously imported on this platform, Chaun Kirkpatrick told me on April twenty second, to my knowledge, neither the Intelligence Community Inspector General nor Department of Defense Inspector General are separately investigating those claims of a government orchestrated extraterrestrial reverse engineering program that was and is Aerrow's responsibility as covered by the Historical Review Legislation legislative language from NDAA fiscal year twenty three. Both the Intelligence Community Inspector General and the Department of Defense Inspector General have been supporting ARO insofar as whistleblower protections legally allowed them.

So, you know, I hate to say this, but all of these stupid people have been arguing with me for almost a year and awo oh no, Steven, he gave his information about the alien crafts retrieval programs to the DoD and the ICIG, and they're investigating his claims and they found his claims urgent and credible. That is all bullshit. It's all bullshit. None of that is true.

Mister Ding goes on to state his comments on the above. For my part, I do not claim to know whether the ICIG is continuing to investigate any of the alien tech allegations that were made by grushen It's interviews with the ICIG the visible clues conflict. But I do find it curious that some advocates on UFO Twitter seem to be taking the position that the director of the Pentagon Intelligence Community Office, who was specifically empowered and tasked by Congress to probe alien tech allegations, among other things, could not possibly know whether the ICIG is also engaged in alien tech investigation. Yet they are confident that they do know, or at least the UFO friendly writers on whom they rely, who hold no clearances at all nor any congressionally and dawn authorities, do know.

Yes, I know about their remarks by Senator Marco Rubio on October twenty fourth about the Intelligence Committee standing aside while allowing the ICIG process to be completed. But I noted also Rubio's comments on a later date, February eighth, twenty twenty four, when Laslow asked are we going to hear from those people whistleblowers within the Senate, to which Rubio responded, there's a whistleblower complaint filed by one of them, and ultimately, I mean, we haven't spent a tremendous amount of time on it lately, but I was hoping that's what Errow would do. That sounds to me like Rubio assumed that AERO would be checking out Rush's allegations, and now we know how that has gone.

If the ICIG and AERO staff actually were independently investigating some of the same alien techt stories, presumably ICIG's staff would have approached some of the same people who have been interviewed by AERO or have been contacted by ERO. It also seems that word of some such ongoing contacts by ICIG investigators would get around. Is there any evidence that is happening? Has any UFO whistleblowers going on the record with incredible report that the Intelligence Community inspector general investigators have knocked on their door recently, say, within the past year, And by the way, despite the certitude of some advocates, I have not seen any public claim by Grush himself or any attorney representing him, asserting that they know the ICIG is currently pursuing an active investigation of Grush's alien to claims, Nor does Grush make such a claim in as may third statement in News Nation.

Instead, Gresh said only I trust in the investigative and law enforcement criminal referral authorities ICG ICIG as independent of DD oversight. Because I'm writing a longer article on some of these matters, I submitted a number of related questions to David Grush's media team on April nineteen, to which I have yet received no response. Before my longer article is published, I will again submit questions to Grush. I hope that Grush will not fall into the pattern too often found among UFO celebrities of declining to engage with anyone who is not willing to receive what he says as purely stemographic or sounding board mode, or to uncritically amplify even implausible claims.

And then there's a section here on Grush and Senator Jillibrand which is interesting regarding UFO whistleblowers, and forgive me, we're skipping somewhat ahead. Told Laslow, I can't assess them unless Aro can talk to them, because Arrow knows what they know and what they've seen and what they've been shown. I queried Kirkpatrick about the attempt at jilibrand Kirkpatrick Grush meeting. He replied by email May third, the meeting was canceled by mister Grush and his attorney.

That was the they Senator jail Brand referred to both she and I confer together to try and arrange changed the meeting through her office. That was yet another attempt for us to get mister Grush to come in. I do not have a reason why they declined and canceled. He later elaborated this occurred full twenty twenty three, likely October November.

We didn't document it because it was being actively handled through Senator jail Brand's office, and I was working it with her right up until I retired, hopefully hopefully he would come in. I wasn't going to get ahead of her. It was up to her when we would acknowledge we were trying to negotiate with them. It may be that Grush has some pertinent information that Jaia Brand is not clear to hear, but both the Senator and Grush have access to legal counsels sufficient to avoid any violation of security protocols.

So is that yet another meeting with Kirkpatrick or Arrow that he canceled or failed to appear at. You know, And it seems very clear to me that Kirkpatrick has gone above and beyond trying to get this man to show his evidence, show your cards, mister whistleblower, and his continual refusal to do that, and his continual I don't know, you know, this looks like one big shell game to me. Oh, I have all this evidence of alien technology. Great, can we see it?

No, can't show it to you. Great. So to finish up the article, mister Dean says, enough for now. I think that non prosaic UFOs exist.

I don't know if the government has technology of non human origin squirreled away somewhere, but if they do, I think we ought to know about it. Yet, preferring for something to be true and then hearing unsubstantiated stories from people who say that thing is true does not necessarily mean that that thing is true. Indeed, we should be especially cautious about too readily accepting unsubstantiated stories about things that we would prefer to be true. Nor should we accept or reject acclaim based on and individual's style or swagger.

Here a worship is a poor substitute for the tedious business of examining evidence. I am working on an article dealing with some of these matters in greater detail, and we'll publish it one of these days. If you want to receive it by email as soon as a come mail comes out, sign up for my website Google Douglas, Dean Johnson plus Mirador rd R. It is free.

Your email address will not be used for any commercial purposes, and you can remove your name at any time. I recommend signing up for his list because then you get a notification when he publishes a new article. We could see by the quality of his work here that he does great work. He closes this with saying some of the other material on that website provides case studies in why it is advisable to be cautious in these matters.

And here is some of those original messages from Sean Kirkpatrick speaking to Christopher Mellon. And isn't an interesting that dark journalists sort of reported that Christopher Mellon is sort of the gatekeeper and puppet master of Sean Kirkpatrick, or excuse me of David Grush. Let me say that again. Christopher Mellon is the gatekeeper or puppet master of David Grush, deciding who cannot who he can and cannot speak to.

And now we see that in order to get information from Dave Grush you have to go through Christopher Mellon somehow, which doesn't make any sense. I don't understand any of this, but Christopher mellen was also some people would say the mouthpiece or handler for luel Azando for quite some time. So it is an interesting. Same person that brought us the fake pentagona UFO program director is bringing us a fake whistleblower who can't show us any evidence, and he can't even show the proper investigating government authorities his evidence.

Where he has office skis avoided, eluded, and done everything he could to avoid Erro. And I freely admit that there's a speculation on my part, but I truly believe that he's doing that because he knows that he doesn't have evidence that will stand up to scrutiny of a good investigator. And it appears that the people at Arrow are decent at least investigators. They are investigating these claims that people are making as well they should.

We're gonna take a moment here to recognize some kind and generous people have the right shirt on today. Praise the cash, Praise the cash. UFO Shane gifts that one true seekers membership, and then another one, and then another one, see my friends. Thank you UFO Shane, well all the time show supporter a member himself, See my friends.

And this is why you should smash that subscribe button For those unaware. When people gift memberships. You can get a free membership just by being a subscriber. Apparently YouTube takes those free memberships, run some kind of random number generators and then distributes those free memberships to people on our channel who are subscribers but not yet YouTube channel members.

And what do you get as a YouTube channel member? You get some extra goodies and also some YouTube extra goodies like that YouTube channel member badge, so people know you're a big supporter prior to reply in the messages and video comments and live chat and whatever else we could do for you. We appreciate that. UFO, Shane, thank you very much for helping us to praise the cast.

And we have also companies aired if you're a member for so many months, they give you a free sort of super chat. You could write a message, Steve, I wish you would then handle Ashton Forbes just the same way you do with Shrat. I'm not sure I understand what that means. What.

Yeah, let me know what you mean. I'm not sure I understand what that means. You know, and I haven't said I wouldn't speak to him, but given the way that he just treated me in a live chat and talked to me like I was a dog or a piece of shit, you know, not feeling very very cordial or like inviting. Right.

Definitely bring up the facts that Jason said. If you don't give back the alien biologics, we're all gonna die. Yes, thank you and high Speed Chase. Look at that.

Here's another reason to subscribe. There is now ten eleven, twelve thirteen free YouTube memberships for our channel here, So make sure, if you haven't already, please do hit that subscribe button if for no other reason you might get some free shit like a free membership. Thank you high Speed Chase, he's the MVP of gifting these free memberships. We appreciate all of you.

Boy wear I should wear the shirt every day. Apparently it's good luck to wear praise cash shirt because it helps you to Uh, yes it does, and yes, ufo Shane. I certainly thank you High Speed Chase, m VP of of free memberships here. We appreciate you.

Thanks for appreciating us, all of you kind and generous people. Uh, let me go to Jason Sands. So many people have been asking me for an update on this other so called whistleblower who hasn't provided any evidence either that you know. People keep asking me for an update on this person, Jason Sands.

I'm trying to find it. Mail UFO, Shane, if you're on Twitter, send me that. Where Where did I put it? I put it here, somewhere.

Let me look at my notifications right one second here? Yes, so Jason Sands has made some outrageous claims and I tweeted earlier. Why can't I find it? Let me just bear with me one moment.

Friends. We've got more from mister d Dean Johnson coming up, but let's get to the Jason Sands stuff. Why is that? Yeah?

I'm sure that I retweeted this earlier. Oh yeah, I faund it. I failed it. Let me a High Speed Chase with another kind of generous ten dollars.

Keep up the great work, brother, got music here on the way. I'll be in touch. Good. I need a good guitar player.

Thank you High Speed Chase for kindness, generosity, support, and of course we're helping us to praise the cat. Thank you High Speed Chase and all of you generous people. We appreciate all of you. Companies.

Eric, let me know in all capital letters what you meant by your comment. I don't know how you're expecting me to treat that person has been very kind to me, in fact, is accusing me of defamation or something. No, the purpose of our stream and our show here is never to embarrass, humiliate, or whatever anyone, or certainly not defamations never are aimed here. It's to educate people, to give them the evidence and let people, you know, sort of make up their minds as to what they believe.

Showing somebody that a hoaxed UFO video is fake is not defamation. And you know, I'm sorry, but somebody be foolish enough to try to sue me for defamation because I said a video was fake, then I'll just bring all the evidence from all the VFX artists that have said that video was fake to court with me, and any reasonable jury or judge would say, Okay, that's not defamation. You were just showing people data and evidence. But it is what it is.

You know what it is if you're some loser that nobody's ever paid attention to your whole life, and then you stumbled across the conspiracy theory that a lot of people like, and you've got on a lot of big podcasts, so you've built this huge following. You know, he's getting real mauthy lately, he's getting real bold, threatening to sue critics and sue debunkers for debunking the videos. And it's it's it's something else. But let's get to Jason Sands before we get back to this other article by d Dean Johnson.

I just wrote, if you didn't already think wack could do, start thinking wack could do. So this is Jason Sands. Do you know something about twenty twenty seven? Jason Sanz says yes.

The information I had was quite chilling for the program, folks, and will apparently take place in a time window that I heard was between twenty twenty five and twenty thirty five ish. While in mission, somebody says, can you explain what you mean? While in mission, and Jason Sant says yes, I and three other analysts intercepted a phone conversation that mentioned the twenty twenty five to twenty thirty five timeframe. We were on a mission for the program at the time.

And somebody says, what was chilling and what is happening between twenty twenty five and twenty thirty five time frame? Jason sand says, what was chilling was that if the program folks don't return the retrieval materials and biologics by the time above the response by the time above, the responsible parties would be put to death. He's saying that if the government doesn't give back the alien spaceships and crash retrieval materials and the alien biologics, that the responsible parties will be murdered, put to death one fury. This explains the sudden controlled disclosure and NDAA clause some in the program may be aiming to avoid.

Oh God. Jason sand says, yes, I still advocate for planned control disclosure. There has to be a degree of amnesty for those who have made mistakes, and I informed Congress on a need for a discreet turnover process. I haven't continued to try to save as many people as possible.

He's trying to save these people from getting murdered. They're going to get murdered, Jason Sands, you are correct, in my opinion. It seems the program is going to come to an impossible impass. They come forward of their own accord, or they face judgment by the non human intelligences.

One way or another, the lies will end they He says, they did not list names nor company names in the telecommunications. I did think the folks who are keeping the stolen tech and biologics are the ones at risk. There are others in the program who are not involved in that part of the retrievals and are safe. And somebody says, when you refer to intercepting a phone call and the NHI stating about the time frame, who did you hear talking?

What was their call? This was a call with non human intelligence on the line, yet et phone home. He was listening to the phone calls and the aliens were telling the humans this was humans. I think you're going to have to clarify a little more about what and who you heard.

It's probably important you clarify asap. And Jason sand says it was a conversation between a biologics person and another individual. So there you have it. The new so called whistleblower, Jason Sands is essentially saying, listen, if these government bureaucrats don't give back to alien biologics and the spaceships, they're going to be murdered.

I don't even know what to say say about this. Friends, What am I supposed to do with that. So for all you people asking for an update, here's the update I have on Jason Sands. If you didn't already think WA could do, you better start thinking what I could do?

You know, this is one of the problems I have with some of these people. It gets, it gets more and more grandiose. Now there's a situation where he heard a conversation that aliens are going to kill people if they don't give the if they don't give the alien bodies and the alien spaceships that they recovered back somehow. And of course this comes from Vicky Verma, who posts the stupidest shit I have to say, but it is what it is.

Yeah, I really don't know what else to say about Jason Sands, but people keep asking me for some sort of update on him, and all I can tell is that he's saying that if they don't give the alien crash retrieval materials and the bodies back to the aliens within ten years, the people responsible are going to be murdered. See, And this is one of those things like, there's a good story, right, but what is the evidence of that? Oh, I heard a phone call once I was listening into phone calls. And by the way, I get that his job was to be some kind of telecommunications officer.

Maybe, but is he supposed to be listening into intelligence community chatter on phone lines while people are speaking. Is that legal? Can he legally survey and listen to private phone conversations that people are having? Does this make any sense?

I mean, I'm not an intelligence guy. Maybe they do that. I just don't. I I don't get it.

I don't get it. And this is where his information is coming from. I was eavesdropping on people that deal with the alien bodies and therefore the aliens or you know, I learned that the aliens are going to kill everybody that won't give the bodies back. Come on, man, it's getting a little deep.

But here's what I will say. So many people have said, interview him, Steve. I'll do it if I can get contact information for him. I have found him on Facebook, but I think you have to.

I can send him a message, but it's going to be in his message requests, and given his age, you know, some of those older gentlemen don't know how to work Facebook. I doubt he'll get the message. But if somebody has an email address for him, be sure to email it to me at Truth Seeker Show at gmail dot com. I will say this, given how many UFO celebrities are attacking that guy, I would speak to him just about that.

Why are all of these other drifters coming out and saying that you're full of shit when they're clearly full of shit? You know, like, it doesn't make any sense. I speak chased with another one too dollars Kanya Generes and says he can legally be a wookies banker. Absolutely, thank you for helping us praise cash all right, At the risk of taking too long here on the Grush story, we have a special guest tonight, which I can't tell you how happy I am.

There's a woman named at Krishley and she has a YouTube channel called chrish Le Tv. You might see pinned in the live chat. I pinned her YouTube channel in the live chat. I was so excited when I found this person because they are single handedly just destroying these fake MH three seventy videos.

She's an incredibly talented v effects artist, an animator, you know, computer graphics person, and on her YouTube channel she is expertly just ripping apart those videos. As what they are fake, which is interesting. Let's get to let's get to this next piece, which applies he kind of covered it in the first article, but I think this is an important enough issue that we should talk about it. I don't know what that's about.

So mister D. Dean Johnson says, one of the burning questions of the day is whether the inspector General of the intelligence community actually is actively engaged in an investigation trying to find out if there exists a hidden program and possession of alien tech. As I sketched in my May fourth long post the Clues Conflict. Sar Kirkpatrick is now on the record to me stating, to my knowledge, neither the ICIG or DODIG are separately investigated in those claims of a government orchestrated extraterrestrial or verse engineering program.

Both the ic IG and DOODIG have been supporting Arrow insofar as whistleblower protections legally allow them. So you know, all of Brush's supporters are saying, oh, no, he gave the evidence. It doesn't matter. He gave the evidence to somebody that's not investigating anything.

He gave them evidence about waste fraud and abuse. That's what the ICIG and the DODIG are concerned with and investigating. That's what they find urgent incredible. If somebody makes a claim of waste, fraud and abuse, they find every claim of waste broad and abuse urgent and credible, and they investigate those claims.

But the claims that they're investigating his alien claims is completely and totally false. You've been lied to by the UFO, profiteering orse scumbags selling you this fake story, and by the man himself, mister Grush. Mister Dean goes on to say, while David Grush has said he gave extensive interviews to the ICIG in twenty twenty two, I have not seen anywhere Grush saying that he knows that the ICIG actually continues to investigate the alien tech allegations. If he did say that within the past year, somebody please show me where he said it.

This is distinct from an investigation of Gresh's complaint that he suffered illicit reprisals somehow connected with his inquiries. The ICIG referred to reprisal aspect to the Department of Defense IG Whistleblower Reprisal Investigations Directorate. If Grush is not satisfied with the results of the reprisal investigation by that entity, Grush would still have the right to request that the ICIG convene an external review panel under PPD nineteen. By law, the ICIG would be one member of any such ERP.

However, whether the ERP is the fact convened is solely within the discretion of the Intelligence Community Inspector General, over and above what Grush has said to the Intelligence Community Inspector General. Matter matter, if someone actually has solid evidence that the ICIG is actively invested mistigating hidden alien tech allegations, not in twenty twenty two, but let's say within the past year, I would love to see it, except if it is classified, in which case I do not want to see it.

And again, Sean Kirkpatrick, to my knowledge, neither the Intelligence Community Inspector General nor the Department of Defense Inspector General are separately investigating those claims of a government orchestrated extraterrestrial reverse engineering program that was and is ARROWS responsible as responsibility as covered by the Historical Review legislative language from NBA Fiscal year twenty three. Both the ICIG and d u D have been supporting Arrow insofar as whistleblower protections legally allowed them. So this is yet another of the dominoes that fall. This is a complete and total joke.

The Intelligence Community Inspector General is not now, nor have they ever, to my knowledge or anybody else, has been investigating Dave Grush's alien and UFO claims. So what we get with Dave Grush is a shell game where he continually they play games with words like the urgent, incredible lie that fell apart. Now everybody claiming that he gave the evidence, and the Intelligence Community Inspector General is investigating his alien claims. No they're not, No, they're not proved me wrong.

Yeah. So I'm excited about tonight because listen, I have been screaming into the void about these MHS three seventy videos for quite some time now, and what is incredibly shocking to me is that the promoters of the of these things. Yeah, I'm glad you're here. So Chrish Lee is here.

So the promoters of these videos, I'm going to ask our special guest tonight, who is a VFX artist and animator and expert in these matters. But we're up to like I've seen at least ten people either debunk or recreate these MH three seventy videos who would be considered experts in VFX in a court of law, people that have ten and twenty years experience in VFX look at these videos and say they're fake. And the promoters have done everything they could to try to get around these debunks, even up to and including threatening to sue people, destroy people, and more. And we'll show you some stuff on that, but for now, let me make sure I have the right thing here.

So I recently found this person's YouTube channel, and I can't tell you how happy I was, because I feel like I've been screaming into the void. And my problem is, though I have a background in computer science, I'm not a v effects expert. I've used after effects, I've used Blender. I'm a real big fan of Blender on Linux, but you know, I'm no expert.

I've made some crude animations. Sometimes you may see, you know, three D text of truth seekers. I make those, but I'm no expert in VFX. But what's so stunning to me is how many experts in VFX have come out and said these videos are fake and here's why.

And then promoters of this video and these false conspiracy theories. By the way, you know, it's kind of slimy because two hundred and thirty nine people died in that tragedy. I don't think they want people making money on the internet pushing fake UFO videos saying that their family members got teleported by aliens. But that's just me.

So this person's YouTube channel, it's chris Lee TV, is pinned at the top of the chat, at least I believe it is after check in on that. If it's not, we'll make it. So, so we're gonna welcome our guests, Chris Lee. Welcome, Chris Lee.

Hi. Can you hear me? Yeah? I can hear you.

Fine, Yeah, I'm so glad you're here. I just for those unaware, chrisally did a stream earlier that just sort of shows exactly she's showing. She's a virtual effects expert. She's doing a live stream that's several hours long, educating everybody, showing exactly how these videos were constructed from the stock effects.

And people are still in the live chat arguing no, it's a cover up and all these things. But before we get started, I'm curious myself. Can you just tell people like what, I know, you're a VFX expert. I can I've seen you live streams, But can you tell people about like your years of experience, your education and these things, how long you've worked in VFX, Because I think it's important that we got to say, look, Chrisly, if I have if I have a leaking pipe in my basement, I'm not a plumbing expert, right, I'm going to get an expert in plumbing and say, all right if you say, but somehow with these videos, even people that have decades of experienced people are still arguing with them that have no years of experience.

So tell us about your experience and education and VFX, just so we know you're qualified to render an expert opinion on these videos. Yes, absolutely so. I think I first got into art in general. I was in high school.

After I got out of high school and I went to UH University and I learned about three D I learned I think I was using three D S three three D S max max. Remember. After that, after I left school, I moved on to Blender. Since it's more open sources.

I don't have to pay for the you know, the subscription all that stuff. I started that program though it's so difficult to learn how to make it do anything. Yeah, I still I still work on it, but I am you know, like with most programs, I would say, yeah, so that you've learned three DX max and then Blender. Yeah.

And then after I think right around that time, I started getting to a photoshop and there there was another one that was feeling it's like baby Stages, which is clip Studio, which is more of an art program, but recently they have like more three D capabilities. After I left school, I went into teaching and I started teaching in a school in my city. I started teaching three D. I started teaching.

It was more like a general we kept changing the subjects, but we did game design three D. We did. That's a great thing to get kids excited about and teach them. Yeah, they were really engaged.

We made some great games. Actually, my son is ate and obsessed with games. He would love that. He's Minecraft guy now.

But now he's getting into video game designer programs and he's like, I'm going to make my own. I'm like, you go do it. You know, if you want to get into this, this industry right now is the best time, Like the barrier of entry is very low. They're making it a lot more accessible these days for regular people, like you know, people who don't have the background to get into it, I think.

And after COVID happened, not to leave the school, so we kind of dropped that and I went into business for myself. I started reaching out to a lot of music artists. I did a couple of music videos animations seeing your demo reel, which was incredibly impressive to me. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I'll do that while we're talking so people can see some of your work.

If you don't mind, you have one of your demo. Yeah, And that's about the time in doing so far. I was with the studio previously, but I left there and I'm doing things a little bit more independently now and most of my work right now currently is corporate. But once I saw these videos pop up, I was like, no, I gotta I need to involve myself in this and kind of show the obvious VFX elements in it because I feel like people are being really misled with this.

Yeah, that's a big understatement. If you ask me, and I wanted to ask you if you were aware you know a lot of a lot of what I do here is that we sort of peel back some of the layers of deception people use to deceive and profit from some of these things. One of the things that really bothered me is that when the first few virtual the first few VFX people or computer graphics people that looked at these and did a video or said these are fake and here's why. Suddenly on Reddit there came these anonymous posters who claimed that they were like the head of Marvel VFX or the head VFX person on top Gun Maverick, and that these videos could not be faked.

You know, there's this It felt like there was this active disinformation campaign being put against the people who were the real experts. It's like, okay, we have an on the record source in the form of quarteror crew. Regardless of what you think, there's three or four guys that will be considered experts in this field. They looked at the videos and said these are fake and here's why.

And the retort or the rebuttal is no, no, an anonymous Reddit poster they're the virtual you know, the VFS head for all Marvel Studios said that those guys are wrong, and it's kind of childish and ridiculous that somebody would go to those lanth like do we not stop the thing? What's that person's name? And by the way, I made a bunch of phone calls and I couldn't get to either of those real people to find out. But I believe other people have and they don't.

They didn't make those posts. So people are using fake evidence to prop up the fake video after experts like you rip them part? Doesn't that say something about their validity? And you know, I don't, I don't.

It's it's a very I think that. The other thing about this that is just so interesting to me is the ability for people to look at something and see something completely different. I'm not because it's one thing for somebody just say something, but if someone will come out and show you what's being done and you can still say no, you're you're lying to me, then I feel like that's that is It's beyond beligan. It's kind of like, yeah, by the way, I want to I want to compliment you, because sometimes things get very personal here in our live chat and people argue and uh.

One of the things that seems to be a real problem is like, let's take for example, for those unaware, the person who took the pictures that were used to create the background came forward and said I took those pictures. He even showed like his passport, the plane TICNT re spipts, and he provided raw files which have all of the time date stamp information proving he took them long before the videos were mede And people are in your live chat saying, oh, he's part of the cover up or somebody paid him, and you refuse to accept that. And I like that stance to just say, if you don't have evidence, don't impugne that person's credibility. He has no reason to lie.

And you guys are, in other words, to try to disprove the debunks. People are basically calling people liars and scammers, which is wrong, just just straight out just calling people liars scammers. What else do they call them fakers? Frauds?

And the problem with that, it's a huge problem, especially for the poor photographer. There's one person who has been I can probably link it to you, uh elsewhere, but if you go to his profile and just search the name of photographer, there will be pages and pages and pages worth of tweets from this person just calling him out, just and not even harassing him. Yeah, that's how they try to silence the critics so that the grift can continue. You know, you're screwing up the grifts, so they try to just shut you up and silence you.

And you've been threatened and yeah, yeah, and just for showing the effects, Like that's that's how serious this is becoming. It it's let me just make sure my audience understands, like, unlike me, who I start calling people cocksuckers and yelling and screaming about scammers and grifters and and you know, her streams are so professional. She just like show like matter of fact, like here's this asset, here's how this asset was used to create the teleport effect. It's it's and you're very matter of fact about it.

You're not getting personal like I tend to like. You know, her streams are amazing, and she's not allowing people to disparage the truthful people coming forward that show. Hey, you know these are fake videos and here's why. Like, it's so insane to me for people unaware we have they found the explosion effect or the teleporting effect.

It was on a website since two thousand and nine and asset site. We have the guy who took the pictures that were used to create the background image of these fake videos, who came forward with all the evidence in proof that prove he took the pictures, and people are still arguing. People are still arguing that the videos can't be vaked. And one of the other things I wanted to compliment you on is I'm sure and if I get this wrong, he's free to correct me.

But Ashton said something, excuse me. The promoters of this thing said, yeah, we decided we're not gonna get you know, We're gonna just just try to stick to the data tonight and not the people. So one of the major promoter of these fake videos has on the record said something like these videos could not be reproduced unless somebody had a whole team of experts and I don't know if it was tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of dollars and you know, unlimited resources or something like that. He said, they couldn't be reproduced.

And I just want to compliment you, Chris Lely, because you're one person and in hours on your live streams, you're recreating every aspect of this by yourself, which means he was wrong about that. They can be it's not even enough. It's not enough. You don't know how many comments and messages that I've been receiving like why aren't you doing it?

Start to finish them? Why can't you recreate it? Point by point? But Ken has already made a shot for shot recreation of one of the videos, and when he that, they said, you just copied the video, and I'm just like, so, there's no there's no satisfying and and then that's that's the trap here.

You can you can put I can put as many hours into this as I want to, but there will always be people who will look at that and say it's not enough. But I think the only answer to that is, honestly, just continuing to put out the truth. And you can't. You can't come to me and demand me to make anything.

I'm not going to do that. I'll show you that done. I'm not gonna I'm not going to they do make demands, they go, well, show me that the that the stills were on that site before the video was made, and then you show them that they want something else that fell into that trap. Chrisly, there's something called Brandolini's law.

Are you familiar with that something? There's something called Brandolini's law, and I fight that all the time with some of these hoaxers. Brandelini's law essentially says that the amount of energy required to dispel bullshit is orders of magnitude more than it takes to create. And I feel that you supply here because look at how many hours you've put into this, and you're just one of the VFX people that have done that.

There's ten VFX people. If we can't corn cruit, there are three or four people. I've seen four or five others. And then you look at all that energy that everybody has to expend.

This is beautiful work, by the way. I love it. The amount of energy that these people require you to expend to dispel their bullshit is truly orders of magnitude more, you know. And then meanwhile, the promoter can just say the videos are real.

You're destroying your reputation. I'm going to sue you. You know, it's ridiculous. The suing aspect is really interesting to me.

I'm sorry, if you can hear this background noise, the suing aspect, what's standing is there for me to be sued. That's my question. I know you're going to be sued because you show people that these are the effects. This this video is the effects and it's not a real video.

It doesn't make any sense. I think. I think maybe some of the griff squads getting desperate, trying to keep the grift going as more and more I'm going to try to collect them up Chrishly, all of the debunks, yeah, and make a video and say, you know, no offense to the promoters of these fake videos, But how are you going to argue with all of these industry experts, you know, look at Chrishly's work here. I'm not thinking to you, but provide no evidence to back up your argument.

Not a single person has put forward any visual, tangible evidence that anything that what I'm saying is false. Not a single person. And then, and I gotta tell you, I was very impressed with how you stood up for yourself in your chat and said, if you're gonna say Chrishly was great. She said, if you're gonna say that that photographer is a scammer, show evidence of that.

I'm not allowed on that in my live chat. You're not gonna damage his reputation. You know, you really stood up for him, which I was happy to see because that guy didn't do anything wrong. He's trying to educate people.

Yeah, it's awful. It's so awful I can't just to think about. And while we're talking, I'm going to share your latest video just so people get a sense of what you do on your channel. And I checked and this video is pinned in the in the live chat, So if you're watching or listening, please go to the pinned video and make sure that you subscribe because this I think Chrisly is doing a community service here, which is something that we feel strongly about.

We make some free documentaries to try to educate people on hoaxes and hoaxers, and we try to help educate people, and Chrisly is doing the same kind of thing over there, but from a perspective of like, here's how the videos were created. I'm gonna just mute it if you don't mind. Just want to give people a look. And this is a and by the way, Chris Ly is also in there doing a Q and A.

You can ask chris Lely any question while she's showing you exactly how these videos were faked, and she'll answer I thought it was so great your stream earlier. I'm glad that I wasn't going to reach out to you because I don't know you. I'm like, I'll just ask her if just do a great work, just ask her to come and explain this to us. So here you're explaining how the teleport effect was made, right, Yes, yes, I am yeah, yeah.

Can you talk a little bit about how this teleport effect is made and talk about the arguments that it doesn't match pixel for pixel with the asset and how it's so stupid because I know, just as an amateur sort of digital artist that you know, artists, they put filters on things, they stretch things, they bend them. So for somebody to make this argument that that asset does not match one hundred pixel for pixel, isn't that a stupid argument from the perspective, not just it's not just a it's a it's not just an irrelevant argument, but the fact that we're trying to also match this to a super low resolution video at the same time, like it's gone through so much compression after converting, and you know, all these all these different things that all these different processes that it has to go to go through.

It's of course it's not going to be one hundred percent pixel for pixel match, but if we can prove that it matches at least with a ninety percent degree of certainty, then it's it's there's not really any there's nothing up to debate here. It's clearly the same silhouette. So what I'm doing, sorry, what I'm doing here is I'm modifying the silhouette. So it took the color information from the original shockwave asset, and it's just using that color information to create a mask.

And it's it's just that's literally what it's doing, refining the silhouette, using those colors to inform how that civillette is. And then after that, all you have to do is stretch it to fit. And that's it. And you know, it's funny.

Someone also just pointed this out to me. I didn't realize this, but the the shockwave asset is apparently stretched the exact same way that the clouds are, meaning that there was some maybe some I don't know, overall transformation that happened to the entire image and it was all stretched in the same way, which means, yeah, it's a typical that an artist would use the same stretch style on multiple objects in one project, I would think, right, more like they they may have stretched it at the same time or the same way. Okay, well, yeah, that kind of makes sense, especially if it's one guy making the whole video right exactly. And then that that's the other thing too, that comes up, like someone would need mega equipment, Like my computer is not amazing, Like my my graphics card is over is almost I think it's six or seven years old at this point.

My best video card is just a ten yeah, yeah, you know, I mean my best video card is like a ten eighty, which is years old at this point. You know, it doesn't take crazy simulations and three just be a longer render time if you had a crappier video card though, really, right, can you repeat that? I didn't hear you. In other words, if you had if you didn't have the latest, greatest video card, like let's say you had one from twenty fourteen, it would just take longer to render the scene, right, literally, That's it.

That's that's the only Yeah. So some arguments have been made that this couldn't have been done in twenty fourteen. How do you feel about that argument? I mean, well, already I just said that even my my CPU EXAMPT for example, has is probably older than twenty fourteen.

So I don't think it's not like it's not a good argument to make. I don't think I get by I fixed computers, so I get by with I call it opt other people's trash, you know, like I have a upgrades. I got a bunch of Intel Imax here because everybody's upgrading them now, and I just buy on opt other people's trash. I don't need to buy anything.

I'll just you know, on network four of them if I need to, right, And it's also just kind of disregarding the fact that they probably had a really good computer. I mean, that's not really it doesn't really come into the conversation when we can reproduce it. And another thing that people bring up is, oh, you're using a more modern version of the software, but that's Adobe doesn't really I know that they release like yearly updates, but they don't really don't change much Like, they don't really change anything. Every tool that I'm using was available unchanged as it was in twenty fourteen.

I think that's something really important to point out too, because it's nothing that should they'll try to throw at you, but it's not. It's it can't come into It doesn't come into the conversation at all. I wanted to get into if you don't mind too. When this video first resurfaced, I did a quick video and said that the cloud static, that it's and what I said, having observed there's a hoax UFO channel called Third Phase of Moon, I did a whole documentary on them, and a method that they used constantly was to use a static background image and then superimpose an animated UFO over it.

And having seen hundreds of those from this hoax UFO channel and busted a bunch of them, I instantly said, this is a static background image that's like, you know, not moving, and they superimposed this animated scene of these orbs and this plane over top. But now that people are arguing if clouds are moving, and on closer examination, they do seem to have a tiny bit of motion. But I credit that to compression from a codec. In other words, when you change when you render it to MPG or MP four or whatever you're going to render it to, there's compression codex that squeeze the file down and that that can cause a slight bit of motion in what is a static image.

Do you think that's what's happening here or was there something I do? Yes, I so later on, later on in the stream, I definitely we talked about it because it's Yeah, I remember you addressed it towards towards the end. I'll see if we can. Yeah, you have the clouds.

Yeah, and you you also have to speed up the video to even see that movement. Yeah, you have to speed up to Boudicris speed. Do you remember that from Spaceball? It's like they have, to the benefit of my audience.

To see any movement whatsoever in these clouds, you have to move it to like sixteen hundred times it's normal speed. So they're being dishonest when they say no, no, the clouds move, and there's a tiny bit of movement. The other problem that I have that I pointed out in your live chat, and I think you agreed with me, is that the air plane goes right up to the side of some of these clouds, even appearing to go through the clouds, but the clouds don't react to the jet wash. I showed this to a jet pilot and he took one look at it and he said, that's not real clouds.

The jetwash from a plane that big would blow those clouds all over the place if it flew that close to them. Or so that's another argument why these are static images, besides the fact for my audience's benefit if they're unaware, the person that took the pictures of the clouds that were taking off of textures dot com website has come forward shows plane ticket and said those are my images. Here's the raw files those want to argue it's amazing, there's a there's a jet floating around too. Of like someone took the photos that he took in the and you know, released and they lined up because you can see Malfuji in the background of some of the photos.

They lined up a series of them and you can see the trajectory of the plane, like I'm guessing the plane was taking a turn to land at the airport and you can kind of see that progression as Mount Fuji kind of changes perspective through the photos. Like that's there's so many data points that lead up to this being legitimate that it boggles my mind that people are still trying to say that this is a cover up. Sometimes things are not a conspiracy, and it's okay, you don't have to find like deeper conspiracy. Sometimes things are just what they are.

And I think that sometimes people have a really hard time accepting that. Yeah, yeah, I'm just still blown away that so many VFS experts have come forward and offered their expert opinion these videos are fake and here's why. And by the way, I think there's a certain consensus. You know, there's some slight differences of opinion, but you know the fact that the image the background was made from a static image.

All the VFX experts that I've looked at that have looked at this said yeah, that's a static image, and here's the source of it. And the same for the for the teleporting effect. It's this stock asset that's been around since two thousand and nine. Here it is the fact that, so, you know, there's just so many VFX experts that are all saying these videos are fake, and here's why.

It's just it's mind blowing to me that that somebody with no v effects experience whatsoever is going to argue with all these experts. Isn't that kind of like disrespectful to those experts. I would think so it is, and it's another reason why I'm so involved in this. It feels like a insult to this community, this industry, this line of work when and not just that, but there's also like the accusation like v EFFX artists would never be this detailed.

This is literally our job, and not that this video has, you know, an insane amount of detail. It's literally just a plane pomped over a bunch of photos sticks together, but just the idea that someone can't have this creativity to make this from their imagination. It's it's not just insulting to VFX experts, it's it's insulting to humanity in general. We are really creative species, like we're someone will would do this like have you.

It makes me feel like people who say stuff like this having gone to movies. They haven't seen the Avengers, they haven't seen Avatar, they haven't seen any of these movies where all these fantastical things are happening on the screen. Those things didn't happen in different universe like the VFX artists made those a VFX artists made this. It's it's really not a stretch.

And the fact that people are still arguing this. It's it's so discouraging, honestly, but I think that's that is to keep speaking about it and keep showing no. I agree, And I admire your courage because you know that you're going to be target. You already a target, aren't you.

Yes, I'm a public target people. But I think that their strength in numbers. I hope that more VFX artists will come out about this. I feel like the more out and start being more vocal about this than the quicker, this will just yeah.

And here's here's a I'm gonna I'm gonna share part of that situation. Quick note to the debunkers who are hiding here reminder, I've given the evidence and Edward Lynn to the ERA who can verify he's the guy who leaked the videos. For those are a where Edward Lynn was arrested before the videos were released for he got in trouble for the charges don't line up. The fact that this promoter of these fake videos is just I call it research by proclamation, you know, like he didn't speak to Edward Lynn.

He got no confirmation from Edward Lynn that he leaked the videos. He just found some dots. He could connect and claim that. But anyway, uh, people have without me asking send me your real names and other personal info.

You were attempting to debunk real videos and covering up a major conspiracy where two hundred and thirty nine people were kidnapped the government. And it won't take the blame that people who will be vilified and have their lives ruined are the debunkers. You. I get that you're mad, especially you christ Lee, but you're literally digging your own grave in a no win situation.

The mhe three seventy videos are real, and the longer it takes you to accept this, the worst things we'll get for you. Just accept the consequences. And then this person says, I'm sadly going to destroy christ Lee, which I take no pleasure in, but she brought it upon herself. Thankfully, she proved beyond any doubt that the debunks are fake for us and fear at the very points Mick West graudulately made.

And by the way, for those un aware, Mick West is another person who would probably be considered an expert in computer graphics and the effects in a court of law that also declared the video is fake. And here's why But he didn't want to waste a lot of time on them, so he just did, you know, like a couple of quick pieces on why they're fake. Right, there's another expert. Yeah, so another thing that comes up.

They accused me of being like in league with Mickwell, I've never spoken to him before. I didn't know about him before any of this came up. I'm not I'm not really involved in the drama that's been going on the video. How you can make the clouds move a little bit with some kind of filter or effect, Right, it's trivial to do it if you really wanted to.

It's not my opinion that that was done, but if that was the case, then that would be how you do it. But yeah, so I've been like accused of being like in league with micwst too in like this big, this big conspiracy to bring down the videos like it's it's I mean, we we Just because there are multiple people saying that this is fake does not mean that they're all working together. It means if the video is fake. Yeah, you would think a reasonable person would just conclude that if if so many the effects experts are all saying these videos are fake, then you know, maybe they're fake.

Maybe there's no huge conspiracy here and somebody just made these videos. I did notice in your live chat back to Brandolini's law, You're right, all these people that think the videos can't be fake demand Christley that you do this or demand that you do that. And I was kind of impressed that You're like, I'm I'm an expert at the effects. I'm showing you what I can show you.

I'm not taking request or demands. You know. I think it's good to push back. Yeah, you're pushing back and saying like, no, I'm not doing that, Like, you know, there's always some argument to be made too, you know, like oh, first, you know, people were arguing like, oh, first people said the clouds didn't move.

Now they say they move, Well, they move if you speed up to sixteen hundred times of speed. Forget the clouds movement in the In the videos, you can see in the background that there's clearly water, right, I'm not sure if I if you can really see in this part of the video, but there's like these little wife flecks in the background that are like very obvious wavecrests. Regardless of the clouds, wouldn't the water be moving at least, wouldn't you see some progression of those waves? It doesn't.

It's a still photo. Yeah. Here the plane flies right by a cloud and there's no movement of the clouds that it's flying right by and through. Which now they just say that it's at a different elevation or something.

Yeah, they give excuses, they give the obvious excuses that it just it just blows my mind that anybody, you know. And by the way, the promoter of this once conceded that the videos were fake and then changed his mind. I think he looked at his YouTube check every month and decided he couldn't let it go yet, right or something, you know. And my challenge to that person is kind of like, if this isn't about money or fame, then turn your monetization off and give back all the money you made promoting these videos.

Is real and it's only fair if it's not about money, you know. I just really want people to I hope that we can create a more open community. Maybe maybe that's not the right word, but I just really want people to do not just their homework, but learn about some of the things that are being talked about. Don't just take my word for it.

Go do some study in photography, learn about camera raw, learn about what else is there compositing, Learn about these things before jumping on people and making these baseless accusations. Because it doesn't it's it's toxic. And you're you complain about this people not being taken this investigation seriously when we're we're we're spending so much time in this petty drama, Like it's so unreal to me, it's it feels childish, and we could be doing we could be doing so much better her with your time right now. Yeah, no, I agree.

Learn learn about this stuff. Learn learn about it. You learned from me, like, learn about it from somewhere else, but just just do some studying on it. First, I was I was very happy.

Uh, don't take this the wrong way, you know, uh, but I was very happy to find out that you were a woman and was standing up to this promoter of this garbage because he's been very nasty to another woman who also kind of debunked the videos crudely, so, you know, like misogynistically. So and I don't really like that word, but in this case, it fits, like and I was so I was so proud of you in that live chatter earlier, because you were kind of standing up to the to the bs and the people making demands of your time and the people disparaging other people or calling them scammers. You kind of said, hey, not in my live chat, and no, one'm not. I'm not capitulating to your demands.

I'm showing you what I'm gonna show you. And you know I was. I was happy to see that, And kudos to you for standing up to this and and sort of like giving some pushback. And honestly, I think the more people like you, chris Ley, that are actual experts and VFX that can come together and form a consensus that these videos are fake, you know, the better I mean.

But I still wonder like we're up to like ten at least VAFX experts that all say the videos are fake at least. But I wonder like if there was a hundred, would he give it up? I don't give it up. And what do you think he's gonna do if they find the plane.

I don't think he'll give it up. He'll start new conspiracy theories. That's not the real plane. They fake the wreckage, right, of course, I mean, that's that's the problem with these kinds of movements is that they feel per secuted by not just the government, but there's like a big boogeyman that they're all kind of running from or feel that they're being pursued by, and that makes them look through everything, look at everything through that lens and I conspiracy, yeah, basically, and that kind of I can understand that mindset, and it can be difficult to break out of because the it's kind of like self retaining almost.

It's like if someone comes up to you and tells you it's fake, they're lying to you, they're trying to fool you, and you don't want to be fooled, so of course you'll you'll be resistant to that. So yeah, but the gymnastics, the amount of mental gymnastics crucially that you have to do to still believe these videos are real. I mean, the person that took the pictures would have to be alling CIA agent or some something, right. The person that found the explosion effects, he's in on it.

Everybody's in on it. The person that released the videos originally I guess I don't know, you know. And another part assumption that needs to be made for this to check out there's There's another thing that everybody's missing is that the channel that this video originated on was filled with fake UFO videos that were cgi the effects. So shouldn't that be relevant that it came from a site?

No, the story, the story there is that they released it there because no one would look for it there, or something like that, or once we get there so that most people more people can see it, or whatever. The it's just it's just always an excuse. There's no there's no stopping it. And what I say, I mean, what I think is that there may be people that we can't reach, and I don't think that we Yeah, I'm big on that too, like we could save the ones we can, but some people no matter how much evidence that we show them.

And we've done some excellent sort of debunking work. But I a would say, I'm not a debunker. I'm a truth seeker. I go into it, I evaluate the evidence, and if it's debunked, it's not my fault.

I just I filed the evidence. So you know, call me where you're gonna call me. But but you're a debunker now, Chryst Lee, and you're gonna have word. It's so dumb.

It's something, but in this community, it's so stigmatized. It's crazy. It's really crazy. Like you, it carries so much weight now that it's I don't, I don't.

I hate I hate being associated with it. And what all I'm doing is just showing what's going on. I'm replicating it on screen so that people can't just you know, they can't just say, okay, are you just saying that you have no source? Here's a source.

Here are the source files. Oh yeah, by the way, everybody, She gives everybody all the sources of everything she's using to recreate these videos. And despite the promoters of these fake videos claiming they couldn't be reproduced in just hours using after effects and admittedly too old computer to this work, chrisly is showing exactly how one person with how many hours do you think it would take to recreate this if you went from scratch, you know, if you had the assets and you just started eight am in the morning, Like and we're if we're talking, so let's look, I don't I need to want to I want to identify, Like are we talking about recreating and like reverse engineering it and recreating it or just making it up from your head, making it up from your head, let's say, because that's a little more difficult, probably less than a day if you start at eight am, lesson a day.

And meanwhile, the promoters of this that it would take I don't remember, he can correct if they can correct me six months or a year, or you need a whole people, ten hundreds of thousands, if you if you exactly exactly, if you consider how quickly it is just to put the mask on this, that took what less than I think it was less than three minutes in total just to create this maths less than three minutes to create that. And this is this is on screen for one frame, one frame. Maybe stitching the photos to thegether will probably take maybe thirty minutes to an hour. And then the the drone movement, it's just a plane.

It's a plane on a path going around. That's it. It's not it's not rocket science. It's not difficult at all.

And could you also talk for a minute about the orbs, And isn't it true that there is a mathematical formula to their movement which also sort of proves its the effects because these three objects could not possibly be moving that synchronized at the same rate and everything, and you know, I there's probably excuse me, there's probably some math involved in terms of how after effects does the the animation, but I think I talked about it on this stream as well. It's it's just three three orbs parented to like a knull and then the null is like rotating. It's it's it's it's procedural in a sense, but it you just tell after effects to rotate on a certain axis and then you parent that to something else. If you want to parent it to the plane, for example, then it will follow the plane wherever the plane goes.

And it's it's just simple as that. You animate it, you parent it to another object, and that's it. There you have it. There's no there's nothing complicated about it.

And I think maybe they saw that they were synchronized sort of. But it's it's just it's just three orbs on like a ring and then the ring is rotating. Yeah, but but it's rotating at a standard or steady rate. It's not it's you know, there, if it was real objects, there would be more variation in the rotation, right, yeah, nature would be or probably more natural movement.

But we're also kind of looking at a like this is also this is this is a six frame I think it's six frames per second, so there's only movement in every six frames too. So you can't you can't really, I feel like you can't look at this clip and then you know, extrapolate some kind of fantastical whatever whatever is it that the argument is at how these orbs are moving. There's not enough information to even grasp something like that. Yeah, and Rick Brooks asks Ditton, a retick guy, identify stock cloud footage you use?

Yeah, but better than that. Not only did I the day identify the stock images used to create the clouds, but the person who actually took the pictures that were used to create that that were sold to For those that are aware, there's stock image websites where you can go and search like clouds, and he was a contributor to some of those sites. They pay people to give them images of clouds. And the guy who took the pic Brooks came forward, gave the raw files proving that they were created before this video.

And also he had like a passport and a plane ticket receipt. Uh. That's you know, it's like over it's so overwhelming that these are fake and how they were faked that the fact that anybody is still arguing, you know, I don't, it's fascinating to me. Yeah, it's like watching It's like watching a cult like in real time.

And there's also a lot of you know, prusually there's a lot of cult like aspects to this, which is something a cult does is control the flow of information. And certainly the promoters of this are actively trying to stop people from seeing work like yours or Quarter Crew. Anybody that goes against the narrative they're pushing is suddenly the devil, like yeah, someone even I even got a there's someone out there. I'm not sure what they use the name is, but they have been trying to get people on that side to report my account for harassment and incitement of harassment.

I'm not harassing anyone. Who am I harassing by showing people how these videos are made? And if they're trying to get my Twitter taken down like all kinds of crazy, that is crazy. And I don't know if you're aware of this, but there are lists of debunkers and yeah to yeah, and I have something that I could share about that.

There are lists of people this person, Grinder Browning says, Hey, guys, your accounts are currently being targeted for harassment by this account. I reported the account to incitement and targeted harassment. Take whatever precautions you feel necessary. And here's some of the people that are Christly you're on that list.

And you know who else? Fires of Truth. This is Spooky who does graphics and used to help with my show. Here is a big friend of the shop, a chat remoderator here is on that list.

And I Spooky, what did you do to get on this list? And Spooky said the I think the picture right there at the bottom it shows the account that if you can click on it or not. No, this is one screenshot the count right there, the one the forty two something something. That is a person who's been telling people to report my account for harassment.

And that's their that's their block list they have they having walked. I've never spoken. I don't think I spoke with this person before ever. I can find another way to share that.

I apologize. I just have to put it in an image viewer and share it that way. One second, I'll do it from there. Yeah, it's it's insane to me.

It's this is cult like behavior. Like these people are going against the cult of the fake m makes three seventy. We got to get them. And we've seen this in multiple other hoaxing events and and other things.

You know, they use these cult like tactics, which is disturbing that they would go that far to try to harass people. And let's be clear, Chrystley, they're trying to harass you to just say, you know what, this isn't worth it and just shut up and move on. That's what they're trying anyway, you know they're trying. They're not going to succeed.

And if for any reason, any of my accounts get taken down, you know why? Now you know why? Yeah, but I won't be gone. I won't be gone long if that happens, I'll be back.

Yeah. I cannot. I cannot believe that some of this stuff that happens. I'm going to share that again so we could see the account at forty two.

It's the secret report these malicious accounts under excess guidelines prohibiting incitement of harassment. You'll find most of their accounts here. How are you harassing people? Christ Ley?

How is spooky harassing anybody, Spooky, I asked, Spooky, I'm like, what did you do? He said, I asked some questions. Apparently asking questions is now incitement or harassment? And uh, yeah, we know that this is This is a socc account of the major promoter of these fake videos, who is making, by some reports, a lot of money pushing this this fake nonsense.

You know, just ridiculous that they would go that far, like, hey, let's let's let's get their Twitter accounts taken down so they can't keep sharing the debunks on Twitter. Sure, if your evidence that this that these that these videos are real, is so strong, you should be able to stand with with stand debate right exactly exactly, But not a nobody has come forward with any hard proof showing that these are that these are real. And I think that even just letting that come into the conversation is center bite, says I'm on page too. I'm so proud DS welcome senting by Yes.

And like I said, to everybody, listen, do me a favor and go and subscribe to christ Lee's channel. We got a couple hundred people watching. If half of you went over there, listen, we have to support the people that are telling us the truth and you know, doing good work. She's using science and showing with computer science how these things are created and educating people about how fake these videos are and suffering consequences.

But there should be some benefit to doing good work for the community, and one of those benefits should be get some subscribers and have more people share her videos on their social media. That certainly helps as well. But pinned in the description of the video is a link to her latest video and just go to her channel and click the subscribe button. I really think that she's doing excellent work.

You're going to keep going on some of this you had enough, I'm not gonna stop. I think that really, And I would say if you are in this business, if you're a VFX artist, if you're any kind of artists and have experience with this, please come forward, Please share your expertise. I feel like the opposite side of this discourse has been kind of low, and the more of us that kind of share, you know, our knowledge about this, the stronger that the truth will become. Because right now there's a lot of lying going on.

It's very loud and yeah, we can see the deception used like I said, all these deep bunks came out from the quarter crew. And then all of a sudden, there's anonymous posters on Reddit that claim to be Marvel, the head of Marvel VFX Studios or the lead VFX person on Top Gun Maverick, who both say these videos can't be fake. And the promoter of this puts this in his slides like, this is my proof that the videos are real. Marvel Virtual the effects said, these videos are real, But what where is that one?

The record comment? Give me his phone number? Right? No one can produce these people.

It's so it's so interesting. No one can produce these people. I think they said it was Jeffrey Ford. Get Jeffrey Ford on the phone.

Where is he? Where is his statement? And then there's the other the other person that they always called I think is the person who was on top Gun. I'm not sure if that source that came from somebody saying yeah, I think this person said that wasn't even I don't even think that one was a written comment.

Yeah, yes, yes. And we want to thank artists and Tony who says, thanks Christley for your work, thank you for your kindness, generosity and support, and you don't know this, Christy, but what we do here every thank you artist and Tony and also I think there was one other one that I missed. The UFO Shane gifted one tree Seekers membership, which is why you should subscribe. You can get a free membership.

YouTube gives them out randomly to anybody who's a subscriber but not yet a member. So thank you UFO Shane for also helping us too. Yeah yeah, so listen, I'm not sure you've been doing these streams that are like pretty intense. Do you have Can you tell us what do you have planned next for going after these videos?

Because I get wait to see the next one. Well, there have been a couple of people who reached out to me to give statements I guess about the VFX, so that will most of those will be happening this week. As I get those details, I can share them. Aside from that, I'll keep continuing to answer questions about this.

I kind of want to go through everything. So I started with the satellite video. I did kind of touch on some aspects of the other one. But after that, you're going to do the thermal thermal one?

Yeah, you do that one? Oh good? So The good news is, friends, that there are people promoting these videos as real that have no evidence they're actually real. But the good news is that there's people like Chryst Lee and others out there now.

And here you're showing how the orbs worked, right, Yeah, someone asked me how the how there was like a heat signature on one side, So I showed how you can do that. I showed how you do like motion blur to kind of have them you can kind of even kind of blur out, was it, you know, the quicker they move, Just showing like all these things are all these things are reproducible. I'm a little confused just looking at your interface here, But I'm no animator. The best that I was getting really good at three D titling and stuff, but then the software I was using to do that got a little too old now, so I have to find something to do that with.

I'm upscaling like seven to twenty video to ten ADP doesn't work that way, or four K it doesn't work too good. Yeah, this is interesting though, that you have such an expertise, And thank you so much for you know, sharing your knowledge so that people can be educated and how these things can be faked and created. I'm happy. I'm happy to I'm really happy to share.

I feel like my my real passion is teaching rather than the effects. And prior to this, I did have a couple of like instructional videos on my channel. I think it's just like in the video. I had some, but I didn't really continue because I feel like there wasn't really getting too much.

But I think that if you know, once this is done, I would definitely probably go back to making that knowledge accessible to other subjects. If you want to learn leunder or after effects or whatever, I'd be happy to keep teaching. Wow. Yeah, I need all the help I can get me.

So yeah, I've been using blenders since. I can't even tell you, like I was an early adopter because I'm a Linux guy and it was Linux first, right and so, but I just don't have time. I wish I did, but I wish I had more time to play with things like this, Christy. But you know, life gets away time consuming.

I guess if you don't know what you're doing, so it takes you ten times longer than somebody like you, you know, to make something right. Yeah, Brett Clark is asking do you teach blender? You said you're gonna be doing some tutorials on your channel. Yeah.

I have a couple of tutorials on my on my channel already. I think I have one about animating jellyfish. I have another one where I have like a little juice box animation, so kind of simple. But I would totally be down to teach blender if people want to.

If people want to learn about that, excellent. Well. I want to thank you for taking the time to join us tonight and encourage everybody to go over your channel and subscribe. I can't wait to see the next live stream about this because listen to you don't know the buzz because maybe you're not like a You're not like a UFO person, right, You're not into UFOs and aliens too much.

I'm not a what. Sorry, I had to turn your volume down so it's not like giving feedback, can you. I said, you may be like very connected to the UFO and alien and UFO Twitter scene, but when you started making these videos, I'm telling you, it must have been like twenty people sent me your videos and we're just like, oh my god, this girl is wrecking these fake videos you got to see this, Steven. So it's nice to connect to you, and I'm glad you're out there.

That's all I can tell. I really really, really really want to expand the conversation on this and include different opinions. I really feel like one size has been extremely vocal and there hasn't really been too much of a too much of a pushback. So yeah, if we can get more people on this, let's do it.

Yeah. Well, thank you for joining us. I appreciate you being here. I'm going to throw you out and do a quick wrap up here.

Thanks so much for everything that you're doing. I'm so glad that I was so glad to see that you're out there doing this because we need somebody like you that is a real expert in these things to say, hey, here's the real deal, that the information that they're not giving you. You know, thank you for giving me the chance to be here. Yeah, my pleasure.

You have a good evening, you too, all right? Thank you? All right? Friends, boy, what this girl is awesome?

And I had a few more things to share, but christ Lee is very you know, she wanted to talk about the data and the things that she can show more than the personalities, and I understand, you know, sometimes we get caught up in I don't know, I guess this sort of back and forth with some of this stuff. But one of the other people that is ripping these videos apart and showing everybody how fake they are is t Powell at TJP of Texas, who's been sharing a lot of stuff, and there is some real disturbing things that the promoter of this fake videos are has been up to. Ashton is trying to head off his critics before the post a bunch of videos of Ashton being Ashton because it will make his critics look bad. Watch the videos below.

He makes all kinds of thinly veiled threats. He targets people by name, and he blasts them on this page for sharing views that he disagrees with. He doesn't even address the facts, just handwave it's all been disproved and jumps to ad Hamman in attacks I've been kind of here. Here's one of those posts.

Ashton uses veil's threats like this fairly often, it seems. Take this one for example, claiming that I am a grifter and engaging in spycraft and that I am lying to quote pushing deliberately false statements, all objectively false statements. Give me his real name, and I will make T. Powell go away.

It's disturbing. He's gonna make T Powell go away? Why? Because T Powell is, you know, proving that the videos are fake.

Anybody who's proven that the videos are fake, you know, is getting threatened by this promoter, this hoax promoter. Here's another one directed at mcwest. Like I said, Mick, if and when the videos are confirmed, I'm going to have the family sue you for everything you have. You have repeatedly made false declarative statements about the videos, after multiple times claiming you wouldn't look into them.

I have documented your various statements for proof you don't and can't know the videos are fake. Yet you continue to pretend like you do, and even wrote a false article and Skeptical Inquirer. I will have them sue Skeptical Inquirer as well. So you better pray they don't confirm the videos.

I mean, this is disturbing. This guy is out there threatening people with legal action because they say the videos are fake. You know. Here's another one.

He threatened to sue me after making a post on Reddit. Not mentioning him and presenting the facts which show the videos are fake. Now he could sleep in a bed he made for himself. This is great.

It means I sue him, pass it on to him. We got a new Corey good He's just going to sue all of his critics. This person who is promoting these fake MH three seventy videos may want to look into how terrible suing your critics can turn out in court. Go look up Corey Goods cases.

Well, this has completely proves my point that this guy is a total nutjob, totally unhinge. Seek mental health. That's another that's another big thing. If you disagree with this person promoting these fake videos, you're a nutbag and a mental case.

Somehow great, here are my haters. Apparently the redditor debunkers have been buying fake engagement and are planning on making some kind of defamatory super cut about me and promoted across Facebook and x If you didn't know, the redditors have a discord where they coordinate scams and fake debunks, including the felony fraud they committed against me in December. There's no proof that the people from Reddit did that. This dummy bought fake information from a scammer.

The irony is I think they think I lie in slander while they make plans to do it themselves. Grider aka Gary Gundark aka the guy I made cry in the Space the other week is planning to target young college feminist demographic Texas. NG and Mitsia spent five hundred and fifty in the last few weeks paying to promote content against me and the MH three seventy videos. If you are somebody out there and here are the here's where it gets most disturbing.

He's making live stream videos to a following of hundreds of thousands, of one hundred or more thousand subscribers, and he's saying things like this, if you are somebody out there who's telling people now to talk to me, you are an absolute piece of shit, and you are one of the worst human beings on the face of the earth. And in the future tell me your name. I'm gonna blast you all over social media my one hundred thousand followers and on live streams as well. And I'm gonna tell you that's a threat.

He's threatening critics with harassment. Tell people what a piece of shit that you are. So don't do it. Last warning.

If you're one of the people who's trying to debunk these videos, I am going to send the families after you to sue you for every single fucking penny that you have. This includes Mick West, it includes the Corridor Crew, It includes Jonas Dereaux and any other debunker that puts their real name next to any debunk of times on these videos. You have been warned that is what I'm gonna do. Maybe I should have warned my don't sue me bro shirt available in our merchandise section for tonight's broadcast.

He's literally saying that he's gonna get the families of the victims to sue the people that are showing that the videos are fake. I think that desperation is kind of seeping into mister Forbes here. Not a threat, it's a promise. I will have them take everything that you have.

I will make sure the media crucifies you and make sure that you are to go down in the history books as an enemy of humanity. Is that one hundred percent clear out there, debunkers and redditors and other pieces of crap. If you say that the videos are fake, even if you have overwhelming evidence they are, then you're an enemy of humanity. Somebody in Griftsville is getting kind of desperate.

I think that this is really disturbing. This is this is this is the behavior of a cult leader. This is scientology technique. Thinks he did he one hundred percent did more than just respond.

He made a debunk video. So he's going to lose all his credibility for the rest of his life. It's not my fault. We got more.

Should we post the next one or say the next one? I don't want to. I don't want anyone to think that I'm trying to blackmail anyone. I'm just trying to put the information out there as soon as possible.

No, he's not trying to blackmail anybody. He's just trying to threaten and intimidate and silence any critical voices that say that the videos are fake. Listen. I agree with Christley and what Chrystley said earlier.

If your evidence is so strong that the videos are real, you wouldn't be threatening to sue people that say the videos are fake, because you'd just be able to easily prove the videos are real, but actually can't prove that. So he just attacks anybody who says the videos are fake. And here's another great example. UFO guy gets publicly embarrassed repeatedly, So we've got some kind of loser reacts streamer right off the bat, right, she's posting our content which we can see here right, which we literally did debunk this, so already work.

He didn't debunk it. He debunked it by declaration, not by research or evidence. And you know we can just tell based on her hair and how she conducts herself that most likely she's unlovable. And she's unlovable because she says the videos are fake.

Why does he have to attack everybody's appearance or call them a nutjob or a mental case if they say the videos are fake? Why why can't you just debate on the merits, sir? Why do you god to attack this girl's appearance? And I'm sorry, but maybe it's just me.

Right, I was raised to respect women and really all people but women. You know, you don't make fun of a woman's appearance, period, full stop, for for really any reason. Uh, I just I don't get it. Right, Oh, she said the videos are fake, So I'm going to tell everybody that she's unlovable is what is that Nobody will ever care about her in her life.

Now we see her, you know, trying to dunk on us. I'm sure she's making a butthole jokes here at this point, because he deserves people making butthole jokes. Remember famously was it on the Danny Jones podcast he said, my butthole does not look like your butthole. It's not the same butthole.

Now let's keep going on. Oh that's not enough. Oh, look, she also has to try to dunk on the fact that we had a felony crime committed against us. Felony crime committed against us.

Oh, that's a good thing that we should make fun of, right, rite, Rebecca, make fun of people that have felonies. Okay, well, let's take a look at you, Rebecca. Let's go ahead and investigate what we find. If we look at Rebecca, what do you guys think?

Well, yeah, that's great. So he's gonna do, I guess, sort of opposition research on all of his critics and trying to dig up dirt. That's another sciencetology cult like tactic, fair game. Anything you've got to do to silence a critic, you do it.

I just keep thinking. You know, if this, if this evidence that this stuff was real was at all good, he wouldn't need to do use tactics like this. This is the tactics of a desperate, sad little man. Uh, you know, attacking a woman like that.

Come on, man, thank you for your work. Chris Li says High Speed Chase. Hope I spelled it right. I struggled myself.

I had to check it three times, so no worries. Thank you for your kindness, generosity and support High Speed Chase and helping us to praise the cat. All right, we're praising the cash and we want to thank wing Nuts who became a YouTube member. For those unaware, if you become a YouTube channel member during the live broadcast, we give you a big shout out and thank you.

I want to take a moment to also recognize and thank you patreons orders. You could join for as little as a buck a month, and all you YouTube channel members use super chatters, PayPal, pleasures and more. We love all of you. Thank you for the support and helping us to praise the cash and keep the show flowing and going.

Guys pray, thank you for your kindness. Thank you for your generosity. Praise all right, well, thank you for your kindness, generosity and support all of you. I think that I have a few more things to share, but please please be sure and I could take some comments and questions from the chat.

Well, I have a little more time to share with you. Please put them in all capital letters. P Brett Clark is here and says, Unfortunately, over the past five years, the more kooks have crawled out of their holes and flocked to this kind of nut jobbery. Can't say I disagree with you, So comments and questions for me, please put them in all capital letters.

In the meantime, I'm trying to find some things I wanted to share with you. Oh yeah, I had one. We're gonna go there. We're gonna share this.

I wasn't gonna share this, but I am. It's from jazz Deep on Twitter. Boy. You know, sometimes to keep yourself saying, you just you've got to laugh at some of this stuff because it is so it is so bizarre that it's worthy of laughing at it.

So look along with all the bad of this person, you know, profiting and promoting from the tragic deaths of two hundred and thirty nine people with his fake videos that he didn't even create and his fake conspiracy theories. At least we get a little bit of good art out of it. So here's a song from jazz Deep on Twitter. This is a banger.

Friends, There's a difference between having an open mind and being mentally disturbed. Ashton forbes and is following have the Brain of birds? Obvious fake video made by a man who's come clean. Ashton just blocks him and says he's being mean.

Why won't Joe Rogan listen and accept my pissed poor evidence? I should block his ass to not having an open mind. Don't get me started on Mick West for not investing his time on wormholes and missing airplanes? Can he tickle muskets o?

Fred you want to see great eagle and not so fast for Preston? Did I get scammed? Oh jeez, you gotta love it. Friends, We want to thank trolley troll.

Troll who says, yeah, I'd like to see that idiot try to collect any money from defaming him. You know, these threats of lawsuits are kind of ridiculous. Ask any lawyer how difficult it is to collect money in the defamation lawsuit. It's one of the most difficult cases to bring.

You know, first of all, you have to have overwhelming evidence that the person maliciously tried to damage your reputation with proof with things that they knew were untrue. You have to prove that they knew they were untrue and that they did it with malicious forethought. Part of me. Then you have to prove that you suffer financial damages.

Relate it to that defamation and the false statements. Showing people that videos are fake isn't defamation and it's not false statements. But thank you trolley troll Troll for your kindness, generosity and support and being a longtime show supporter and for being a member. So comments questions for me, please put them in all capital letters.

There are a little bit more time to share with you. And meanwhile, we're going to check in with our PayPal pledgers. Instructions for how to send a PayPal pledger and the instructions description excuse me of this video or podcast. And we appreciate every single one of you, especially those people who send those big, those big helpful PayPal pledges.

We want to thank dB who says, hey, Steve paying my dues. Hope you and your family. One second, hope you and your family are keeping well. With a kind of generous ten dollars PayPal pledge.

Thank you for a kind of generosity and support. And we've got Maria with a kind of generous fifty dollars PayPal pledge. Longtime show supporter who says, please keep up the coverage of the wacky world of Wilcock. His latest video is crazy.

I don't know if we're going to do that this week, you know, Can I skip one of those three and a half hour ego fests? Maybe not. We'll see how the week shakes out and what we have and the three to zero The thirty King is here from Chryst Lee's channel. I think that's a moderator from chrys Lee's channel.

Big hug, Well, thank you and thanks for what you did in the chat trying to keep things civil. Wing Nuts says, still coughing up coffee from that tune here, Well, thank you for being a member. Thank Jazz Deep for that. High Speed Chase says, good night, have a great night, guys.

Well, yeah, we appreciate all of your We appreciate everything that you do. A high Speed Chase to support the show. Big Show supporter and YouTube channel members Hank McGirk is here and just says, hey, cam Be and fellows, so listen. I think we've done our due diligence.

I'm sure there's a lot more that I could or should share, you know, but back to Brandolini's law, the amount of energy and you know, required to dispel bullshit as orders of magnitude more than it takes to create it, which is really true. And I find it interesting that so much many people have invested so much time to try to dispel the bullshit that the promoters of these fake videos have put on. And we've detailed some of that. Incredible Brandon Lani's law applies to these MH three seventy videos.

You've got ten v effects artists all investing hours and hours and hours to say these videos are fake and here's why. And yet some people still want to argue with them. Interesting that christ Lee's stream earlier got sort of infected with people that want to argue. I haven't seen very much of that in our live chat.

Maybe they didn't find us yet. It is what it is. I wish I'd been here from the start. Please restate the editor ladies YouTube wing nuts.

It's in. It's pinned in the live chat right at the top of the live chat. Just click that link and you'll go it's christ Lee christ Lee se r I s h l e E t V. If you just put c r Y s h l e E t V or click on her userride d Right.

Oh, christ Lee says he's on Twitter right now talking about this. Oh boy, well, do we really want to check in? Uh? Maybe is it just Ashton?

I think I don't know what his Uh. I have to look to see what his Twitter is. You know, I certainly don't follow him. No, that's not it.

Uh, somebody tell me in the live chat what is his Uh? What is his Twitter handle? Lot? I don't really know.

Uh. Or you know what, if I do a search for m H three seventy, I'm sure I'll find something from him and find his it's just ex Ashton. Well, I don't see anything specific to us that he's talking about. Maybe I have to check and replies maybe I don't know macroscopic phase conjugation big words.

Oh yeah, he says, I did find something. Oh man, it's getting thick. It's getting thick. Ashton says, I don't like wasting energy arguing with the Bunker, but we've had a lot of new followers, and I constantly have people posting links to YouTubers promoting falsified VFX comparison.

But it's important to address because the deception convinces even prominent podcasters like Joe Rogan only look at claims at face value and don't see the disinformation under the surface. Yeah, if you say the videos are fake, you're a disinformation agent. We have an impossible list of requirements to fake the MH three seventy videos, including an unclaimed hundred and fifty thousand dollars bounty. I don't believe he'll ever pay that if somebody reaches whatever he wants.

A mountain of evidence the videos are real? What mountain? No, you don't. You don't have one verified real VFX expert who says the videos are real.

And meanwhile, on the debunker or skeptical side, you've got ten that say they're fake. And here's why. Mountain of evidence that they're real includes the name of the military personnel who leaked them. He has no verification that that person leaked them.

He has no evidence that leaked them. He has his opinion that that's who leaked them. The events in the video are corroborated by real eyewitness sightings who are dismissed and discredited. The stakes could not be higher if these videos are real.

I'm putting my personal safety at risk. Oh, this is a perfect example of a grifter. Free energy is on the line for humanity. Now, these videos have something to do with free energy.

These videos have the potential to revolutionize the planet. I'm just going to tell you, Ashton, I'm going to ask you a direct question. How many free energy devices have you built? I have a background in computer science and electronics.

I've built many of them. You know one thing in common with all free energy devices, none of them work. Free energy is not real. You cannot break the laws of physics.

There's no such thing as free energy. But okay, you're turning into Stephen Greer Grift here. You're talking about free energy and UFO propulsion by free energy. The people hiding the truth fate of MH three seventy will do anything to prevent this information from going mainstream.

It is likely that this will be the only chance any of us get in our lifetimes to set the timetable for disclosure on our terms. In the process, we could solve a cold case and find solace for two hundred and thirty nine souls and their loved ones. I wonder what those two hundred and thirty nine souls loved ones think of you pushing these free energy conspiracy garbage conspiracy theories in which you're claiming that an entire airplane with two hundred and forty people, two hundred and thirty nine people on it were teleported by what aliens? It's ridiculous.

It's just complete this. This guy has lost it, but it is. Yeah, I think I've had enough. It's just NonStop ridiculous, you know.

All right, let's uh take a moment and I have I don't know. There's a there's a video that somebody sent me that they want me to play. This is from lou Reviews. We're just gonna play and it's about harassment and some of the stuff in the UFO community and kind of fits in with what we're talking about here.

So we're going to share this before we close down our broadcast. For the truth. You can't handle the truth, Jesus, it took you motherfucking long enough to bring me up to speak. Goddamn bro agreed, you can be a skeptic and still be one of us.

I'm a perfect example of that. I'm a believer, but I'm also very, very very skeptical about most of the stuff I hear in these spaces. But I can still handle part of the community. He could do the same if he went about it a different way.

But he's got like some sort of God complex. H He's out here fapping in spaces. That's gross. He ain't gonna slap shit.

He's a fucking moron. You sat here and just said he's intelligent, and he can't even do a couple of minutes worth of research to determine that I am not the person he claimed I was. But he made a whole stink about it on his motherfucking show, So he's not being intelligent like you said, Kevin, I'm sorry. I respect you, though.

Well, then I will keep calling him certain words people don't like because it's great content. It's just mad weird for someone to like spit atheist at me, as if it's a derogatory slur. When atheists are skeptics by nature, and he claims he's like the ultimate skeptic. Like, what are you talking about?

Like you sound stupid? How about a simple Google search of dead Bluebird will prove that I've been using this name my gamer tag since two thousand and nine. There's a couple of YouTube channels I'm on, a couple Twitter profiles on the internet. Everyone as dead Bluebird.

He's dumb. Some that dude who has a YouTube channel. Yeah, he's all but hurt because Luel Azondo broke up with him. Bro, I come from the competitive call of duty scene.

Okay, I don't give a fuck about that guy, and I will go in there and make fun of him all the time. I don't care what content he tries to make out of it. I don't care. Is not the wolf, that's all he is.

He's not a wolf, he's not a lion. He's a bridge troll. Whether he comes in here to speak or not, he's still gonna listen anonymously and clip us no matter what. So he gives off how I speak to anybody, Nobody, none of you, None of you will tell me how I can and cannot speak to other people.

He wouldn't have gotten called a fat fucking retard. If you want to spat atheist at me like it was a slur upon himself. He's dumb. I will make fun of him.

I die if he wants to stay here the entire time and be all up in our faces the entire time, We'll make fun of him. Don't worry, guys, I've been doing it this whole time. I say the things everyone else is scared to say. I'll be the bitch.

That's okay, listen, I'll solve it this way. Lou reviews one v one me call of duty, any call of duty, one B, one v one rust quick scopes. Let's go. He wants us talking another hour about him, and it's worth it if we solve this problem once and for all.

Right, it's it's worth it to solve this. But he has a research This is more of a pest than than an addiction has saying should shouldn't he just not even be ether? Should he? He shouldn't even be zero point energy?

He shouldn't even be back right, Like, he's just a parasite. And we need to figure out how to get asking me to, you know, in a in an ethical manner, and we have the tools to do it. I don't know, but this this should be an easy problem to solve. No, it's it's it should be any problem.

Sol He's a person. He's not a parasite. We can't refer to people as parasites. That dehumanizes them.

He has feelings, and he's in a position he's in because he feels, you know, a certain way, because he was hurt, like any of us would be if we were in his shoes, right, I would say we would behave the same way he would. But you can't do humanizing like that. And you know, I don't know the fuck. I've been requesting this whole motherfucking time to come up here and ask him why he made the claim that I am Willith a serial harasser and doopts her, and you just fucking ignored my request the entire time.

Thanks a lot. She's very angry it fucking oozed this from her. And I believe if I'm not mistaken, and I believe if I'm not misstaken, and I believe if I'm not mistaken, where this started really what she used to be Lilith Rising on Twitter a little cry baby bitch. I can't stand that dude.

And then he's got little daughters like TJ and Bobby Broadway fucking messaging me like Bobby Broadway's like, yeah, go make some bad AI art some more and try to pass it off as your own. And then he tagged me in my m Age three seventy song like, bro, that's not AI art, you war on? And then I wonder how Lou reviews, because Lou, you're probably still listening anonymously. You know, your little butt buddy TJ.

Did you know he was also butt buddies with King Milk Fart like livery on the t KMF for fucking months and months? Did you know that? But he deleted his other accounts, so you probably wouldn't be able to see that. Just thought you should know.

Lou doesn't have those extra dense clusters in his brain, so he wouldn't understand that. But you know what, it could have been so easy to like, like, Lou is in here, right, But believe me, there weren't. There were more people requesting to talk to him than I could accept, right, So what do you want me to do? Just get rid of someone that everyone wants to talk to.

I feel a little dirty. The truth you can't handle the truth. He wouldn't have gotten called fat fucking retard. Wow, Wow, there's something else.

Apparently she's going to go on a show on Friday. People love a good argument, so she should do great numbers with that. I would think, Yeah, it's worked for us here, Lew says, dehumanizing others like this girl isn't part of my approach. She at this aspect often goes unnoticed within our community.

I find it deeply concerning that such language is tolerated. How can we justify this? Should legal action be considered against the individual in question? I'm uncertain, but their recent behavior certainly warrants serious scrutiny.

The fact that dumer Zaddy there called to harm someone simply because they hold different beliefs about UFOs is utterly unacceptable. There's no room for discussion or acknowledgement of their humanity. It's as if disagreement automatically equates to a desire for their adication. And this is a problem with some of this stuff.

It's just so toxic. Yeah, so, friends, we've done our due diligence. I'll take a few more comments and questions from the lat Chat monkey's throwing pooh, Yeah, that's kind of what this equates to. Patty says, this is hilarious.

Why a wife ful says she doesn't like me either, I don't know. Imagine being stuck and with that. Yeah, hell has no fury like a woman. Man.

I don't like arguing with women. I generally don't. I don't even argue with my wife. Man.

They always win, especially if it's your significant other. You know, they got the Trump card, so they usually win any argument. One of them is on the phone to the duty doc. We've got to be quiet here.

Yeah, I've never heard of that game. I'm a competitive Call of duty expert. Oh my goodness. All right, Miss Tessa Marie is here, says late getting here Steven, Hello, fellow truth seekers.

Yeah, can I get anything like a watch? We started two hours and twenty two minutes ago, But I'm still happy to see you, Miss Tessa Marie. Better late than never. You got to make a big entrance.

Yes, Patty says, you can't win when you argue with us. Correct, absolutely, so listen. I want to thank all of you kind of generous benefactors. I want to thank our wonderful surprise guest.

I only connected with her like an hour or two before the show. Excellent guest, and I hope we'll hear more from miss christ Lee and again pinned in the live chat and in the description of this podcast is a link to her latest video. From there, you can just click on her channel and go and subscribe. I highly recommend it.

And also you can follow her on Twitter. Be sure to do that. It's at Christley c r Y s h l e E at c r y s h l e E. Go follow her on Twitter, go follow her on YouTube.

I think she's doing excellent work and I love to see that. I love to see somebody that's doing you know, we try here. I always say this, We try to be of public benefit to our viewers here, and she's certainly doing that. It's definitely a public benefit to dispel these fake conspiracy theories and to you know, educate people about the truth behind some of this stuff.

You saw me the other night, Hank, you had that look in my eye. Yeah. And in closing, I just wanted to mention that if the promoters of these fake videos arguments were so strong, they wouldn't need to resort to threatening to sue people. They wouldn't need to resort to making lists of people to have their accounts messed with or you know, report people for abuse and harassment when all they're doing is talking about the videos being fake.

These are cult like tactics that are kind of disturbing to see. It's been a while, quite honestly, since people have docs threatened, intimidated, or harassed me. But I'm sure that, given my stance, that these videos are one hundred percent fake. And by the way, my opinion is not just formed of my own research into this and my own experience with computers and video editing and VFX.

My experience with animation and VFX is quite limited. I default it to the experts, people at Corter Crew and Christley and mcwest and others. How can this person, Ashton stand in the face of all those experts and say I'm right and your wrong. To me, it's the height of arrogance and stupidity.

But that's just my opinion. You know what more can I say? So We've done our due diligence for this evening. I will be back tomorrow night at nine p m.

Eastern Standard time. I've got three or four more great shows ready to go in a folder, and I'm hoping to get as many of them as possible sort of make up for our lack of live shows last week, which again I apologized, but you know, being a married father of two children, one of them special needs, sometimes you just got to take a step back and get some things done in the real world, and that's what I was doing last week. And so you know, I'm sorry to those people who said, oh, this isn't a live show, or you know, come on. We did produce something like fourteen hours of replay content, which I thought was excellent because it was so information packed about all these UFO crash retrieval cases and all these former UFO whistleblowers that never proved anything, but they all made lots of money selling their stories.

History really is our greatest teacher. So you know, what more can I say. I'll be back tomorrow night at nine pm Eastern Standard time. No place I'd rather be, and I hope you'll be here with me.

We want to thank our excellent guests, Miss christ Lee, and remind you again in the description of the video and pinned in the live chat. That is her YouTube channel. Go over there and subscribe and follow her on Twitter. It's at c R Y s H L E E.

Christ Lee, I hope, I'm I hope that's right. But for the benefit of the audio podcast listeners, it's at c r Y s h l e E. And also for the benefit of the audio podcast listeners, you can find her YouTube channel very easily. Just go to going over to YouTube, click the little magnifying glass the search bar, put in c r Y s h l e e TV.

That's her YouTube channel. You'll find her over there doing great work educating people and dispelling bullshit, which is something that I highly support. I can't tell you how much I enjoyed our stream earlier tonight. Watch her latest video.

It's really worth it if you want to get an education into how these fake videos were created. And so that's all I got for your friends. Until next time, My name is Stephen Camby, and good night and God bless all of the announce listens listenssssssss listen to s

Comments & Upvotes

Transcript

Barrow, Doctor John Trapatrick, Hearo, Baro, Baro Herrow, Doctor John Trapatrick, Hearo, Hearo Herro, dumpster fire, Hero, Doctor seanrack Patrick takes brush, dumpster fire Arrow, Doctor seanrack Patrick takes rush for the ra says yeah. Harry Nolan, Harry Nolan, Harry Nolan, Harry Nolan, Hero, Barrow, Harry Nolan, Harry Nolan, Harry Nolan, Harry Nolan, Barrow, Sparrow, her narrow, her narrow here, boats here boat Herro arro her ow narrow here, boat here, boats here, boats here, boats here, boat Hero Arrow found no evidence of extraterrestrial technology. The lack of any evidence, any evidence. Barro found no evidence of extraterrestrial technology, the lack of any evidence, any evidence.

Trust me, Bro, don't worry about the evident. David Crush. Trust me, Bro, don't worry about the evident David Brush with zero evidence, incredible evidence into the star, with zero evidence, incredible evidence into the Star, Kirkpatrick's evidence. Where is Arrow's evidence?

Kirkpatrick's evidence? Where is Arrow's evidence? If I if I call your hooker, if I call your mother hooker, if I call your mother hooker, if I call your mother a hooker. If I call your hook Saliens and extraterrestrials, trust me, trust me Bro.

If I call your but hooker, Aliens and extra dress trust me Bro trust me brow hair hair Broke. Aliens and extraterrestrials trust me Brow trust me Brow and you. Aliens and extraterrestrials trust me Bro trust me brow hair hair folk, Aliens and extra terrestrials trust me Bro trust me Brow. Sharoh sharrow like sharrow, Sharoh booker, booker, booker, Pharaoh booker, booker, Boomer Barrow booker, Boober booker, Pharoh booker, booker, over booker, pharoh s.

Greetings and salutations, friends, and welcome back. Tonight. We're going to be covering some recent revelations about Dave Grush, who, for those unaware, as a high ranking former military officer Air Force, in fact an intelligence officer who some time ago three hundred and thirty seven days ago made some out of this world claims. Claims that anybody familiar with UFOs and aliens has probably heard before that the United States government is in possession, in fact of alien spacecraft, alien spacecraft crash debris, and even alien bodies.

Interestingly, it has since been learned that David Grush has very close ties and associations with many of what I call the UFO promoters and others have called the spooky hustlers, the same group of people who have been making these out of this world claims but never actually providing evidence or proof of those claims for many years, in some cases decades. So we are now at three hundred and thirty seven days. I've said it before, I'm going to say it again. The excuses for this man to stand up in front of Congress and make these allegations and claims without providing a single shread of evidence is honestly mind blowing to me.

Equally mind blowing is the media's copy and paste narrative. Dave Grush made these claims. Perhaps thousands of media outlets simply copied and pasted his claims into what most people would call credulous articles, articles which just took mister Grush's claims at face value without actually taking a moment to step back and say he hasn't provided any evidence whatsoever of his claims. So now we're at three hundred and thirty seven days, and many people have suggested that at three hundred and sixty five days, which were coming up one years, it's another thirty days or so, I should bake a cake and we should have a one year Still no evidence from Grush party.

I have been covering this story critically since it began on June fifth, twenty twenty three. I will continue to cover any developments in the Dave Grush saga. You may be aware that over the weekend I put together two of what I believe are my favorite pieces that should educate people on the claims of Dave Grush, an entire five or six hour special about so called UFO whistleblowers the past. I believe that history truly is our greatest teacher, and what we learn when we take a step back and look at these claims through the lens of history.

What we learn is that no previous so called UFO whistleblower, including many high ranking intelligence and military officers who made claims very similar to Grush, ever proved any of them or ever provided any evidence of their claims. But they all have one thing in common. They all profited a great deal wearing the right shirt for this. Today they all praise the cash every chance they got telling their evidence free, faith based believed stories.

Recently, a researcher on Twitter, which I admire spect I'm going to add his links in the description of the video, made some significant progress towards proving that David Grush is misleading the public. Now, I should say that mister D. D. Johnson is sort of a gentleman.

He's kind of like others that we've talked about here. I lack the tact that some other more professional I would say researchers or journalists have. He was very I think fair in his assessment. But still you showing that Dave Grush and by extension, his followers and the people promoting his story have been misleading the American public have been essentially lying to all of us.

And the proof is very clear, because after all, mister Grush is making claims that should be investigated by the proper governmental office to investigate these claims, and that would be arrow headed by once headed by doctor Scheun Kirkpatrick, who has since retired and left. But interesting that mister Rush fails to provide any proof of evidence to the very governmental office that is tasked with investigating his claims. But yet still somehow claims to be some sort of whistleblower. Where have we ever seen in history that the whistleblower comes out and says, can't show you my evidence.

I know you're the proper authority to investigate my claims here that are blowing the whistle on, but can't show you any of the evidence. I gave it to this other office. But what we're going to see in our presentation tonight is that this is very misleading, I would say, outright deceptive and just lies. If you are caught and call yourself a whistleblower, maybe you should show evidence to the proper investigating authority.

All we have gotten from Dave Grush for three hundred and thirty seven days now by extension, his supporters and the UFO profiteering whoes who are profiting. Some would say that hundreds of thousands of dollars have been made and you know, I know, I get messages in the comments and people send me nasty messages. If you can do third grade math, you can add up all the monetized views on YouTube alone, that's not counting audio podcasts promoting David Grush's evidence free claims, and see that hundreds of thousands of dollars has been generated from Dave Grush telling his stories, but yet there's no evidence. And we've talked about this in great detail.

I have a real problem with what I call the UFO circle jerk crowd. If you're going to cover a story but only cover one half of it, you're not doing anybody any favors. But I guess you're doing your wallet some favors, because, after all, people who just you know, promote these evid it's free claims dead hundreds or thousand times more the views than people who do it the proper way and show both sides of the so called evidence. But it's kind of hard to show both sides of the evidence when so far Dave Grush is not provided any.

But don't let things like facts and evidence. We've learned this before. You do not let things like facts and evidence get in the way of a good fake story that you can profit from. So we're going to get into our presentation, and by the way, I do want apologize last week was very Look, I'm just gonna say this.

Can we all acknowledge that show hosts, including me, are human and sometimes life gets in the way and things take you away from that which you would prefer to be doing. I would prefer to do a show here every night. However, I have a wife, two children, one of them is nonverbal, autistic, special needs child, which requires a great deal of time and energy and attention. And I've also got some financial interests outside of this show that need my attention at times, need all of my attention.

So last week, I honestly I did the best that I could do. It was one of the toughest weeks in the history of our show. I did one live show, and then I put together two sort of montages, one of them five or six hours long and one of them an entire nine hours long on UFO crashes. I forgot to mention that earlier.

If you're interested in the claims being made about many of the things that Dave Grosh has said, please check our video section. There's fourteen hours of material for you to educate yourself on the history of both people making these claims and on the stories of so called UFO crash retrievals. Once I did sort of a wide view of these things, I came away quite honestly underwhelmed. For all of the claims that people make, the evidence is virtually non existent unless you count stories.

We get plenty of stories in UFO land. It's just, you know, the problem comes when you ask for evidence. And also, I just wanted to mention because I got several messages about Michael Schratt's presentation in that UFO Crash piece we did. I wanted to include both sides of the story, and Michael's sort of a true believer who, by the way, makes really beautiful if you're in the UFO poorn like I am, you know, nice pictures of aliens and UFOs and alien crash retrieval sites.

Michael Shratt does a great job of that. But I will agree with some of our viewers who said that essentially what Michael Schratt does is make pretty pictures to go along with evidence free stories, which I could see how some people would say that really doesn't help. It's just providing another layer to add to the story, like here's some pictures to go with the story that still has no evidence. And while I strongly disagree with many of mister Schratt's conclusions, I like Michael Shratt.

He's you know, an interesting fellow, and I hope that he and I will remain friends and just agree to disagree on things. There's things we completely totally agree on, like Bob Lazaar, which is interesting, but we disagree on many other things. And as far as who he works for, you know, listen, it's not my place. I've expressed what I feel about Michael Schratt and some of the people that he has allowed himself to be employed by.

It's not my place to tell. Man. You know, there's an old saying. I think it's from like, isn't it from the Sopranos?

Like nobody gets to tell you how to cover your nut. It's not my place to tell him who he can and can't work for. While I strongly dislike and disagree with some of the people that he worked for, I'm not going to tell me who he can't work for. I have expressed to him that I think that his credibility is affected by some of the people that he's associated himself with.

It is what it is. You know, I like him as a person. I'm not going to attack them. I'm not gonna you know, and for anybody that says I'm giving him a pass, I'm telling you exactly the same things that I would tell Michael to his face.

We're good, We're okay. And I think it's a good idea sometimes to include the believer side. If we have somebody that's willing to come here and share their thoughts and opinions, even if we wildly disagree on their conclusions, we can still learn something from that. And I for one them all for that.

Sometimes there's some very militant skeptics of my audience, and I love and appreciate all of you, but you have to be kind to the guests or we'll never have any So we're going to get into the Dave Grush situation first, because I think that people have a tendency to miss some things when it's kind of hard to digest. And let's be honest. I remember the days of blogs and everything was in a blog or a text website. But you know, the media landscape has become much more multi media based and rich and video and audio, and you know, so some people miss some of these things because it requires you to have to go old school and read a lot of stuff.

And I get it. Some people don't have the patience for that. And I want to make sure that I remember to tell you this person d Dean Johnson is just an excellent researcher, and it's at D Dean D E. A.

N. Johnson j O H N S O N. For the benefit of the audio listeners, I highly recommend that you follow him because he does some excellent work. He has a piece here called More Zigzags by UFO whistleblower David Grush.

Former Department of Defense senior intelligence official Chris Mellon said to Seun Kirkpatrick, then the director of Pentagon's All Domain Anomaly Research Office AERO, in a June thirteenth, twenty twenty three signal message contained an a four yeer release obtained by john from the Black Vault inserted below. I spoke with Dave Grush at Kirkpatrick's request, and his first question was why hadn't Narrow gotten all the info from the intelligence community Inspector General Inspector General of the intelligence community. It is all there and fully documented, to include confirmation on the alien technology program is a real and AT is real from active cleared insiders. On June thirteenth, Kirkpatrick texted back to Mellon, DOJ Department of Justice has to release it is part of a criminal investigation.

They have it yet, he Dave Grush needs to come and tell us separate from his criminal complaint. By email on April nineteenth, I asked Sean Kirkpatrick a series of questions seeking to understand what the Department of Justice had to do with any of this. He replied to me on April twentieth, twenty twenty four, mister Mellon and I were referring to both of mister Grush's IG complaints, which fall under Department of Justice rules and authorities. In order for Arrow to have received any of his evidence, the Intelligence the Inspector General would have to release it, which would require mister Grush to authorize.

He did not. There is no other investigation, so that's interesting. All of you people that are falsely claiming that the Intelligence Commedian Inspector of General is investigating mister Grush's alien in UFO claims are completely and totally mistaken. Mister Dean goes on to say the answer surprised me, so I then asked Kirkpatrick, do I understand correctly that to this day Arrow has not received the detailed alien reverse engineering allegations that Grush says he provided first to the ICIG then to two intelligence committees in twenty twenty two, and that the ICIG would have been willing to release those transcripts to ARROW if Dave Grush has authorized it, but that Grush refused to authorize the release of the transcripts to ARROW or failed to respond when asked to authorize such release.

To this, Kirkpatrick responded on April twenty first, twenty four, Yes, that is correct. I conveyed this to his attorney in a phone call that all he has to do is authorize release of the ICIG transcripts. That did not happen. In a further response to me on April twenty second, Kirkpatrick said, quote, both the ICIG and DODIG have been supporting ARO insofar as whistleblower protections legally allowed them.

David Grusse said on May third written statement to News Nation reproduced below to be clear, Arrow that does not have we have access to the information I provided to the Intelligence Community, Inspector General, and of the Congressional Intelligence Committee under PDP nineteen whistle blowing process. Then goes on to say my comments on the above. In the Foyer release obtained by John Greenwald, we saw first that Grush challenged Kirkpatrick Vam Mellen as to why Kirkpatrick had not examined the ICIG interview transcript Yet now we learn that subsequently Grush failed to authorize the release of those same transcripts to Aro after Aro explicitly asked that he do so. Regrettably, this appears to be another example in an emerging pattern of zigzags and substantially misleading public statements on certain matters by Grush.

Enlightened the communications that were occurring as early as June twenty twenty three between Grush and Aro, some of which now are spread to the public record thanks to the work of John Greenwald. I believe that Grush engendered a misleading impression in the public's mind regarding Arrow's interest in hearing his testimony. Grush October thirty one, twenty twenty three statements in News Nation calling Shoan Kirkpatrick a liar for saying that Aro had repeatedly reached out to Grush was misleading. Kirkpatrick was entirely truthful in the specific statement to which Grush was reacting.

Misleading in some way, in my opinion, is the second sentence of Grush's May third twenty twenty four statements in News Nation. We should also recall Grush's words to the Congresswoman Anna Paulina Luna during the July twenty six, twenty twenty three UAP hearing before the National Security Subcommittee of the House Over sit and Accountability Committee, when Grush said, quote, I had a classified conversation with Sean Kirkpatrick in April twenty twenty two before he took over Arrow in July twenty twenty two, and I provided him some concerns I had. I was happy to give sage counsel to him on where to look when he took the helm of Arrow. From that exchange, no viewer would have gotten the impression that Grush would be unwilling to share his classified testimony with AERO.

Grush might have good reasons for not participating in a classified interview with ARO, but Grush's stated reasons for not participating in a classified interview with Arrow have been contrived and implausible. So essentially what we have here is, you know, everybody is saying, oh, well, he gave the Intelligence Community Inspector General all the evidence. Yeah, and he's supposed to be giving that evidence to ARO, and he could all he has to do is authorize the release of that information from the ICIG, who could then give it all to ARO. He has so far either refused or denied doing that.

He will not allow the Office of ARO to get the same information. Why is that Some have been speculating that he knows that he knew that the Intelligence Community Inspector General would not he would not investigate his alien in UFO claims, so he gave some evidence to them knowing it's worthless to them. They're not going to investigate anything. But Arrow is investigating all the claims made to them.

So maybe, just maybe this is a shell game because Grush had heard through the grapevine, and I've heard this from several sources that some of these people go into Arrow, heard that Arrow is exhaustively investigating the claims that people are making to them. Perhaps mister Grush knew that his claims could not stand up to real investigative scrutiny and therefore didn't want to give that information to them. Yeah, so essentially, nobody claims that Grush is legally obligated. The article goes on to state nobody claims that Grush is legally obligated to submit to an interview with Arrow, or that Arrow has any authority to compel Grush's testimony.

If a lawyer's client does not wish to do something that he is not legally required to do, that lawyer might provide his client with ideas for optical justifications for what the client has already decided to do. But that is something very different from asserting that the client would be placing himself in legal jeopardy by complying with the formal requests of high ranking government officials. So one of the other excuses is Arrow doesn't have the required clearances to see the evidence that mister Grush has that has been proven completely and totally false. And one of the other excuses all he could go to prison if he releases that information to Arrow.

He gave it to the ICIG. This is all a shell game. Grush could give that evidence to Arrow. They're legally entitled to have any evidence at all, according to the Office of Arrow and doctor Schouan Kirkpatrick.

Johnson in this article goes on to say, Sean Kirkpatrick told me April twentieth, I don't want to speculate on motivations, but clearly, as documented, we gave every written authorization assurance and pointed to the law as written authorizing Arrow to get him in to review his evidence. We had an Office of General Counsel, Department of Defense provide an official Pentagon read of the law in mister Grush's lawyer through the Congress. We also provided further od and I Office of Director of National Intelligence assurances. In the face of all that he has still not come in.

I even spoke with his attorney directly. Given all of these efforts, I would say that any commentators suggesting legal prudence are perhaps blind to the truth and are continuing to pedal misinformation. So every excuse that Grush has for not giving his evidence to Arrow, which is the office that's supposed to be investigating his claims, fall apart under scrutiny. And here's where it gets great.

Is the Intelligence Community Inspector General currently investigating alien tech claims. As I previously imported on this platform, Chaun Kirkpatrick told me on April twenty second, to my knowledge, neither the Intelligence Community Inspector General nor Department of Defense Inspector General are separately investigating those claims of a government orchestrated extraterrestrial reverse engineering program that was and is Aerrow's responsibility as covered by the Historical Review Legislation legislative language from NDAA fiscal year twenty three. Both the Intelligence Community Inspector General and the Department of Defense Inspector General have been supporting ARO insofar as whistleblower protections legally allowed them. So, you know, I hate to say this, but all of these stupid people have been arguing with me for almost a year and awo oh no, Steven, he gave his information about the alien crafts retrieval programs to the DoD and the ICIG, and they're investigating his claims and they found his claims urgent and credible.

That is all bullshit. It's all bullshit. None of that is true. Mister Ding goes on to state his comments on the above.

For my part, I do not claim to know whether the ICIG is continuing to investigate any of the alien tech allegations that were made by grushen It's interviews with the ICIG the visible clues conflict. But I do find it curious that some advocates on UFO Twitter seem to be taking the position that the director of the Pentagon Intelligence Community Office, who was specifically empowered and tasked by Congress to probe alien tech allegations, among other things, could not possibly know whether the ICIG is also engaged in alien tech investigation. Yet they are confident that they do know, or at least the UFO friendly writers on whom they rely, who hold no clearances at all nor any congressionally and dawn authorities, do know. Yes, I know about their remarks by Senator Marco Rubio on October twenty fourth about the Intelligence Committee standing aside while allowing the ICIG process to be completed.

But I noted also Rubio's comments on a later date, February eighth, twenty twenty four, when Laslow asked are we going to hear from those people whistleblowers within the Senate, to which Rubio responded, there's a whistleblower complaint filed by one of them, and ultimately, I mean, we haven't spent a tremendous amount of time on it lately, but I was hoping that's what Errow would do. That sounds to me like Rubio assumed that AERO would be checking out Rush's allegations, and now we know how that has gone. If the ICIG and AERO staff actually were independently investigating some of the same alien techt stories, presumably ICIG's staff would have approached some of the same people who have been interviewed by AERO or have been contacted by ERO. It also seems that word of some such ongoing contacts by ICIG investigators would get around.

Is there any evidence that is happening? Has any UFO whistleblowers going on the record with incredible report that the Intelligence Community inspector general investigators have knocked on their door recently, say, within the past year, And by the way, despite the certitude of some advocates, I have not seen any public claim by Grush himself or any attorney representing him, asserting that they know the ICIG is currently pursuing an active investigation of Grush's alien to claims, Nor does Grush make such a claim in as may third statement in News Nation. Instead, Gresh said only I trust in the investigative and law enforcement criminal referral authorities ICG ICIG as independent of DD oversight. Because I'm writing a longer article on some of these matters, I submitted a number of related questions to David Grush's media team on April nineteen, to which I have yet received no response.

Before my longer article is published, I will again submit questions to Grush. I hope that Grush will not fall into the pattern too often found among UFO celebrities of declining to engage with anyone who is not willing to receive what he says as purely stemographic or sounding board mode, or to uncritically amplify even implausible claims. And then there's a section here on Grush and Senator Jillibrand which is interesting regarding UFO whistleblowers, and forgive me, we're skipping somewhat ahead. Told Laslow, I can't assess them unless Aro can talk to them, because Arrow knows what they know and what they've seen and what they've been shown.

I queried Kirkpatrick about the attempt at jilibrand Kirkpatrick Grush meeting. He replied by email May third, the meeting was canceled by mister Grush and his attorney. That was the they Senator jail Brand referred to both she and I confer together to try and arrange changed the meeting through her office. That was yet another attempt for us to get mister Grush to come in.

I do not have a reason why they declined and canceled. He later elaborated this occurred full twenty twenty three, likely October November. We didn't document it because it was being actively handled through Senator jail Brand's office, and I was working it with her right up until I retired, hopefully hopefully he would come in. I wasn't going to get ahead of her.

It was up to her when we would acknowledge we were trying to negotiate with them. It may be that Grush has some pertinent information that Jaia Brand is not clear to hear, but both the Senator and Grush have access to legal counsels sufficient to avoid any violation of security protocols. So is that yet another meeting with Kirkpatrick or Arrow that he canceled or failed to appear at. You know, And it seems very clear to me that Kirkpatrick has gone above and beyond trying to get this man to show his evidence, show your cards, mister whistleblower, and his continual refusal to do that, and his continual I don't know, you know, this looks like one big shell game to me.

Oh, I have all this evidence of alien technology. Great, can we see it? No, can't show it to you. Great.

So to finish up the article, mister Dean says, enough for now. I think that non prosaic UFOs exist. I don't know if the government has technology of non human origin squirreled away somewhere, but if they do, I think we ought to know about it. Yet, preferring for something to be true and then hearing unsubstantiated stories from people who say that thing is true does not necessarily mean that that thing is true.

Indeed, we should be especially cautious about too readily accepting unsubstantiated stories about things that we would prefer to be true. Nor should we accept or reject acclaim based on and individual's style or swagger. Here a worship is a poor substitute for the tedious business of examining evidence. I am working on an article dealing with some of these matters in greater detail, and we'll publish it one of these days.

If you want to receive it by email as soon as a come mail comes out, sign up for my website Google Douglas, Dean Johnson plus Mirador rd R. It is free. Your email address will not be used for any commercial purposes, and you can remove your name at any time. I recommend signing up for his list because then you get a notification when he publishes a new article.

We could see by the quality of his work here that he does great work. He closes this with saying some of the other material on that website provides case studies in why it is advisable to be cautious in these matters. And here is some of those original messages from Sean Kirkpatrick speaking to Christopher Mellon. And isn't an interesting that dark journalists sort of reported that Christopher Mellon is sort of the gatekeeper and puppet master of Sean Kirkpatrick, or excuse me of David Grush.

Let me say that again. Christopher Mellon is the gatekeeper or puppet master of David Grush, deciding who cannot who he can and cannot speak to. And now we see that in order to get information from Dave Grush you have to go through Christopher Mellon somehow, which doesn't make any sense. I don't understand any of this, but Christopher mellen was also some people would say the mouthpiece or handler for luel Azando for quite some time.

So it is an interesting. Same person that brought us the fake pentagona UFO program director is bringing us a fake whistleblower who can't show us any evidence, and he can't even show the proper investigating government authorities his evidence. Where he has office skis avoided, eluded, and done everything he could to avoid Erro. And I freely admit that there's a speculation on my part, but I truly believe that he's doing that because he knows that he doesn't have evidence that will stand up to scrutiny of a good investigator.

And it appears that the people at Arrow are decent at least investigators. They are investigating these claims that people are making as well they should. We're gonna take a moment here to recognize some kind and generous people have the right shirt on today. Praise the cash, Praise the cash.

UFO Shane gifts that one true seekers membership, and then another one, and then another one, see my friends. Thank you UFO Shane, well all the time show supporter a member himself, See my friends. And this is why you should smash that subscribe button For those unaware. When people gift memberships.

You can get a free membership just by being a subscriber. Apparently YouTube takes those free memberships, run some kind of random number generators and then distributes those free memberships to people on our channel who are subscribers but not yet YouTube channel members. And what do you get as a YouTube channel member? You get some extra goodies and also some YouTube extra goodies like that YouTube channel member badge, so people know you're a big supporter prior to reply in the messages and video comments and live chat and whatever else we could do for you.

We appreciate that. UFO, Shane, thank you very much for helping us to praise the cast. And we have also companies aired if you're a member for so many months, they give you a free sort of super chat. You could write a message, Steve, I wish you would then handle Ashton Forbes just the same way you do with Shrat.

I'm not sure I understand what that means. What. Yeah, let me know what you mean. I'm not sure I understand what that means.

You know, and I haven't said I wouldn't speak to him, but given the way that he just treated me in a live chat and talked to me like I was a dog or a piece of shit, you know, not feeling very very cordial or like inviting. Right. Definitely bring up the facts that Jason said. If you don't give back the alien biologics, we're all gonna die.

Yes, thank you and high Speed Chase. Look at that. Here's another reason to subscribe. There is now ten eleven, twelve thirteen free YouTube memberships for our channel here, So make sure, if you haven't already, please do hit that subscribe button if for no other reason you might get some free shit like a free membership.

Thank you high Speed Chase, he's the MVP of gifting these free memberships. We appreciate all of you. Boy wear I should wear the shirt every day. Apparently it's good luck to wear praise cash shirt because it helps you to Uh, yes it does, and yes, ufo Shane.

I certainly thank you High Speed Chase, m VP of of free memberships here. We appreciate you. Thanks for appreciating us, all of you kind and generous people. Uh, let me go to Jason Sands.

So many people have been asking me for an update on this other so called whistleblower who hasn't provided any evidence either that you know. People keep asking me for an update on this person, Jason Sands. I'm trying to find it. Mail UFO, Shane, if you're on Twitter, send me that.

Where Where did I put it? I put it here, somewhere. Let me look at my notifications right one second here? Yes, so Jason Sands has made some outrageous claims and I tweeted earlier.

Why can't I find it? Let me just bear with me one moment. Friends. We've got more from mister d Dean Johnson coming up, but let's get to the Jason Sands stuff.

Why is that? Yeah? I'm sure that I retweeted this earlier. Oh yeah, I faund it.

I failed it. Let me a High Speed Chase with another kind of generous ten dollars. Keep up the great work, brother, got music here on the way. I'll be in touch.

Good. I need a good guitar player. Thank you High Speed Chase for kindness, generosity, support, and of course we're helping us to praise the cat. Thank you High Speed Chase and all of you generous people.

We appreciate all of you. Companies. Eric, let me know in all capital letters what you meant by your comment. I don't know how you're expecting me to treat that person has been very kind to me, in fact, is accusing me of defamation or something.

No, the purpose of our stream and our show here is never to embarrass, humiliate, or whatever anyone, or certainly not defamations never are aimed here. It's to educate people, to give them the evidence and let people, you know, sort of make up their minds as to what they believe. Showing somebody that a hoaxed UFO video is fake is not defamation. And you know, I'm sorry, but somebody be foolish enough to try to sue me for defamation because I said a video was fake, then I'll just bring all the evidence from all the VFX artists that have said that video was fake to court with me, and any reasonable jury or judge would say, Okay, that's not defamation.

You were just showing people data and evidence. But it is what it is. You know what it is if you're some loser that nobody's ever paid attention to your whole life, and then you stumbled across the conspiracy theory that a lot of people like, and you've got on a lot of big podcasts, so you've built this huge following. You know, he's getting real mauthy lately, he's getting real bold, threatening to sue critics and sue debunkers for debunking the videos.

And it's it's it's something else. But let's get to Jason Sands before we get back to this other article by d Dean Johnson. I just wrote, if you didn't already think wack could do, start thinking wack could do. So this is Jason Sands.

Do you know something about twenty twenty seven? Jason Sanz says yes. The information I had was quite chilling for the program, folks, and will apparently take place in a time window that I heard was between twenty twenty five and twenty thirty five ish. While in mission, somebody says, can you explain what you mean?

While in mission, and Jason Sant says yes, I and three other analysts intercepted a phone conversation that mentioned the twenty twenty five to twenty thirty five timeframe. We were on a mission for the program at the time. And somebody says, what was chilling and what is happening between twenty twenty five and twenty thirty five time frame? Jason sand says, what was chilling was that if the program folks don't return the retrieval materials and biologics by the time above the response by the time above, the responsible parties would be put to death.

He's saying that if the government doesn't give back the alien spaceships and crash retrieval materials and the alien biologics, that the responsible parties will be murdered, put to death one fury. This explains the sudden controlled disclosure and NDAA clause some in the program may be aiming to avoid. Oh God. Jason sand says, yes, I still advocate for planned control disclosure.

There has to be a degree of amnesty for those who have made mistakes, and I informed Congress on a need for a discreet turnover process. I haven't continued to try to save as many people as possible. He's trying to save these people from getting murdered. They're going to get murdered, Jason Sands, you are correct, in my opinion.

It seems the program is going to come to an impossible impass. They come forward of their own accord, or they face judgment by the non human intelligences. One way or another, the lies will end they He says, they did not list names nor company names in the telecommunications. I did think the folks who are keeping the stolen tech and biologics are the ones at risk.

There are others in the program who are not involved in that part of the retrievals and are safe. And somebody says, when you refer to intercepting a phone call and the NHI stating about the time frame, who did you hear talking? What was their call? This was a call with non human intelligence on the line, yet et phone home.

He was listening to the phone calls and the aliens were telling the humans this was humans. I think you're going to have to clarify a little more about what and who you heard. It's probably important you clarify asap. And Jason sand says it was a conversation between a biologics person and another individual.

So there you have it. The new so called whistleblower, Jason Sands is essentially saying, listen, if these government bureaucrats don't give back to alien biologics and the spaceships, they're going to be murdered. I don't even know what to say say about this. Friends, What am I supposed to do with that.

So for all you people asking for an update, here's the update I have on Jason Sands. If you didn't already think WA could do, you better start thinking what I could do? You know, this is one of the problems I have with some of these people. It gets, it gets more and more grandiose.

Now there's a situation where he heard a conversation that aliens are going to kill people if they don't give the if they don't give the alien bodies and the alien spaceships that they recovered back somehow. And of course this comes from Vicky Verma, who posts the stupidest shit I have to say, but it is what it is. Yeah, I really don't know what else to say about Jason Sands, but people keep asking me for some sort of update on him, and all I can tell is that he's saying that if they don't give the alien crash retrieval materials and the bodies back to the aliens within ten years, the people responsible are going to be murdered. See, And this is one of those things like, there's a good story, right, but what is the evidence of that?

Oh, I heard a phone call once I was listening into phone calls. And by the way, I get that his job was to be some kind of telecommunications officer. Maybe, but is he supposed to be listening into intelligence community chatter on phone lines while people are speaking. Is that legal?

Can he legally survey and listen to private phone conversations that people are having? Does this make any sense? I mean, I'm not an intelligence guy. Maybe they do that.

I just don't. I I don't get it. I don't get it. And this is where his information is coming from.

I was eavesdropping on people that deal with the alien bodies and therefore the aliens or you know, I learned that the aliens are going to kill everybody that won't give the bodies back. Come on, man, it's getting a little deep. But here's what I will say. So many people have said, interview him, Steve.

I'll do it if I can get contact information for him. I have found him on Facebook, but I think you have to. I can send him a message, but it's going to be in his message requests, and given his age, you know, some of those older gentlemen don't know how to work Facebook. I doubt he'll get the message.

But if somebody has an email address for him, be sure to email it to me at Truth Seeker Show at gmail dot com. I will say this, given how many UFO celebrities are attacking that guy, I would speak to him just about that. Why are all of these other drifters coming out and saying that you're full of shit when they're clearly full of shit? You know, like, it doesn't make any sense.

I speak chased with another one too dollars Kanya Generes and says he can legally be a wookies banker. Absolutely, thank you for helping us praise cash all right, At the risk of taking too long here on the Grush story, we have a special guest tonight, which I can't tell you how happy I am. There's a woman named at Krishley and she has a YouTube channel called chrish Le Tv. You might see pinned in the live chat.

I pinned her YouTube channel in the live chat. I was so excited when I found this person because they are single handedly just destroying these fake MH three seventy videos. She's an incredibly talented v effects artist, an animator, you know, computer graphics person, and on her YouTube channel she is expertly just ripping apart those videos. As what they are fake, which is interesting.

Let's get to let's get to this next piece, which applies he kind of covered it in the first article, but I think this is an important enough issue that we should talk about it. I don't know what that's about. So mister D. Dean Johnson says, one of the burning questions of the day is whether the inspector General of the intelligence community actually is actively engaged in an investigation trying to find out if there exists a hidden program and possession of alien tech.

As I sketched in my May fourth long post the Clues Conflict. Sar Kirkpatrick is now on the record to me stating, to my knowledge, neither the ICIG or DODIG are separately investigated in those claims of a government orchestrated extraterrestrial or verse engineering program. Both the ic IG and DOODIG have been supporting Arrow insofar as whistleblower protections legally allow them. So you know, all of Brush's supporters are saying, oh, no, he gave the evidence.

It doesn't matter. He gave the evidence to somebody that's not investigating anything. He gave them evidence about waste fraud and abuse. That's what the ICIG and the DODIG are concerned with and investigating.

That's what they find urgent incredible. If somebody makes a claim of waste, fraud and abuse, they find every claim of waste broad and abuse urgent and credible, and they investigate those claims. But the claims that they're investigating his alien claims is completely and totally false. You've been lied to by the UFO, profiteering orse scumbags selling you this fake story, and by the man himself, mister Grush.

Mister Dean goes on to say, while David Grush has said he gave extensive interviews to the ICIG in twenty twenty two, I have not seen anywhere Grush saying that he knows that the ICIG actually continues to investigate the alien tech allegations. If he did say that within the past year, somebody please show me where he said it. This is distinct from an investigation of Gresh's complaint that he suffered illicit reprisals somehow connected with his inquiries. The ICIG referred to reprisal aspect to the Department of Defense IG Whistleblower Reprisal Investigations Directorate.

If Grush is not satisfied with the results of the reprisal investigation by that entity, Grush would still have the right to request that the ICIG convene an external review panel under PPD nineteen. By law, the ICIG would be one member of any such ERP. However, whether the ERP is the fact convened is solely within the discretion of the Intelligence Community Inspector General, over and above what Grush has said to the Intelligence Community Inspector General. Matter matter, if someone actually has solid evidence that the ICIG is actively invested mistigating hidden alien tech allegations, not in twenty twenty two, but let's say within the past year, I would love to see it, except if it is classified, in which case I do not want to see it.

And again, Sean Kirkpatrick, to my knowledge, neither the Intelligence Community Inspector General nor the Department of Defense Inspector General are separately investigating those claims of a government orchestrated extraterrestrial reverse engineering program that was and is ARROWS responsible as responsibility as covered by the Historical Review legislative language from NBA Fiscal year twenty three. Both the ICIG and d u D have been supporting Arrow insofar as whistleblower protections legally allowed them. So this is yet another of the dominoes that fall. This is a complete and total joke.

The Intelligence Community Inspector General is not now, nor have they ever, to my knowledge or anybody else, has been investigating Dave Grush's alien and UFO claims. So what we get with Dave Grush is a shell game where he continually they play games with words like the urgent, incredible lie that fell apart. Now everybody claiming that he gave the evidence, and the Intelligence Community Inspector General is investigating his alien claims. No they're not, No, they're not proved me wrong.

Yeah. So I'm excited about tonight because listen, I have been screaming into the void about these MHS three seventy videos for quite some time now, and what is incredibly shocking to me is that the promoters of the of these things. Yeah, I'm glad you're here. So Chrish Lee is here.

So the promoters of these videos, I'm going to ask our special guest tonight, who is a VFX artist and animator and expert in these matters. But we're up to like I've seen at least ten people either debunk or recreate these MH three seventy videos who would be considered experts in VFX in a court of law, people that have ten and twenty years experience in VFX look at these videos and say they're fake. And the promoters have done everything they could to try to get around these debunks, even up to and including threatening to sue people, destroy people, and more. And we'll show you some stuff on that, but for now, let me make sure I have the right thing here.

So I recently found this person's YouTube channel, and I can't tell you how happy I was, because I feel like I've been screaming into the void. And my problem is, though I have a background in computer science, I'm not a v effects expert. I've used after effects, I've used Blender. I'm a real big fan of Blender on Linux, but you know, I'm no expert.

I've made some crude animations. Sometimes you may see, you know, three D text of truth seekers. I make those, but I'm no expert in VFX. But what's so stunning to me is how many experts in VFX have come out and said these videos are fake and here's why.

And then promoters of this video and these false conspiracy theories. By the way, you know, it's kind of slimy because two hundred and thirty nine people died in that tragedy. I don't think they want people making money on the internet pushing fake UFO videos saying that their family members got teleported by aliens. But that's just me.

So this person's YouTube channel, it's chris Lee TV, is pinned at the top of the chat, at least I believe it is after check in on that. If it's not, we'll make it. So, so we're gonna welcome our guests, Chris Lee. Welcome, Chris Lee.

Hi. Can you hear me? Yeah? I can hear you.

Fine, Yeah, I'm so glad you're here. I just for those unaware, chrisally did a stream earlier that just sort of shows exactly she's showing. She's a virtual effects expert. She's doing a live stream that's several hours long, educating everybody, showing exactly how these videos were constructed from the stock effects.

And people are still in the live chat arguing no, it's a cover up and all these things. But before we get started, I'm curious myself. Can you just tell people like what, I know, you're a VFX expert. I can I've seen you live streams, But can you tell people about like your years of experience, your education and these things, how long you've worked in VFX, Because I think it's important that we got to say, look, Chrisly, if I have if I have a leaking pipe in my basement, I'm not a plumbing expert, right, I'm going to get an expert in plumbing and say, all right if you say, but somehow with these videos, even people that have decades of experienced people are still arguing with them that have no years of experience.

So tell us about your experience and education and VFX, just so we know you're qualified to render an expert opinion on these videos. Yes, absolutely so. I think I first got into art in general. I was in high school.

After I got out of high school and I went to UH University and I learned about three D I learned I think I was using three D S three three D S max max. Remember. After that, after I left school, I moved on to Blender. Since it's more open sources.

I don't have to pay for the you know, the subscription all that stuff. I started that program though it's so difficult to learn how to make it do anything. Yeah, I still I still work on it, but I am you know, like with most programs, I would say, yeah, so that you've learned three DX max and then Blender. Yeah.

And then after I think right around that time, I started getting to a photoshop and there there was another one that was feeling it's like baby Stages, which is clip Studio, which is more of an art program, but recently they have like more three D capabilities. After I left school, I went into teaching and I started teaching in a school in my city. I started teaching three D. I started teaching.

It was more like a general we kept changing the subjects, but we did game design three D. We did. That's a great thing to get kids excited about and teach them. Yeah, they were really engaged.

We made some great games. Actually, my son is ate and obsessed with games. He would love that. He's Minecraft guy now.

But now he's getting into video game designer programs and he's like, I'm going to make my own. I'm like, you go do it. You know, if you want to get into this, this industry right now is the best time, Like the barrier of entry is very low. They're making it a lot more accessible these days for regular people, like you know, people who don't have the background to get into it, I think.

And after COVID happened, not to leave the school, so we kind of dropped that and I went into business for myself. I started reaching out to a lot of music artists. I did a couple of music videos animations seeing your demo reel, which was incredibly impressive to me. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I'll do that while we're talking so people can see some of your work.

If you don't mind, you have one of your demo. Yeah, And that's about the time in doing so far. I was with the studio previously, but I left there and I'm doing things a little bit more independently now and most of my work right now currently is corporate. But once I saw these videos pop up, I was like, no, I gotta I need to involve myself in this and kind of show the obvious VFX elements in it because I feel like people are being really misled with this.

Yeah, that's a big understatement. If you ask me, and I wanted to ask you if you were aware you know a lot of a lot of what I do here is that we sort of peel back some of the layers of deception people use to deceive and profit from some of these things. One of the things that really bothered me is that when the first few virtual the first few VFX people or computer graphics people that looked at these and did a video or said these are fake and here's why. Suddenly on Reddit there came these anonymous posters who claimed that they were like the head of Marvel VFX or the head VFX person on top Gun Maverick, and that these videos could not be faked.

You know, there's this It felt like there was this active disinformation campaign being put against the people who were the real experts. It's like, okay, we have an on the record source in the form of quarteror crew. Regardless of what you think, there's three or four guys that will be considered experts in this field. They looked at the videos and said these are fake and here's why.

And the retort or the rebuttal is no, no, an anonymous Reddit poster they're the virtual you know, the VFS head for all Marvel Studios said that those guys are wrong, and it's kind of childish and ridiculous that somebody would go to those lanth like do we not stop the thing? What's that person's name? And by the way, I made a bunch of phone calls and I couldn't get to either of those real people to find out. But I believe other people have and they don't.

They didn't make those posts. So people are using fake evidence to prop up the fake video after experts like you rip them part? Doesn't that say something about their validity? And you know, I don't, I don't.

It's it's a very I think that. The other thing about this that is just so interesting to me is the ability for people to look at something and see something completely different. I'm not because it's one thing for somebody just say something, but if someone will come out and show you what's being done and you can still say no, you're you're lying to me, then I feel like that's that is It's beyond beligan. It's kind of like, yeah, by the way, I want to I want to compliment you, because sometimes things get very personal here in our live chat and people argue and uh.

One of the things that seems to be a real problem is like, let's take for example, for those unaware, the person who took the pictures that were used to create the background came forward and said I took those pictures. He even showed like his passport, the plane TICNT re spipts, and he provided raw files which have all of the time date stamp information proving he took them long before the videos were mede And people are in your live chat saying, oh, he's part of the cover up or somebody paid him, and you refuse to accept that. And I like that stance to just say, if you don't have evidence, don't impugne that person's credibility. He has no reason to lie.

And you guys are, in other words, to try to disprove the debunks. People are basically calling people liars and scammers, which is wrong, just just straight out just calling people liars scammers. What else do they call them fakers? Frauds?

And the problem with that, it's a huge problem, especially for the poor photographer. There's one person who has been I can probably link it to you, uh elsewhere, but if you go to his profile and just search the name of photographer, there will be pages and pages and pages worth of tweets from this person just calling him out, just and not even harassing him. Yeah, that's how they try to silence the critics so that the grift can continue. You know, you're screwing up the grifts, so they try to just shut you up and silence you.

And you've been threatened and yeah, yeah, and just for showing the effects, Like that's that's how serious this is becoming. It it's let me just make sure my audience understands, like, unlike me, who I start calling people cocksuckers and yelling and screaming about scammers and grifters and and you know, her streams are so professional. She just like show like matter of fact, like here's this asset, here's how this asset was used to create the teleport effect. It's it's and you're very matter of fact about it.

You're not getting personal like I tend to like. You know, her streams are amazing, and she's not allowing people to disparage the truthful people coming forward that show. Hey, you know these are fake videos and here's why. Like, it's so insane to me for people unaware we have they found the explosion effect or the teleporting effect.

It was on a website since two thousand and nine and asset site. We have the guy who took the pictures that were used to create the background image of these fake videos, who came forward with all the evidence in proof that prove he took the pictures, and people are still arguing. People are still arguing that the videos can't be vaked. And one of the other things I wanted to compliment you on is I'm sure and if I get this wrong, he's free to correct me.

But Ashton said something, excuse me. The promoters of this thing said, yeah, we decided we're not gonna get you know, We're gonna just just try to stick to the data tonight and not the people. So one of the major promoter of these fake videos has on the record said something like these videos could not be reproduced unless somebody had a whole team of experts and I don't know if it was tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of dollars and you know, unlimited resources or something like that. He said, they couldn't be reproduced.

And I just want to compliment you, Chris Lely, because you're one person and in hours on your live streams, you're recreating every aspect of this by yourself, which means he was wrong about that. They can be it's not even enough. It's not enough. You don't know how many comments and messages that I've been receiving like why aren't you doing it?

Start to finish them? Why can't you recreate it? Point by point? But Ken has already made a shot for shot recreation of one of the videos, and when he that, they said, you just copied the video, and I'm just like, so, there's no there's no satisfying and and then that's that's the trap here.

You can you can put I can put as many hours into this as I want to, but there will always be people who will look at that and say it's not enough. But I think the only answer to that is, honestly, just continuing to put out the truth. And you can't. You can't come to me and demand me to make anything.

I'm not going to do that. I'll show you that done. I'm not gonna I'm not going to they do make demands, they go, well, show me that the that the stills were on that site before the video was made, and then you show them that they want something else that fell into that trap. Chrisly, there's something called Brandolini's law.

Are you familiar with that something? There's something called Brandolini's law, and I fight that all the time with some of these hoaxers. Brandelini's law essentially says that the amount of energy required to dispel bullshit is orders of magnitude more than it takes to create. And I feel that you supply here because look at how many hours you've put into this, and you're just one of the VFX people that have done that.

There's ten VFX people. If we can't corn cruit, there are three or four people. I've seen four or five others. And then you look at all that energy that everybody has to expend.

This is beautiful work, by the way. I love it. The amount of energy that these people require you to expend to dispel their bullshit is truly orders of magnitude more, you know. And then meanwhile, the promoter can just say the videos are real.

You're destroying your reputation. I'm going to sue you. You know, it's ridiculous. The suing aspect is really interesting to me.

I'm sorry, if you can hear this background noise, the suing aspect, what's standing is there for me to be sued. That's my question. I know you're going to be sued because you show people that these are the effects. This this video is the effects and it's not a real video.

It doesn't make any sense. I think. I think maybe some of the griff squads getting desperate, trying to keep the grift going as more and more I'm going to try to collect them up Chrishly, all of the debunks, yeah, and make a video and say, you know, no offense to the promoters of these fake videos, But how are you going to argue with all of these industry experts, you know, look at Chrishly's work here. I'm not thinking to you, but provide no evidence to back up your argument.

Not a single person has put forward any visual, tangible evidence that anything that what I'm saying is false. Not a single person. And then, and I gotta tell you, I was very impressed with how you stood up for yourself in your chat and said, if you're gonna say Chrishly was great. She said, if you're gonna say that that photographer is a scammer, show evidence of that.

I'm not allowed on that in my live chat. You're not gonna damage his reputation. You know, you really stood up for him, which I was happy to see because that guy didn't do anything wrong. He's trying to educate people.

Yeah, it's awful. It's so awful I can't just to think about. And while we're talking, I'm going to share your latest video just so people get a sense of what you do on your channel. And I checked and this video is pinned in the in the live chat, So if you're watching or listening, please go to the pinned video and make sure that you subscribe because this I think Chrisly is doing a community service here, which is something that we feel strongly about.

We make some free documentaries to try to educate people on hoaxes and hoaxers, and we try to help educate people, and Chrisly is doing the same kind of thing over there, but from a perspective of like, here's how the videos were created. I'm gonna just mute it if you don't mind. Just want to give people a look. And this is a and by the way, Chris Ly is also in there doing a Q and A.

You can ask chris Lely any question while she's showing you exactly how these videos were faked, and she'll answer I thought it was so great your stream earlier. I'm glad that I wasn't going to reach out to you because I don't know you. I'm like, I'll just ask her if just do a great work, just ask her to come and explain this to us. So here you're explaining how the teleport effect was made, right, Yes, yes, I am yeah, yeah.

Can you talk a little bit about how this teleport effect is made and talk about the arguments that it doesn't match pixel for pixel with the asset and how it's so stupid because I know, just as an amateur sort of digital artist that you know, artists, they put filters on things, they stretch things, they bend them. So for somebody to make this argument that that asset does not match one hundred pixel for pixel, isn't that a stupid argument from the perspective, not just it's not just a it's a it's not just an irrelevant argument, but the fact that we're trying to also match this to a super low resolution video at the same time, like it's gone through so much compression after converting, and you know, all these all these different things that all these different processes that it has to go to go through. It's of course it's not going to be one hundred percent pixel for pixel match, but if we can prove that it matches at least with a ninety percent degree of certainty, then it's it's there's not really any there's nothing up to debate here. It's clearly the same silhouette.

So what I'm doing, sorry, what I'm doing here is I'm modifying the silhouette. So it took the color information from the original shockwave asset, and it's just using that color information to create a mask. And it's it's just that's literally what it's doing, refining the silhouette, using those colors to inform how that civillette is. And then after that, all you have to do is stretch it to fit.

And that's it. And you know, it's funny. Someone also just pointed this out to me. I didn't realize this, but the the shockwave asset is apparently stretched the exact same way that the clouds are, meaning that there was some maybe some I don't know, overall transformation that happened to the entire image and it was all stretched in the same way, which means, yeah, it's a typical that an artist would use the same stretch style on multiple objects in one project, I would think, right, more like they they may have stretched it at the same time or the same way.

Okay, well, yeah, that kind of makes sense, especially if it's one guy making the whole video right exactly. And then that that's the other thing too, that comes up, like someone would need mega equipment, Like my computer is not amazing, Like my my graphics card is over is almost I think it's six or seven years old at this point. My best video card is just a ten yeah, yeah, you know, I mean my best video card is like a ten eighty, which is years old at this point. You know, it doesn't take crazy simulations and three just be a longer render time if you had a crappier video card though, really, right, can you repeat that?

I didn't hear you. In other words, if you had if you didn't have the latest, greatest video card, like let's say you had one from twenty fourteen, it would just take longer to render the scene, right, literally, That's it. That's that's the only Yeah. So some arguments have been made that this couldn't have been done in twenty fourteen.

How do you feel about that argument? I mean, well, already I just said that even my my CPU EXAMPT for example, has is probably older than twenty fourteen. So I don't think it's not like it's not a good argument to make. I don't think I get by I fixed computers, so I get by with I call it opt other people's trash, you know, like I have a upgrades.

I got a bunch of Intel Imax here because everybody's upgrading them now, and I just buy on opt other people's trash. I don't need to buy anything. I'll just you know, on network four of them if I need to, right, And it's also just kind of disregarding the fact that they probably had a really good computer. I mean, that's not really it doesn't really come into the conversation when we can reproduce it.

And another thing that people bring up is, oh, you're using a more modern version of the software, but that's Adobe doesn't really I know that they release like yearly updates, but they don't really don't change much Like, they don't really change anything. Every tool that I'm using was available unchanged as it was in twenty fourteen. I think that's something really important to point out too, because it's nothing that should they'll try to throw at you, but it's not. It's it can't come into It doesn't come into the conversation at all.

I wanted to get into if you don't mind too. When this video first resurfaced, I did a quick video and said that the cloud static, that it's and what I said, having observed there's a hoax UFO channel called Third Phase of Moon, I did a whole documentary on them, and a method that they used constantly was to use a static background image and then superimpose an animated UFO over it. And having seen hundreds of those from this hoax UFO channel and busted a bunch of them, I instantly said, this is a static background image that's like, you know, not moving, and they superimposed this animated scene of these orbs and this plane over top. But now that people are arguing if clouds are moving, and on closer examination, they do seem to have a tiny bit of motion.

But I credit that to compression from a codec. In other words, when you change when you render it to MPG or MP four or whatever you're going to render it to, there's compression codex that squeeze the file down and that that can cause a slight bit of motion in what is a static image. Do you think that's what's happening here or was there something I do? Yes, I so later on, later on in the stream, I definitely we talked about it because it's Yeah, I remember you addressed it towards towards the end.

I'll see if we can. Yeah, you have the clouds. Yeah, and you you also have to speed up the video to even see that movement. Yeah, you have to speed up to Boudicris speed.

Do you remember that from Spaceball? It's like they have, to the benefit of my audience. To see any movement whatsoever in these clouds, you have to move it to like sixteen hundred times it's normal speed. So they're being dishonest when they say no, no, the clouds move, and there's a tiny bit of movement.

The other problem that I have that I pointed out in your live chat, and I think you agreed with me, is that the air plane goes right up to the side of some of these clouds, even appearing to go through the clouds, but the clouds don't react to the jet wash. I showed this to a jet pilot and he took one look at it and he said, that's not real clouds. The jetwash from a plane that big would blow those clouds all over the place if it flew that close to them. Or so that's another argument why these are static images, besides the fact for my audience's benefit if they're unaware, the person that took the pictures of the clouds that were taking off of textures dot com website has come forward shows plane ticket and said those are my images.

Here's the raw files those want to argue it's amazing, there's a there's a jet floating around too. Of like someone took the photos that he took in the and you know, released and they lined up because you can see Malfuji in the background of some of the photos. They lined up a series of them and you can see the trajectory of the plane, like I'm guessing the plane was taking a turn to land at the airport and you can kind of see that progression as Mount Fuji kind of changes perspective through the photos. Like that's there's so many data points that lead up to this being legitimate that it boggles my mind that people are still trying to say that this is a cover up.

Sometimes things are not a conspiracy, and it's okay, you don't have to find like deeper conspiracy. Sometimes things are just what they are. And I think that sometimes people have a really hard time accepting that. Yeah, yeah, I'm just still blown away that so many VFS experts have come forward and offered their expert opinion these videos are fake and here's why.

And by the way, I think there's a certain consensus. You know, there's some slight differences of opinion, but you know the fact that the image the background was made from a static image. All the VFX experts that I've looked at that have looked at this said yeah, that's a static image, and here's the source of it. And the same for the for the teleporting effect.

It's this stock asset that's been around since two thousand and nine. Here it is the fact that, so, you know, there's just so many VFX experts that are all saying these videos are fake, and here's why. It's just it's mind blowing to me that that somebody with no v effects experience whatsoever is going to argue with all these experts. Isn't that kind of like disrespectful to those experts.

I would think so it is, and it's another reason why I'm so involved in this. It feels like a insult to this community, this industry, this line of work when and not just that, but there's also like the accusation like v EFFX artists would never be this detailed. This is literally our job, and not that this video has, you know, an insane amount of detail. It's literally just a plane pomped over a bunch of photos sticks together, but just the idea that someone can't have this creativity to make this from their imagination.

It's it's not just insulting to VFX experts, it's it's insulting to humanity in general. We are really creative species, like we're someone will would do this like have you. It makes me feel like people who say stuff like this having gone to movies. They haven't seen the Avengers, they haven't seen Avatar, they haven't seen any of these movies where all these fantastical things are happening on the screen.

Those things didn't happen in different universe like the VFX artists made those a VFX artists made this. It's it's really not a stretch. And the fact that people are still arguing this. It's it's so discouraging, honestly, but I think that's that is to keep speaking about it and keep showing no.

I agree, And I admire your courage because you know that you're going to be target. You already a target, aren't you. Yes, I'm a public target people. But I think that their strength in numbers.

I hope that more VFX artists will come out about this. I feel like the more out and start being more vocal about this than the quicker, this will just yeah. And here's here's a I'm gonna I'm gonna share part of that situation. Quick note to the debunkers who are hiding here reminder, I've given the evidence and Edward Lynn to the ERA who can verify he's the guy who leaked the videos.

For those are a where Edward Lynn was arrested before the videos were released for he got in trouble for the charges don't line up. The fact that this promoter of these fake videos is just I call it research by proclamation, you know, like he didn't speak to Edward Lynn. He got no confirmation from Edward Lynn that he leaked the videos. He just found some dots.

He could connect and claim that. But anyway, uh, people have without me asking send me your real names and other personal info. You were attempting to debunk real videos and covering up a major conspiracy where two hundred and thirty nine people were kidnapped the government. And it won't take the blame that people who will be vilified and have their lives ruined are the debunkers.

You. I get that you're mad, especially you christ Lee, but you're literally digging your own grave in a no win situation. The mhe three seventy videos are real, and the longer it takes you to accept this, the worst things we'll get for you. Just accept the consequences.

And then this person says, I'm sadly going to destroy christ Lee, which I take no pleasure in, but she brought it upon herself. Thankfully, she proved beyond any doubt that the debunks are fake for us and fear at the very points Mick West graudulately made. And by the way, for those un aware, Mick West is another person who would probably be considered an expert in computer graphics and the effects in a court of law that also declared the video is fake. And here's why But he didn't want to waste a lot of time on them, so he just did, you know, like a couple of quick pieces on why they're fake.

Right, there's another expert. Yeah, so another thing that comes up. They accused me of being like in league with Mickwell, I've never spoken to him before. I didn't know about him before any of this came up.

I'm not I'm not really involved in the drama that's been going on the video. How you can make the clouds move a little bit with some kind of filter or effect, Right, it's trivial to do it if you really wanted to. It's not my opinion that that was done, but if that was the case, then that would be how you do it. But yeah, so I've been like accused of being like in league with micwst too in like this big, this big conspiracy to bring down the videos like it's it's I mean, we we Just because there are multiple people saying that this is fake does not mean that they're all working together.

It means if the video is fake. Yeah, you would think a reasonable person would just conclude that if if so many the effects experts are all saying these videos are fake, then you know, maybe they're fake. Maybe there's no huge conspiracy here and somebody just made these videos. I did notice in your live chat back to Brandolini's law, You're right, all these people that think the videos can't be fake demand Christley that you do this or demand that you do that.

And I was kind of impressed that You're like, I'm I'm an expert at the effects. I'm showing you what I can show you. I'm not taking request or demands. You know.

I think it's good to push back. Yeah, you're pushing back and saying like, no, I'm not doing that, Like, you know, there's always some argument to be made too, you know, like oh, first, you know, people were arguing like, oh, first people said the clouds didn't move. Now they say they move, Well, they move if you speed up to sixteen hundred times of speed. Forget the clouds movement in the In the videos, you can see in the background that there's clearly water, right, I'm not sure if I if you can really see in this part of the video, but there's like these little wife flecks in the background that are like very obvious wavecrests.

Regardless of the clouds, wouldn't the water be moving at least, wouldn't you see some progression of those waves? It doesn't. It's a still photo. Yeah.

Here the plane flies right by a cloud and there's no movement of the clouds that it's flying right by and through. Which now they just say that it's at a different elevation or something. Yeah, they give excuses, they give the obvious excuses that it just it just blows my mind that anybody, you know. And by the way, the promoter of this once conceded that the videos were fake and then changed his mind.

I think he looked at his YouTube check every month and decided he couldn't let it go yet, right or something, you know. And my challenge to that person is kind of like, if this isn't about money or fame, then turn your monetization off and give back all the money you made promoting these videos. Is real and it's only fair if it's not about money, you know. I just really want people to I hope that we can create a more open community.

Maybe maybe that's not the right word, but I just really want people to do not just their homework, but learn about some of the things that are being talked about. Don't just take my word for it. Go do some study in photography, learn about camera raw, learn about what else is there compositing, Learn about these things before jumping on people and making these baseless accusations. Because it doesn't it's it's toxic.

And you're you complain about this people not being taken this investigation seriously when we're we're we're spending so much time in this petty drama, Like it's so unreal to me, it's it feels childish, and we could be doing we could be doing so much better her with your time right now. Yeah, no, I agree. Learn learn about this stuff. Learn learn about it.

You learned from me, like, learn about it from somewhere else, but just just do some studying on it. First, I was I was very happy. Uh, don't take this the wrong way, you know, uh, but I was very happy to find out that you were a woman and was standing up to this promoter of this garbage because he's been very nasty to another woman who also kind of debunked the videos crudely, so, you know, like misogynistically. So and I don't really like that word, but in this case, it fits, like and I was so I was so proud of you in that live chatter earlier, because you were kind of standing up to the to the bs and the people making demands of your time and the people disparaging other people or calling them scammers.

You kind of said, hey, not in my live chat, and no, one'm not. I'm not capitulating to your demands. I'm showing you what I'm gonna show you. And you know I was.

I was happy to see that, And kudos to you for standing up to this and and sort of like giving some pushback. And honestly, I think the more people like you, chris Ley, that are actual experts and VFX that can come together and form a consensus that these videos are fake, you know, the better I mean. But I still wonder like we're up to like ten at least VAFX experts that all say the videos are fake at least. But I wonder like if there was a hundred, would he give it up?

I don't give it up. And what do you think he's gonna do if they find the plane. I don't think he'll give it up. He'll start new conspiracy theories.

That's not the real plane. They fake the wreckage, right, of course, I mean, that's that's the problem with these kinds of movements is that they feel per secuted by not just the government, but there's like a big boogeyman that they're all kind of running from or feel that they're being pursued by, and that makes them look through everything, look at everything through that lens and I conspiracy, yeah, basically, and that kind of I can understand that mindset, and it can be difficult to break out of because the it's kind of like self retaining almost. It's like if someone comes up to you and tells you it's fake, they're lying to you, they're trying to fool you, and you don't want to be fooled, so of course you'll you'll be resistant to that. So yeah, but the gymnastics, the amount of mental gymnastics crucially that you have to do to still believe these videos are real.

I mean, the person that took the pictures would have to be alling CIA agent or some something, right. The person that found the explosion effects, he's in on it. Everybody's in on it. The person that released the videos originally I guess I don't know, you know.

And another part assumption that needs to be made for this to check out there's There's another thing that everybody's missing is that the channel that this video originated on was filled with fake UFO videos that were cgi the effects. So shouldn't that be relevant that it came from a site? No, the story, the story there is that they released it there because no one would look for it there, or something like that, or once we get there so that most people more people can see it, or whatever. The it's just it's just always an excuse.

There's no there's no stopping it. And what I say, I mean, what I think is that there may be people that we can't reach, and I don't think that we Yeah, I'm big on that too, like we could save the ones we can, but some people no matter how much evidence that we show them. And we've done some excellent sort of debunking work. But I a would say, I'm not a debunker.

I'm a truth seeker. I go into it, I evaluate the evidence, and if it's debunked, it's not my fault. I just I filed the evidence. So you know, call me where you're gonna call me.

But but you're a debunker now, Chryst Lee, and you're gonna have word. It's so dumb. It's something, but in this community, it's so stigmatized. It's crazy.

It's really crazy. Like you, it carries so much weight now that it's I don't, I don't. I hate I hate being associated with it. And what all I'm doing is just showing what's going on.

I'm replicating it on screen so that people can't just you know, they can't just say, okay, are you just saying that you have no source? Here's a source. Here are the source files. Oh yeah, by the way, everybody, She gives everybody all the sources of everything she's using to recreate these videos.

And despite the promoters of these fake videos claiming they couldn't be reproduced in just hours using after effects and admittedly too old computer to this work, chrisly is showing exactly how one person with how many hours do you think it would take to recreate this if you went from scratch, you know, if you had the assets and you just started eight am in the morning, Like and we're if we're talking, so let's look, I don't I need to want to I want to identify, Like are we talking about recreating and like reverse engineering it and recreating it or just making it up from your head, making it up from your head, let's say, because that's a little more difficult, probably less than a day if you start at eight am, lesson a day. And meanwhile, the promoters of this that it would take I don't remember, he can correct if they can correct me six months or a year, or you need a whole people, ten hundreds of thousands, if you if you exactly exactly, if you consider how quickly it is just to put the mask on this, that took what less than I think it was less than three minutes in total just to create this maths less than three minutes to create that. And this is this is on screen for one frame, one frame. Maybe stitching the photos to thegether will probably take maybe thirty minutes to an hour.

And then the the drone movement, it's just a plane. It's a plane on a path going around. That's it. It's not it's not rocket science.

It's not difficult at all. And could you also talk for a minute about the orbs, And isn't it true that there is a mathematical formula to their movement which also sort of proves its the effects because these three objects could not possibly be moving that synchronized at the same rate and everything, and you know, I there's probably excuse me, there's probably some math involved in terms of how after effects does the the animation, but I think I talked about it on this stream as well. It's it's just three three orbs parented to like a knull and then the null is like rotating. It's it's it's it's procedural in a sense, but it you just tell after effects to rotate on a certain axis and then you parent that to something else.

If you want to parent it to the plane, for example, then it will follow the plane wherever the plane goes. And it's it's just simple as that. You animate it, you parent it to another object, and that's it. There you have it.

There's no there's nothing complicated about it. And I think maybe they saw that they were synchronized sort of. But it's it's just it's just three orbs on like a ring and then the ring is rotating. Yeah, but but it's rotating at a standard or steady rate.

It's not it's you know, there, if it was real objects, there would be more variation in the rotation, right, yeah, nature would be or probably more natural movement. But we're also kind of looking at a like this is also this is this is a six frame I think it's six frames per second, so there's only movement in every six frames too. So you can't you can't really, I feel like you can't look at this clip and then you know, extrapolate some kind of fantastical whatever whatever is it that the argument is at how these orbs are moving. There's not enough information to even grasp something like that.

Yeah, and Rick Brooks asks Ditton, a retick guy, identify stock cloud footage you use? Yeah, but better than that. Not only did I the day identify the stock images used to create the clouds, but the person who actually took the pictures that were used to create that that were sold to For those that are aware, there's stock image websites where you can go and search like clouds, and he was a contributor to some of those sites. They pay people to give them images of clouds.

And the guy who took the pic Brooks came forward, gave the raw files proving that they were created before this video. And also he had like a passport and a plane ticket receipt. Uh. That's you know, it's like over it's so overwhelming that these are fake and how they were faked that the fact that anybody is still arguing, you know, I don't, it's fascinating to me.

Yeah, it's like watching It's like watching a cult like in real time. And there's also a lot of you know, prusually there's a lot of cult like aspects to this, which is something a cult does is control the flow of information. And certainly the promoters of this are actively trying to stop people from seeing work like yours or Quarter Crew. Anybody that goes against the narrative they're pushing is suddenly the devil, like yeah, someone even I even got a there's someone out there.

I'm not sure what they use the name is, but they have been trying to get people on that side to report my account for harassment and incitement of harassment. I'm not harassing anyone. Who am I harassing by showing people how these videos are made? And if they're trying to get my Twitter taken down like all kinds of crazy, that is crazy.

And I don't know if you're aware of this, but there are lists of debunkers and yeah to yeah, and I have something that I could share about that. There are lists of people this person, Grinder Browning says, Hey, guys, your accounts are currently being targeted for harassment by this account. I reported the account to incitement and targeted harassment. Take whatever precautions you feel necessary.

And here's some of the people that are Christly you're on that list. And you know who else? Fires of Truth. This is Spooky who does graphics and used to help with my show.

Here is a big friend of the shop, a chat remoderator here is on that list. And I Spooky, what did you do to get on this list? And Spooky said the I think the picture right there at the bottom it shows the account that if you can click on it or not. No, this is one screenshot the count right there, the one the forty two something something.

That is a person who's been telling people to report my account for harassment. And that's their that's their block list they have they having walked. I've never spoken. I don't think I spoke with this person before ever.

I can find another way to share that. I apologize. I just have to put it in an image viewer and share it that way. One second, I'll do it from there.

Yeah, it's it's insane to me. It's this is cult like behavior. Like these people are going against the cult of the fake m makes three seventy. We got to get them.

And we've seen this in multiple other hoaxing events and and other things. You know, they use these cult like tactics, which is disturbing that they would go that far to try to harass people. And let's be clear, Chrystley, they're trying to harass you to just say, you know what, this isn't worth it and just shut up and move on. That's what they're trying anyway, you know they're trying.

They're not going to succeed. And if for any reason, any of my accounts get taken down, you know why? Now you know why? Yeah, but I won't be gone.

I won't be gone long if that happens, I'll be back. Yeah. I cannot. I cannot believe that some of this stuff that happens.

I'm going to share that again so we could see the account at forty two. It's the secret report these malicious accounts under excess guidelines prohibiting incitement of harassment. You'll find most of their accounts here. How are you harassing people?

Christ Ley? How is spooky harassing anybody, Spooky, I asked, Spooky, I'm like, what did you do? He said, I asked some questions. Apparently asking questions is now incitement or harassment?

And uh, yeah, we know that this is This is a socc account of the major promoter of these fake videos, who is making, by some reports, a lot of money pushing this this fake nonsense. You know, just ridiculous that they would go that far, like, hey, let's let's let's get their Twitter accounts taken down so they can't keep sharing the debunks on Twitter. Sure, if your evidence that this that these that these videos are real, is so strong, you should be able to stand with with stand debate right exactly exactly, But not a nobody has come forward with any hard proof showing that these are that these are real. And I think that even just letting that come into the conversation is center bite, says I'm on page too.

I'm so proud DS welcome senting by Yes. And like I said, to everybody, listen, do me a favor and go and subscribe to christ Lee's channel. We got a couple hundred people watching. If half of you went over there, listen, we have to support the people that are telling us the truth and you know, doing good work.

She's using science and showing with computer science how these things are created and educating people about how fake these videos are and suffering consequences. But there should be some benefit to doing good work for the community, and one of those benefits should be get some subscribers and have more people share her videos on their social media. That certainly helps as well. But pinned in the description of the video is a link to her latest video and just go to her channel and click the subscribe button.

I really think that she's doing excellent work. You're going to keep going on some of this you had enough, I'm not gonna stop. I think that really, And I would say if you are in this business, if you're a VFX artist, if you're any kind of artists and have experience with this, please come forward, Please share your expertise. I feel like the opposite side of this discourse has been kind of low, and the more of us that kind of share, you know, our knowledge about this, the stronger that the truth will become.

Because right now there's a lot of lying going on. It's very loud and yeah, we can see the deception used like I said, all these deep bunks came out from the quarter crew. And then all of a sudden, there's anonymous posters on Reddit that claim to be Marvel, the head of Marvel VFX Studios or the lead VFX person on Top Gun Maverick, who both say these videos can't be fake. And the promoter of this puts this in his slides like, this is my proof that the videos are real.

Marvel Virtual the effects said, these videos are real, But what where is that one? The record comment? Give me his phone number? Right?

No one can produce these people. It's so it's so interesting. No one can produce these people. I think they said it was Jeffrey Ford.

Get Jeffrey Ford on the phone. Where is he? Where is his statement? And then there's the other the other person that they always called I think is the person who was on top Gun.

I'm not sure if that source that came from somebody saying yeah, I think this person said that wasn't even I don't even think that one was a written comment. Yeah, yes, yes. And we want to thank artists and Tony who says, thanks Christley for your work, thank you for your kindness, generosity and support, and you don't know this, Christy, but what we do here every thank you artist and Tony and also I think there was one other one that I missed. The UFO Shane gifted one tree Seekers membership, which is why you should subscribe.

You can get a free membership. YouTube gives them out randomly to anybody who's a subscriber but not yet a member. So thank you UFO Shane for also helping us too. Yeah yeah, so listen, I'm not sure you've been doing these streams that are like pretty intense.

Do you have Can you tell us what do you have planned next for going after these videos? Because I get wait to see the next one. Well, there have been a couple of people who reached out to me to give statements I guess about the VFX, so that will most of those will be happening this week. As I get those details, I can share them.

Aside from that, I'll keep continuing to answer questions about this. I kind of want to go through everything. So I started with the satellite video. I did kind of touch on some aspects of the other one.

But after that, you're going to do the thermal thermal one? Yeah, you do that one? Oh good? So The good news is, friends, that there are people promoting these videos as real that have no evidence they're actually real.

But the good news is that there's people like Chryst Lee and others out there now. And here you're showing how the orbs worked, right, Yeah, someone asked me how the how there was like a heat signature on one side, So I showed how you can do that. I showed how you do like motion blur to kind of have them you can kind of even kind of blur out, was it, you know, the quicker they move, Just showing like all these things are all these things are reproducible. I'm a little confused just looking at your interface here, But I'm no animator.

The best that I was getting really good at three D titling and stuff, but then the software I was using to do that got a little too old now, so I have to find something to do that with. I'm upscaling like seven to twenty video to ten ADP doesn't work that way, or four K it doesn't work too good. Yeah, this is interesting though, that you have such an expertise, And thank you so much for you know, sharing your knowledge so that people can be educated and how these things can be faked and created. I'm happy.

I'm happy to I'm really happy to share. I feel like my my real passion is teaching rather than the effects. And prior to this, I did have a couple of like instructional videos on my channel. I think it's just like in the video.

I had some, but I didn't really continue because I feel like there wasn't really getting too much. But I think that if you know, once this is done, I would definitely probably go back to making that knowledge accessible to other subjects. If you want to learn leunder or after effects or whatever, I'd be happy to keep teaching. Wow.

Yeah, I need all the help I can get me. So yeah, I've been using blenders since. I can't even tell you, like I was an early adopter because I'm a Linux guy and it was Linux first, right and so, but I just don't have time. I wish I did, but I wish I had more time to play with things like this, Christy.

But you know, life gets away time consuming. I guess if you don't know what you're doing, so it takes you ten times longer than somebody like you, you know, to make something right. Yeah, Brett Clark is asking do you teach blender? You said you're gonna be doing some tutorials on your channel.

Yeah. I have a couple of tutorials on my on my channel already. I think I have one about animating jellyfish. I have another one where I have like a little juice box animation, so kind of simple.

But I would totally be down to teach blender if people want to. If people want to learn about that, excellent. Well. I want to thank you for taking the time to join us tonight and encourage everybody to go over your channel and subscribe.

I can't wait to see the next live stream about this because listen to you don't know the buzz because maybe you're not like a You're not like a UFO person, right, You're not into UFOs and aliens too much. I'm not a what. Sorry, I had to turn your volume down so it's not like giving feedback, can you. I said, you may be like very connected to the UFO and alien and UFO Twitter scene, but when you started making these videos, I'm telling you, it must have been like twenty people sent me your videos and we're just like, oh my god, this girl is wrecking these fake videos you got to see this, Steven.

So it's nice to connect to you, and I'm glad you're out there. That's all I can tell. I really really, really really want to expand the conversation on this and include different opinions. I really feel like one size has been extremely vocal and there hasn't really been too much of a too much of a pushback.

So yeah, if we can get more people on this, let's do it. Yeah. Well, thank you for joining us. I appreciate you being here.

I'm going to throw you out and do a quick wrap up here. Thanks so much for everything that you're doing. I'm so glad that I was so glad to see that you're out there doing this because we need somebody like you that is a real expert in these things to say, hey, here's the real deal, that the information that they're not giving you. You know, thank you for giving me the chance to be here.

Yeah, my pleasure. You have a good evening, you too, all right? Thank you? All right?

Friends, boy, what this girl is awesome? And I had a few more things to share, but christ Lee is very you know, she wanted to talk about the data and the things that she can show more than the personalities, and I understand, you know, sometimes we get caught up in I don't know, I guess this sort of back and forth with some of this stuff. But one of the other people that is ripping these videos apart and showing everybody how fake they are is t Powell at TJP of Texas, who's been sharing a lot of stuff, and there is some real disturbing things that the promoter of this fake videos are has been up to. Ashton is trying to head off his critics before the post a bunch of videos of Ashton being Ashton because it will make his critics look bad.

Watch the videos below. He makes all kinds of thinly veiled threats. He targets people by name, and he blasts them on this page for sharing views that he disagrees with. He doesn't even address the facts, just handwave it's all been disproved and jumps to ad Hamman in attacks I've been kind of here.

Here's one of those posts. Ashton uses veil's threats like this fairly often, it seems. Take this one for example, claiming that I am a grifter and engaging in spycraft and that I am lying to quote pushing deliberately false statements, all objectively false statements. Give me his real name, and I will make T.

Powell go away. It's disturbing. He's gonna make T Powell go away? Why?

Because T Powell is, you know, proving that the videos are fake. Anybody who's proven that the videos are fake, you know, is getting threatened by this promoter, this hoax promoter. Here's another one directed at mcwest. Like I said, Mick, if and when the videos are confirmed, I'm going to have the family sue you for everything you have.

You have repeatedly made false declarative statements about the videos, after multiple times claiming you wouldn't look into them. I have documented your various statements for proof you don't and can't know the videos are fake. Yet you continue to pretend like you do, and even wrote a false article and Skeptical Inquirer. I will have them sue Skeptical Inquirer as well.

So you better pray they don't confirm the videos. I mean, this is disturbing. This guy is out there threatening people with legal action because they say the videos are fake. You know.

Here's another one. He threatened to sue me after making a post on Reddit. Not mentioning him and presenting the facts which show the videos are fake. Now he could sleep in a bed he made for himself.

This is great. It means I sue him, pass it on to him. We got a new Corey good He's just going to sue all of his critics. This person who is promoting these fake MH three seventy videos may want to look into how terrible suing your critics can turn out in court.

Go look up Corey Goods cases. Well, this has completely proves my point that this guy is a total nutjob, totally unhinge. Seek mental health. That's another that's another big thing.

If you disagree with this person promoting these fake videos, you're a nutbag and a mental case. Somehow great, here are my haters. Apparently the redditor debunkers have been buying fake engagement and are planning on making some kind of defamatory super cut about me and promoted across Facebook and x If you didn't know, the redditors have a discord where they coordinate scams and fake debunks, including the felony fraud they committed against me in December. There's no proof that the people from Reddit did that.

This dummy bought fake information from a scammer. The irony is I think they think I lie in slander while they make plans to do it themselves. Grider aka Gary Gundark aka the guy I made cry in the Space the other week is planning to target young college feminist demographic Texas. NG and Mitsia spent five hundred and fifty in the last few weeks paying to promote content against me and the MH three seventy videos.

If you are somebody out there and here are the here's where it gets most disturbing. He's making live stream videos to a following of hundreds of thousands, of one hundred or more thousand subscribers, and he's saying things like this, if you are somebody out there who's telling people now to talk to me, you are an absolute piece of shit, and you are one of the worst human beings on the face of the earth. And in the future tell me your name. I'm gonna blast you all over social media my one hundred thousand followers and on live streams as well.

And I'm gonna tell you that's a threat. He's threatening critics with harassment. Tell people what a piece of shit that you are. So don't do it.

Last warning. If you're one of the people who's trying to debunk these videos, I am going to send the families after you to sue you for every single fucking penny that you have. This includes Mick West, it includes the Corridor Crew, It includes Jonas Dereaux and any other debunker that puts their real name next to any debunk of times on these videos. You have been warned that is what I'm gonna do.

Maybe I should have warned my don't sue me bro shirt available in our merchandise section for tonight's broadcast. He's literally saying that he's gonna get the families of the victims to sue the people that are showing that the videos are fake. I think that desperation is kind of seeping into mister Forbes here. Not a threat, it's a promise.

I will have them take everything that you have. I will make sure the media crucifies you and make sure that you are to go down in the history books as an enemy of humanity. Is that one hundred percent clear out there, debunkers and redditors and other pieces of crap. If you say that the videos are fake, even if you have overwhelming evidence they are, then you're an enemy of humanity.

Somebody in Griftsville is getting kind of desperate. I think that this is really disturbing. This is this is this is the behavior of a cult leader. This is scientology technique.

Thinks he did he one hundred percent did more than just respond. He made a debunk video. So he's going to lose all his credibility for the rest of his life. It's not my fault.

We got more. Should we post the next one or say the next one? I don't want to. I don't want anyone to think that I'm trying to blackmail anyone.

I'm just trying to put the information out there as soon as possible. No, he's not trying to blackmail anybody. He's just trying to threaten and intimidate and silence any critical voices that say that the videos are fake. Listen.

I agree with Christley and what Chrystley said earlier. If your evidence is so strong that the videos are real, you wouldn't be threatening to sue people that say the videos are fake, because you'd just be able to easily prove the videos are real, but actually can't prove that. So he just attacks anybody who says the videos are fake. And here's another great example.

UFO guy gets publicly embarrassed repeatedly, So we've got some kind of loser reacts streamer right off the bat, right, she's posting our content which we can see here right, which we literally did debunk this, so already work. He didn't debunk it. He debunked it by declaration, not by research or evidence. And you know we can just tell based on her hair and how she conducts herself that most likely she's unlovable.

And she's unlovable because she says the videos are fake. Why does he have to attack everybody's appearance or call them a nutjob or a mental case if they say the videos are fake? Why why can't you just debate on the merits, sir? Why do you god to attack this girl's appearance?

And I'm sorry, but maybe it's just me. Right, I was raised to respect women and really all people but women. You know, you don't make fun of a woman's appearance, period, full stop, for for really any reason. Uh, I just I don't get it.

Right, Oh, she said the videos are fake, So I'm going to tell everybody that she's unlovable is what is that Nobody will ever care about her in her life. Now we see her, you know, trying to dunk on us. I'm sure she's making a butthole jokes here at this point, because he deserves people making butthole jokes. Remember famously was it on the Danny Jones podcast he said, my butthole does not look like your butthole.

It's not the same butthole. Now let's keep going on. Oh that's not enough. Oh, look, she also has to try to dunk on the fact that we had a felony crime committed against us.

Felony crime committed against us. Oh, that's a good thing that we should make fun of, right, rite, Rebecca, make fun of people that have felonies. Okay, well, let's take a look at you, Rebecca. Let's go ahead and investigate what we find.

If we look at Rebecca, what do you guys think? Well, yeah, that's great. So he's gonna do, I guess, sort of opposition research on all of his critics and trying to dig up dirt. That's another sciencetology cult like tactic, fair game.

Anything you've got to do to silence a critic, you do it. I just keep thinking. You know, if this, if this evidence that this stuff was real was at all good, he wouldn't need to do use tactics like this. This is the tactics of a desperate, sad little man.

Uh, you know, attacking a woman like that. Come on, man, thank you for your work. Chris Li says High Speed Chase. Hope I spelled it right.

I struggled myself. I had to check it three times, so no worries. Thank you for your kindness, generosity and support High Speed Chase and helping us to praise the cat. All right, we're praising the cash and we want to thank wing Nuts who became a YouTube member.

For those unaware, if you become a YouTube channel member during the live broadcast, we give you a big shout out and thank you. I want to take a moment to also recognize and thank you patreons orders. You could join for as little as a buck a month, and all you YouTube channel members use super chatters, PayPal, pleasures and more. We love all of you.

Thank you for the support and helping us to praise the cash and keep the show flowing and going. Guys pray, thank you for your kindness. Thank you for your generosity. Praise all right, well, thank you for your kindness, generosity and support all of you.

I think that I have a few more things to share, but please please be sure and I could take some comments and questions from the chat. Well, I have a little more time to share with you. Please put them in all capital letters. P Brett Clark is here and says, Unfortunately, over the past five years, the more kooks have crawled out of their holes and flocked to this kind of nut jobbery.

Can't say I disagree with you, So comments and questions for me, please put them in all capital letters. In the meantime, I'm trying to find some things I wanted to share with you. Oh yeah, I had one. We're gonna go there.

We're gonna share this. I wasn't gonna share this, but I am. It's from jazz Deep on Twitter. Boy.

You know, sometimes to keep yourself saying, you just you've got to laugh at some of this stuff because it is so it is so bizarre that it's worthy of laughing at it. So look along with all the bad of this person, you know, profiting and promoting from the tragic deaths of two hundred and thirty nine people with his fake videos that he didn't even create and his fake conspiracy theories. At least we get a little bit of good art out of it. So here's a song from jazz Deep on Twitter.

This is a banger. Friends, There's a difference between having an open mind and being mentally disturbed. Ashton forbes and is following have the Brain of birds? Obvious fake video made by a man who's come clean.

Ashton just blocks him and says he's being mean. Why won't Joe Rogan listen and accept my pissed poor evidence? I should block his ass to not having an open mind. Don't get me started on Mick West for not investing his time on wormholes and missing airplanes?

Can he tickle muskets o? Fred you want to see great eagle and not so fast for Preston? Did I get scammed? Oh jeez, you gotta love it.

Friends, We want to thank trolley troll. Troll who says, yeah, I'd like to see that idiot try to collect any money from defaming him. You know, these threats of lawsuits are kind of ridiculous. Ask any lawyer how difficult it is to collect money in the defamation lawsuit.

It's one of the most difficult cases to bring. You know, first of all, you have to have overwhelming evidence that the person maliciously tried to damage your reputation with proof with things that they knew were untrue. You have to prove that they knew they were untrue and that they did it with malicious forethought. Part of me.

Then you have to prove that you suffer financial damages. Relate it to that defamation and the false statements. Showing people that videos are fake isn't defamation and it's not false statements. But thank you trolley troll Troll for your kindness, generosity and support and being a longtime show supporter and for being a member.

So comments questions for me, please put them in all capital letters. There are a little bit more time to share with you. And meanwhile, we're going to check in with our PayPal pledgers. Instructions for how to send a PayPal pledger and the instructions description excuse me of this video or podcast.

And we appreciate every single one of you, especially those people who send those big, those big helpful PayPal pledges. We want to thank dB who says, hey, Steve paying my dues. Hope you and your family. One second, hope you and your family are keeping well.

With a kind of generous ten dollars PayPal pledge. Thank you for a kind of generosity and support. And we've got Maria with a kind of generous fifty dollars PayPal pledge. Longtime show supporter who says, please keep up the coverage of the wacky world of Wilcock.

His latest video is crazy. I don't know if we're going to do that this week, you know, Can I skip one of those three and a half hour ego fests? Maybe not. We'll see how the week shakes out and what we have and the three to zero The thirty King is here from Chryst Lee's channel.

I think that's a moderator from chrys Lee's channel. Big hug, Well, thank you and thanks for what you did in the chat trying to keep things civil. Wing Nuts says, still coughing up coffee from that tune here, Well, thank you for being a member. Thank Jazz Deep for that.

High Speed Chase says, good night, have a great night, guys. Well, yeah, we appreciate all of your We appreciate everything that you do. A high Speed Chase to support the show. Big Show supporter and YouTube channel members Hank McGirk is here and just says, hey, cam Be and fellows, so listen.

I think we've done our due diligence. I'm sure there's a lot more that I could or should share, you know, but back to Brandolini's law, the amount of energy and you know, required to dispel bullshit as orders of magnitude more than it takes to create it, which is really true. And I find it interesting that so much many people have invested so much time to try to dispel the bullshit that the promoters of these fake videos have put on. And we've detailed some of that.

Incredible Brandon Lani's law applies to these MH three seventy videos. You've got ten v effects artists all investing hours and hours and hours to say these videos are fake and here's why. And yet some people still want to argue with them. Interesting that christ Lee's stream earlier got sort of infected with people that want to argue.

I haven't seen very much of that in our live chat. Maybe they didn't find us yet. It is what it is. I wish I'd been here from the start.

Please restate the editor ladies YouTube wing nuts. It's in. It's pinned in the live chat right at the top of the live chat. Just click that link and you'll go it's christ Lee christ Lee se r I s h l e E t V.

If you just put c r Y s h l e E t V or click on her userride d Right. Oh, christ Lee says he's on Twitter right now talking about this. Oh boy, well, do we really want to check in? Uh?

Maybe is it just Ashton? I think I don't know what his Uh. I have to look to see what his Twitter is. You know, I certainly don't follow him.

No, that's not it. Uh, somebody tell me in the live chat what is his Uh? What is his Twitter handle? Lot?

I don't really know. Uh. Or you know what, if I do a search for m H three seventy, I'm sure I'll find something from him and find his it's just ex Ashton. Well, I don't see anything specific to us that he's talking about.

Maybe I have to check and replies maybe I don't know macroscopic phase conjugation big words. Oh yeah, he says, I did find something. Oh man, it's getting thick. It's getting thick.

Ashton says, I don't like wasting energy arguing with the Bunker, but we've had a lot of new followers, and I constantly have people posting links to YouTubers promoting falsified VFX comparison. But it's important to address because the deception convinces even prominent podcasters like Joe Rogan only look at claims at face value and don't see the disinformation under the surface. Yeah, if you say the videos are fake, you're a disinformation agent. We have an impossible list of requirements to fake the MH three seventy videos, including an unclaimed hundred and fifty thousand dollars bounty.

I don't believe he'll ever pay that if somebody reaches whatever he wants. A mountain of evidence the videos are real? What mountain? No, you don't.

You don't have one verified real VFX expert who says the videos are real. And meanwhile, on the debunker or skeptical side, you've got ten that say they're fake. And here's why. Mountain of evidence that they're real includes the name of the military personnel who leaked them.

He has no verification that that person leaked them. He has no evidence that leaked them. He has his opinion that that's who leaked them. The events in the video are corroborated by real eyewitness sightings who are dismissed and discredited.

The stakes could not be higher if these videos are real. I'm putting my personal safety at risk. Oh, this is a perfect example of a grifter. Free energy is on the line for humanity.

Now, these videos have something to do with free energy. These videos have the potential to revolutionize the planet. I'm just going to tell you, Ashton, I'm going to ask you a direct question. How many free energy devices have you built?

I have a background in computer science and electronics. I've built many of them. You know one thing in common with all free energy devices, none of them work. Free energy is not real.

You cannot break the laws of physics. There's no such thing as free energy. But okay, you're turning into Stephen Greer Grift here. You're talking about free energy and UFO propulsion by free energy.

The people hiding the truth fate of MH three seventy will do anything to prevent this information from going mainstream. It is likely that this will be the only chance any of us get in our lifetimes to set the timetable for disclosure on our terms. In the process, we could solve a cold case and find solace for two hundred and thirty nine souls and their loved ones. I wonder what those two hundred and thirty nine souls loved ones think of you pushing these free energy conspiracy garbage conspiracy theories in which you're claiming that an entire airplane with two hundred and forty people, two hundred and thirty nine people on it were teleported by what aliens?

It's ridiculous. It's just complete this. This guy has lost it, but it is. Yeah, I think I've had enough.

It's just NonStop ridiculous, you know. All right, let's uh take a moment and I have I don't know. There's a there's a video that somebody sent me that they want me to play. This is from lou Reviews.

We're just gonna play and it's about harassment and some of the stuff in the UFO community and kind of fits in with what we're talking about here. So we're going to share this before we close down our broadcast. For the truth. You can't handle the truth, Jesus, it took you motherfucking long enough to bring me up to speak.

Goddamn bro agreed, you can be a skeptic and still be one of us. I'm a perfect example of that. I'm a believer, but I'm also very, very very skeptical about most of the stuff I hear in these spaces. But I can still handle part of the community.

He could do the same if he went about it a different way. But he's got like some sort of God complex. H He's out here fapping in spaces. That's gross.

He ain't gonna slap shit. He's a fucking moron. You sat here and just said he's intelligent, and he can't even do a couple of minutes worth of research to determine that I am not the person he claimed I was. But he made a whole stink about it on his motherfucking show, So he's not being intelligent like you said, Kevin, I'm sorry.

I respect you, though. Well, then I will keep calling him certain words people don't like because it's great content. It's just mad weird for someone to like spit atheist at me, as if it's a derogatory slur. When atheists are skeptics by nature, and he claims he's like the ultimate skeptic.

Like, what are you talking about? Like you sound stupid? How about a simple Google search of dead Bluebird will prove that I've been using this name my gamer tag since two thousand and nine. There's a couple of YouTube channels I'm on, a couple Twitter profiles on the internet.

Everyone as dead Bluebird. He's dumb. Some that dude who has a YouTube channel. Yeah, he's all but hurt because Luel Azondo broke up with him.

Bro, I come from the competitive call of duty scene. Okay, I don't give a fuck about that guy, and I will go in there and make fun of him all the time. I don't care what content he tries to make out of it. I don't care.

Is not the wolf, that's all he is. He's not a wolf, he's not a lion. He's a bridge troll. Whether he comes in here to speak or not, he's still gonna listen anonymously and clip us no matter what.

So he gives off how I speak to anybody, Nobody, none of you, None of you will tell me how I can and cannot speak to other people. He wouldn't have gotten called a fat fucking retard. If you want to spat atheist at me like it was a slur upon himself. He's dumb.

I will make fun of him. I die if he wants to stay here the entire time and be all up in our faces the entire time, We'll make fun of him. Don't worry, guys, I've been doing it this whole time. I say the things everyone else is scared to say.

I'll be the bitch. That's okay, listen, I'll solve it this way. Lou reviews one v one me call of duty, any call of duty, one B, one v one rust quick scopes. Let's go.

He wants us talking another hour about him, and it's worth it if we solve this problem once and for all. Right, it's it's worth it to solve this. But he has a research This is more of a pest than than an addiction has saying should shouldn't he just not even be ether? Should he?

He shouldn't even be zero point energy? He shouldn't even be back right, Like, he's just a parasite. And we need to figure out how to get asking me to, you know, in a in an ethical manner, and we have the tools to do it. I don't know, but this this should be an easy problem to solve.

No, it's it's it should be any problem. Sol He's a person. He's not a parasite. We can't refer to people as parasites.

That dehumanizes them. He has feelings, and he's in a position he's in because he feels, you know, a certain way, because he was hurt, like any of us would be if we were in his shoes, right, I would say we would behave the same way he would. But you can't do humanizing like that. And you know, I don't know the fuck.

I've been requesting this whole motherfucking time to come up here and ask him why he made the claim that I am Willith a serial harasser and doopts her, and you just fucking ignored my request the entire time. Thanks a lot. She's very angry it fucking oozed this from her. And I believe if I'm not mistaken, and I believe if I'm not misstaken, and I believe if I'm not mistaken, where this started really what she used to be Lilith Rising on Twitter a little cry baby bitch.

I can't stand that dude. And then he's got little daughters like TJ and Bobby Broadway fucking messaging me like Bobby Broadway's like, yeah, go make some bad AI art some more and try to pass it off as your own. And then he tagged me in my m Age three seventy song like, bro, that's not AI art, you war on? And then I wonder how Lou reviews, because Lou, you're probably still listening anonymously.

You know, your little butt buddy TJ. Did you know he was also butt buddies with King Milk Fart like livery on the t KMF for fucking months and months? Did you know that? But he deleted his other accounts, so you probably wouldn't be able to see that.

Just thought you should know. Lou doesn't have those extra dense clusters in his brain, so he wouldn't understand that. But you know what, it could have been so easy to like, like, Lou is in here, right, But believe me, there weren't. There were more people requesting to talk to him than I could accept, right, So what do you want me to do?

Just get rid of someone that everyone wants to talk to. I feel a little dirty. The truth you can't handle the truth. He wouldn't have gotten called fat fucking retard.

Wow, Wow, there's something else. Apparently she's going to go on a show on Friday. People love a good argument, so she should do great numbers with that. I would think, Yeah, it's worked for us here, Lew says, dehumanizing others like this girl isn't part of my approach.

She at this aspect often goes unnoticed within our community. I find it deeply concerning that such language is tolerated. How can we justify this? Should legal action be considered against the individual in question?

I'm uncertain, but their recent behavior certainly warrants serious scrutiny. The fact that dumer Zaddy there called to harm someone simply because they hold different beliefs about UFOs is utterly unacceptable. There's no room for discussion or acknowledgement of their humanity. It's as if disagreement automatically equates to a desire for their adication.

And this is a problem with some of this stuff. It's just so toxic. Yeah, so, friends, we've done our due diligence. I'll take a few more comments and questions from the lat Chat monkey's throwing pooh, Yeah, that's kind of what this equates to.

Patty says, this is hilarious. Why a wife ful says she doesn't like me either, I don't know. Imagine being stuck and with that. Yeah, hell has no fury like a woman.

Man. I don't like arguing with women. I generally don't. I don't even argue with my wife.

Man. They always win, especially if it's your significant other. You know, they got the Trump card, so they usually win any argument. One of them is on the phone to the duty doc.

We've got to be quiet here. Yeah, I've never heard of that game. I'm a competitive Call of duty expert. Oh my goodness.

All right, Miss Tessa Marie is here, says late getting here Steven, Hello, fellow truth seekers. Yeah, can I get anything like a watch? We started two hours and twenty two minutes ago, But I'm still happy to see you, Miss Tessa Marie. Better late than never.

You got to make a big entrance. Yes, Patty says, you can't win when you argue with us. Correct, absolutely, so listen. I want to thank all of you kind of generous benefactors.

I want to thank our wonderful surprise guest. I only connected with her like an hour or two before the show. Excellent guest, and I hope we'll hear more from miss christ Lee and again pinned in the live chat and in the description of this podcast is a link to her latest video. From there, you can just click on her channel and go and subscribe.

I highly recommend it. And also you can follow her on Twitter. Be sure to do that. It's at Christley c r Y s h l e E at c r y s h l e E.

Go follow her on Twitter, go follow her on YouTube. I think she's doing excellent work and I love to see that. I love to see somebody that's doing you know, we try here. I always say this, We try to be of public benefit to our viewers here, and she's certainly doing that.

It's definitely a public benefit to dispel these fake conspiracy theories and to you know, educate people about the truth behind some of this stuff. You saw me the other night, Hank, you had that look in my eye. Yeah. And in closing, I just wanted to mention that if the promoters of these fake videos arguments were so strong, they wouldn't need to resort to threatening to sue people.

They wouldn't need to resort to making lists of people to have their accounts messed with or you know, report people for abuse and harassment when all they're doing is talking about the videos being fake. These are cult like tactics that are kind of disturbing to see. It's been a while, quite honestly, since people have docs threatened, intimidated, or harassed me. But I'm sure that, given my stance, that these videos are one hundred percent fake.

And by the way, my opinion is not just formed of my own research into this and my own experience with computers and video editing and VFX. My experience with animation and VFX is quite limited. I default it to the experts, people at Corter Crew and Christley and mcwest and others. How can this person, Ashton stand in the face of all those experts and say I'm right and your wrong.

To me, it's the height of arrogance and stupidity. But that's just my opinion. You know what more can I say? So We've done our due diligence for this evening.

I will be back tomorrow night at nine p m. Eastern Standard time. I've got three or four more great shows ready to go in a folder, and I'm hoping to get as many of them as possible sort of make up for our lack of live shows last week, which again I apologized, but you know, being a married father of two children, one of them special needs, sometimes you just got to take a step back and get some things done in the real world, and that's what I was doing last week. And so you know, I'm sorry to those people who said, oh, this isn't a live show, or you know, come on.

We did produce something like fourteen hours of replay content, which I thought was excellent because it was so information packed about all these UFO crash retrieval cases and all these former UFO whistleblowers that never proved anything, but they all made lots of money selling their stories. History really is our greatest teacher. So you know, what more can I say. I'll be back tomorrow night at nine pm Eastern Standard time.

No place I'd rather be, and I hope you'll be here with me. We want to thank our excellent guests, Miss christ Lee, and remind you again in the description of the video and pinned in the live chat. That is her YouTube channel. Go over there and subscribe and follow her on Twitter.

It's at c R Y s H L E E. Christ Lee, I hope, I'm I hope that's right. But for the benefit of the audio podcast listeners, it's at c r Y s h l e E. And also for the benefit of the audio podcast listeners, you can find her YouTube channel very easily.

Just go to going over to YouTube, click the little magnifying glass the search bar, put in c r Y s h l e e TV. That's her YouTube channel. You'll find her over there doing great work educating people and dispelling bullshit, which is something that I highly support. I can't tell you how much I enjoyed our stream earlier tonight.

Watch her latest video. It's really worth it if you want to get an education into how these fake videos were created. And so that's all I got for your friends. Until next time, My name is Stephen Camby, and good night and God bless all of the announce listens listenssssssss listen to s